Cargill and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Cargill and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 50 (30 January 2025)

Applicant/s:  Duncan McDermott Cargill

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/9013

Tribunal:General Member Gallagher

Place:Perth

Date of Decision:                30 January 2025

Decision:The Reviewable Decision, being the decision of the Delegate dated 6 November 2024, to exercise the discretion not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s Special Category (Temporary) (Class TY) (Subclass 444) visa under section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) is affirmed.

………………………[SGD]………......

General Member

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – decision of delegate of Minister not to revoke mandatory cancellation of visa – character test – Direction no. 110 – primary and other considerations – protection of Australian community – nature and seriousness of criminal offending – risk to the Australian community should the Applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct  – strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia – best interests of children – expectations of the Australian community – extent of impediments if removed – Applicant is a 64 year old citizen of New Zealand – extent of impediments if returned to New Zealand – Non-Revocation Decision is affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 15, 189, 196, 197C, 198, 499, 499(1), 499(2A), 500(6B), 500(1)(b), 501, 501(3A), 501(3A)(b), 501(3A)(a)(i), 501(6), 501(6)(a), 501(6)(e)(i), 501(7)(c), 501CA, 501CA(3), 501CA(4), 501CA(4)(b), 501CA(4)(b)(i), 501CA(4)(b)(ii), 501E, 501F, 503

CASES

AJL20 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1305

Bartlett and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 1561

BHL19 v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2022] FCA 313

BSJ16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1181

Craig v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 196

CRNL v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCAFC 138

Dalzell and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] ARTA 17

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185

Hambledon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 7

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 273 FCR 121

Ismail v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 2

Mayes and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] AATA 32

Metcalfe and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2021] AATA 3498

Minister for Home Affairs v HSKJ [2018] FCAFC 217; (2018) 266 FCR 591

QJYD and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] AATA 1

Re Harrison and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] AATA 47; (2009) 106 ALD 666

Singh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1273

Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594

Uelese v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 248 FCR 296

Wightman and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] AATA 1208

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Minister for Citizenship, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, Direction No 99: Visa Refusal and Cancellation under Section 501 and Revocation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cargill and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affai... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Tribunal involves an application for the review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to cancel a visa under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act. The Applicant, currently detained at Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre, contests the Minister's decision, arguing that his visa cancellation should be revoked. The key legal issues are whether the Applicant fails the character test under section 501(6) of the Migration Act, and if so, whether there are other reasons to revoke the visa cancellation decision under section 501CA of the Act.

The Tribunal examined whether the Applicant fails the character test, which he does, given his substantial criminal record and conviction of a sexually based offence involving a child. This failure triggers the need to assess whether there is another reason to revoke the cancellation decision. The Tribunal must consider the primary and other considerations as outlined in Direction no. 110, which provides a framework for decision-makers in such cases. These principles include Australia's sovereign right to determine entry and residence of non-citizens, the priority of the safety of the Australian community, and the expectation that non-citizens engaging in criminal conduct should not be allowed to remain in Australia.

The Tribunal concluded that the Applicant does not pass the character test and, after considering all relevant factors under Direction no. 110, found no sufficient grounds to revoke the visa cancellation decision. The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in the statutory obligations and ministerial directions, ensuring a balanced and legally sound decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns the cancellation of the Applicant's visa under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act, which occurred on 16 April 2024. The cancellation was based on the Applicant having a substantial criminal record and being imprisoned for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a state, or territory. Following the cancellation, the Applicant requested the revocation of this decision and submitted representations to the Delegate, who subsequently decided not to revoke the cancellation. The Applicant then applied for review of this decision by the Tribunal, which heard the case on 6 and 7 January 2025. The Applicant, represented by Mr Hamish Glenister, was appearing by video link from Karnet Prison Farm, while the Respondent, represented by Mr Jarvis Kirstenfeldt, appeared in person. Other witnesses, including family members and the Applicant's ex-partner, also gave evidence. Various documents were marked as exhibits, including statements and letters of support.

The case originated from the decision by the Delegate to cancel the Applicant's visa on 16 April 2024. Following this, the Applicant requested the revocation of the cancellation decision and made representations to the Delegate, who decided not to revoke the cancellation on 6 November 2024. The Applicant then applied for review of the Delegate's decision by the Tribunal, which was heard on 6 and 7 January 2025. During the hearing, the Applicant and several other witnesses gave evidence, and various documents were presented as exhibits. The Tribunal was required to consider whether the Applicant passed the character test and, if not, whether there was another reason to revoke the cancellation decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Making a revocation decision under s 501CA requires the decision-maker to first decide whether the person passes the character test under s 501CA(4)(b)(i) and, only if satisfied that the person does not, to then decide under s 501CA(4)(b)(ii) if there is ‘another reason’ why the original decision should be revoked.[35] [35] HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 273 FCR 121, 136 [66].THE HEARING AND THE EVIDENCE The hearing was held on 6 and 7 January 2025 at the Tribunal’s Perth Registry. The Applicant was represented by Mr Hamish Glenister, of William Gerard Legal. The Respondent was represented by Mr Jarvis Kirstenfeldt of Sparke Helmore Lawyers. The Applicant appeared by video link from Karnet Prison Farm. All other parties appeared in person. At the hearing, the Applicant gave evidence and was cross-examined. The following witnesses also gave evidence and were cross-examined:[36](a)Dr Jeffry Cargill, the Applicant’s son; (b)Ms Tracy Cargill, the Applicant’s daughter-in-law;(c)Mr Daniel Cargill, the Applicant’s son;(d)Ms Jennifer Day, the Applicant’s ex-partner;(e)Ms Theresa Cargill, the Applicant’s daughter; and(f)Mr Todd Wehi, the Applicant’s son-in-law.[36] Apart from the Applicant, all witnesses appeared in person. The following documents were marked as exhibits:(a)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated and filed 26 November 2024 (Exhibit A1);(b)Statement of Duncan Cargill, undated, filed 10 December 2024 (Exhibit A2); (c)Statement of Tracy Cargill, dated 6 December 2024 and filed 10 December 2024 (Exhibit A3); (d)Statement of Todd Wehi dated and filed 6 December 2024 (Exhibit A4);(e)Further Statement of Theresa Cargill with attachments dated 17 December 2024 and filed 20 December 2024 (Exhibit A5);(f)Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues, and Contentions dated and filed 10 December 2024 (Exhibit R1);(g)Respondent’s Section 501 G Documents, comprising 237 pages, filed 19 November 2024 (Exhibit R2); and(h)Respondent’s Tender Bundle, comprising 123 pages, filed 10 December 2024 (Exhibit R3). The Tribunal has taken into account the additional letters of support from the Applicant’s relatives, friends and community contacts.[37] At hearing, the Tribunal provided the opportunity for the parties to respond to matters put by the Member, directed at matters relevant to ‘Direction no. 110 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA’ (Direction no. 110), in their oral closing submissions. [37] See Exhibits A2-A5 (inclusive); Exhibit R2, G12, pp 188-95.DOES THE APPLICANT PASS THE CHARACTER TEST? As noted above, the character test is defined in s 501(6) of the Migration Act. Section 501(6)(a) of the Migration Act provides that a person does not pass the character test if they have a ‘substantial criminal record’, as defined by s 501(7). Relevant to the Applicant’s case, a person has a substantial criminal record if they have been ‘sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more’.[38] Further, and relevantly, s 501(6)(e)(i) of the Migration Act provides that a person does not pass the character test if they have been convicted of ‘one or more sexually based offences involving a child’. Failure to pass the character test arises as a matter of law.[39][38] Migration Act, s 501(7)(c).[39] Re Harrison and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] AATA 47; (2009) 106 ALD 666, 685 [63].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 16 April 2024, the Delegate cancelled the Applicant’s visa under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act on the basis that the Applicant had a substantial criminal record within the meaning of s 501(6)(a) of the Migration Act and was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis in a custodial institution, for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a state or territory (the Cancellation Decision).[26] The Applicant was notified by letter of the same date, which he received by hand delivery to Karnet Prison Farm.[27][26] Exhibit R2, G17, p 205.[27] Exhibit R2, G17, pp 205-12. Following the Cancellation Decision, the Applicant made a request for revocation of the Cancellation Decision and made representations to the Delegate in support of his request for revocation of the Cancellation Decision under s 501CA of the Act.[28][28] Exhibit R2, G8, G9. On 6 November 2024, the Delegate found that they were not satisfied that there was ‘another reason’ to revoke the Cancellation Decision, therefore the power under s 501CA(4) was not enlivened and the Delegate made the Reviewable Decision.[29] The next day, the Applicant’s representative was notified of the Reviewable Decision by email.[30] [29] Exhibit R2, G3, p 17.[30] Exhibit R2, G3, p 15. On 7 November 2024, the Applicant lodged an application for review in the Tribunal, for review of the Reviewable Decision.[31] [31] Exhibit R2, G2. At the time of hearing, the Applicant was imprisoned at Karnet Prison Farm. He was granted parole on 10 December 2024 and was released on parole on 8 January 2025. He is currently detained at Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre. ISSUES The issues before the Tribunal are:whether the Applicant passes the character test, as defined by s 501(6) of the Migration Act; and(b)if the Applicant does not pass the character test, whether the Tribunal is satisfied that there is ‘another reason’ why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked.[32]LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK[32] See Migration Act, s 501CA(4).Migration Act The Migration Act provides special powers for the Minister to refuse or cancel visas on character grounds. In some circumstances, where a visa is cancelled on character grounds, the Minister can revoke that cancellation decision. These powers generally involve consideration of whether a person passes the character test and, if they do not, consideration of whether there is another reason that the decision to cancel or refuse a visa should be revoked. The character test is set out in s 501(6) of the Migration Act and provides that a person does not pass the character test if the circumstances listed in that subsection apply. Section 501(6)(a) of the Migration Act relevantly provides that:6For the purposes of this section, a person does not pass the character test if:(a)the person has a substantial criminal record (as defined by subsection (7)); or …(e) a court in Australia or a foreign country has:(i) convicted the person of one or more sexually based offences involving a child(emphasis in original.)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the Applicant passes the character test.[42][42] See Migration Act, s 501CA(4)(b)(i).CONSIDERATION OF REVOCATION As the Tribunal is not satisfied that the Applicant passes the character test, the Tribunal must then determine whether, having regard to the primary and other considerations contained within Direction no. 110, there is ‘another reason’ why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked. The statutory power to revoke will only be enlivened if there is ‘another reason’ why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked.[43][43] Migration Act, s 501CA(4)(b)(ii). The Tribunal is required to form a state of satisfaction as to whether there is ‘another reason’ why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked, reasonably and on a correct understanding of the law. By reason of s 499(2A) of the Migration Act, in doing so, the Tribunal must comply with written directions about the performance of its functions or the exercise of those powers which are given by the Minister pursuant to s 499(1) of the Migration Act.Direction no. 110 On 7 June 2024, the Minister made Direction no. 110 under s 499 of the Migration Act, which commenced operation on 21 June 2024. This Direction replaced the previous Direction No. 99.[44][44] Direction no. 110, paras 2-3. An objective of Direction no. 110 is to guide decision-makers in exercising powers under ss 501 or 501CA of the Migration Act.[45] In exercising the power under s 501CA(4), the Tribunal must have regard to the primary and other considerations set out in Direction [45] Direction no. 110, para 5.1(4). [46] Direction no. 110, para 6. no. 110 where relevant to the decision.[46] Paragraph 5.1 of Direction no. 110 sets out ‘[o]bjectives’, including para 5.1(3) which provides that: Under subsection 501(3A) of the Act, the decision-maker must cancel a visa that has been granted to a person if the decision-maker is satisfied that the person does not pass the character test because of the operation of paragraph (6)(a) (on the basis of paragraph (7)(a), (b) or (c) or paragraph (6)(e)) and the non-citizen is serving a sentence of imprisonment, on a full­time basis in a custodial institution, for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory. A non-citizen who has had their visa cancelled under section 501(3A) may request revocation of that decision under section 501CA of the Act. Where the decision-maker considering the request is not satisfied that the non-citizen passes the character test, the decision-maker must consider whether there is another reason to revoke the cancellation given the specific circumstances of the case. Paragraph 5.2 of Direction no. 110 sets out ‘[p]rinciples’ which must be taken into account by decision-makers under ss 501 and 501CA of the Migration Act. These principles ‘provide the framework within which decision-makers should approach their task of deciding whether to … revoke a mandatory cancellation under section 501CA’ and are expressed as follows: 1Australia has a sovereign right to determine whether non-citizens who are of character concern are allowed to enter and/or remain in Australia. Being able to come to or remain in Australia is a privilege Australia confers on non­ citizens in the expectation that they are, and have been, law-abiding, will respect important institutions, such as Australia's law enforcement framework, and will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community.2The safety of the Australian Community is the highest priority of the Australian Government. 3Non-citizens who engage or have engaged in criminal or other serious conduct should expect to be denied the privilege of coming to, or to forfeit the privilege of staying in, Australia.4The Australian community expects that the Australian Government can and should refuse entry to non-citizens, or cancel their visas, if they engaged in conduct, in Australia or elsewhere, that raises serious character concerns. This expectation of the Australian community applies regardless of whether the non-citizen poses a measureable [sic] risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community.5Australia has a low tolerance of any criminal or other serious conduct by visa applicants or those holding a limited stay visa, or by other non-citizens who have been participating in, and contributing to, the Australian community only for a short period of time.6With respect to decisions to refuse, cancel, and revoke cancellation of a visa, Australia may afford a higher level of tolerance of criminal or other serious conduct by non-citizens who have lived in the Australian community for most of their life, or from a very young age. 7Decision-makers must take into account the primary and other considerations relevant to the individual case. In some circumstances, the nature of the non­ citizen's conduct, or the harm that would be caused if the conduct were to be repeated, may be so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient to justify not cancelling or refusing the visa, or revoking a mandatory cancellation. 8The inherent nature of certain conduct such as family violence is so serious that even strong countervailing considerations may be insufficient to justify not cancelling or refusing the visa, or revoking a mandatory cancellation, even if the information available at the time of consideration suggests that the non-citizen does not pose a measurable risk of causing physical harm to the Australian community.