Cape Alumina Pty Ltd v Silverback Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Cape Alumina Pty Ltd v Silverback Properties Pty Ltd  [2008] QLC 0183
PARTIES:

Cape Alumina Pty Ltd ACN 107817694
(applicant)

v

Silverback Properties Pty Ltd ACN 067400088
(respondent)
FILE NO: MRAA00079/2008
DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland – General Division
PROCEEDING: Application for declarations and injunctive relief and cross application for declarations and injunctive relief
DELIVERED ON: 3 September 2008
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD AT: Brisbane
MEMBER: Mr PA Smith
ORDERS:

1.As regards EPM 14547:

(A) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 22 May 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (“the MRA”);

(B) It is declared that the Notices of Renewal of 24 and 27 July 2007 were not validly given pursuant to s. 164 of the MRA and are invalid and of no effect;

(C)    The applicant/explorer is restrained from entering the respondent/landholder’s property in reliance on the Notices of Renewal of 24 and 27 July 2007

(D) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 13 August 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA

(E) It is declared that further Notices of Entry may be given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA in the event that there is no current Notice of Entry or renewal thereof;

(F)    Subject to order 1 (C), the respondent/landholder is restrained from any conduct which may inhibit the lawful exercise of the applicant/explorer’s rights of access pursuant to EPM 14547.

2.     As regards EPM 15278:

(A) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 2 October 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA;

(B) It is declared that the Notice of Renewal of 14 December 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 164 of the MRA;

(C) It is declared that further Notices of Entry may be given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA in the event that there is no current Notice of Entry or renewal thereof;

(D)   The respondent/landholder is restrained from any conduct which may inhibit the lawful exercise of the applicant/explorer’s rights of access pursuant to EPM 15278.

3.     The respondent/landholder pay 50% of the applicant/explorer’s costs, including reserved costs, in so far as such costs relate to EPM 14547.

4.     The respondent/landholder pay 100% of the applicant/explorer’s costs, including reserved costs, in so far as such costs relate to EPM 15278.

CATCHWORDS:

MINING – exploration permits – access to land – notice of entry – renewal – right of landholder to refuse access – validity of notices

LEGISLATION – principals of construction – clear and plain intention – purposive approach – historical development of mining regime

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE  – Declarations and Injunctive relief

APPEARANCES:

Mr PA Freeburn SC (instructed by Clayton Utz, Lawyers), for the applicant
Mr W Cochrane (instructed by McColm Matsinger, Lawyers), for the respondent

Background

  1. Cape Alumina Pty Ltd (the explorer) seeks various orders against Silverback Properties Pty Ltd (the landholder) relating to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cape Alumina Pty Ltd v Silverback Properties Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QLC 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Cape Alumina Pty Ltd sought relief against Silverback Properties Pty Ltd concerning access to land for the purposes of mining exploration. The dispute arose under the Mineral Resources Act 1989, specifically regarding the validity of various notices of entry and renewal notices given by Cape Alumina, and the right of Silverback Properties to refuse access to its land. The matter was heard and determined by the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the interpretation and application of sections 163 and 164 of the MRA, which pertain to notices of entry and renewal for exploration purposes, and the extent to which a landholder can refuse access to their land. The court was also required to consider the principles of statutory construction, particularly the requirement for clarity and the purposive approach to interpreting the legislation. The court examined the historical development of the mining regime to understand the legislative intent behind the provisions at issue.

The court found that the initial notice of entry given by Cape Alumina on 22 May 2007 was valid under s. 163 of the MRA. However, the subsequent renewal notices dated 24 and 27 July 2007 were invalid as they did not comply with the requirements of s. 164. The court further determined that a new notice of entry dated 13 August 2007 was valid. Regarding the second exploration permit, the initial notice of entry dated 2 October 2007 and the renewal notice dated 14 December 2007 were both found to be valid. The court also addressed the rights of Silverback Properties, concluding that while it had the right to refuse access, it could not do so in a manner that inhibited the lawful exercise of Cape Alumina’s rights.

The court made several orders, including declarations of validity and invalidity of the notices, and injunctive relief to prevent Silverback Properties from obstructing Cape Alumina’s lawful access to the land. Costs were awarded to Cape Alumina, with the respondent to pay 50% of the costs relating to the first exploration permit and 100% of the costs relating to the second exploration permit.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. As regards EPM 14547:

(A) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 22 May 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (“the MRA”);

(B) It is declared that the Notices of Renewal of 24 and 27 July 2007 were not validly given pursuant to s. 164 of the MRA and are invalid and of no effect;

(C) The applicant/explorer is restrained from entering the respondent/landholder’s property in reliance on the Notices of Renewal of 24 and 27 July 2007

(D) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 13 August 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA

(E) It is declared that further Notices of Entry may be given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA in the event that there is no current Notice of Entry or renewal thereof;

(F) Subject to order 1 (C), the respondent/landholder is restrained from any conduct which may inhibit the lawful exercise of the applicant/explorer’s rights of access pursuant to EPM 14547.

2. As regards EPM 15278:

(A) It is declared that the Notice of Entry of 2 October 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA;

(B) It is declared that the Notice of Renewal of 14 December 2007 was validly given pursuant to s. 164 of the MRA;

(C) It is declared that further Notices of Entry may be given pursuant to s. 163 of the MRA in the event that there is no current Notice of Entry or renewal thereof;

(D) The respondent/landholder is restrained from any conduct which may inhibit the lawful exercise of the applicant/explorer’s rights of access pursuant to EPM 15278.

3. The respondent/landholder pay 50% of the applicant/explorer’s costs, including reserved costs, in so far as such costs relate to EPM 14547.

4. The respondent/landholder pay 100% of the applicant/explorer’s costs, including reserved costs, in so far as such costs relate to EPM 15278.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.