CDC Clinics v Daemolzekr

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S EAPCI 2021 0048

CDC CLINICS PTY LTD (ACN 109 209 921) Applicant
v
ZEINAB DAEMOLZEKR Respondent

---

JUDGES: NIALL, KENNEDY and MACAULAY JJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 9 March 2022
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 7 April 2022
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2022] VSCA 54
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: [2021] VCC 292 (Wischusen J)

---

TORT – Medical negligence – Damages – Breach of duty of care – Laser treatment – Cause of scarring injuries – Where burns finding dependent on judge’s assessment of oral evidence – Whether burns finding ‘glaringly improbable’ and/or open on the evidence – Whether adverse inference should be drawn from failure to call witnesses – Whether failure to consider evidence admitted on voir dire – Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129, applied – Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679, applied – Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298, considered – Cargill Australia Ltd v Viterra Malt Pty Ltd (No 28) [2022] VSC 13, considered – Leave to appeal refused.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant Mr M O’Connor Moray & Agnew Lawyers
For the Respondent  Mr N Murdoch with
Ms F Ellis
Henry Carus & Associates

NIALL JA
KENNEDY JA
MACAULAY JA:

  1. On 28 June 2017, the respondent attended the applicant’s clinic (the ‘CDC Clinic’) in order to undergo laser treatment to remove tattoos from each of her forearms.  The respondent claims that the scarring which now appears on her forearms was caused by the applicant’s negligence in administering that treatment.

  1. It was agreed by the parties that the resolution of the case turned on what caused the scarring, and, in particular, whether the respondent was burnt by the treatment.[1]

    [1]Since it was never suggested that the respondent had consented to the risk of being burnt.

  1. A County Court judge found that the scarring of the respondent’s forearms in the area treated by the applicant resulted from burns sustained in the course of her treatment on 28 June 2017, during which too high a fluence[2] was applied to her tattoos.  His Honour thereby ordered the applicant to pay the respondent damages fixed at $90,000, plus interest and indemnity costs. 

    [2]According to Dr Rish (whose evidence was accepted by his Honour), the ‘fluence’ is the measurement of power applied to the skin by the laser machine, measured per centimetre square.

  1. The applicant now seeks leave to appeal from this decision, and advances the following three relevant proposed grounds:[3]

1.The trial judge erred in finding that the applicant caused burns to the respondent’s skin when such a finding was not open on the evidence.

2.The trial judge erred in failing to draw any inference from the plaintiff’s failure to call any medical practitioner from the Wantirna Mall Clinic or from the Monash Medical Centre.

3.The trial judge erred in rejecting the contemporaneous note of the treating nurse Ms Clow, without any evidential basis;  and after admitting it into evidence on a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CDC Clinics v Daemolzekr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSCA 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CDC Clinics challenged the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria in relation to a medical negligence claim brought by Daemolzekr. The dispute centred on whether CDC Clinics was liable for scarring injuries suffered by Daemolzekr following laser treatment. The Supreme Court of Victoria had found CDC Clinics liable and awarded damages. CDC Clinics appealed to the Court of Appeal, contending that the trial judge’s finding that Daemolzekr had suffered burns was ‘glaringly improbable’ and that the trial judge failed to consider certain evidence. Daemolzekr responded by arguing that the trial judge’s finding was open on the evidence and that any failure to consider evidence was not sufficient to warrant an adverse inference.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the trial judge’s finding that Daemolzekr had suffered burns was ‘glaringly improbable’ and/or open on the evidence, and whether an adverse inference should be drawn from CDC Clinics’ failure to call certain witnesses. Additionally, the Court needed to determine if the trial judge had failed to consider evidence admitted on voir dire. The Court of Appeal considered the principles articulated in Lee v Lee, which emphasised the importance of the trial judge's role in assessing the credibility of witnesses and the weight to be given to their evidence. The Court also referred to Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott and Jones v Dunkel to understand the standards of review for findings of fact and the circumstances in which an adverse inference may be drawn. The Court examined the trial judge's assessment of the evidence and the reasons provided for the findings made.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge's finding that Daemolzekr had suffered burns was open on the evidence, and that the trial judge had considered all relevant evidence, including that admitted on voir dire. The Court held that the finding was not ‘glaringly improbable’ and that the trial judge had appropriately exercised his discretion in assessing the credibility of the evidence. The Court also found that there was no basis for drawing an adverse inference from CDC Clinics’ failure to call certain witnesses. As a result, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Court of Appeal denied CDC Clinics leave to appeal to the High Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, CDC Clinics, instituted proceedings against the defendant, Daemolzekr, for medical negligence. The plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained during a laser treatment provided by CDC Clinics. The treatment resulted in scarring injuries to the plaintiff. The primary dispute in the case revolved around the cause of the scarring injuries. The plaintiff alleged that the injuries were caused by the defendant's breach of the duty of care in administering the laser treatment. The defendant, in turn, disputed the plaintiff's allegations and argued that the injuries were not caused by the laser treatment. The determination of whether the plaintiff suffered burns during the treatment was central to the case, as it was believed to be a key factor in establishing the cause of the scarring injuries. The issue of whether the plaintiff sustained burns was left to the judge's assessment of the oral evidence presented during the trial.

The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The plaintiff, CDC Clinics, filed the proceedings against the defendant, Daemolzekr, seeking damages for medical negligence. The matter proceeded to a trial before a judge. During the trial, evidence was presented, and witnesses were called to testify. The plaintiff argued that the defendant's breach of duty of care during the laser treatment resulted in scarring injuries, while the defendant disputed the plaintiff's claims. The trial concluded with the judge making findings on the cause of the scarring injuries. The defendant subsequently appealed the decision, arguing that the judge's finding on the cause of the scarring injuries was 'glaringly improbable' and/or open on the evidence. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, and leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal was refused.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the judge's finding that the plaintiff sustained burns during the laser treatment was 'glaringly improbable' and/or open on the evidence.
2. Whether an adverse inference should be drawn from the defendant's failure to call certain witnesses.
3. Whether the judge failed to consider evidence admitted on voir dire.
4. The application of Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129, Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679, and Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 to the case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the judge's finding that the plaintiff sustained burns during the laser treatment was not 'glaringly improbable' and/or open on the evidence.
2. The court held that an adverse inference should not be drawn from the defendant's failure to call certain witnesses.
3. The court found that the judge did not fail to consider evidence admitted on voir dire.
4. The court applied Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129, Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679, and Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 to the case, determining their relevance and impact on the findings and reasoning.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented during the trial, focusing on the plaintiff's claims of burns resulting from the laser treatment administered by the defendant. The judge's finding was based on the oral evidence, which the court found to be sufficient and not 'glaringly improbable' or open to challenge. In addressing the second issue, the court considered the defendant's decision not to call certain witnesses and concluded that no adverse inference should be drawn from this omission. The court emphasised that the absence of testimony from these witnesses did not undermine the judge's findings.

Regarding the third issue, the court reviewed the voir dire evidence and determined that the judge had appropriately considered all relevant evidence. The court highlighted that the judge's decision-making process was thorough and that there was no failure to consider pertinent evidence.

In applying the legal principles from Lee v Lee, Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott, and Jones v Dunkel, the court reaffirmed the importance of assessing the evidence presented and the weight to be given to expert opinions. The court found that the judge's application of these principles was correct and consistent with established legal standards. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in medical negligence cases, where findings are based on the assessment of oral evidence, such findings are not easily characterised as 'glaringly improbable' or open, unless the evidence is clearly insufficient or unreliable. Additionally, the court's approach to drawing adverse inferences from the failure to call witnesses and considering evidence on voir dire was deemed appropriate, reinforcing the importance of a balanced and fair evaluation of the presented evidence.