Cardno BSD Pty Ltd v Water Corporation [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   CARDNO BSD PTY LTD -v- WATER CORPORATION [No 2] [2011] WASCA 161

CORAM:   MARTIN CJ

NEWNES JA
MURPHY JA

HEARD:   20 JUNE 2011

DELIVERED          :   2 AUGUST 2011

FILE NO/S:   CACV 63 of 2010

CACV 115 of 2010

BETWEEN:   CARDNO BSD PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

WATER CORPORATION
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :SLEIGHT DCJ

Citation  :WATER CORPORATION -v- CARDNO BSD PTY LTD [2010] WADC 87

File No  :CIV 2735 of 2007

Catchwords:

Contract law - Design engineering - Admission of breach of duty - Issue of which contract applies - Construction of exclusion clauses - Leave to appeal from costs order of District Court judge - Exercise of discretion to award costs - Assessment of damages - Impact of salvage value of damaged pipes on assessment - Discretion to award interest on costs incurred before commencement of proceedings

Legislation:

District Court of Western Australia Act 1969 (WA), s 79(1)(a), s 79(2)
Supreme Court Act 1935 (WA), s 32, s 60(1)(e)

Result:

CACV 63 of 2010:
Appeal dismissed
Cross-appeal allowed
Notice of contention allowed

CACV 115 of 2010:
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr A P Hershowitz & Mr R L Marando

Respondent:     Mr R D Shaw

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Jackson McDonald

Respondent:     Lavan Legal

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Anderson v Littlemore [1985] WAR 157

British Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Co Ltd v Underground Railways Co of London Ltd [1912] AC 673

Forbes v Git [1922] 1 AC 256

Gates v City Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 1

Gronow v Gronow [1979] HCA 63; (1979) 144 CLR 513

Haines v Bendall [1991] HCA 15; (1991) 172 CLR 60

Mallet v Mallet [1984] HCA 21; (1984) 156 CLR 605

Monteleone v Owners of the Old Soap Factory [2007] WASCA 79

Tenbohmer v Eden (1992) 6 WAR 366

Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2010] WADC 87

  1. MARTIN CJ:  I agree with Murphy JA for the reasons he gives, that all grounds of appeal should be dismissed, and that both grounds of cross‑appeal should be allowed, although the respondent's success on ground 1 of the cross‑appeal should be negated by upholding the appellant's notice of contention.  The result of those conclusions is that the only variation to the judgment below will be to increase the amount of interest awarded to the Water Corporation.

  2. I do, however, wish to add a few short observations of my own.

The appeals on liability

  1. All grounds of appeal which challenged the conclusion of the trial judge to the effect that the Water Corporation was entitled to damages for breach of a duty of care at common law or in contract, without any upper limit imposed by the contract between the parties, depended upon the success of ground 1.  Although ground 1 is not elegantly expressed, it became clear during argument…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cardno BSD Pty Ltd v Water Corporation [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] WASCA 161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cardno BSD Pty Ltd appealed against the District Court's decision that it was liable for the Water Corporation's costs associated with replacing defective 'Class 2' overflow pipes with more robust 'Class 4' pipes. The Water Corporation cross-appealed regarding the quantum of damages awarded. Cardno admitted to breaching its contract and being negligent in specifying Class 2 overflow pipes, which cracked and went out of shape. The primary judge's reasons are documented in Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2010] WADC 87. The contractual framework involved the 'Panel A contract' and the 'Panel B contract'. Cardno contended that the Panel A contract, which contained the exclusion clauses, applied to its provision of the defective final drawings, thus limiting its liability. The Water Corporation argued that even if the Panel A contract applied, the exclusion clauses did not form part of the contract on its proper construction.

The key legal issues before the court were: (a) whether the Panel A contract (containing the exclusion clauses) applied, or whether the Panel B contract applied; (b) if the Panel A contract applied, whether it, on its proper construction, contained the exclusion clauses, or if they had been excluded by the Water Corporation's general conditions; and (c) even if the Panel A contract, in its original form, did not include the exclusion clauses, whether the parties had subsequently varied the Panel A contract to incorporate the exclusion clauses. The court examined the contractual terms and the conduct of the parties to determine the applicable contract and the effect of the exclusion clauses on Cardno's liability.

The court found that the Panel B contract applied to the provision of the defective final drawings, rather than the Panel A contract. Consequently, the exclusion clauses did not limit Cardno's liability. The court also determined that even if the Panel A contract applied, the exclusion clauses did not form part of that contract on its proper construction. The court rejected Cardno's argument that the exclusion clauses were incorporated by variation of the Panel A contract. The court's findings resulted in Cardno being held liable for the full extent of the damages associated with the replacement of the defective pipes. Additionally, the court addressed the Water Corporation's cross-appeal regarding the quantum of damages, finding that the assessment of damages took into account the salvage value of the damaged pipes and the discretion to award interest on costs incurred before the commencement of proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These appeals concern a matter in the District Court in which the appellant (the defendant in the District Court action) was ordered to pay the respondent (the plaintiff in the District Court action) damages for breach of contract and negligence. The learned primary judge's reasons are in Water Corporation v Cardno BSD Pty Ltd [2010] WADC 87. In the first appeal (CACV 63 of 2010), the appellant (Cardno) appeals against the judge's findings regarding liability. The respondent (the Water Corporation) also cross‑appeals on quantum, in relation to which there is a notice of contention. In the second appeal (CACV 115 of 2010), Cardno appeals against costs orders made against it. In summary, from 1995 the Water Corporation was engaged in a large public infrastructure project in providing deep sewerage to Cardno was engaged as a design engineer to perform a variety of tasks in relation to the Eaton project. In late December 2002 and early January 2003, it submitted design drawings to the Water Corporation which specified 'Class 2' overflow pipes. Those overflow pipes were defective. They cracked and went out of shape, and had to be replaced with more robust 'Class 4' overflow pipes. The Water Corporation sued Cardno for the costs associated with their replacement. Cardno admitted, during the course of the trial, that it was in breach of contract and negligent in specifying, in its final drawings, Class 2 overflow pipes. The final drawings were sent in A3 form on 19 December 2002 and re‑sent in A1 form, and signed, on 17 January 2003 - collectively the 'defective final drawings'. Cardno submitted, however, that by its contract with the Water Corporation, it was not liable to be sued because, it said, there was a contractual provision which, in effect, precluded suit after 12 months, and the Water Corporation had not sued within 12 months. Alternatively, it said that its liability was limited under the contract to $100,000 (I will refer to these alleged contractual provisions as 'exclusion clauses'). The contractual framework within which the question of the application of the exclusion clauses arose involved a consideration of what was called the 'Panel A contract' and the 'Panel B contract'. It was common ground that Cardno had, at various times, been engaged to provide certain services under both the Panel A contract and the Panel B contract. The Panel A contract contained (Cardno alleged) the exclusion clauses. The Panel B contract did not. Cardno's principal contention was that the Panel A contract (either in its original form or as varied) applied to its provision of the defective final drawings and that, accordingly, the exclusion clauses applied. The Water Corporation alleged that even if the Panel A contract applied, on its proper construction the exclusion clauses did not form part of the Panel A contract. The principal issues before the judge on liability were, relevantly: (a)whether the Panel A contract (containing the alleged exclusion clauses) applied, or whether the Panel B contract applied (which, it was agreed, did not contain the exclusion clauses); (b)if the Panel A contract applied, did it, nevertheless, on its proper construction contain the exclusion clauses, or had they themselves been excluded from the Panel A contract by the Water Corporation's general conditions?(c)even if the Panel A contract, in its original form, did not include the exclusion clauses, had the parties subsequently varied the Panel A contract so that, as varied, it incorporated the exclusion clauses?