Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v AdultShop.Com Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.Com Limited [2008] FCA 423

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – non-compliance with security for costs order – no evidence as to capacity to comply - application to dismiss proceedings – deferred order to dismiss – whether should be with or without prejudice to institution of further proceedings – indemnity costs sought but not ordered

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 56(4)

Federal Court Rules O 35 r 6

Billinudgel Pastoral Co Pty Ltd & Ors v Westpac Banking Corporation [1994] FCA 728
Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop .com.Limited [2008] FCA 40
Cosdean Investments Pty Ltd v Football Federation Australia Ltd (No 3) [2007] FCA 766
Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2002] NSWCA 271
Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2002] NSWSC 18
Jalpalm Pty Ltd v Hamilton Island Enterprises Pty Ltd & Anor [1995] FCA 1498
Microbio Resources Inc v Betatene Ltd [1993] FCA 848
Minero Pty Ltd v Redero Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court, NSW, Santow J, 29 July 1998)

CAPITAL WEBWORKS PTY LTD ACN 003 384 932 v ADULTSHOP.COM LIMITED ACN 009 147 924 and MALCOLM DAY
WAD 49 OF 2000

MCKERRACHER J
31 MARCH 2008
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 49 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

CAPITAL WEBWORKS PTY LTD
ACN 003 384 932
Applicant

AND:

ADULTSHOP.COM LIMITED
ACN 009 147 924
First Respondent

MALCOLM DAY
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MARCH 2008

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant is to pay into Court the further security due to be paid on 20 February 2008 ($68,000) on or before 3 months from the date of these orders (the due date).

2.If the further security is not paid on or before the due date, the application is to be dismissed without prejudice to the applicant’s entitlement, if any, to issue further proceedings with the applicant to pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the application to be taxed together with reserved costs.

3.The orders of 2 November 2007 be otherwise vacated.

4.The applicant to pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the motion dated 25 February 2008 in any event.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 49 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

CAPITAL WEBWORKS PTY LTD
ACN 003 384 932
Applicant

AND:

ADULTSHOP.COM LIMITED
ACN 009 147 924
First Respondent

MALCOLM DAY
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE:

31 MARCH 2008

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. These reasons relate to the respondents’ (Adultshop’s) recent and urgent motion to dismiss these proceedings due to non compliance by the applicant (Capital) with an order that it pay into court $68,000 by way of further security for Adultshop’s legal costs.  There is a deal of history to this fiercely contested litigation.  Much of it has been relied upon by Capital in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v AdultShop.Com Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v AdultShop.Com Ltd, the Federal Court was tasked with addressing an urgent motion brought by AdultShop, the respondent, to dismiss the proceedings due to the applicant, Capital, failing to comply with an order to pay $68,000 into court as further security for AdultShop’s legal costs. The dispute between the parties has a lengthy history, originating from litigation commenced in 2000. The immediate consequence of Capital's non-payment of the security was the stay of the proceedings and the loss of imminent trial dates, which had been set for five days starting on 28 April 2008.

The legal issues before the court included whether the court should exercise its discretion under section 56(4) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 to dismiss the proceedings due to the non-payment of the ordered security. The court considered factors such as the prospect of Capital being able to post the security, the delays in the proceedings attributable to Capital, and the prejudice to AdultShop caused by the delay. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the dismissal should be with or without prejudice.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed analysis of the history of the case, the financial commitments made by Capital, and the evidence presented regarding Capital's capacity to pay the ordered security. The court acknowledged the readiness of the parties for trial and the substantial financial commitment made by Capital but emphasised the need for clarity and predictability in case of non-compliance. The court concluded that a three-month period for Capital to pay the security was appropriate and that the dismissal should be without prejudice to allow Capital the possibility to raise the funds and proceed with the litigation.

The court's orders required Capital to pay the further security into court within three months from the date of the orders, with the proceedings to be dismissed without prejudice if the payment was not made by the due date. The orders also directed that if the security was not paid, Capital would be responsible for paying AdultShop’s costs of the application. The court's decision balanced the need to ensure that the proceedings could proceed without further undue delay while also considering the history of the litigation and the financial commitments made by both parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant is to pay into Court the further security due to be paid on 20 February 2008 ($68,000) on or before 3 months from the date of these orders (the due date).

2. If the further security is not paid on or before the due date, the application is to be dismissed without prejudice to the applicant’s entitlement, if any, to issue further proceedings with the applicant to pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the application to be taxed together with reserved costs.

3. The orders of 2 November 2007 be otherwise vacated.

4. The applicant to pay the first and second respondents’ costs of the motion dated 25 February 2008 in any event.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons relate to the respondents’ (Adultshop’s) recent and urgent motion to dismiss these proceedings due to non compliance by the applicant (Capital) with an order that it pay into court $68,000 by way of further security for Adultshop’s legal costs. There is a deal of history to this fiercely contested litigation. Much of it has been relied upon by Capital in its arguments. The result to date of the failure to pay the security into court has been the stay of the proceedings and the loss of imminent trial dates. Those dates were finally fixed in proceedings which were commenced as long ago as 2000. For reasons canvassed below the proceedings will not be dismissed now but if the security is not paid into Court within a further period of three months from the date of publication of these orders, the proceedings will be dismissed without prejudice to the applicant’s entitlement to issue further proceedings.BACKGROUND On 30 January 2008 following a contested hearing on 17 December 2007, I gave reasons (Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop .com.Limited [2008] FCA 40) requiring Capital to pay into Court, by 20 February 2008 security for Adultshop’s costs in the amount of $68,000. That was quite a brief timeframe, but the reason it was so was because the matter had already been listed for trial for five days from 28 April 2008. The immediate consequence of the non-payment pursuant to the orders made in relation to the payment of security has been that the proceedings have been stayed. It has been accepted that it therefore follows as a matter of logic, if not by formal application, that the trial dates of 28 April 2008 for five days will have to be vacated. As a separate consequence, by notice of motion dated 25 February 2008, Adultshop moved for orders dismissing the proceedings forthwith due to Capital’s failure to comply with the security for costs order. There have been previous security for costs orders. Capital has paid a total of $65,000 in to Court by way of security for costs in favour of Adultshop. The first tranche for $30,000 was ordered on 23 August 2000. Capital failed to provide security in the timeframe stipulated by the Court and took no further steps in the proceedings for over 7 months. The proceedings were then stayed. Capital ultimately paid the first tranche into Court on 10 April 2001. A second tranche in the amount of $35,000 to cover Adultshop’s costs up to the final hearing of the proceedings was paid into Court on 20 June 2003 pursuant to orders of Nicholson J, made on 3 April 2003. The current application was brought very soon after the failure to pay in the security. It is based on s 56(4) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act) which provides that if security or further security is not given in accordance with an order under this section, the Court or a judge may order that the proceeding be dismissed. The discretion of the Court under s 56 of the Act is broad and unfettered but must be exercised judicially. In Adultshop’s submission the following matters are relevant for consideration in the exercise of the discretion under s 56(4) of the Act:(a) the prospect of Capital being able to post security;(b) Capital’s election to refrain from identifying its potential sources of funding;(c)the quantum of risk that Capital cannot satisfy an order for costs (d)the delays in the proceeding since commencement, including delays directly attributable to Capital;(e)the inability to meet the trial date or explain the delay in paying further security as ordered; and(f)the continuing prejudice to the respondents by delay.Evidence of capacity to pay

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The discretion of the Court under s 56 of the Act is broad and unfettered but must be exercised judicially. In Adultshop’s submission the following matters are relevant for consideration in the exercise of the discretion under s 56(4) of the Act:(a) the prospect of Capital being able to post security;(b) Capital’s election to refrain from identifying its potential sources of funding;(c)the quantum of risk that Capital cannot satisfy an order for costs (d)the delays in the proceeding since commencement, including delays directly attributable to Capital;(e)the inability to meet the trial date or explain the delay in paying further security as ordered; and(f)the continuing prejudice to the respondents by delay.Evidence of capacity to pay Adultshop stress that Capital has put on no evidence whatsoever of:(a) attempts to pay;(b) capacity to pay; or(c) willingness to pay;the ordered further security. No explanation is proffered for the failure of a company officer (or any other person) to give such evidence. Lengthy delays by Capital in meeting prior orders for security are conceded. The inability of Capital, unaided, to satisfy the further security is not disputed. No evidence of the intentions, capacity or even identity of historical or future litigation financiers is before the Court. Adultshop contends that the proper inference to be drawn from the absence of evidence and, in particular, Capital’s failure to call evidence of its efforts, capacity or willingness to pay further security from an officer of Capital should be adverse. Adultshop stresses that the evidence clearly shows that Capital has no current assets other than this cause of action, that the shareholders of Capital are professional trustees who have no beneficial interest in Capital or in the cause of action and that the inability of Capital to meet from its own funds a security for costs order is readily conceded by Capital. Adultshop relies upon the fact that there is no evidence before the Court to suggest any improvement in Capital’s position and while Capital was able to raise funds to meet earlier security for costs orders, there is no evidence as to the present ability of Capital to raise those funds. Capital relies upon an affidavit of Ms Yin Fang, solicitor for Capital who outlines the history of the previous security for costs orders which have been met by Capital, albeit in some circumstances with a considerable delay. The other two factors arising from Ms Fang’s affidavit are that Capital has spent in excess of the $309,000 in connection with this litigation including a recent payment made in January 2008 in excess of $79,000 in respect of costs and disbursements incurred by Capital’s solicitors. The evidence about that payment is adduced not to demonstrate that Capital was able to find those funds but rather to clarify that the payment was made at a time before any order was made by this Court for security for costs to be paid (that order being foreshadowed in reasons on 30 January 2008).Legal considerations relating to dismissal for non-payment of security

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
I consider that taking into account the readiness of the parties for trial, taking the very substantial commitment so far in funding by Capital into account and taking into account the statement, albeit only a ‘hope’ that the funds will be raised to meet the Court orders within a ‘few weeks’, a period of three months to make the payment or face dismissal of the proceedings is an appropriate timeframe. Mr Tottle has urged me to simply adjourn Adultshop’s motion but I do not consider that outcome would do justice to the prejudice facing Adultshop. All the arguments would just be ventilated once again. The orders I propose making do place some pressure on Capital but in the absence of evidence as to the impossibility of compliance with such orders and indeed any evidence on steps taken to achieve compliance of the orders, the time has come in my view for greater predictability and clarity if there is non compliance.Conclusion on dismissal application On the material which is before me the appropriate disposition, in my view, is to make orders dismissing the proceedings which will be deferred for a considerable period of time. I indicated to counsel that I had in mind a period of two months before those orders should operate. I have reflected on this since foreshadowing it in argument consider that three months would be more appropriate. I allow the period of three months on the basis that the trial is no longer imminent and the more immediate time frame in the context of an imminent trial is no longer necessary. ‘With prejudice’ Adultshop seeks orders framed in terms of dismissal of the application ‘with prejudice’. By this expression Adultshop wishes to emphasise that the appropriate order to be made by the Court should reflect that it is intended that the issues in dispute between the parties should be resolved once and for all by way of the dismissal notwithstanding there has been no consideration of the substantive issues on which the proceedings are framed. It is submitted that the appropriate means to effect clarity with respect to the status of the judgment is to adopt the words ‘with prejudice’, which reflect, in negative, the language in O 35 r 6. Order 35 r 6 of the Federal Court Rules provides as follows:6(1)Where the Court makes an order for the dismissal of proceedings or for the dismissal of proceedings so far as concerns any cause of action or the whole or any part of any claim for relief, the Court may order that such dismissal shall be without prejudice to any right of the applicant or claimant to bring fresh proceedings or to claim the same relief in fresh proceedings.(2) Where:(a)the Court makes an order for the dismissal of proceedings so far as concerns any cause of action or the whole or any part of any claim for relief by any party;(b)the Court orders that party to pay any costs; and(c)before payment of the costs, that party brings against a party to whom the costs are payable further proceedings on the same or substantially the same cause of action for the same or substantially the same relief.the Court may stay the further proceedings until those costs are paid.It is said that use of ‘with prejudice’ is desirable to put beyond doubt the Court’s intention by ordering dismissal. This was identified by Santow J in Minero Pty Ltd v Redero Pty Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court, NSW, Santow J, 29 July 1998) (at 18), dealing with the equivalent NSW rule:The rule, if not expressly then at least by implication, proceeds on the premise that a dismissal order does not automatically preclude the party originally claiming relief from bringing a new action. Although reference is made in r6(1) of the Federal Court Rules to the ability of the Court to order that a dismissal shall be "without prejudice to any right of the applicant or claimant to bring fresh proceedings or to claim the same relief in fresh proceedings", this does not, in my view, mean that a dismissal which does not include such a "without prejudice" order results automatically in a bar to new proceedings being commenced. The Rule clearly proceeds on the basis that, should fresh proceedings be instituted, the fact that a previous dismissal order has been made need not necessarily prejudice such fresh proceedings. Whether they are prejudiced, or indeed precluded, will depend on whether the parties intended a dismissal or disposal that was interlocutory or final, as manifested by the order made considered in its forensic context.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J

Capital relies upon an affidavit of Ms Yin Fang, solicitor for Capital who outlines the history of the previous security for costs orders which have been met by Capital, albeit in some circumstances with a considerable delay. The other two factors arising from Ms Fang’s affidavit are that Capital has spent in excess of the $309,000 in connection with this litigation including a recent payment made in January 2008 in excess of $79,000 in respect of costs and disbursements incurred by Capital’s solicitors. The evidence about that payment is adduced not to demonstrate that Capital was able to find those funds but rather to clarify that the payment was made at a time before any order was made by this Court for security for costs to be paid (that order being foreshadowed in reasons on 30 January 2008).Legal considerations relating to dismissal for non-payment of security The approach to exercise of the power was expressed by the Full Court of the Federal Court in Microbio Resources Inc v Betatene Ltd [1993] FCA 848 in these terms:The Court is careful to see that orders for security for costs do not work injustice to parties against whom such orders are made, but if those parties do not comply with the orders and give no evidence or explanation as to why they have not complied with them, they cannot be heard to complain of injustice if, after a considerable length of time, and extensions of time, the ultimate sanction of dismissal is applied. It is incumbent on parties in such circumstances to provide evidence of their position. Microbio Resources [1993] FCA 848 was followed in Jalpalm Pty Ltd v Hamilton Island Enterprises Pty Ltd & Anor [1995] FCA 1498 per Kiefel J and also in Billinudgel Pastoral Co Pty Ltd & Ors v Westpac Banking Corporation [1994] FCA 728 and Cosdean Investments Pty Ltd v Football Federation Australia Ltd (No 3) [2007] FCA 766. In Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2002] NSWSC 18 at [24], Einstein J listed five factors flowing from remarks of the Full Court in Microbio Resources [1993] FCA 848. Those are the factors said to be relevant to the exercise of a discretion as to whether to dismiss a proceeding where there has been a failure to comply with an order for security for costs. The decision of Einstein J was upheld by the Court of Appeal of New South Wales on that issue in Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2002] NSWCA 271. Those factors were:1.The period that has elapsed since security was ordered;2.The fact that the plaintiff has been on notice of the application for dismissal;3.The seeming inability of the plaintiff to further fund the main proceedings;4.The prejudice to the defendants; and5.The position of the Court. A consideration of those five factors in the present circumstances reveals they are quite evenly balanced:·There has not been a long period since security was ordered. Adultshop has acted promptly in the circumstances but those circumstances include the fact that it was preparing in a concerted fashion for an imminent trial. The need to act promptly was necessary. Equally, the delay in compliance with the order could not be such as to suggest contumelious disregard of the order by Capital. Generally, this factor is neutral.·As to the question of when Capital was on notice of the application for dismissal, Capital would say that in light of the nature of the order originally sought for security for costs (that is say the stay of the proceedings rather than the dismissal), the notice given to Capital has only been evident from correspondence which immediately preceded the issuing of this motion. There is some force in that argument but equally, there was always the prospect that Adultshop would apply for dismissal as it has done on a number of previous occasions in these proceedings. Adultshop could be expected to seek dismissal, especially given the history of these proceedings and the fact that they were stayed in any event as a result of the non-payment of the security on both this occasion and previously. ·On the topic of the inability to further fund the proceedings, the evidence is unclear. Counsel for Capital, Mr Tottle, urges me to take into account that Capital was close to being ready for trial and it has spent in excess of $300,000 on its own solicitor/client costs both in these proceedings and in connected proceedings such as a Full Court appeal and an application for special leave to the High Court. I do consider that the state of readiness for trial on the part of Capital and its financial commitment to its own solicitor/client costs as well as the earlier payments for security for costs are factors which do give rise to an inference that it is more likely than not that Capital will make an earnest effort to meet the security for costs order so that the trial which had been imminent can proceed. ·With regard to the prejudice to Adultshop, the prejudice is self-evident. Adultshop has also invested a substantial amount in defending these proceedings. If Adultshop is not protected with suitable orders designed to go some way to ensure that if it succeeds it will recover a contribution to costs then the prejudice would be significantly increased. That risk of prejudice should be minimised. ·Finally as to the position of the Court, it is unfortunate that the trial dates will have to be vacated in circumstances where there is a public need for the availability of the Court’s resources. However, I do not consider this factor as being particularly significant in the present circumstances. I reiterate that I am unable to draw any conclusion that the failure to meet the security for costs order is a contumelious disregard of the orders.