Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com.Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com.Limited [2008] FCA 40

COSTS – security for costs – application to vary order for further security – earlier order several years old – consideration of change in material circumstances – complete indemnity declined – order made

Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) s 56, 56(3)

Federal Court Rules O 28 r 5(2)

Brundza v Robbie & Co (No 2) (1952) 88 CLR 171
Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com.limited [2002] FCA 1420
Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com Ltd [2005] FCA 438
Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com.Limited [2007] FCA 567
Truth about Motorways Pty Ltd v Macquarie Infrastructure Investment Management Ltd [2001] FCA 1603

CAPITAL WEBWORKS PTY LTD (ACN 003 384 932) v ADULTSHOP.COM.LIMITED (ACN 009 147 924), MALCOLM DAY AND MELBOURNE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 073 716 793)

WAD 49 OF 2000

MCKERRACHER J
30 JANUARY 2008
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 49 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

CAPITAL WEBWORKS PTY LTD
(ACN 003 384 932)

AND:

ADULTSHOP.COM.LIMITED
(ACN 009 147 924)
First Respondent

MALCOLM DAY
Second Respondent

MELBOURNE INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 073 716 793)
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE:

30 JANUARY 2008

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. This litigation was commenced over seven years ago.  It has not advanced rapidly.  The applicant (Capital) is a company with very limited funds.  The first and second respondents (collectively Adultshop) and the third respondent (Melbourne Information) have previously sought and obtained orders some years ago that Capital provide security for their legal costs incurred in defending the proceedings.  The matter is now set down for trial.  Adultshop seeks additional security for costs by reason of several events described below.  Melbourne Information had also sought further security for costs but since filing its motion Melbourne Information and Capital have fully settled their disputes arising in these proceedings. 

    BACKGROUND

  2. The proceedings were instituted on 5 April 2000.  Capital has made previous payments into Court by way of security for costs.  The total of those payments was $65,000 each for both Adultshop and Melbourne Information.  These payments were made following orders which in turn followed contested hearings.  There is some history of this aspect and the steps leading to it in Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com Ltd [2005] FCA 438 from which it can be seen that on 5 April 2000, Capital commenced these proceedings following its removal (on 29 March 2000) from the register of Melbourne Information.  Capital was disentitled to use the domain name adultshop.com.au (‘the domain name’).  Adultshop became the registered owner of the domain name on 30 March 2000.  

  3. On 23 August 2000, Capital was ordered to provide security for the costs of each of the respondents. The proceedings were stayed pending the provision of security.  It failed to provide security within the timeframe stipulated by the Court’s orders and took no further steps in the proceedings for over 7 months.  

  4. On 25 February 2002, Adultshop sought additional…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com.Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Capital Webworks Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Adultshop.com. Limited and Melbourne Information in 2000, which involved disputes over the domain name adultshop.com.au. The case has experienced delays and required Capital to provide security for costs on several occasions. The most recent motion by Adultshop seeks an increase in the security for costs due to the prolonged duration of the case and changes in the estimated costs of litigation. The court had to determine whether there has been a material change in circumstances since the last order for security for costs was made, and if so, whether the increase in security requested by Adultshop was justified.

The court examined the considerations relevant to ordering security for costs, including the genuineness of the claim, the financial situation of the parties, and the potential impact of the order on the proceedings. It also considered the principle that the court should not provide a complete indemnity to the claimant but should balance the interests of both parties. The court found that while some changes had occurred, such as the passage of time and increase in legal fees, the overall circumstances had not changed significantly enough to warrant the substantial increase in security requested by Adultshop. The court concluded that the order for security for costs should be varied to require Capital to provide further security for Adultshop’s costs, but not to the full extent requested.

The court ordered Capital to provide additional security of $68,000 by way of payment into Court within 21 days, to cover Adultshop’s costs up to and including the completion of the trial. The court also invited the parties to attempt to reach agreement on the appropriate terms of the orders. This decision underscores the need for a balanced approach in determining security for costs, taking into account the specific circumstances of each case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This litigation was commenced over seven years ago. It has not advanced rapidly. The applicant (Capital) is a company with very limited funds. The first and second respondents (collectively Adultshop) and the third respondent (Melbourne Information) have previously sought and obtained orders some years ago that Capital provide security for their legal costs incurred in defending the proceedings. The matter is now set down for trial. Adultshop seeks additional security for costs by reason of several events described below. Melbourne Information had also sought further security for costs but since filing its motion Melbourne Information and Capital have fully settled their disputes arising in these proceedings. BACKGROUND The proceedings were instituted on 5 April 2000. Capital has made previous payments into Court by way of security for costs. The total of those payments was $65,000 each for both Adultshop and Melbourne Information. These payments were made following orders which in turn followed contested hearings. There is some history of this aspect and the steps leading to it in Capital Webworks Pty Ltd v Adultshop.com Ltd [2005] FCA 438 from which it can be seen that on 5 April 2000, Capital commenced these proceedings following its removal (on 29 March 2000) from the register of Melbourne Information. Capital was disentitled to use the domain name adultshop.com.au (‘the domain name’). Adultshop became the registered owner of the domain name on 30 March 2000. On 23 August 2000, Capital was ordered to provide security for the costs of each of the respondents. The proceedings were stayed pending the provision of security. It failed to provide security within the timeframe stipulated by the Court’s orders and took no further steps in the proceedings for over 7 months. On 25 February 2002, Adultshop sought additional security for costs. As it happened, this motion was not heard by the Court until April of the following year as the proceedings were stayed in late February 2002 following an application for further security for costs by Melbourne Information on 4 February 2002. Following the lifting of the stay of proceedings, on 3 April 2003, Nicholson J ordered Capital to provide additional security for Adultshop’s costs in the amount of $35 000. Capital was ordered to pay the costs of that notice of motion including any reserved costs in any event. On 20 June 2003, Capital paid the additional security into the Court after Adultshop had filed a notice of motion seeking orders for judgment owing to the non-compliance by Capital with the Court’s orders of 3 April 2003. As observed by Nicholson J:31On 21 March 2003, in an affidavit sworn on behalf of the applicant (in opposition to the first and second respondents’ application for further security for costs), Mr Edward Sweeney deposed inter alia:(a)Neither he, nor his brother Charles, had any assets upon which they could raise funds; (b)Mr Sweeney was a full-time university student and his brother (at the time of swearing the affidavit) was looking for employment;(c)The applicant had no current assets other than the cause of action against the respondents;(d)The applicant had no debts other than the funds borrowed to pay the security into the Court; (e)The shareholders of the applicant are professional trustees (one an accountant and one a solicitor) who have no beneficial interest in the applicant or in the cause of action; and(f)The applicant was impecunious and financially embarrassed.32Despite these matters, the applicant has been able to pay $65 000 into this Court by way of security for the costs of both the first and second respondents. It is believed that the same sum has also been paid with respect to the third respondent’s costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
I would place more weight on the first three points than on the remaining two points. CONCLUSION The only real issue arising in this motion is the extent to which, if at all, circumstances have materially changed since security for costs was ordered in 2003 when a four day trial was thought to be reasonably imminent. In my view and for the reasons stated, the nature of the changes which have occurred since the order was made are less significant than suggested by Adultshop. I accept that the order which it seeks to vary is now several years old and therefore undoubtedly the increase in legal fees and counsel fees since that time will play a role. I do not propose to conduct a minute analysis of the estimated bill of costs quite properly prepared by Adultshop but I do intend to discount it as I consider some of the factors to which I have alluded are given greater emphasis by Adultshop than I consider is necessary. Secondly I consider that the balancing exercise required precludes the granting of a complete indemnity to Adultshop. I was urged to factor into the appropriate amount of security the fact that the funder of security or some person or entity other than and in addition to Capital must stand to benefit if Capital succeeds in the action. On the other hand, it is argued, the funder will not be exposed to a liability to pay costs to Adultshop if Adultshop succeeds. While common sense and life experience suggests that the funder benefiting in some sense may well be possible, there is no evidence to support the suggestion that the funder will actually benefit if the litigation is resolved adversely to Adultshop. It is theoretically possible that the security funder is sympathetically disposed to Capital. There is, as I say, no evidence either way. I consider that appropriate protection in accordance with the principles which I have outlined would be achieved if the order for security for costs which Adultshop seeks to have varied were to be varied by ordering that within 21 days, Capital provide further security for costs of Adultshop up to and including completion of the trial in the amount of $68,000 by way of payment into Court. The parties are engaged in compliance with pre-trial directions with the trial to take place shortly. I have not referred to any order staying the proceedings in the absence of compliance but I invite counsel to attempt to reach agreement on the appropriate terms of the orders to reflect the conclusion in these reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J

The fundamental question in this application will be to what degree, if any, there has been a material change in circumstances since security for costs was previously ordered. RELEVANT LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS There is of course no doubt about the power under s 56 of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) to order an applicant (or a respondent) to give security for costs and also a power to increase the amount of any security ordered to be given. Relevant considerations have been referred to in many cases. Amongst the list of considerations which may be taken into account are the following:1.whether the claim is genuine and has a reasonable prospect of succeeding;2.whether the party applying for security for costs is attempting to shut down a genuine claim;3.whether the impecuniosity might have been caused or contributed to by the conduct of the applying party;4.whether, in the case of a corporation, those standing behind the corporation have made their assets available to fund the costs of litigation and in turn for the benefit that they might receive if it is successful; and5.whether making the order would frustrate the claim. There are also instances where orders have been made where the existence or otherwise of the matter of public interest has been taken into account in the exercise of the discretion. In addition to the express power to increase the security to be given (s 56(3) of the Federal Court Act 1976), O 28 r 5(2) of the Federal Court Rules provides that ‘… the Court may set aside or vary any order made under this Order’. Ordinarily in an application to set aside or vary an order of a substantive nature made after a contested hearing it would be expected that a material change in circumstances since the original order was made has occurred or new evidence provided which was not otherwise reasonably available at the time of the granting of the order: Truth about Motorways Pty Ltd v Macquarie Infrastructure Investment Management Ltd [2001] FCA 1603. The primary purpose of an order for security for costs is to ensure that the successful party has protection for the costs incurred in defending the unsuccessful party’s proceedings. It is in the circumstances of the impecuniosity of the unsuccessful party pursuing the litigation that protection is afforded to the successful party. In the present case there is no dispute in relation to the issue of impecuniosity relative to a possible costs order. It is not the case that the Court should give a complete and certain indemnity to a claimant: Brundza v Robbie & Co (No 2) (1952) 88 CLR 171 at 175. In the previous application the Court exercised its discretion to fix the amount of security to be provided by Adultshop at half of the amount sought. There is to be a balance between ensuring that an impecunious corporation or other applicant does not use the impecuniosity in order to put unfair pressure on another party on the one hand and, on the other hand, between shutting out an impecunious applicant on its entitlement to pursue a legitimate case. ADULTSHOP’S ARGUMENTS