BGZX and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

BGZX and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 197 (11 March 2025)

Applicant:BGZX

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/10956

Tribunal:  Senior Member Clues

Place:Hobart

Date:11 March 2025

Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

……………………[SGD]………………………..

Senior Member Clues

Catchwords:

MIGRATION – cancellation of Applicant’s Class XE Subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa – invited to make representations – substantial criminal record – attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug – non-refoulement obligations – Direction No. 110 – primary and other considerations - protection of the Australian community - strength nature and duration of ties - best interests of minor children - legal consequences - extent of impediments if removed - decision affirmed

Legislation
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Migration Amendment Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Amendment (Removal and Other Measures) Act 2024 (Cth)
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases
Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Splendido [2019] FCAFC 132
BSJ16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1181
Cargill v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 50
CRNL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] FCA 1482
Hambledon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 7
MBBG and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] ARTA 53
Minister for Home Affairs v HSKJ [2018] FCAFC 217; (2018) 266 FCR 591
NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37
Suleiman v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 594
Tanielu v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 673
VRRQ and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 9
XRGY and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] AATA 755

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 110 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under s 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA (7 June 2024)

Statement of Reasons

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made on 17 December 2024 by a delegate of the Respondent (the Minister) to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s Class XE Subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa (‘SHEV’). Such cancellation was made pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).

    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant is a 33-year-old national of Iran.[1] He arrived in Australia in 2012 from Iran by boat.[2] On 9 May 2016, the Applicant made a valid application for a Subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa (SHEV). On 10 January 2017, a SHEV was granted to the Applicant as the Minister found he was a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. Accordingly, the Minister made a protection finding within the meaning of s 197(5)(a) of the Act. On 9 December 2021, the Applicant made a subsequent valid application for a SHEV. On 16 February 2023, this SHEV application was converted to be an application for a Resolution…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BGZX and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 197
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of BGZX and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration), the Applicant, a 33-year-old national of Iran residing in Australia, sought a review of the Minister's decision to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his Safe Haven Enterprise visa under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958. The Applicant's visa was cancelled following his conviction for attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug, methamphetamine. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the Minister's decision to maintain the visa cancellation was justified, considering the Applicant's character and other relevant factors under the Act and associated regulations.

The Tribunal examined the decision under the framework provided by the Direction issued by the Minister, which outlines the primary considerations for such visa cancellation decisions. These include the protection of the Australian community from criminal conduct, the nature of the offending, and the Applicant's ties and obligations to Australia. The Tribunal considered the gravity of the offence, the Applicant's role and intent, and his background, including his mental health conditions and personal circumstances. The evidence revealed that the Applicant had attempted to possess over 10 kilograms of pure methamphetamine, significantly exceeding the commercial quantity threshold. Despite his remorse and efforts towards rehabilitation while in custody, the Tribunal found that the Applicant's actions demonstrated a high degree of recklessness and a significant threat to community safety.

After weighing these factors, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant did not meet the character test required for revocation of the visa cancellation. The Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision, determining that there was no 'another reason' to revoke the cancellation under section 501CA(4) of the Act. The decision reflects the importance of upholding the integrity of Australia's immigration laws and ensuring that individuals who engage in serious criminal conduct, particularly involving dangerous substances, do not benefit from a visa that provides a pathway to permanent residency.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of a decision made on 17 December 2024 by a delegate of the Respondent (the Minister) to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s Class XE Subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa (‘SHEV’). Such cancellation was made pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (‘the Act’).BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 33-year-old national of Iran.[1] He arrived in Australia in 2012 from Iran by boat.[2] On 9 May 2016, the Applicant made a valid application for a Subclass 790 Safe Haven Enterprise visa (SHEV). On 10 January 2017, a SHEV was granted to the Applicant as the Minister found he was a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. Accordingly, the Minister made a protection finding within the meaning of s 197(5)(a) of the Act. On 9 December 2021, the Applicant made a subsequent valid application for a SHEV. On 16 February 2023, this SHEV application was converted to be an application for a Resolution of Status (Subclass 851) visa (RSV) by operation of reg 2.08G of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (‘the Regulations’). On 27 June 2024, the Applicant’s SHEV was cancelled under s 501 of the Act, and consequently, his application for an RSV was refused by operation of s 501F of the Act. Irrespective of the Applicant’s RSV being refused under s 501F of the Act, his protection finding within the meaning of s 197C(5)(a) of the Act remains relevant for the purposes of s 197C(3) of the Act. This means that the Applicant will not be involuntarily removed to Iran, unless a decision is made under s 197D that a protection finding would no longer be made.[3][1] HB, 63.[2] HB, 121.[3] HB, 282-3. On 30 October 2023, the Applicant was convicted of attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug, being methamphetamine. He was sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 4 years, 9 months.[4] This sentence gave rise to the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s SHEV by the Minister, which occurred on 27 June 2024 pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Act (‘the cancellation decision’).[4] HB, 117. The Applicant was notified of the cancellation decision and invited to make representations to the Minister requesting revocation of the cancellation decision. Within the 28 days prescribed by the Regulations[5] he requested revocation of the cancellation decision and made representations in accordance with the invitation.[5] reg 2.52(2)(b). On 17 December 2024, the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation decision (‘the reviewable decision’).[6] The Applicant was notified of the reviewable decision on the following day, by email to his then authorised representative.[7] The Applicant sought review of the reviewable decision on 27 December 2024 in the Administrative Review Tribunal (the Tribunal), within the 9 days prescribed by s 500(6B) of the Act.[6] HB, 49.[7] HB, 45. The hearing took place in the Tribunal on 27 February 2025. The parties and their legal representatives attended the hearing in person in Sydney. The Senior Member constituted to the matter attended via Microsoft Teams video. The Applicant was conveyed from prison to the hearing room. He gave oral evidence with the assistance of a Persian interpreter. His partner also gave evidence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 30 October 2023, the Applicant appeared before Judge T Smith SC, of the District Court of NSW, Campbelltown, for sentencing in relation to the offence of attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug, being methamphetamine. In her sentencing of the Applicant, the Judge made the following comments:·The offence, which is under the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth), carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.[11][11] HB, 69.·The Applicant attempted to take possession of a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug in the form of 10.21 kilograms of pure methamphetamine.[12][12] HB, 70.·The Applicant made repeated contact with the customs broker about the relevant consignment and made arrangements for the consignment to be delivered to an address close to his residence.[13][13] HB, 70.·Police substituted the methamphetamine with a harmless substance and conducted a controlled delivery. During the controlled delivery, the Applicant represented himself as the consignee and took possession of the consignment.[14][14] HB, 70.·It was an agreed fact that there was no evidence that the Applicant knew the precise weight of the border controlled drug or that the Applicant was involved in facilitating the importation of the consignment into Australia.[15][15] HB, 77.·The Applicant was involved in contact with the customs broker on multiple occasions in regard to the relevant package.·The Applicant was reckless as to the fact that the consignment contained a border controlled drug. The degree of recklessness involved was quite high.[16][16] HB, 81.·The amount of pure methamphetamine that the Applicant attempted to possess exceeded 10 kilograms. This is well in excess of the commercial quantity threshold being only 0.75 kilograms.[17][17] HB, 81.·The fact that such a large quantity was involved does highlight the potential deleterious harm that may have been inflicted upon the community if not for the intervention of police.[18][18] HB, 83.·The Applicant’s role was a relatively important one given his repeated contact with the customs broker and the fact that he was the one that nominated the ultimate delivery address for the consignment and that it was him alone that took physical possession of the delivery.[19][19] HB, 83.·The Applicant’s involvement extended over a period of months. It was not a situation where he only became involved a short time prior to the delivery taking place on the spur of the moment with little time for reflection. There was clearly a degree of planning and preparation involved.[20][20] HB, 83-4.·This was an isolated act of offending. The motivation in committing the offence was clearly financial reward.[21][21] HB, 84.·The psychologist records[22] that the Applicant said that he was struggling financially, being out of work due to a workplace injury he had sustained. He was desperate to help his family (which consists of his partner and a young child) and it was out of desperation that he committed the offence.[23][22] HB, 158.[23] HB ,84-5.·At the relevant time of the offending the Applicant had also acquired an addiction to pain medication that he had initially been prescribed following his workplace injury and he had also commenced the use of the illicit drug heroin at some point following that workplace incident.[24][24] HB, 85.·In terms of the objective seriousness, the offence is a significant example of an offence of its type.[25][25] HB, 88.·The Applicant had no previous criminal record in Australia and was of good character prior to committing the offence.[26][26] HB, 89.·The Applicant originally came from Iran. His parents and two younger sisters still live in Iran. Whilst he was growing up in Iran it was a volatile and unstable country with his family experiencing ongoing political issues.[27][27] HB, 89.·The Applicant arrived in Australia via boat in 2015. After spending approximately 12 months in a detention centre in South Australia he was released, with him moving to Sydney in 2017. He told the psychologist that he went on to gain employment as a security guard, as an Uber driver and that he then settled into a career in formwork as a carpenter. He reported to the psychologist that within two years he was able to pursue an intimate relationship with his now de facto partner and purchase his first home. In 2019 he suffered a major workplace injury which resulted in serious physical injuries to his left shoulder and lower back. He ended up having to stop work and he suffered significant pain.[28][28] HB, 91.·Workers Compensation reports confirm that in January 2021, the Applicant underwent spinal surgery after which he continued to experience some pain. A medical report dated 24 May 2022 refers to it being unlikely that the Applicant could return to any physical work.[29]·The Sentencing Assessment Report refers to the fact that the Applicant had indicated that prior to his arrest in June 2022 he had been in receipt of workers compensation payments for a back injury incurred during previous employment.[30]·The psychologist opined in his report that the Applicant presented with symptoms consistent with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and generalised anxiety disorder (GAD).[31]·There is some form of causal connection between the Applicant’s PTSD and GAD and his offending. As a result there is some, although not great, reduction in the Applicant’s moral culpability. The moderation is not great given that there was another factor at play being the Applicant’s use of heroin.[32]·In a letter to the court, the Applicant expressed his regret and apologised for his actions. He said there was no excuse for breaking the law and acknowledged his actions as well as the harm to the community as a result of his conduct.[33] He told the psychologist that he was appalled by his actions and expressed regret with remorse.[34]·Some aspects of the Sentencing Assessment Report ‘jar’ with this. That report refers to a degree of a lack of acknowledgement by the Applicant of the commission of the offence and the impact of his offending behaviour. He demonstrated attitudes of denial and victimisation.[35]·The Applicant expressed an understanding of how illicit substances ‘ruin’ people lives but the Applicant held no accountability for his actions by stating, ‘Not responsible not my drugs’.[36]·It is a concerning feature that the Applicant does not appreciate the impact of his actions. If it had not been for police intercepting the consignment, his actions would have contributed to there eventually being over 10 kilograms of pure methamphetamine ending up in the community.[37]·Whilst in custody the Applicant had been attending Narcotics Anonymous, some remand addiction sessions, the Salvation Army Positive Lifestyle Program, a reading and writing class run by TAFE NSW, and studying a Certificate I in Access to Vocational Pathways. The Applicant retains the support of his partner and has a young son who he wants to be there for and provide a good role model for. Overall, the Applicant has good prospects of rehabilitation and it is unlikely that he will reoffend.[38]·There are great social consequences that follow generally from the movement of large quantities of drugs into Australia and there is a need to discourage others who might be tempted by the prospect of ‘easy money’.[39][29] HB, 91-2.[30] HB, 92-3.[31] HB, 159 and HB, 95.[32] HB, 101.[33] HB, 103.[34] HB, 163.[35] HB ,105.[36] HB, 106.[37] HB, 107.[38] HB, 108-10.[39] HB, 112.Other documentary evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Applicant does not pass the character test, and having evaluated and weighed all of the considerations, the Tribunal has determined that there is not ‘another reason’ to revoke the cancellation decision. Accordingly, the Tribunal has determined that the reviewable decision should be affirmed.DECISION The decision not to revoke the cancellation of Applicant’s SHEV under s 501CA(4) of the Act is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Direction contains five primary considerations, which are:(1) protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct;(2) whether the conduct engaged in constituted family violence;(3) the strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia;(4) the best interests of minor children in Australia;(5) expectations of the Australian community.[10][10] Ibid cl 8.THE OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Clause 9 of the Direction states:(1)In making a decision under section 501(1), 501(2) or 501CA(4), the considerations below must also be taken into account, where relevant, in accordance with the following provisions. These considerations include (but are not limited to):a)legal consequences of the decision;b)extent of impediments if removed;d)impact on Australian business interests. SUMMARY OF THE EVIDENCEJudge’s sentencing comments On 30 October 2023, the Applicant appeared before Judge T Smith SC, of the District Court of NSW, Campbelltown, for sentencing in relation to the offence of attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug, being methamphetamine. In her sentencing of the Applicant, the Judge made the following comments:·The offence, which is under the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth), carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment.[11][11] HB, 69.·The Applicant attempted to take possession of a commercial quantity of a border controlled drug in the form of 10.21 kilograms of pure methamphetamine.[12][12] HB, 70.·The Applicant made repeated contact with the customs broker about the relevant consignment and made arrangements for the consignment to be delivered to an address close to his residence.[13][13] HB, 70.·Police substituted the methamphetamine with a harmless substance and conducted a controlled delivery. During the controlled delivery, the Applicant represented himself as the consignee and took possession of the consignment.[14][14] HB, 70.·It was an agreed fact that there was no evidence that the Applicant knew the precise weight of the border controlled drug or that the Applicant was involved in facilitating the importation of the consignment into Australia.[15][15] HB, 77.·The Applicant was involved in contact with the customs broker on multiple occasions in regard to the relevant package.·The Applicant was reckless as to the fact that the consignment contained a border controlled drug. The degree of recklessness involved was quite high.[16][16] HB, 81.·The amount of pure methamphetamine that the Applicant attempted to possess exceeded 10 kilograms. This is well in excess of the commercial quantity threshold being only 0.75 kilograms.[17][17] HB, 81.·The fact that such a large quantity was involved does highlight the potential deleterious harm that may have been inflicted upon the community if not for the intervention of police.[18][18] HB, 83.·The Applicant’s role was a relatively important one given his repeated contact with the customs broker and the fact that he was the one that nominated the ultimate delivery address for the consignment and that it was him alone that took physical possession of the delivery.[19][19] HB, 83.·The Applicant’s involvement extended over a period of months. It was not a situation where he only became involved a short time prior to the delivery taking place on the spur of the moment with little time for reflection. There was clearly a degree of planning and preparation involved.[20][20] HB, 83-4.·This was an isolated act of offending. The motivation in committing the offence was clearly financial reward.[21][21] HB, 84.·The psychologist records[22] that the Applicant said that he was struggling financially, being out of work due to a workplace injury he had sustained. He was desperate to help his family (which consists of his partner and a young child) and it was out of desperation that he committed the offence.[23][22] HB, 158.[23] HB ,84-5.·At the relevant time of the offending the Applicant had also acquired an addiction to pain medication that he had initially been prescribed following his workplace injury and he had also commenced the use of the illicit drug heroin at some point following that workplace incident.[24][24] HB, 85.·In terms of the objective seriousness, the offence is a significant example of an offence of its type.[25][25] HB, 88.·The Applicant had no previous criminal record in Australia and was of good character prior to committing the offence.[26][26] HB, 89.·The Applicant originally came from Iran. His parents and two younger sisters still live in Iran. Whilst he was growing up in Iran it was a volatile and unstable country with his family experiencing ongoing political issues.[27][27] HB, 89.·The Applicant arrived in Australia via boat in 2015. After spending approximately 12 months in a detention centre in South Australia he was released, with him moving to Sydney in 2017. He told the psychologist that he went on to gain employment as a security guard, as an Uber driver and that he then settled into a career in formwork as a carpenter. He reported to the psychologist that within two years he was able to pursue an intimate relationship with his now de facto partner and purchase his first home. In 2019 he suffered a major workplace injury which resulted in serious physical injuries to his left shoulder and lower back. He ended up having to stop work and he suffered significant pain.[28][28] HB, 91.·Workers Compensation reports confirm that in January 2021, the Applicant underwent spinal surgery after which he continued to experience some pain. A medical report dated 24 May 2022 refers to it being unlikely that the Applicant could return to any physical work.[29]·The Sentencing Assessment Report refers to the fact that the Applicant had indicated that prior to his arrest in June 2022 he had been in receipt of workers compensation payments for a back injury incurred during previous employment.[30]·The psychologist opined in his report that the Applicant presented with symptoms consistent with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and generalised anxiety disorder (GAD).[31]·There is some form of causal connection between the Applicant’s PTSD and GAD and his offending. As a result there is some, although not great, reduction in the Applicant’s moral culpability. The moderation is not great given that there was another factor at play being the Applicant’s use of heroin.[32]·In a letter to the court, the Applicant expressed his regret and apologised for his actions. He said there was no excuse for breaking the law and acknowledged his actions as well as the harm to the community as a result of his conduct.[33] He told the psychologist that he was appalled by his actions and expressed regret with remorse.[34]·Some aspects of the Sentencing Assessment Report ‘jar’ with this. That report refers to a degree of a lack of acknowledgement by the Applicant of the commission of the offence and the impact of his offending behaviour. He demonstrated attitudes of denial and victimisation.[35]·The Applicant expressed an understanding of how illicit substances ‘ruin’ people lives but the Applicant held no accountability for his actions by stating, ‘Not responsible not my drugs’.[36]·It is a concerning feature that the Applicant does not appreciate the impact of his actions. If it had not been for police intercepting the consignment, his actions would have contributed to there eventually being over 10 kilograms of pure methamphetamine ending up in the community.[37]·Whilst in custody the Applicant had been attending Narcotics Anonymous, some remand addiction sessions, the Salvation Army Positive Lifestyle Program, a reading and writing class run by TAFE NSW, and studying a Certificate I in Access to Vocational Pathways. The Applicant retains the support of his partner and has a young son who he wants to be there for and provide a good role model for. Overall, the Applicant has good prospects of rehabilitation and it is unlikely that he will reoffend.[38]·There are great social consequences that follow generally from the movement of large quantities of drugs into Australia and there is a need to discourage others who might be tempted by the prospect of ‘easy money’.[39][29] HB, 91-2.[30] HB, 92-3.[31] HB, 159 and HB, 95.[32] HB, 101.[33] HB, 103.[34] HB, 163.[35] HB ,105.[36] HB, 106.[37] HB, 107.[38] HB, 108-10.[39] HB, 112.Other documentary evidence