Carson v Legal Services Commissioner and Anor.

Link copied
Case Copied 234 min read
CITATION: Carson v Legal Services Commissioner and Anor. [2000] NSWSC 64 revised - 24/02/2000
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 12553/97
HEARING DATE(S): 25/5/98,26/5/98,27/5/98,28/5/98,29/5/98,
1/6/98,2/7/98,3/6/98,4/6/98,5/6/98,
9/6/98,10/6/98,11/6/98,12/6/98,
16/6/98,17/6/98,18/6/98
JUDGMENT DATE: 23 February 2000

PARTIES :


Nicholas Roderick CARSON - Claimant
Legal Services Commissioner - First Opponent
Legal Services Tribunal - Second Oponent
JUDGMENT OF: Simpson J at 1
COUNSEL : Mr P Brereton SC - Claimant
Mr W Haylen QC with Mr M Marien - Opponent
SOLICITORS: Atanaskovic Hartnell - Claimant
I V Knight, Crown Solicitor - Opponent
LEGISLATION CITED: Legal Profession Act 1987
CASES CITED: See Appendix C
DECISION: Orders deferred.

INDEX TO JUDGMENT

      Paragraph No.
      1. INTRODUCTORY
      19 The Summons
      23 The Evidence
      24 The Background
      55 Rajski’s Complaint to the LSC
      59 The Complaint and Information in the Tribunal
      60 THE GROUNDS IN THE SUMMONS
      1. The first decision (s.138(2)):
      Ground 1 of the Summons.

      61 Facts

      72 (a) Do the Rules of Procedural Fairness apply to a decision under s 138(2) of the Legal Profession Act?

      91 (b) Was the obligation to observe the rules of procedural fairness adequately discharged?

      96 (c) Reasonableness.

      113 2. The second decision: s 155:
      Ground 2 of the Summons: Procedural Fairness

      135 OTHER PROCEDURAL MATTERS

      3. Ground 3 of the Summons

      138 Facts

      144 4. Ground 4 of the Summons

      145 Duplicity: professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct

      156 Unsatisfactory professional conduct in respect of conduct occurring before 1 January 1988

      159 Unsatisfactory professional conduct in respect of conduct occurring more than three years before the date of the complaint.

      164 The Information is brought in respect of conduct some of which is not the subject of any complaint - not a complaint as required by s 167.

      169 5. Ground 5 of the Summons

      171 Delay

      180 Unfair and improper investigation

      183 Improperly obtained evidence

      186 SUBSTANTIVE MATTERS

      Ground 5.5 in the Summons:
      Abuse of Process

      193 Ground 1 in the Information
      Wood and Donaldson

      195 Facts

      231 Ground 2 in the Information
      Legal Aid

      234 Facts

      286 Ground 3 of the Information
      Carneys Defamation Proceedings

      287 Facts

      312 Ground 4 in the Information
      Yerushalmy

      313 Facts

      318 Ground 5 in the Information
      Dr Metcalf

      319 Facts

      346 Ground 6 in the Information
      The Fairfax Defamation Proceedings.

      350 Facts

      373 Ground 7 in the Information

      376 Ground 7(v) -
      Costs - Defamation Proceedings before Hunt J

      377 Facts

      383 Ground 7 (vi) -
      Tutor Application

      384 Facts

      406 Ground 7 (viii)
      Costs in the Application before Campbell J.

      407 Facts

SUMMARY OF CONCLUSIONS

      Paragraph No.
      90 The rules of procedural fairness apply to a decision under s.138(2) of Legal Profession Act 1987 to accept a complaint out of time.

      95 The requirements of the rules of procedural fairness were adequately met in this respect.

      112 It was not unreasonable for the LSC to accept the complaint out of time.

      116 The rules of procedural fairness apply to a decision under s 155 of the Act to institute proceedings in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carson v Legal Services Commissioner and Anor. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 64
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a claim for judicial review by Nicholas Roderick Carson, a legal practitioner, against two decisions made by the Legal Services Commissioner (LSC) and the Legal Services Tribunal (Tribunal) under the Legal Profession Act 1987. The claimant sought to have the decisions declared void, and to permanently stay the proceedings in the Tribunal. The legal issues before the Court included whether the LSC was required to observe the rules of procedural fairness in deciding to accept a complaint out of time and to institute proceedings in the Tribunal, as well as whether the proceedings in the Tribunal were an abuse of process, oppressive, or vexatious. The Court found that the rules of procedural fairness applied to both decisions, and that the LSC had adequately met its obligations in relation to the decision to accept the complaint out of time, but had failed to observe the rules of procedural fairness in deciding to institute proceedings in the Tribunal. However, the Court declined to declare the decisions void, and instead ordered the parties be given an opportunity to be heard on the form of the orders to be made.

The Court found that the LSC was not unreasonable in deciding to accept the complaint out of time, as the allegations concerned serious misconduct that needed to be investigated. However, the Court held that the LSC had not afforded the claimant procedural fairness in deciding to institute proceedings in the Tribunal, as the claimant was not provided with an opportunity to respond to the complaint before the Information was filed. The Court also found that although there were delays in the investigation and proceedings, and some procedural irregularities, these did not warrant a stay of the proceedings as an abuse of process.

In relation to the substantive allegations against the claimant, the Court found that it would not be open to the Tribunal to find the claimant guilty of professional misconduct in relation to some of the grounds in the Information, including those concerning the approaches to Wood and Donaldson, the advice given to Yerushalmy, and the evidence given in the Fairfax defamation proceedings. The Court found that there was evidence capable of establishing that the claimant had acted improperly in relation to the grant of legal aid to Rajski and Raybos, and that this ground should not be deleted from the Information.

In summary, the Court held that while there were some procedural failings, these did not warrant a declaration that the decisions were void, or a permanent stay of the proceedings. The Court ordered the parties be given an opportunity to be heard on the form of the orders to be made, and that certain grounds in the Information be deleted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.