Cat Media Pty Ltd v Apex Marketing Group LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Cat Media Pty Ltd to extension of time for registration of trade mark application 810133 Hair No More proceeding in the name of Apex Marketing Group LLC.

Delegate:

Iain Thompson

Representation:

Opponent

.Written submissions by Brian Elkington of Clayton Utz

Applicant

Andrew Fox of Counsel instructed by Janet Lazzaro of Goldrick Farrell Mullin.

Decision:

1. s224(2) Extension of time in which to pay registration fee.  Opposition not established – time extended

2 Costs ordered against opponent.

Background

  1. This matter flows directly from that decided by Hearing Officer Skivington in Cat Media Pty Limited v Apex Marketing Group LLC [2004] ATMO 31. The applicant, in that matter, Apex Marketing Group LLC (‘Apex’) was represented by Mr Mark Landyn, Director and Chief Executive Officer of the applicant, who attended by teleconference from the USA.

  2. Material to this decision, Ms Skivington found:

    On the basis of the facts before me I am satisfied that the applicant [Apex] was the first user, in Australia, of its trade mark HAIR NO MORE, in relation to 'the same kind of thing' - Re Hicks' Trade Mark (1897) 22 VLR 636. It follows that in terms of section 58 of the Act, the applicant is the owner in Australia, of the trade mark, HAIR NO MORE.

  3. Ms Skivington appears to have concluded that, on the evidence before her, Apex made first public use of its trade mark in Australia in November 1998, whereas Cat Media Pty Ltd (‘Cat’) made first public use of its trade mark in Australia some six months later in May 1999.

  4. Ms Skivington decided:

    None of the grounds of opposition relied on by the opponent [Cat] has been established. Therefore, the applicant's trade mark may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until the appeal has been decided or discontinued.

  5. No appeal against Ms Skivington’s decision was filed by Cat.

  6. Mr Landyn attests that he believed that the registration fees had been paid and that it was a matter of time until he received a certificate of registration.  At the time of, and subsequent to the hearing by Ms Skivington, I gather that, with responsibility for the application divided between Mr Landyn and his then legal representatives, each believed the other to be responsible for the payment of this fee.  This fee was not paid despite a standard notice from the office to his address for service (which appears to have been Cowley Hearne, Lawyers), Apex’s legal advisors at that time.  Mr Landyn is now represented by Ms Janet Lazzaro of Goldrick Farrell Mullin, Solicitors, and Apex has applied for an extension of time in terms of subsection 224(2) in which to pay the registration fee.

  7. This application has been opposed by Cat.  Cat have re-filed and re-served the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cat Media Pty Ltd v Apex Marketing Group LLC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition to an application for an extension of time for the final registration of a trade mark, heard by a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The applicant was Apex Marketing Group LLC, and the opponent was Cat Media Pty Ltd. Apex sought an extension of time to complete the registration process for the trade mark HAIR NO MORE, while Cat Media opposed this extension.

The primary legal issue before the delegate was whether to grant Apex's application for an extension of time under section 224 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth). This required the delegate to consider whether the delay in completing the registration was due to an error, omission, or circumstances beyond Apex's control. The delegate also had to assess the length of the requested extension, the sufficiency of the reasons provided, whether a proper case had been made out, and the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest.

In reaching a decision, the delegate noted that a prior decision had established Apex as the owner of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE in Australia. Applying the principles from relevant case law, the delegate balanced the competing interests. The delegate found that Cat Media, not being the owner of the trade mark, could not be disadvantaged by its registration. Furthermore, the delegate considered it to be in the public interest to ensure the Register accurately reflected trade mark ownership with minimal expense. Consequently, the delegate allowed Apex's application, extending the date for final registration to 16 May 2005, and awarded Apex its costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The dispute between Cat Media Pty Ltd and Apex Marketing Group LLC pertains to the extension of time for the final registration of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE. This opposition to the extension of time was heard in Sydney on 12 February 2007. The applicant, Cat Media, was represented by Andrew Fox of Counsel, instructed by Janet Lazzaro of Goldrick Farrell Mullin, while the opponent, Apex Marketing, was represented by its Managing Director, Mark Landyn, who attended the hearing by teleconference from the USA. Cat Media did not appear and was not represented at the hearing.

The factual background to the dispute is rooted in the ownership and use of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE. There is considerable evidence surrounding the extent to which Cat Media has been using the trade mark and the potential impact of Apex’s request for an extension of time for final registration. Apex submitted several statutory declarations, including those from Mark Landyn and Mel Landyn, dated 9 and 19 August 2005, and Colin Goldrick dated 19 August 2005. Cat Media opposed the extension of time and provided a statutory declaration from Sonia Amoroso dated 16 February 2006. In response, Apex provided additional declarations from Mark Landyn dated 19 May 2006, Peter Reed dated 22 May 2006, and Janet Lazzaro dated 19 May 2006, while Cat Media filed a further declaration from Sonia Amoroso dated 30 August 2006.

The crux of the matter revolves around the contention that Cat Media has been destocking goods carrying the trade mark HAIR NO MORE, although this aspect is not deemed primary in the context of the decision. The more pertinent issue is the ongoing use of the trade mark by Apex in Australia. The decision to allow the extension of time for final registration hinges on various factors, including the appropriateness of the requested extension period, the sufficiency of reasons provided, and the balancing of conveniences and public interest. The prior decision by Ms Skivington, which established Apex as the owner of the trade mark, forms the backdrop against which these factors are assessed.

The proceedings in Cat Media Pty Ltd v Apex Marketing Group LLC began as an application for the extension of time for final registration of a trade mark, which was heard in the Trade Marks Hearings division of the Australian court. The matter was brought before the court by Apex Marketing Group LLC, represented by Andrew Fox of Counsel, to request an extension of time beyond the statutory deadline for final registration of a trade mark. The application was opposed by Cat Media Pty Ltd, which did not appear or present any representation at the hearing. The hearing took place in Sydney on 12 February 2007, with the Managing Director of Apex, Mark Landyn, participating via teleconference from the USA. Prior to the hearing, both parties had filed statutory declarations in support of their respective positions. Apex submitted declarations from Mark Landyn, Mel Landyn, and Colin Goldrick, while Cat filed a declaration from Sonia Amoroso. In response to Apex's application, Cat also filed a declaration from Sonia Amoroso. The substantive debate centred around Cat's use of the trade mark and the potential impacts on it if the extension was granted. However, the primary focus of the decision was on whether the application should be allowed based on the principles outlined in relevant case law, considering factors such as the length of time, reasons provided, justification for the extension, and the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard this matter – the opposition to the extension of time – in Sydney on 12 February 2007. The applicant was represented by Andrew Fox of Counsel, instructed by Janet Lazzaro of Goldrick Farrell Mullin. Mr Mark Landyn, Managing Director of Apex, attended the hearing by teleconference from the USA. The opponent did not appear and was not represented at the hearing.Evidence The following statutory declarations have been served and filed by the parties: Apex filed the following statutory declarations in support of its application for extension:ØStatutory declaration of Mark Landyn dated 9 May 2005 ØStatutory declaration of Mark Landyn dated 19 August 2005 ØStatutory declaration of Mel Landyn dated 19 August 2005 ØStatutory declaration of Colin Goldrick dated 19 August 2005 Cat served and filed the following declaration in support of its opposition to the extension of time:ØStatutory declaration of Sonia Amoroso dated 16 February 2006 Apex served and filed the following declarations as evidence in answer:Ø•Statutory declaration of Mark Landyn dated 19 May 2006 Ø•Statutory declaration of Peter Reed dated 22 May 2006 Ø•Statutory declaration of Janet Lazzaro dated 19 May 2006 Cat served and filed as evidence in answer:ØStatutory declaration of Sonia Amoroso dated 30 August 2006 There is considerable debate in the evidence as to Cat’s use of the trade mark and the potential impacts on it of the request for extension of time for final registration, if granted. I accept Apex’s submissions that, following Ms Skivington’s decision, it appears from the evidence that Cat have been ‘destocking’ goods which carry the trade mark. To an extent, however, this (for reasons which will become obvious) is not of primary relevance to my decision. What is potentially more important to note in the context of Ms Skivington’s decision is that Apex’s use of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE in Australia has continued.Reasoning Section 224(2) provides:224 Extension of time(2) If, because of:(a) an error or omission by the person concerned or by his or her agent; or(b) circumstances beyond the control of the person concerned;a relevant act that is required by this Act to be done within a certain time is not, or cannot be, done within that time, the Registrar may, on application made by the person concerned in accordance with the regulations, extend the time for doing the act. Subsections 224(5) and (6) provide:(5) If an application is made under subsection (2) or (3) for an extension of time for more than 3 months, the Registrar must advertise the application in the Official Journal.(6) A person may, as prescribed, oppose the granting of the application. This matter is not a revisit of the substantive issues that were decided by Ms Skivington. However, if it were, the position cannot have altered from her finding that Apex is the owner of the trade mark in Australia. It is in the light of this prior finding of ownership that I approach the principles that I should apply in assessing whether this application should be allowed. Guidelines upon the issues to be determined have been laid down in cases such as Vangedal-Nielsen v Smith (Cmr of Patents) (1980) 3 ALN N21; 33 ALR 144; 1A IPR 731 and Lyons (t/as Mitty's Authorized Newsagency) v Registrar of Trade Marks (1983) 50 ALR 496; 1 IPR 416. I must consider and balance whether: ·the length of time is appropriate; ·sufficient reasons have been provided;·a proper case has been made out justifying the extension; and,·the relative inconvenience to the parties concerned and the public interest.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Viewed in this light, the balance of conveniences, and the public interest, flow very much in the direction of allowing the application. Cat, despite having three opposed acceptances, is not the owner of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE and so cannot be disadvantaged by the registration of the trade mark. It is in the public interest to have the Register accurately reflect the ownership of the trade mark, with a minimum of expense to traders. This object will be most readily achieved by allowing the application to extend the final date of registration.Decision I therefore allow the application and direct that the date for final registration be extended until 16 May 2005, subject to any appeal against this decision notified to the Registrar within one month of the date of these reasons. If such appeal is notified to the Registrar, the disposition of the application for extension of time for final registration should be in accordance with the Court’s direction. I note that the registration fee was paid prior to 16 May 2005 and thus, if there is no appeal against this decision, registration may proceed.Costs Apex sought its costs, should it be successful in these proceedings. Having been successful, Apex is entitled to its costs at the official scale.Iain ThompsonHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings26 March 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began its reasoning by emphasizing the need to balance various factors in determining whether to grant the extension of time for final registration of the trade mark. It recognized that the decision was not a revisit of the substantive issues regarding the ownership of the trade mark but was instead focused on whether the application for an extension under s 224(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) should be allowed. The court noted that the prior finding by Ms Skivington that Apex Marketing Group LLC was the owner of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE in Australia was relevant to the decision.

The court then outlined the principles it would apply in assessing the application for an extension of time. It highlighted the importance of considering the appropriateness of the length of the extension, the sufficiency of the reasons provided, whether a proper case for the extension had been made out, and the relative inconvenience to the parties and the public interest. The court cited Vangedal-Nielsen v Smith and Lyons v Registrar of Trade Marks as authorities guiding its approach to these considerations.

In examining whether the application was justified due to an error, omission, or circumstances beyond the control of the applicant, the court found that the applicant had provided sufficient reasons to support the extension. The applicant argued that its failure to meet the deadline for final registration was due to an error or omission and circumstances beyond its control. The court accepted these submissions, noting that the applicant's use of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE in Australia had continued despite the destocking of goods by Cat Media Pty Ltd.

The court also considered whether the applicant had provided sufficient reasons for the extension and demonstrated a proper case for it. It found that the applicant had adequately explained the reasons for the delay and had made a proper case for the extension. The court noted that the applicant had filed statutory declarations from Mark Landyn and Mel Landyn, as well as Colin Goldrick, which supported the application for an extension.

In determining the appropriate length of time for the extension, the court decided that extending the date for final registration until 16 May 2005 was appropriate. The court noted that the registration fee had already been paid, and if there was no appeal against the decision, registration could proceed.

The court then balanced the relative inconveniences to the applicant, opponent, and the public interest. It found that Cat Media Pty Ltd, who had opposed the acceptance of the trade mark, was not the owner of the trade mark and therefore could not be disadvantaged by the registration. The court emphasized that it was in the public interest to have the Register accurately reflect the ownership of the trade mark with minimal expense to traders. Allowing the application for an extension would achieve this objective.

The court also considered whether the application for an extension of time should be advertised in the Official Journal under s 224(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). It determined that, given the circumstances, such advertisement was not necessary.

Finally, the court addressed whether the application for an extension of time should be opposed by the opponent under s 224(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). Since the opponent did not appear or oppose the application, the court found that there was no need to consider this issue further.

In conclusion, the court allowed the application for an extension of time for final registration of the trade mark HAIR NO MORE. It directed that the date for final registration be extended until 16 May 2005, subject to any appeal against the decision. The court also ordered that Apex Marketing Group LLC was entitled to its costs at the official scale.