CDPJ and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

[2014] AATA 535

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/5029

Re

CDPJ

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal Ms J Redfern, Senior Member
Date 5 August 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

...............[sgd].........................................................

Ms J Redfern, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION AND REVENUE – income tax – employment termination payment – life benefit termination payment – whether the payment was a transitional termination payment – lump sum payment under a deed – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 s 175A

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 s 82-130
Income Tax (Transitional Provisions) Act 1997 ss 82-10, 82-10C, 82-10D

Taxation Administration Act 1953 s 14ZZK

CASES

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (2009) 239 CLR 27; [2009] HCA 41

Dibb v Commissioner of Taxation (2004) 136 FCR 388; 207 ALR 151
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Spedley Securities Ltd (1988) 19 ATR 938
Le Grand v Commissioner of Taxation (2002) 124 FCR 53; 195 ALR 194
McLaurin v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1961) 104 CLR 381
Re Perfrement and Commissioner of Taxation [2011] AATA 264

Reynolds v Southcorp Wines Pty Ltd (2002) 122 FCR 301

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Tax Laws Amendment (Simplified Superannuation) Bill 2006 (Cth) Explanatory Memorandum

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms J Redfern, Senior Member

5 August 2014

INTRODUCTION

  1. This was an application for review of an objection decision made by a delegate of the Commissioner of Taxation in respect of a lump sum payment received by the applicant in the 2011 income year following the settlement of an employment dispute. The applicant requested that the hearing be in private under s 14ZZE of the Taxation Administration Act 1953. Accordingly, he has been given a pseudonym and is referred to as CDPJ in these reasons.

  2. CDPJ worked as a senior manager at St George Bank (St George) from 1988, and later with the Westpac Banking Corporation (Westpac), until the termination of his employment on 7 August 2009. He, and a number of other senior managers, were made redundant following the merger of St George with Westpac in late 2008.

  3. CDPJ commenced proceedings against Westpac in the Federal Court of Australia in October 2009 in respect of his termination. Westpac filed a cross claim and CDPJ cross claimed against Westpac and others in those cross claim proceedings. Part of CDPJ’s claim, being his claim for the payment of a bonus for the 2008/2009 year, was resolved in November 2010. The balance of the proceedings, including Westpac’s cross claim, was settled by deed of release dated 3 May 2011.

  4. Under the terms of the deed Westpac agreed to pay CDPJ $1,937,000; CDPJ agreed to the dismissal of his claim and cross claims against Westpac; Westpac agreed to the dismissal of its cross claims and the parties provided mutual releases to each other.

  5. At the time of the termination of his employment, CDPJ received a termination payment of $700,492.48, of which $88,939 was treated as a tax-free redundancy payment and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CDPJ and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 535
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of CDPJ and Commissioner of Taxation involves a dispute over the taxability of a redundancy payment made to CDPJ upon his termination of employment. The primary issue before the court was whether the redundancy payment, which included a pro-rata bonus for a year not fully worked, should be considered as assessable income under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. CDPJ argued that the payment was a transitional termination payment exempt from tax under section 82-10 of the ITTPA, while the Commissioner of Taxation contended that it should be subject to income tax.

The court considered the nature of the redundancy payment, focusing on whether it could be determined using a formula in place as of 9 May 2006, the date the transitional termination payment provisions came into effect. CDPJ submitted that the bonus, while not determined until November 2010, was nonetheless ascertainable using a pre-existing formula. The Commissioner argued that the payment should not be considered exempt because it was not entirely ascertainable at the relevant time. The court examined the policy in place at the time of CDPJ’s termination, which provided a formula for calculating redundancy payments based on years of service. The court found that the payment was capable of being determined by reference to the bonus that was eventually agreed upon, and thus fell within the transitional termination payment exemption.

In conclusion, the court determined that the redundancy payment made to CDPJ was a transitional termination payment exempt from income tax under section 82-10 of the ITTPA. The court ordered that the Commissioner of Taxation’s assessment of the payment as assessable income was incorrect and should be amended accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

According to CDPJ, it was irrelevant that the bonus could not be determined until after 9 May 2006 or indeed that it was not agreed until November 2010. Relevantly, the bonus was in fact agreed and this was evidence that the subsequent redundancy payment, which comprised part of the May 2011 lump sum settlement, was capable of being determined using a formula that was in place as at 9 May 2006. As such, the payment could be calculated by reference to the bonus that was agreed in November 2010, which was $536,794, a weekly amount based on the bonus and the formula set out in the redundancy policy, which provided for a formula based on years of service up to a maximum of 90 weeks. This amount was calculated to be $929,066.96 and was part of the May 2011 settlement. It was paid before 1 July 2012 and, as such, was a transitional termination payment for the purposes of s 82-10 of the ITTPA.BACKGROUND FACTS CDPJ commenced employment with St George in its Treasury Division. He was promoted to a senior management role in St George in 2005. His remuneration comprised base salary and annual incentives, namely an award of shares in St George pursuant to the Medium Term Incentive Plan (MTIP) and a bonus paid pursuant to the Treasury Incentive Plan (TIP). In the six years prior to the termination of his employment CDPJ receive bonuses every year which exceeded his base salary. In the two years before the termination of his employment, CDPJ’s bonus was nearly double his base salary. A copy of the Treasury Incentive Plan was not provided to the tribunal and no documents were produced recording how the bonus was calculated. The only documents provided were copies of letters from St George confirming approval of a bonus for each year from 2002/2003 to 2007/2008. There is no contest that the redundancy policy in force as at 9 May 2006 provided as follows:Retrenchment paymentExcept for staff covered under a Service Agreement, if you’re retrenched you receive a retrenchment payment, which is calculated as follows:· 6 weeks pay in lieu of notice· 7 weeks pay for your first completed year of service· 4 weeks pay for each subsequent year from 2 to 10 completed years of service· 3 weeks pay for each subsequent year from 11 to 16 completed years of service· 2 weeks pay for each subsequent year to a maximum of 25 completed years of service including the first yearPLUS· 1 weeks pay for each year over 45 years of agePLUS· Pro-rata pay for each completed month of workTo a maximum of 85 weeks (90 weeks for staff over 45 years old) pay including the 6-week notice period. On his termination, CDPJ was not paid any bonus for 2008/2009. His redundancy was paid in accordance with the formula referred to in the policy but was based on his base salary. CDPJ commenced proceedings against Westpac in 2009. The proceedings included a claim for a pro-rated bonus for 2008/2009. There was an exchange of correspondence between the solicitors for Westpac, Allens Arthur Robinson (AAR), and CDPJ’s lawyers, Gillis Delaney, which culminated in the settlement of the pro-rated bonus claim. According to a letter from AAR dated 11 June 2010, which was produced by Westpac in response to a summons issued in these proceedings, there was correspondence between Westpac and CDPJ dated 28 November 2008 in relation to CDPJ’s redundancy package. A copy of this letter was not provided to the tribunal but the letter from AAR purported to paraphrase the letter, noting as follows:· if a comparable role could not be identified for [CDPJ] he would be entitled to a redundancy package, calculated in accordance with his existing St George entitlements;· in recognition of his contribution during the merger period, and in addition to the redundancy package, he would be eligible for a pro-rata variable reward payment for the period 1 October 2008 to the end of his time in the transition role;· the amount of the pro-rata payment would be based on the performance of Westpac and the Institutional Bank as well as [his] personal performance over the period; and· provided the performance of Westpac and the Institutional Bank were at plan and his individual performance was effective he could expect the variable award amount to be consistent with his 2008 award (adjusted for actual time worked during the year).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The artificiality of this characterisation is highlighted by the fact that the sum identified in CDPJ’s tax return for the 2011 income year as having been made pursuant to the redundancy was asserted to have been incorrectly calculated based on $560,000 because CDPJ “inadvertently rounded” up the agreed 2008/2009 bonus.CONSIDERATION The parties referred to a number of cases which, while not directly on point, considered the question of how lump sum settlement payments should be treated for the purposes of other cases of income tax law. The Commissioner referred to the High Court case of McLaurin v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1961) 104 CLR 381 which has been applied in a number of tax cases that followed. In McLaurin the taxpayer commenced proceedings against the Commissioner of Railways to recover £30,000 for damages to his property arising out of a fire. The claim included several different heads of damage. The Commissioner made a lump sum offer to Mr McLaurin of £12,350 based on a valuation of the items which were accepted by the Commissioner of Railways. The basis of the offer was not communicated to Mr McLaurin. He accepted the offer and the Commissioner of Taxation assessed Mr McLaurin for tax on the amount of particularised claims which had been apparently accepted by the Commissioner of Railways but not communicated to or agreed by Mr McLaurin. The High Court (Dixon CJ and Fullagar and Kitto JJ) rejected the assessment made by the Commissioner, observing as follows (at 390):No doubt it was discussed item by item during the negotiations which resulted in the settlement. But the settlement, nevertheless, was for a lump sum of damages, not composed of agreed constituents, offered and accepted in full satisfaction of the entirety of the appellant’s causes of action against the Commissioner for Railways. It may be the fact, and it makes no difference if it is, that the appellant, because of the course the discussions had followed, was in a position to make a confident guess as to the amount Mr. Cameron had allowed for each item in making his recommendation to the Assistant Solicitor for Railways. But he was not concerned to make the guess. He had simply to weigh £12,350 against the entirety of his claim, and accept it or reject it as a whole. Obviously, to accept the lump sum was not to assent to any figure in respect of any individual item of his claim. According to the High Court, “in point of law it would plainly be unsound to allow a determination of the character of a receipt in the hands of the recipient to be affected by consideration of the uncommunicated reasoning which led the payer to agree to it” (at 391). The Commissioner’s “dissection” of the lump sum to attribute part of the sum to assessable income could not be justified in the circumstances. The High Court nonetheless provided guidance as to when apportionment may be justified (at 391, footnotes omitted):It is true that in a proper case a single payment or receipt of a mixed nature may be apportioned amongst the several heads to which it relates and an income or non-income nature attributed to portions of it accordingly: Texas Co. (Australasia) Ltd. v. Federal Commissioner of Taxation; Ronpibon Tin N. L. and Tongkah Compound N. L. v. Federal Commissioner of Taxation; The National Mutual Life Association of Australasia Ltd. v. Federal Commissioner of Taxation. But while it may be appropriate to follow such a course where the payment or receipt is in settlement of distinct claims of which some at least are liquidated, cf. Carter v. Wadman, or are otherwise ascertainable by calculation: cf. Tilley v. Wales, it cannot be appropriate where the payment or receipt is in respect of a claim or claims for unliquidated damages only and is made or accepted under a compromise which treats it as a single, undissected amount of damages. In such a case the amount must be considered as a whole: Du Cros v. Ryall.