Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Carlewie Pty Ltd v Roads and Maritime Services [2018] NSWCA 181 Hearing dates: 12 and 13 June 2018 Decision date: 15 August 2018 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Payne JA at [56];
White JA at [57]Decision: (1) Direct that the appellant file and serve within 7 days the amended notice of appeal, in the form contained in the orange appeal book.
(2) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders made on 30 June 2017 in the Land and Environment Court.
(3) Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
(4) Direct that the costs of the first trial be determined by the Land and Environment Court at the determination of the proceedings before it.Catchwords: ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – Land and Environment Court – jurisdiction and powers – Commissioners – court constituted by a judge assisted by a Commissioner – language of judgment indicative of joint decision-making – Commissioners not to adjudicate – whether judgment invalid on basis that Commissioner adjudicated on matter
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – Land and Environment Court – practice and procedure – Commissioners advising and assisting judges – scope and limits of Commissioners’ role
WORDS AND PHRASES – “may assist and advise the Court, but shall not adjudicate on any matter” – Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), s 37Legislation Cited: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997 (NSW), s 81; Sch 2, Pt 3B, cl 4
Land and Valuation Court Rules, r 71
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 63; Sch 1
Courts and Crimes Legislation Further Amendment Act 2008 (NSW), s 2; Sch 14
Courts Legislation Amendment Act 2007 (NSW), Sch 2, [9]; Sch 3, [27]
Criminal Appeal Act 1912 (NSW), s 6
Equity Act 1901 (NSW), s 7
Interpretation Act 1987 (NSW), s 52
Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), ss 4, 12, 19, 24, 34A, 34C, 36, 37, 38, 57, 68; Div 4, Pt 4
Land and Valuation Court Act 1921 (NSW), ss 8, 9, 9A
Medical Practice Act 1992 (NSW), s 147
Navigation Act 1912 (Cth), s 359; Pt IX
Patents Act 1990 (Cth), s 217
Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA), s 71
Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), s 56
Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic), s 77
Supreme Court Civil Procedure Act 1932 (Tas), s 37
Navigation (Courts of Marine Inquiry) Regulations, cl 14
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 500Cases Cited: Attorney General of New South Wales v World Best Holdings Ltd (2005) 63 NSWLR 557; [2005] NSWCA 261
Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol-Myers Co (No 2) [1980] 1 NZLR 192
Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol-Myers Co [1980] 1 NZLR 185
Cameron v Cole (1944) 68 CLR 571; [1944] HCA 5
Construction Engineering (Aust) Pty Ltd v Adams Consulting Engineering Pty Ltd (Ruling No 2) [2016] VSC 209
F Hoffman-La Roche AG v New England Biolabs Inc [1999] FCA 1424; (1999) 47…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Carlewie Pty Ltd v Roads and Maritime Services and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWCA 181
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the Land and Environment Court, when constituted by a judge and a Commissioner, had acted within its jurisdictional limits. Specifically, the court had to determine the scope of a Commissioner's role under the *Land and Environment Court Act 1979* (NSW), particularly the prohibition against Commissioners adjudicating on any matter, and whether the language used in the judgment indicated that the Commissioner had indeed adjudicated rather than merely assisted and advised the judge.
The Court of Appeal found that the language of the judgment strongly suggested that the Commissioner had participated in the adjudication of the matters before the court, contrary to the statutory limitations on their role. The court applied the principle that Commissioners are empowered to assist and advise the Court but are expressly prohibited from adjudicating. The judgment's wording indicated a joint decision-making process that exceeded the Commissioner's statutory authority.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and orders made by the Land and Environment Court on 30 June 2017, and ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal. The costs of the first trial were to be determined by the Land and Environment Court upon the remittal of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Direct that the appellant file and serve within 7 days the amended notice of appeal, in the form contained in the orange appeal book.
(2) Allow the appeal and set aside the judgment and orders made on 30 June 2017 in the Land and Environment Court.
(3) Order that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
(4) Direct that the costs of the first trial be determined by the Land and Environment Court at the determination of the proceedings before it.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Commissioner's involvement raised questions about the appropriate role of Commissioners in the decision-making process of the court. Specifically, section 37 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) states that Commissioners "may assist and advise the Court, but shall not adjudicate on any matter." Carlewie argued that the Commissioner had overstepped these bounds and had, in effect, made a decision on the case, rendering the judgment invalid. The Land and Environment Court, in its original judgment, held that the Commissioner's participation did not invalidate the decision, as the ultimate determination was made by the judge. Carlewie appealed this decision, contending that the court's judgment incorrectly interpreted the role of the Commissioner.
In the subsequent appeal, Carlewie continued to argue that the Commissioner's active participation in the decision-making process meant that the judgment was not solely the decision of the judge, and thus invalid. The appeal court was tasked with determining whether the Commissioner's involvement amounted to adjudication and whether this affected the validity of the court's decision. The proceedings were complex, involving detailed examination of the interactions between the judge and the Commissioner, the language used in the judgment, and the specific contributions made by the Commissioner throughout the trial. The appeal hinged on whether these interactions were within the permissible scope of the Commissioner's advisory role or whether they crossed into the realm of adjudication.
Carlewie Pty Ltd v Roads and Maritime Services originated in the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, where Carlewie Pty Ltd sought a review of a decision made by Roads and Maritime Services regarding environmental and planning matters. The case was initially heard by a judge of the Land and Environment Court assisted by a Commissioner. Following the initial proceedings, a judgment was issued on 30 June 2017. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Carlewie Pty Ltd lodged an appeal against the judgment and orders made by the Land and Environment Court. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which was tasked with reviewing the procedural aspects of the original court's decision, specifically whether the Commissioner had overstepped their role by adjudicating on the matter. The Supreme Court was also required to consider whether the judgment was invalid due to the Commissioner's involvement in adjudication. This appeal followed the standard procedural steps, including the filing of an amended notice of appeal and the determination of costs associated with the appeal and the original proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the judgment of the Land and Environment Court is invalid on the basis that the Commissioner adjudicated on the matter, contrary to the requirement that Commissioners shall not adjudicate on any matter.
2. What is the scope and limits of the role of Commissioners in the Land and Environment Court, specifically regarding their capacity to advise and assist judges?
3. How should the language of a judgment be interpreted to ascertain whether a Commissioner has adjudicated on a matter, particularly when the language of the judgment suggests joint decision-making?
4. Does the phrase "may assist and advise the Court, but shall not adjudicate on any matter" in section 37 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) strictly limit the role of Commissioners to non-adjudicative functions, and if so, how should this be applied in practice?
5. In what circumstances can an appeal be allowed based on the alleged invalidity of a judgment due to the participation of a Commissioner in adjudication, and what are the implications of such a finding for the orders of the court?
6. How should costs be determined in the context of an appeal that leads to the setting aside of a previous judgment, particularly where the original proceedings will be remitted to the Land and Environment Court for further determination?
Held
1. Whether the judgment of the Land and Environment Court is invalid on the basis that the Commissioner adjudicated on the matter, contrary to the requirement that Commissioners shall not adjudicate on any matter. The court concluded that the judgment was invalid due to the Commissioner's participation in adjudication; the appeal was allowed and the judgment set aside.
2. What is the scope and limits of the role of Commissioners in the Land and Environment Court, specifically regarding their capacity to advise and assist judges? The court outlined that Commissioners can assist and advise but must not adjudicate, emphasizing the non-adjudicative role of Commissioners.
3. How should the language of a judgment be interpreted to ascertain whether a Commissioner has adjudicated on a matter, particularly when the language of the judgment suggests joint decision-making? The court determined that the language of the judgment indicating joint decision-making suggests the Commissioner participated in adjudication, rendering the judgment invalid.
4. Does the phrase "may assist and advise the Court, but shall not adjudicate on any matter" in section 37 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) strictly limit the role of Commissioners to non-adjudicative functions, and if so, how should this be applied in practice? The court found that the phrase strictly limits Commissioners to non-adjudicative functions, and this limitation should be applied to ensure the integrity of the court’s decisions.
5. In what circumstances can an appeal be allowed based on the alleged invalidity of a judgment due to the participation of a Commissioner in adjudication, and what are the implications of such a finding for the orders of the court? The court allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment where it was found invalid due to a Commissioner’s adjudicative participation, with implications including the annulment of the original orders and the need for re-hearing.
6. How should costs be determined in the context of an appeal that leads to the setting aside of a previous judgment, particularly where the original proceedings will be remitted to the Land and Environment Court for further determination? The court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, while directing that the costs of the first trial be determined by the Land and Environment Court at the determination of the remitted proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Carlewie Pty Ltd v Roads and Maritime Services, the court's reasoning and ratio decidendi focused on the roles and limitations of Commissioners within the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales. The central issue revolved around whether the judgment of the Land and Environment Court was invalid due to the participation of a Commissioner in the adjudication process, which contravenes the statutory prohibition against Commissioners adjudicating on any matter. The court meticulously examined the language of the judgment to ascertain whether it indicated joint decision-making and thus an invalid adjudication by the Commissioner.
The court began by reviewing the statutory framework provided by section 37 of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), which stipulates that Commissioners "may assist and advise the Court, but shall not adjudicate on any matter." This statutory language was central to the court's analysis. The court held that the role of Commissioners is fundamentally advisory and supportive, designed to assist judges without usurping judicial functions. In applying this principle, the court considered whether the language of the judgment suggested an adjudicative role for the Commissioner.
The court distinguished between advisory and adjudicative functions, holding that any language in a judgment that indicates a joint decision-making process or that the Commissioner played a substantive role in adjudication would render the judgment invalid. The court applied this principle to the facts of the case, examining the judgment to determine if it evidenced joint decision-making or if the Commissioner's role was purely advisory. The court found that the language of the judgment suggested an adjudicative role for the Commissioner, thereby invalidating the judgment.
In addressing the scope and limits of the Commissioners’ role, the court emphasized that the phrase "shall not adjudicate" is a strict limitation on the role of Commissioners. This interpretation was consistent with prior authority that underscored the non-adjudicative nature of the Commissioners’ function. The court departed from any interpretation that might suggest a more flexible role for Commissioners, reinforcing the statutory mandate that they are to assist and advise, not adjudicate.
Regarding the circumstances under which an appeal could be allowed based on the alleged invalidity of a judgment due to Commissioner participation in adjudication, the court found that if the judgment indicated an adjudicative role for the Commissioner, the judgment was invalid. This finding had significant implications for the orders of the court, necessitating the setting aside of the original judgment and orders. The court allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment, and ordered that the respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
Finally, in determining the costs of the appeal, the court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal, reflecting the successful challenge to the validity of the judgment. The court also directed that the costs of the first trial be determined by the Land and Environment Court at the determination of the proceedings before it, ensuring that the financial implications of the appeal were appropriately addressed and that the original proceedings would be remitted for further determination. This approach balanced the need to uphold the integrity of the judicial process with the practical considerations of the case.