Cavallaro v FNE Lawyers

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

CAVALLARO v FNE LAWYERS

[2012] SASC 189

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

16 October 2012

PROCEDURE - COSTS

Lawyer sued client for his costs in Magistrates Court which adjourned hearing for the costs to be taxed in this Court under s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 – client sought variation of retainer agreement under s 42(7) for costs to be assessed on the Family Law Act 1975 Scale and not on the Supreme Court Scale – held it was for the Supreme Court, and not the Magistrates Court, to determine which was the applicable scale – as the costs claimed were for acting in a matrimonial matter in the Federal Magistrates Court the Family Law Act Rules on costs as between lawyer and his own client did not apply to the proceedings in the Federal Magistrates Court.

CAVALLARO v FNE LAWYERS
[2012] SASC 189

JUDGE LUNN:

Reasons on the preliminary issue of the scale on which the costs are to be adjudicated

Definitions

  1. The applicant, Domenico Cavallaro, is referred to as the client.  The respondent, FNE Lawyers, which was the trading name of Francis Elekwachi, is referred to as the lawyer.

    Background

  2. At about the beginning of 2008 the client’s former wife instituted proceedings against him in the Federal Magistrates Court in Cairns seeking orders for a property settlement.  The client consulted a Queensland lawyer, Mr Lago, who quoted him fees of between $300 and $350 per hour plus GST to defend the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings and also required an immediate payment of $4000 into his trust account.  The client did not then retain Mr Lago.

  3. In late March 2008 the client approached the lawyer about him acting for him.  The lawyer accepted the instructions.  The client signed a written retainer agreement which is dated 27 March 2008.  It provided the lawyer would charge his fees by reference to the Supreme Court of (South) Australia scale of costs.[1]  It also provided that subject to certain conditions, the lawyer’s fees would not become due for payment until the matter was resolved.

    [1]    The scale annexed to the agreement was Schedule 1 to the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006.

  4. The lawyer then acted for the client in the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings.  His application to have the proceedings transferred to the Adelaide Registry of the Federal Magistrates Court was unsuccessful.  In about September 2008 the client terminated the lawyer’s instructions and instructed Mr Lago to act in the matter.  On 23 September 2008 the client signed a payment authority directed to Mr Lago authorising him to pay to the lawyer his costs of $25,299.  The proceedings were subsequently settled on terms which the client now regards as disadvantageous to him.  None of the lawyer’s costs have been paid.

  5. The client lodged a complaint about the lawyer with the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board.  The Board obtained a report dated 3 November 2009 from a costs assessor, Ms Woodhead, who…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cavallaro v FNE Lawyers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cavallaro v FNE Lawyers, the applicant, Domenico Cavallaro, sought to have his costs assessed under the Family Law Act 1975 Scale rather than the Supreme Court Scale as outlined in the retainer agreement with the respondent, FNE Lawyers. The case began when Cavallaro’s former wife instituted proceedings against him in the Federal Magistrates Court. Cavallaro initially consulted a different lawyer but ultimately retained FNE Lawyers. The retainer agreement stipulated that fees would be charged according to the Supreme Court of South Australia scale of costs, with the scale detailed in Schedule 1 to the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006. After Cavallaro terminated the lawyer's instructions and settled the proceedings, he disputed the costs claimed by FNE Lawyers, leading to a lawsuit in the Magistrates Court.

The legal issues central to this case were whether the costs should be assessed under the Supreme Court Scale or the Family Law Act Scale and if the retainer agreement could be varied under s 42(7) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981. The Court had to determine the jurisdiction to decide which scale applied and whether the Family Law Act Rules on costs were relevant in the context of the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings. The Court found that the determination of the applicable scale was outside the jurisdiction of the Magistrates Court and was instead the responsibility of the Supreme Court. Since the costs arose from acting in a matrimonial matter in the Federal Magistrates Court, the Family Law Act Rules on costs between lawyer and client did not apply.

The Court held that the Supreme Court was the appropriate forum to decide which scale should be applied to the costs in question. The client’s attempt to vary the retainer agreement to reflect the Family Law Act Scale was unsuccessful. The Court emphasized that the assessment of the proper scale for costs was a matter for the Supreme Court, and the client’s negligence claims and any other broader losses would need to be addressed in separate proceedings. The Court’s decision underscored the need for clear demarcation of jurisdictions between the Magistrates Court and the Supreme Court in such matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Domenico Cavallaro, is referred to as the client. The respondent, FNE Lawyers, which was the trading name of Francis Elekwachi, is referred to as the lawyer.Background At about the beginning of 2008 the client’s former wife instituted proceedings against him in the Federal Magistrates Court in Cairns seeking orders for a property settlement. The client consulted a Queensland lawyer, Mr Lago, who quoted him fees of between $300 and $350 per hour plus GST to defend the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings and also required an immediate payment of $4000 into his trust account. The client did not then retain Mr Lago. In late March 2008 the client approached the lawyer about him acting for him. The lawyer accepted the instructions. The client signed a written retainer agreement which is dated 27 March 2008. It provided the lawyer would charge his fees by reference to the Supreme Court of (South) Australia scale of costs.[1] It also provided that subject to certain conditions, the lawyer’s fees would not become due for payment until the matter was resolved.[1] The scale annexed to the agreement was Schedule 1 to the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006. The lawyer then acted for the client in the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings. His application to have the proceedings transferred to the Adelaide Registry of the Federal Magistrates Court was unsuccessful. In about September 2008 the client terminated the lawyer’s instructions and instructed Mr Lago to act in the matter. On 23 September 2008 the client signed a payment authority directed to Mr Lago authorising him to pay to the lawyer his costs of $25,299. The proceedings were subsequently settled on terms which the client now regards as disadvantageous to him. None of the lawyer’s costs have been paid. The client lodged a complaint about the lawyer with the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board. The Board obtained a report dated 3 November 2009 from a costs assessor, Ms Woodhead, who calculated the costs properly payable to the lawyer at $16,618.53 on the basis of the Family Law Act 1975 Scale. The lawyer objected that this was not the applicable scale. The Board obtained a second report from Ms Woodhead dated 26 February 2010[2] in which she calculated the costs payable to the lawyer on the Supreme Court Scale at $23,387.50. The Board subsequently determined that the costs were payable on the Supreme Court Scale and were properly fixed at $23,387.50. The lawyer accepted a recommendation of the Board that he reduce the amount he claimed to that figure. [2] Neither of the reports of Ms Woodhead are in evidence before me. On 10 May 2011 the lawyer sued the client in the Magistrates Court for $23,387.50. The client defended the action and represented himself. There was a three day trial in January 2012 before Mr Millard SM. On 21 March 2012 Mr Millard SM delivered a detailed set of reasons and found that the client was liable to pay the lawyer his fees for a sum to be fixed by a taxation in this Court under s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981[3] (“the Act”). He then adjourned the proceedings for that taxation to occur. [3] Section 42 refers to a taxation of costs but 6R 272 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 refers to the process as an adjudication.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 15 June 2012 the client instituted this action seeking a taxation of the lawyer’s costs under s 42. As part of his proceedings he has also sought an order under s 42(7) of that Act that the retainer agreement of 27 March 2008 be varied on the grounds that it was not fair and reasonable in providing that the costs should be payable on the Supreme Court Scale and not the Family Law Act Scale. I directed that I should first determine a preliminary issue on the adjudication of whether the costs were to be adjudicated on the Supreme Court Scale or on the Family Law Act Scale. Until the correct scale is ascertained, it is impossible for the lawyer to file a meaningful itemised schedule of the costs for adjudication. In this action the client has represented himself.The evidence I have before me affidavits of Mr Elekwachi filed on 14 September 2012 (FDN6) and of the client filed on 26 September 2012 (FDN7). In the course of his submissions the client made reference to some other affidavits which are not on the Court file and which I presume he sought to file but were rejected by the Court registry. These affidavits do not appear to be crucial to the determination which I need to make. Reopening the hearing to consider if they should be received would only add significantly to the costs. Regrettably, the costs of this action will almost certainly exceed the amount which is at stake. Neither party sought to cross-examine on the affidavits which are before me.Reasons of Mr Millard SM By virtue of the relevant legislation, recovery of lawyers’ costs from clients can require separate proceedings in two different courts. It is for the Magistrates Court to determine the retainer and the contractual liability of the client to the lawyer and it is for this Court to determine the proper quantum of the costs which are payable.[4] I am not sitting on appeal against the findings of Mr Millard SM. There is probably an issue estoppel between the parties arising from his findings, insofar as he had jurisdiction to make them, which now prevents them being contested in these proceedings. [4] Von Doussas Legal Pty Ltd v NASR (2009) 105 SASR 46 at 58-60. It is necessary to ascertain the precise boundaries of the jurisdictions of this Court and of the Magistrates Court in this matter. At [81] of his reasons Mr Millard found that the retainer agreement “entitles the bill to be drawn on the Supreme Court Scale”. I do not consider that it was within his jurisdiction to determine this. The appropriate scale is only relevant to the quantification of the costs. Issues of quantification are for the Supreme Court and not the Magistrates Court. Therefore, I do not consider myself bound by Mr Millard’s determination on the point. I determine it afresh as a matter to be decided as part of the preliminary question in this action. In his papers the client has raised issues of negligence and breach of duty by the lawyer in his conduct of the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings. It is likely that he will seek to raise these issues on the adjudication. Negligence issues can only be raised where they are confined to the quantum of a particular item of costs claimed in the itemised schedule. Where any wider loss is claimed by the client the issues need to be resolved in separate proceedings.[5] Here the client has not brought any counterclaim in the Magistrates Court proceeding. It will be for the Magistrates Court now to decide whether he should now be permitted to do so. If he does not do so, he may be barred by Anshun estoppel[6] from raising it in subsequent proceedings.[5] Dal Pont “Law of Costs” 2nd Ed paras [5.35-5.39].[6] See Civil Procedure South Australia [6R 193.55.15].The applicability of the Family Law Act Scale

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.