Carlino v Leichhardt Municipal Council

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
Reported Decision: (2005) 144 LGERA 235

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION:

Carlino v Leichhardt Municipal Council [2005] NSWLEC 198

PARTIES:

APPELLANT:
Sam Anthony Carlino

RESPONDENT:
Leichhardt Municipal Council

FILE NUMBER(S):

60005 of 2004

CORAM:

Lloyd J

KEY ISSUES:

Appeal :- severity of Local Court sentence

Environmental Offences: - contravention of condition of development consent - permanent harm - serious offence - general deterrence - specific deterrence - principle of even-handedness

Prosecution: - plea of guilty - penalty - mitigation

LEGISLATION CITED:

Crime (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), ss 3A, 10, 17, 21A(2) and (3)
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), ss 76A(1)(b), 125(1), 126, 127(3)
Fines Act 1996, s 6
Leichhardt Local Environment Plan 2000
Development Control Plan No. 21.

CASES CITED:

Axer Pty Ltd v Environmental Protection Authority (1993) 113 LGERA 357;
Bankstown City Council v Taouk Constructions Pty Ltd [2004] NSWLEC 402;
Bayley v Leichhardt Municipal Council [2005] NSWLEC 34;
Camilleri's Stock Feed Pty Limited v Environment Protection Authority (1993) NSWLR 683;
Capral Aluminium Ltd v WorkCover Authority of New South Wales (Inspector Mayo-Ramsay) (2000) 49 NSWLR 61;
Fletcher Constructions Australia Limited v WorkCover Authority of New South Wales (Inspector Fisher) (1999) 91 IR 66;
Hannah v Wonah Pty Ltd (1992) 34 AILR 333;
Hornsby Shire Council v Atifame Pty Limited & Anor [1999] NSWLEC 69;
Inspector Petar Ankucic v William George Young [2004] NSWIRComm 184;
Keir v Sutherland Shire Council [2004] NSWLEC 754;
Ku-ring-gai Council v Nettcorp Pty Ltd [2003] NSWLEC 203;
Lawrenson Diecasting Pty Ltd v WorkCover Authority of New South Wales (Inspector Ch'ng) (1999) 90 IR 464;
Mosman Municipal Council v Menai Excavations Pty Limited (2002) LGERA 89;
R v Luong Doan (2000) 40 NSWLR 115 ;
R v Oliver (1980) 7 A Crim R 174;
R v Rushby [1977] 1 NSWLR 594;
R v Thomson; R v Houlton (2000) 49 NSWLR 383;
R v Visconti (1982) 2 NSWLR 104;
Sutherland Shire Council v Nustas [2004] NSWLEC 608 ;
Sutherland Shire Council v Upper Class Developments Pty Ltd [2003] NSWLEC 414;
Walden v Hensler (1987) 163 CLR 561;
Willoughby City Council v P and V Masonry Pty Limited [2003] NSWLEC 312;
WorkCover Authority of New South Wales (Inspector Kelsey) v University of Sydney [1977] NSWIRComm 44

DATES OF HEARING: 12/04/2005; 13/04/2005 and 14/04/2005 (written submissions)
 
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 


04/27/2005

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

APPELLANT:
D Gasic (barrister)
SOLICITORS:
MatthewsFolbigg

RESPONDENT:
T G Howard (barrister)
SOLICITORS:
Ritchie & Castellan


JUDGMENT:

- 10 -

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      LLOYD J

      Wednesday, 27 April 2005

      LEC No. 60005 of 2004

      CARLINO v LEICHHARDT MUNICIPAL COUNCIL [2005] NSWLEC 198

      JUDGMENT

Introduction

1 LLOYD J: The offender, Mr Sam Carlino, appeals against the severity of the sentence imposed by Magistrate S G Seagrave in proceedings prosecuted by the Leichhardt Council (the “Council”) in the Balmain Local Court for a contravention of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlino v Leichhardt Municipal Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWLEC 198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sam Carlino appeals against the sentence imposed by Magistrate S G Seagrave in the Balmain Local Court for a contravention of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) (the "EP&A Act"). The offender pleaded guilty to carrying out development not in accordance with the conditions of development consent (DA/2001/80) contrary to s 76A(1)(b) of the EP&A Act. The maximum penalty for an offence against this section is a fine of $1,100,000: EP&A Act, s 126. Pursuant to s 127(3) of the EP&A Act, however, the maximum monetary penalty that the Local Court Magistrate could impose in respect of this offence was 1,000 penalty units, being $110,000: Crime (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), s 17. On 1 October 2004, Magistrate Seagrave convicted the offender and fined him the sum of $30,250 and ordered him to pay court costs of $63.00 and the costs of the prosecutor in the agreed sum of $3,800. The court's task in these proceedings is to re-exercise the sentencing discretion and determine the appropriate penalty for the offence. The primary consideration in sentencing is the objective gravity or seriousness of the offence. A number of factors indicate the seriousness of the offence in question. Firstly, the actual or likely consequences of a breach may be taken into account in assessing the gravity of the offence. Here, the maximum penalty is $1,100,000. Such a large penalty indicates the gravity of the offence as perceived by the community. The task of the court is to assess the relative seriousness of the offender’s particular offence in relation to a worst case for which the maximum penalty is provided. Having determined the relative seriousness of the offence, the penalty to be imposed is that which approximately correlates upon the scale of penalty set by the legislature from zero to the maximum. The maximum penalty of $1,100,000 for an offence against s 125(1) of the EP&A Act reflects the public expression by Parliament of the seriousness of the offence. In addition, the following circumstances highlight the seriousness of the offence in this case. The offender was fully aware of the conditions of the consent given that it was not a consent of the Council, but of the Court. Further, in contravening the consent, the offender had complete disregard to the planning law and also for the legitimate interests of the adjoining neighbours. Moreover, as Mr T G Howard submits on behalf of the Council, the offender contravened the very conditions which, it may be inferred, gave the Court sufficient comfort to approve the construction of the garage. Finally, although the most recent modification consent (allowing use of the stone blocks in front of the concrete block wall) may ameliorate some of the actual harm caused by the contravention, that consent neither minimises nor diminishes the actual breach and permanent harm which still remains. The court finds that all of the above factors highlight the seriousness of the offence. General deterrence is also a major consideration in the imposition of penalties for environmental offences. Thus, the penalty imposed must deter not only the offender, but also those engaged in similar activities, from committing like offences and also to procure that they will take the precautions necessary to ensure that offences do not occur and the environment is not exposed to a risk of harm. For strict liability offences, however, care must be taken to ensure that the penalty imposed does not cause the offender to shoulder an unfair burden of community education. In particular, there is a need to protect the public interest by ensuring that conditions of consent seeking to minimise the impact of development are observed. Similarly, specific deterrence is also an important consideration as it aims to deter the offender from repeating the environmental offence that has been committed. The Council submits a risk of re-offending still exists. In particular, the Council submits that due to the reckless nature of the contravention, Mr Carlino needs to be made aware that, when working in an area where environmental laws and approvals operate to protect the environment, those laws and approvals must be complied with and appropriate precautions taken. The court accepts that the risk of Mr Carlino re-offending is low. However, since he continues to work in an area in which laws enacted to protect the environment operate, the penalty should reflect some element of specific deterrence. A further consideration is the principle of even-handedness, which requires the Court to consider any pattern in sentencing for the particular offence in order to pursue a consistent approach in the imposition of penalties. The court considers the decisions of the Court in a number of cases, which similarly concerned contraventions of development consents. The court finds that these decisions do not provide assistance in determining penalty in this case. The court finds that the decision in Willoughby City Council v P and V Masonry Pty Limited [2003] NSWLEC 312 is more analogous to the proceedings currently before the court. That case also involved the reckless construction of sandstone walls in breach of a development consent. The offender was aware of the requirement for development consent and believed that the consent which had been obtained for the dwelling extended to the landscape plan. Subjectively the offender was very similar to Mr Carlino, having no prior convictions, good character, a dependent family and limited financial means. In convicting the offender and imposing a fine of $5,000, Bignold J held that the offence was a “moderately serious offence” which “far transcend[ed] and [exceed] any notion that the offence [was] “trivial in nature” and consequently it should not have been dismissed pursuant to s 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW). Finally, several subjective factors, both aggravating and mitigating, are also relevant considerations in determining an appropriate penalty, but are secondary to the factors relating to the seriousness of the offence. Pursuant to s 21A(2) of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW), the Court must take into account various aggravating matters when assessing penalty, including whether the loss or damage caused by the events was substantial (s 21A(2)(g)). In this case, the damage to the environment was substantial in view of the specific conditions of the consent and the provisions of both the DCP 21 and the LEP to which I have referred. In addition, the Court must also consider any mitigating factors pursuant to s 21A(3) of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) 1999 Act (NSW), including whether a plea of guilty has been entered and the timing of such a plea as provided in s 22 of the Act. Mr Carlino pleaded guilty, albeit not at the first available opportunity, and the utilitarian value of this plea must be taken into account. Further, I accept that, as Magistrate Seagrave recognised, the offender’s plea demonstrates a degree of remorse for the offence. Finally, it must

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.