Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2016] QLAC 1

PARTIES:

CASELDAN PTY LTD (ACN 100 589 571) AS TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 705893791

(appellant)

v
MORETON BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

LAC No. 001-15

Land Court No. AQL809-12

DIVISION:

Land Appeal Court of Queensland

PROCEEDING:

Appeal from the Land Court of Queensland

ORIGINATING COURT:

Land Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

24 June 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

31 March 2015 – 2 April 2015

THE COURT:

Peter Lyons J
PA Smith, Member of the Land Court
WL Cochrane, Member of the Land Court

ORDERS:

1.       The appeal is allowed

2.       Compensation is determined in the amount of Four Million, One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($4,100,000).

CATCHWORDS:

REAL PROPERTY – COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND – compensation – assessment – market value – highest and best use – where land used as a golf course was compulsorily acquired by Council for “recreation ground purposes” – whether the subject site could be used for mixed use development – consideration of access alternatives in the context of surrounding development – whether the Land Court erred in finding that the hypothetical prudent purchaser would have considered the likelihood of obtaining appropriate access for development on the subject site was low – whether the Land Court erred in concluding that the highest and best use of the land was for sport and recreation purposes

REAL PROPERTY – COMPULSORY ACQUISITION – compensation – assessment – other considerations – whether Council’s opposition to the use of its private road for access to development on the subject site was a result of the resumption process – whether the Council could have been required by the Planning and Environment Court to allows its road to be used for access to the resumed land

REAL PROPERTY – COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND – compensation – assessment – market value – whether offers to purchase the resumed land could be taken into account – whether offers were genuine – relevance

Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (Qld)
Land Court Act 2000 (Qld) s 7
Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) s 324, s 325, s 329(1)(b), s 344, s 345

Auxil Pty Ltd & Anor v Terranova & Ors (2009) 260 ALR 164
Baiyai Pty Ltd v Guy [2009] NSWCA 65
Brisbane City Council v Mio Art Pty Ltd [2012] 2 Qd R 1
Chen v Karandonis [2002] NSWCA 412
Cordelia Holdings Pty Ltd v Newkey Investments Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 48
Goold v Commonwealth (1993) 42 FCR 51
Gregory & Anor v Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia (1971) 123 CLR 547
Haig v Minister Administering the National Parks and Wildlife Act 1974 (1994) 85 LGERA 143
Heavey Lex No. 64 Pty Ltd v Chief Executive, Department of Transport (2001) 22 QLCR 177
Intrapac Parkridge Pty Ltd v Logan City Council & Anor [2014] QPEC 48
James Patrick & Co Pty Ltd v Minister of State for the Navy [1944] ALR 254
McDonald v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caseldan Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QLAC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Caseldan Pty Ltd has appealed against a decision of the Land Court which determined the compensation payable to the company for land compulsorily acquired by Moreton Bay Regional Council for recreation purposes. The Land Court had determined that the market value of the land, as at the date of resumption, was $1.8 million. The central issues in the appeal are whether the Land Court was correct in concluding that the highest and best use of the land was for sport and recreation purposes, and whether it was correct in finding that the hypothetical prudent purchaser would have considered the likelihood of obtaining appropriate access for development on the subject site was low.

The Court found that the Land Court erred in its assessment of the likelihood of obtaining appropriate access for development on the subject site. The Court held that the Land Court had not given sufficient weight to the possibility of access being obtained by a loop road or the possibility of the Council's private road being used for access. The Court found that the Land Court had also erred in its assessment of the highest and best use of the land, and held that the highest and best use of the land was for a mixed use development, rather than solely for sport and recreation purposes.

The appeal was allowed and compensation was determined in the amount of Four Million, One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($4,100,000).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed

2. Compensation is determined in the amount of Four Million, One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($4,100,000).

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 July 2012, land then owned by the appellant (Caseldan) was resumed “for recreation ground purposes”[1]. Caseldan has appealed against the determination of the value of the land, as at the date of resumption, of $1.8 million.[1] See Vol 3 of the Appeal Record (AR) 502; in the Notice of Intention to Resume, the purpose was said to be “sport and recreation purposes”: 3 AR 485.General background The only shareholders of Caseldan are Ms George and her husband[2]. Ms George is also the sole director and secretary of Caseldan.[2] Reasons for Judgment of the Land Court (RJ) [68]. The land is on the eastern side of South Pine Road at Brendale, a short distance north of the Cash’s Crossing Bridge over the South Pine River. The learned Land Court Member described the shape of the land as “something like a reversed letter C”[3]. The upper and lower arms of this irregularly shaped allotment have frontage to South Pine Road at their western ends.[3] RJ [13]. The land has an area of 10.1 hectares. At the date of resumption, it was being used as a ten hole golf course with some associated facilities and a restaurant. Notwithstanding its road frontages, vehicular access was only to the northern arm, via a short service road on the eastern side of South Pine Road[4].[4] RJ [13] – [14] The land falls gently east from South Pine Road, towards the South Pine River. The eastern part of the land terraces down to the flood plain. Power lines cross the land on an easement running from the northeast to the southwest. Under the Pine Rivers Plan 2006 (2006 Plan), the land was zoned for sport and recreation[5]. That zoning reflected the zoning of the land from at least 1988[6].[5] RJ [21].[6] See RJ [73]. Enclosed within the arms of the land, and having frontage to South Pine Road, are two parcels of land, together referred to as the Comiskey land[7]. This land has good access to South Pine Road. In 2009, approval was granted for the development of the southern parcel for a hotel and motel, at a time when this land was included in the sport and recreation zone. The hotel, but not the motel, had been constructed at the time of the resumption. An appeal to the Planning and Environment Court in relation to an application for a development approval for a supermarket and some related development on the northern parcel of the Comiskey land was unresolved at the date of resumption.[7] RJ [15]. Approximately opposite the boundary between the northern and southern parcels of the Comiskey land, on the western side of South Pine Road, is Bunya Park Drive, which gives access to a substantial area of urban residential development, generally to the west. A short distance to the north, approximately opposite the northern boundary of the resumed land, is Eaton’s Crossing Road, which runs initially west, then northwest, from South Pine Road. From where Eaton’s Crossing Road changes direction, back to South Pine Road, is a short road, Apex Grove. It would appear that Apex Grove is dedicated through to South Pine Road, joining it approximately opposite the boundary between the Comiskey land and the northern arm of the resumed land; but that the constructed road surface does not continue through to South Pine Road[8].[8] See 4 AR 693.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At a further hearing on 24 October 2012, the appellant in the Comiskey appeal was unable to demonstrate that satisfactory arrangements could be made for access to the proposed development, and the appeal was dismissed on 15 November 2012[28].[28] 7 AR 1346-1355, specifically paras [32]-[33].Decision of Land Court The learned Member determined the market value of the resumed land at $1.8 million at the date of its resumption[29], resulting in what appears to be a declaration to that effect[30]. In coming to his conclusion, the learned Member accepted the evidence of Mr Gillespie, the valuer who gave evidence in the Council’s case[31]. Mr Gillespie valued the land on the basis of its use as a 10-hole golf course with an uplift of 20 per cent to allow for the possibility of some further development of that part of it adjoining South Pine Road, adjacent to the veterinary surgery[32], consistent with the view of Mr Simonic, the town planner called in the Council’s case[33].[29] RJ [221].[30] 13 AR 2673.[31] See RJ [218].[32] RJ [196].[33] 3 AR 563-564 In reaching this conclusion, the learned Member rejected major components of the case advanced on behalf of Caseldan. The first was that the highest and best use of the land, by reference to which it should be valued for the purpose of compensation, was as a site for a mixed use development consistent with a plan prepared by Mr Ovenden (Ovenden plan)[34]. It is apparent that this involved far more extensive development than that allowed for in Mr Gillespie’s valuation[35]. The second component which the learned Member rejected was advanced in the alternative, namely that the land was to be valued by reference to its potential conversion into sporting fields for private clubs or schools[36]. The third was that substantial weight should be given to a series of offers made for the purchase of the resumed land between 2005 and 2011, ranging in amounts from $3.69 million to between $6 million and $8 million[37].[34] RJ [23]; the plan appears at 4 AR 733 and 3 AR 647. Some explanation of the plan appears in Mr Ovenden’s report at 3 AR 642-644.[35] See 3 AR 593, 563-564.[36] RJ [23].[37] The offers are listed at RJ [197]. In relation to the highest and best use of the resumed land, the learned Member held that a prudent purchaser would have considered the likelihood of obtaining town planning approval for the mixed use development of the kind shown in the Ovenden Plan, as very low[38]. In considering this issue, the learned Member concluded that “(t)he availability of the loop road was crucial”[39], noting Mr Ovenden’s agreement that “access was fundamental” for such a form of development[40]. His Honour said[41],“(t)he hypothetical prudent purchaser would have considered the likelihood of obtaining appropriate access for development in accordance with the Ovenden Plan as very low and, if able to be achieved at all, to be expensive due to the need to buy cooperation in addition to constructions costs”.[38] RJ [152].[39] RJ [143].[40] RJ [144].[41] RJ [145].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.