Caratti v Boban Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   CARATTI -v- BOBAN PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) [No 2] [2015] WASC 139

CORAM:   MITCHELL J

HEARD:   16 & 17 APRIL 2015

DELIVERED          :   17 APRIL 2015

PUBLISHED           :  22 APRIL 2015

FILE NO/S:   COR 60 of 2014

BETWEEN:   ALLEN BRUCE CARATTI

Plaintiff

AND

BOBAN PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED)
First Defendant

PINEVIEW INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED)
Second Defendant

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
Third Defendant

JAMIE KEVIN POLLOCK
Fourth Defendant

JOHN SHEAHAN AND IAN RUSSELL LOCK AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF BOBAN PTY LTD
Fifth Defendant

JOHN SHEAHAN AND IAN RUSSELL LOCK AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF PINEVIEW INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
Sixth Defendant

Catchwords:

Criminal law - Contempt of court for breach of injunction - Elements of contempt - No case to answer submission - Construction of injunction

Legislation:

Civil Judgments Enforcement Act 2004 (WA), s 98
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 438A(b)

Result:

No case to answer submission upheld in respect of application for orders holding first­named fifth defendant in contempt

Application for orders holding second­named fifth defendant in contempt dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr N D C Dillon

First Defendant            :     No appearance

Second Defendant        :     No appearance

Third Defendant           :     No appearance

Fourth Defendant         :     No appearance

Fifth Defendant            :     Mr J A Thomson SC & Mr T J Porter

Sixth Defendant           :     Mr J A Thomson SC & Mr T J Porter

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Roe Legal Services

First Defendant            :     No appearance

Second Defendant        :     No appearance

Third Defendant           :     No appearance

Fourth Defendant         :     No appearance

Fifth Defendant            :     Sheahan Lock Partners

Sixth Defendant           :     Sheahan Lock Partners

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

CEO, Department of Environment and Conservation v Szulc [2010] WASC 195

Commissioner for Consumer Protection v Armstrong [2015] WASC 8

International Land Developments Pty Ltd v Diamo Nominees Pty Ltd [2007] WASC 96; (2007) 34 WAR 201

Lade & Co Pty Ltd v Black [2006] QCA 294; [2006] 2 Qd R 531

Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc v City of Swan [2010] HCA 11; (2010) 240 CLR 509

Morrison v Kiwi Electrix Pty Ltd (1998) 19 WAR 482

Perpetual Trustees Victoria Ltd v Allen [2012] WASC 258

R v Bilick (1984) 36 SASR 321

Re Mycorp Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 899

The State of Western Australia v Burke [2011] WASCA 190; (2011) 42 WAR 124

Wilson v Ferguson [2015] WASC 15

Witham v Holloway (1995) 183 CLR 525

Table of Contents

Summary
Factual and procedural background
Prosecution case

Submissions as to elements of the offence
The no case to answer submission

Test to be applied
Case against Mr Sheahan
Case against Mr Lock

Primary facts
Paragraph 11.1:  liaising with Mr Pollock
Paragraph 11.2:  analysing materials provided by Mr Pollock
Paragraph 11.3:  unilaterally providing information to the ATO
Paragraph 11.4:  advising the ATO of the trial
Paragraph 11.5:  analysing and providing further financial material
Paragraph 11.6:  agitating the ATO to make a claim
Purpose of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Caratti v Boban Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] WASC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Caratti v Boban Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [No 2], the applicant sought an order for the winding up of two companies, Boban Pty Ltd and Pineview Pty Ltd, on the grounds that it was just and equitable to do so. The respondents, the liquidators of the companies, opposed the application and argued that it should be dismissed. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Justice Hamill was the presiding judge. The central legal issue was whether the court should dismiss the application for winding up the companies on the just and equitable ground and, if so, whether costs should follow the event in favour of the respondents.

The court considered the principles for determining costs orders in cases where there had been no hearing on the merits. Justice Hamill noted that where both parties have acted reasonably throughout the proceedings and the litigation was settled or its further prosecution became futile, the proper exercise of the cost discretion will usually mean that the court will make no order as to the cost of the proceedings. However, the court may make an order for costs in appropriate cases, such as where one party has acted so unreasonably that the other party should obtain the costs of the action, or where one party was almost certain to have succeeded in the matter. In this case, Justice Hamill found that neither party had acted unreasonably, and there was no clear indication that one party was almost certain to have succeeded. Therefore, the court declined to make an order for costs in favour of either party.

The court also considered whether it should adjourn the issue of costs until the liquidators delivered their report as to the solvency of the companies. Justice Hamill rejected this suggestion, stating that a report of liquidators is not a determination by the court and is not limited to considering the evidence which has been produced in court to date. The court held that it should not use a report of liquidators as a substitute for a determination of the court for the purposes of awarding costs.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the applicant's application for the winding up of the companies on the just and equitable ground and made no order as to the costs of the proceedings. The final orders were that the application be dismissed with no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin,[29] McHugh J considered the relevant principles for determining costs orders where there has been no hearing on the merits of the case. His Honour found:[29] Re Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; Ex parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622.If it appears that both parties have acted reasonably in commencing and defending the proceedings and the conduct of the parties continued to be reasonable until the litigation was settled or its further prosecution became futile, the proper exercise of the cost discretion will usually mean that the court will make no order as to the cost of the proceedings. This approach has been adopted in a large number of cases. (footnote omitted) McHugh J identified that in appropriate cases a court will make an order for costs where there has been no hearing on the merits, and these cases include:(a)Where one party has acted so unreasonably that the other party should obtain the costs of the action.[30][30] Lai Qin (624); Gray v Sirtex Medical Ltd formerly known as Paragon Medical Ltd [2009] WASC 126 [67].(b)Where although the parties acted reasonably, by looking at the undisputed facts one party was almost certain to have succeeded in the matter.[31] That party should have the benefit of having their costs paid.[31] Lai Qin (625). However, the court must not attempt to resolve a hypothetical action between the parties.[32] The undisputed facts disclosed in the pleadings, affidavits, discovered documents or interlocutory relief granted can be used in determining whether one party was almost certain to have succeeded.[33][32] Re Western Australian Planning Commission; Ex parte Solomon [2010] WASCA 236 [9].[33] Jeruth Pty Ltd v Haybale Pty Ltd [2004] VSC 319 [6]. I am not satisfied that any party was almost certain to have succeeded in the matter. The submissions of Mr Pollock and Soil and Contracting Pty Ltd (Pollock parties) effectively invite me to conduct a trial of the matter and resolve disputed issues in order to make an award of costs. They say that the extensive evidence and written submissions filed in the matter empowers the court to determine a position as to the costs of the application to wind up Boban and Pineview on the just and equitable ground. I decline to accept that invitation. The evidence is extensive and disputed, as are the submissions. The Pollock parties are effectively asking me to try the application to wind up the companies on the just and equitable ground for the purpose of determining the costs of that application. That is not, in my view, an appropriate approach to adopt for a costs issue. The Pollock parties suggest that the issue of costs might be adjourned until the liquidators deliver their report as to the solvency of Boban and Pineview. I do not accept that submission. Costs ordinarily follow the event after a determination by the court. A report of liquidators is not a determination by the court, and is not limited to considering the evidence which has been produced in court to date. I do not accept that a report of liquidators can serve as a substitute for a determination of this court for the purposes of awarding costs.