Caterpillar Inc. v ESCO Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Caterpillar Inc. v ESCO Corporation [2016] APO 30

Patent Application:                2012240099

Title:Hardfaced wearpart using brazing and associated method and assembly for manufacturing

Patent Applicant:                   ESCO Corporation

Opponent:  Caterpillar Inc.

Delegate:  R Subbarayan

Decision Date:  23 May 2016

Hearing Date:  8 March 2016, at Melbourne

Catchwords:  PATENTS - section 59 – opposition to grant of patent – hardfaced wear part – claim construction – whether certain features are inessential - whether claims are clear and fairly based – whether claims are novel and inventive –whether claims are useful – whether claims are to a manner of manufacture – opposition successful – Claims 29, 30, 32 to 41 and 64 to 68 are not fairly based - Claims 64 and 66-68 are not novel - costs awarded

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Stephen Burley SC instructed by Stephen Worthley and Wayne McMaster of Minter Ellison

Opponent:Freehills Patent Attorneys

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2012240099

Title:Hardfaced wearpart using brazing and associated method and assembly for manufacturing

Patent Applicant:                   ESCO Corporation

Date of Decision:                   23 May 2016

DECISION

The opposition is successful. Claims 29, 30, 32 to 41 and 64 to 68 are not fairly based. Claims 64 and 66-68 are not novel over documents D6 and D8. I award costs according to Schedule 8 against the applicant ESCO Corporation.

REASONS FOR DECISION

BACKGROUND

  1. Patent application 2012240099 in the name of ESCO Corporation (ESCO) was filed as a PCT application (PCT/US2012/032410) on 5 April 2012 and claims priority from a US priority application filed on 6 April 2011. Following examination it was accepted on 23 July 2014. The application has been opposed under section 59 of the Patents Act by Caterpillar Inc. (Caterpillar). After the filing of evidence in support, evidence in answer and evidence in reply, the matter was set for hearing on 8 March 2016. On 16 February 2016, Caterpillar advised that they would not have representation at the hearing and also did not intend to file any written submissions for the hearing. The hearing went ahead in Melbourne on 8 March 2016 with only the applicant appearing. ESCO made their submissions addressing the Statement of Grounds and Particulars and the evidence filed by Caterpillar. Hereinafter when I make reference to submissions from Caterpillar, I am referring to their written submissions included in their Statement of Grounds and Particulars and/or the evidence of their expert witness.

    GROUNDS OF OPPOSITION

  2. Caterpillar has opposed the grant of the patent on the grounds of Novelty, Inventive Step, Manner of Manufacture, Utility, Clarity and Fair Basis.

    EVIDENCE

  3. Evidence in support consists of:

    • Declaration of Dr Catherine Hewett dated 16 April 2015 with exhibits CH-1 to CH-3 (Hewett #1)
    • Declaration of Dr Catherine Hewett dated 12 May 2015 with exhibit CH-1. (Hewett #2)
  4. Evidence in answer consists of:

    • Declaration of Dr Paul Graeme Huggett dated 4 August 2015 with exhibits PGH-1 to PGH-2. (Huggett #1)
    • Declaration of Dr Paul Graeme Huggett dated 11 August 2015 with exhibit PGH-3.
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caterpillar Inc. v ESCO Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] APO 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Caterpillar Inc. v ESCO Corporation, heard by the Federal Court of Australia, involved a dispute over the validity of certain patent claims made by ESCO Corporation in relation to a hardfaced wear part. Caterpillar Inc. opposed the grant of these patents, arguing that the claims were not clear, not fairly based on the material disclosed in the patent application, not novel, not inventive, and not useful. Additionally, Caterpillar contended that some of the claims did not relate to a manner of manufacture as required by the relevant legislation.

The court had to determine whether certain features of the claims were inessential, whether the claims were clear and fairly based on the material disclosed, whether the claims were novel and inventive, and whether the claims were useful and related to a manner of manufacture. The court examined the specifications, drawings, and other materials provided by ESCO to assess these issues. In its reasoning, the court found that several of the claims were not fairly based on the material disclosed because they included features that were not described or necessarily implied in the application as filed. Furthermore, the court ruled that some of the claims were not novel as they had been anticipated by prior art. The court also found that certain claims did not relate to a manner of manufacture, which is a requirement under Australian patent law.

As a result of these findings, the court disallowed claims 29, 30, 32 to 41 and 64 to 68 for being not fairly based. Additionally, claims 64 and 66 to 68 were disallowed for being not novel. The court awarded costs to Caterpillar Inc. in recognition of the success of the opposition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.