Capel v Caram Finance Aust Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No. 589 of 1991
Before the Hon. Justice Muir

[Capel v Caram Finance Aust. Ltd]

BETWEEN:

ELWYN JOHN CAPEL

(for himself and as Assignee of the Trustee

in Bankruptcy of Estate 1256 of 1988)        

Plaintiff
AND:

CARAM FINANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED

ACN 000 098 402 (formerly called MARAC

FINANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED)

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - MUIR J.

Judgment delivered 29 May 1998

CATCHWORDS:     CIVIL CONTEMPT - failure to observe undertaking - relevance of respondent's bankruptcy - remedy/penalty.

Counsel:Mr B Thomas for the plaintiff/respondent

Mr R.G. Bain S.C. for the defendant/first applicant

Solicitors:Ellison Moschella for the plaintiff/respondent

Clayton Utz for the defendant/first applicant

Hearing date:           26 May 1998

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No. 589 of 1991
Before the Hon. Justice Muir

[Capel v Caram Finance Aust. Ltd]

BETWEEN:

ELWYN JOHN CAPEL

(for himself and as Assignee of the Trustee

in Bankruptcy of Estate 1256 of 1988)        

Plaintiff
AND:

CARAM FINANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED

ACN 000 098 402 (formerly called MARAC

FINANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED)

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - MUIR J.

Judgment delivered 29 May 1998

The plaintiff in this action, Caram Finance Australia Limited, alleges that the defendant, Elwyn John Capel committed a contempt of court by failing to comply with undertakings given to the Court on 31 October 1996. It seeks to have him committed to prison for contempt. The respondent, who was represented by counsel, admits the contempt alleged but argues that his conduct does not warrant a term of imprisonment.  

The Background to the Undertakings Given on 31 October 1996

The applicant and the respondent have been engaged in litigation since 11 October 1985.  On that date the applicant, a finance company, commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court against the respondent alleging that the respondent had defaulted in making repayment of a loan of $40,000. Litigation between the parties has continued, with varying degrees of intensity, since that time. Something of the flavour of the litigation may be gained by reference to a few of the events in its long history. 

  • 10 September 1987    The applicant presented a creditors’ petition against the respondent

  • 11 November 1988     A sequestration order was made against the estate of the respondent

  • 3 April 1991               The respondent’s trustee in bankruptcy, in consideration of the sum of $2,500, executed a deed assigning to the respondent, inter alia, claims against the applicant

  • 4 April 1991               Action 589 of 1991 against the applicant is commenced by the respondent

  • 9 May 1991               The respondent was discharged from bankruptcy

  • 25 September 1995    Thomas J. orders that the respondent’s statement of claim in the action be struck out

  • 26 March 1996          The Court of Appeal dismissed the respondent’s appeal from Thomas J.’s decision.

  • 16 April 1996  The respondent applied for special leave to appeal to the High Court against the decision of the Court of Appeal on 26 March 1996

  • 31 October 1996        The hearing of an application by the applicant for, inter alia, an order staying the action until such time…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Capel v Caram Finance Aust Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QSC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Capel v Caram Finance Australia Limited, the plaintiff, Caram Finance Australia Limited, alleged that the defendant, Elwyn John Capel, committed contempt of court by failing to comply with undertakings given to the court on 31 October 1996. The plaintiff sought to have Capel committed to prison for the contempt. Capel admitted the contempt but argued that imprisonment was not warranted. The litigation between the parties had a long history, with the plaintiff originally suing Capel for defaulting on a loan repayment in 1985. Capel was eventually made bankrupt in 1998. The specific undertakings given by Capel on 31 October 1996 included paying certain costs to the plaintiff's solicitors upon the dismissal of his application for special leave to appeal to the High Court and upon the delivery of a certificate of taxation for other costs.

The court considered the principles of law relevant to civil contempt, noting that an undertaking in a civil action has the same force as a court injunction, and its breach is contempt. The court also considered the remedies available for civil contempt, including committal, sequestration, or fines. The court acknowledged that while Capel's bankruptcy might normally absolve him from the ability to honour the undertakings, the circumstances suggested otherwise. Capel had demonstrated an ability to borrow money and had significant claims, including a personal injury claim potentially worth over $200,000, which were not available to his creditors due to bankruptcy.

The court concluded that Capel's wilful breach of his undertakings must be addressed to assert the court's authority. While the court recognised that Capel's contempt was not as severe as in other reported cases, it also noted Capel's history of litigation and apparent unwillingness to make full financial disclosures. The court opted for a penalty that balanced the need to assert the court's authority with the mitigating factors, ordering Capel to pay a fine of $30,000 by a specified date or face imprisonment for 21 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.