Carmody and Minister for Transport and Regional Services

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2007] AATA 1411

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No A2007/12

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION )
Re BERNADETTE CARMODY

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR TRANSPORT AND REGIONAL SERVICES

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Mr S. Webb, Member

Date8 June 2007

PlaceCanberra

Decision The decision under review is set aside, and in place thereof the Tribunal decides that Ms Carmody’s application to import her CJ750 Chiang Jiang motorcycle is approved.  

..............signed...............................

Mr S. Webb, Member

Was the motorcycle manufactured before 1 January 1989?

10.     Ms Carmody submits that the motorcycle was manufactured prior to 1989, in all likelihood in 1957.  She says that the motorcycle was assembled from parts that were manufactured a long time ago, certainly before 1989.

11. The word ‘manufacture’ is given meaning at s.5 of the Act, as “in relation to a road vehicle, includes modify the vehicle and assemble the vehicle”. That definition is modified for the purposes of Division 4.1 of the Regulations, and does not include ‘modify’ for that purpose (Reg 7A). Thus it can be seen that a vehicle that was assembled after 1 January 1989 is not within the terms of Reg 17, which only applies to vehicles “manufactured” before that date.

12.     To be within the terms of Reg 17, necessarily, the motorcycle must have been manufactured prior to 1 January 1989.  Doing the best with the available evidence, it appears that Ms Carmody’s CJ750 motorcycle was not.

13.     I am reasonably satisfied on Ms Carmody’s own evidence (and there is no probative evidence on this point) that the motorcycle was assembled in response to her order in 2004.  It is possible that the vehicle components were manufactured at some earlier time, possibly before 1 January 1989.  Even if there was some probative evidence to support that conclusion, which there is not, it would not assist Ms Carmody’s case. 

14.     Ms Carmody did not contest that the motorcycle is a ‘road motor vehicle’ as defined[10].  I am satisfied that it is and so find.  

[10] Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989, section 5.

15.     The definition of ‘manufacture’ is inclusive in its terms and is not precise.  The ordinary meaning of the word is “the making of goods or wares by manual labour or machinery… to make in any manner… to work up (material) into form for use… to produce by mere mechanical industry without inspiration”[11].  The meaning of ‘manufacture’ and related terms has long been the subject of consideration in patent law cases[12].  The principles enunciated, albeit primarily in relation to issues of patents and the manner of manufacture and derived from the Statute of Monopolies 1623[13], are nonetheless apposite here.  Thus, as the manner of manufacture is essentially concerned with the practice, means and product of making, ‘manufacture’ pertains to the bringing into existence or the material improvement of a tangible product whereby a physical change or transformation is effected.  The product in issue here is Ms Carmody’s motorcycle.  The method of its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carmody and Minister for Transport and Regional Services and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] AATA 1411
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Carmody, sought judicial review of a decision made by the respondent, the Minister for Transport and Regional Services, to refuse her application to import a non-standard road vehicle, a CJ750 Chiang Jiang motorcycle. The refusal was based on the vehicle's lack of an identification plate and alleged non-compliance with the Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 and the Motor Vehicle Standards Regulations 1989. Ms Carmody argued that the vehicle met the definition of a 'manufacture' and that she had owned and used the vehicle for a continuous period of 12 months. The court was required to determine the interpretation of the relevant statutory terms and whether the Minister exercised his discretion appropriately.

The court examined the meaning of 'manufacture' and 'owned and used' for a continuous period of 12 months, considering relevant case law and statutory provisions. The court held that the Minister's interpretation of these terms was not the only possible interpretation and that the decision was made without adequate consideration of the relevant factors. The court also noted that the Minister's discretion was not exercised appropriately, as he did not consider all relevant factors and did not provide reasons for his decision. The court found that the decision was flawed and set it aside.

The court ordered that the decision under review be set aside, and in its place, the Tribunal decide that Ms Carmody's application to import her CJ750 Chiang Jiang motorcycle is approved. The court did not make any further orders, as the setting aside of the decision was sufficient to resolve the dispute.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside, and in place thereof the Tribunal decides that Ms Carmody’s application to import her CJ750 Chiang Jiang motorcycle is approved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established