Catalano v Managing Australian Destinations Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Catalano v Managing Australian Destinations Pty Limited [2012] FCA 632

Citation: Catalano v Managing Australian Destinations Pty Limited [2012] FCA 632
Parties: NATHAN CATALANO, SAM, MAUREEN & NATHAN CATALANO AS TRUSTEES OF THE EQUICAP PTY LIMITED PROVIDENT FUND (ABN 70 739 750 546) and FINE FOOD SOLUTIONZ PTY LIMITED (ABN 83 134 923 005) v MANAGING AUSTRALIAN DESTINATIONS PTY LIMITED (ABN 58 070 373 689), BYRON KURTH, JUY HEPNER, THE GOURMET DIM SIM COMPANY PTY LIMITED (ACN 156 541 712) and BEN LYDEN
File number(s): NSD 715 of 2012
Judge: YATES J
Date of judgment: 14 June 2012
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – application under s 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – alleged breach of directors’ duties – alleged contravention of s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law – alleged passing off

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for interlocutory injunctive relief – whether there is a serious question to be tried – whether the balance of convenience lies in favour of granting the interlocutory injunctive relief  

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 236, 237
Date of hearing: 13 June 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 51
Counsel for the Plaintiffs: Mr MK Minehan
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Shaw McDonald Lawyers
Counsel for the Defendants: Mr DLK Atkinson

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 715 of 2012

BETWEEN:

NATHAN CATALANO
First Plaintiff

SAM, MAUREEN & NATHAN CATALANO AS TRUSTEES OF THE EQUICAP PTY LIMITED PROVIDENT FUND (ABN 70 739 750 546)
Second Plaintiffs

FINE FOOD SOLUTIONZ PTY LIMITED (ABN 83 134 923 005)
Third Plaintiff

AND:

MANAGING AUSTRALIAN DESTINATIONS PTY LIMITED (ABN 58 070 373 689)
First Defendant

BYRON KURTH
Second Defendant

JUY HEPNER
Third Defendant

THE GOURMET DIM SIM COMPANY PTY LIMITED (ACN 156 541 712)
Fourth Defendant

BEN LYDEN
Fifth Defendant

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 JUNE 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The first plaintiff be granted leave pursuant to s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to bring this proceeding on behalf of the third plaintiff.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

2.The first plaintiff and the third plaintiff each give the usual undertaking as to damages in relation to the interlocutory orders made below.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT, SUBJECT TO ANY FURTHER OR OTHER ORDER:

3.The second, third and fourth defendants, whether by themselves, their servants or agents, deliver up to the third plaintiff  at the premises known as 6A Dunlop Road, Hoppers Crossing, Victoria 3029 the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment presently located at those premises within 48 hours of written notice to that effect being given by the third plaintiff acting through the first plaintiff, and that the said defendants grant access to the third plaintiff to the said premises to enable it to decommission, dismantle and carry out such other work as may reasonably be necessary to remove the said shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment from the said premises…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Catalano v Managing Australian Destinations Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 632
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, the plaintiffs, Sam Catalano and Maureen Catalano, brought an application against several defendants, primarily the Kurth/Hepner interests, concerning various disputes regarding the management and operations of the company. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants engaged in conduct that constituted misleading or deceptive conduct, passing off, false or misleading representations, and interference with contractual relations. They also claimed breaches of director duties and an unlawful interference with the company’s contractual relations. The plaintiffs sought interlocutory injunctive relief to address these issues, including the return of specific equipment, restrictions on certain business activities, and access to the company’s website.

The court had to decide whether the plaintiffs had established a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the interlocutory injunctive relief. The plaintiffs needed to demonstrate that there was a substantial likelihood that their claims would succeed at trial and that the potential harm of not granting the relief outweighed the harm that the defendants might suffer if the relief was granted. The court considered the evidence presented, including the history of disputes, the defendants' conduct, and the company's need to protect its assets and business interests.

After examining the evidence, the court found that the plaintiffs had indeed established a serious question to be tried on their claims. The court also concluded that the balance of convenience favoured the plaintiffs, as the potential harm to the company from the defendants' conduct outweighed the harm to the defendants from the grant of interlocutory relief. Therefore, the court granted the plaintiffs' application for interlocutory injunctive relief.

The final orders included the return of specific equipment, restrictions on certain business activities by the defendants, and provisions for the plaintiffs to gain access to the company’s website. The court also modified previous orders to accommodate the new interlocutory order regarding the equipment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first plaintiff be granted leave pursuant to s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to bring this proceeding on behalf of the third plaintiff.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

2. The first plaintiff and the third plaintiff each give the usual undertaking as to damages in relation to the interlocutory orders made below.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT, SUBJECT TO ANY FURTHER OR OTHER ORDER:

3. The second, third and fourth defendants, whether by themselves, their servants or agents, deliver up to the third plaintiff at the premises known as 6A Dunlop Road, Hoppers Crossing, Victoria 3029 the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment presently located at those premises within 48 hours of written notice to that effect being given by the third plaintiff acting through the first plaintiff, and that the said defendants grant access to the third plaintiff to the said premises to enable it to decommission, dismantle and carry out such other work as may reasonably be necessary to remove the said shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment from the said premises for relocation to the premises in Victoria of Rethink Group Pty Limited trading as Rethink Party Food.

4. The third and fourth defendants, whether by themselves, their servants or agents, each be restrained from representing by any means to any person that the third defendant is employed by or that the third or fourth defendants are now associated with or act on behalf of the third plaintiff or in relation to the third plaintiff’s products supplied under the brand “Crazy Dragon”.

5. The third and fourth defendants, whether by themselves, their servants or agents, each be restrained from trading, operating, advertising or otherwise promoting any business concerning the production or supply of Asian food products under the name “The New Crazy Dragon” or any name including the words “Crazy Dragon”.

6. The third defendant transfer the mobile telephone number 0405 746 423 to the third plaintiff.

7. In accordance with the resolution of the directors of the third plaintiff signed on 30 September 2011, the second defendant execute all cheques drawn on the bank account of the third plaintiff that are required for payment of the day-to-day running expenses of the third plaintiff incurred in the normal operation of its business, including for the payment of supplies and wages, within 24 hours of the first plaintiff providing lists of cheques and/or payments required, subject to the second defendant reasonably satisfying himself that such expenses are due and payable by the third plaintiff.

8. The second, third and fifth defendants do all acts and things and give all directions as may be necessary and within their power to be done or given to permit the third plaintiff, through the first plaintiff, access to and control of the third plaintiff’s website hosted by the fifth defendant and to provide all domain names, log-in codes and passwords necessary for such access.

9. Order 3 made on 25 May 2012 and continued on 29 May 2012 is modified only to the extent that it is necessary to give effect to the interlocutory order made above with respect to delivery up of the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is convenient to refer to the first plaintiff, Sam Catalano and Maureen Catalano as the “Catalano interests” and to the first to fourth defendants as the “Kurth/Hepner interests”. It is also convenient to refer to the first plaintiff and the company, collectively, as “the plaintiffs”.Background There has been a history of disputes between the Catalano interests and the Kurth/Hepner interests in relation to the direction of the company’s business and its management. More recently, from about March 2012, disputes have arisen between them about the following matters, as well as other matters:(a)The incorporation on 28 March 2012 of the fourth defendant by the third defendant, with the third defendant as its sole director, secretary and shareholder, apparently at the instigation, or at least the urgings, of the second defendant.(b)The registration on 29 March 2012 of the business name “The New Crazy Dragon”. A Victorian Business Name Extract records the third and fourth defendants as the owners of an extant business operating under that name. The nature of the business is recorded as “Asian food production”.(c)The refusal by the third defendant on about 29 March 2012 to permit the relocation of a shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment from premises at 6A Dunlop Road, Hoppers Crossing, Victoria to the Victorian premises of Rethink Holdings Pty Limited (Rethink), the company’s intended and preferred contract manufacturer of “Crazy Dragon” brand shumai products.(d)The negotiation of a lease on or about 29 March 2012 by the third defendant of the Hoppers Crossing premises, where the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment are currently located.(e)The use by the third and fourth defendants of the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment at the Hoppers Crossing premises to produce orders for shumai products placed with the company by one of its customers (Alpha Flight Services), without accounting to the company for the proceeds of that supply.(f)The fact that the third defendant and the fourth defendant appear to be using, or at least threaten to use, the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment to compete directly with the company under the name “The New Crazy Dragon” in relation to the production and supply of shumai products. The first plaintiff’s evidence is that, because of the involvement of the third defendant in the conduct summarised above, he terminated the third defendant’s employment with the company on 30 April 2012. The second defendant does not accept that the first plaintiff had authority to terminate the third defendant’s employment. It is necessary to say something more about the shumai machine and associated bag sealing equipment. This equipment, together with other equipment employed in the company’s business (collectively, the Equipment), is said to be leased by the second defendant and his wife (the third defendant’s mother) from the Bank of Queensland (BOQ). The Equipment is also the subject of a chattel mortgage in favour of the BOQ. The mortgagors are the first and third defendants. The second defendant and his wife are guarantors under the chattel mortgage. Under the Heads of Agreement, the second defendant and his wife agreed to assign the lease to the company. This has not been formalised. Nevertheless, it would seem that the company has been making regular and timely payments in respect of the lease to the BOQ. The financial records of the company show the Equipment to be assets of the company and there seems to be little doubt on the present state of the evidence that the Equipment has been used for the production of products supplied by the company under its business name, and the brand “Crazy Dragon”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although the plaintiffs have not as yet filed a statement of claim, in substance they allege, amongst other things, that:(a)The third and fourth defendants’ conduct, taken as a whole, constitutes misleading or deceptive conduct, passing off, the making of false or misleading representations, and an unlawful interference with the company’s contractual relations. They also contend that the third defendant’s conduct was “a breach of his duty of good faith and confidentiality under his then employment contract” with the company.(b)The first and second defendants’ conduct in purporting to revoke the company’s right to use the Equipment, and to sell it, was without any proper legal basis and was a breach of the Heads of Agreement (specifically of the term to assign the lease to the company) as well as a breach by the second defendant of his duties as a director of the company. They also contend that the first and second defendants’ conduct constitutes an unlawful interference with the company’s contractual relations. (c)The second defendant’s conduct in refusing to authorise payment of the company’s expenses in a timely manner is a breach of the resolution made on 30 September 2011 and a breach of the second defendant’s duties as a director of the company.(d)The conduct of the fifth defendant in denying access to the company’s website is an “interference with contractual relations”. Application under s 237 of the Corporations Act The first plaintiff submits, and I accept, that this is an appropriate case for granting leave to the first plaintiff under s 237 of the Act to bring proceedings on behalf of the company in relation to the relief claimed in the originating process. The first plaintiff is an officer of the company: see s 236(1). As the relief sought is in respect of the company’s claims against, principally, the Kurth/Hepner interests, which can be seen to own 50% of the company’s issued shares and to have equal representation on the company’s board of directors, I am satisfied that it is probable that the company will not itself bring the proceedings or, alternatively, properly take responsibility for them or for the steps in them: see s 237(2)(a). Indeed, the second defendant has made clear his position that he does not give permission for the present proceedings to be brought against the Kurth/Hepner interests. On the evidence presently before me, I am satisfied that the first plaintiff is acting in good faith and that it is in the best interests of the company that he be granted the leave that he seeks: see s 237(2)(b) and (c). For the reasons I will give, I am also satisfied that the first plaintiff has established that there is a serious question to be tried in relation to the relief that is presently claimed: see s 237(2)(d). The first plaintiff has not given prior written notice of his application to seek leave: see s 237(2)(e)(i). Nevertheless, I am satisfied that it is appropriate that leave should be granted: see s 237(2)(e)(ii). Claim for interlocutory relief – serious question to be tried