Burtenshaw v Dunn

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Burtenshaw & Ors v Dunn [2010] QLC 0070
PARTIES: Rosemary Anne Burtenshaw, Cameron Grenville Frederick Burtenshaw and Gary Frederick Burtenshaw
(applicants)
v.
Gary Dunn
(respondent)
and
Chief Executive, Department of Environment and Resource Management
(statutory party)
FILE NOS: MRA113/2009, EPA114/2009, MRA115/2009, and EPA116/2009
DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland - General Division
PROCEEDING: Applications for mining leases and objections thereto
DELIVERED ON: 13 April 2010
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARD AT: Brisbane with video link to Mareeba
MEMBER: Mr PA Smith
ORDERS:

1.     Provided that a special condition consistent with paragraph 38 is made, and subject to the fulfilment of any processes under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cwth), I recommend to the Honourable the Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy and Minister for Trade that ML20541 be granted to the applicants for the purposes and term sought by the applicants.

2.     Provided that a special condition consistent with paragraph 38 is made, and subject to the fulfilment of any processes under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cwth), I recommend to the Honourable the Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy and Minister for Trade that ML20542 be granted to the applicants for the purposes and term sought by the applicants.

3.     The applicants’ strike-out application is dismissed.

4.     The applicants pay the objector's costs of the strike-out application to be agreed between the parties or assessed.

5.     The objector pay 50% of the applicants' costs of the hearing, including reserved costs but excluding any costs relating to the strike-out application, to be agreed between the parties or assessed.

6.   I direct the Registrar of the Court to forthwith provide a copy of this decision to the Mining Registrar, Mareeba, drawing the Mining Registrar's particular attention to paragraphs 47, 51, 63 and 67 hereof. 

CATCHWORDS:

Mining – mining Lease – objections - strike-out application – precautionary principle – public roads – use of chemicals – conditions – unreasonable conduct during hearing - costs
Mineral Resources Act 1989
Environmental Protection Act 1994

APPEARANCES:

Mr A Palmer, solicitor, Rees R and Sydney Jones, solicitors, for the applicants
Mr Dunn, self-representing, assisted by Ms Ford
Mr A Kwan, legal officer, Department of Environment and Resource Management, for the statutory party

Background:

  1. The Court has before it two applications for mining leases, both located on Coolgarra Station, Mt Garnet within the Mareeba mining district. The mining lease applications are lodged in the names of Rosemary Anne Burtenshaw (33.3334%); Cameron Grenville Frederick Burtenshaw (33.3333%) and Gary Frederick Burtenshaw (33.3333%) (“the applicants”). The applicants are the owners of Coolgarra Station.

  2. Mr Gary Dunn (the objector) lodged objections to both mining lease applications. The objections are made under the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (the MRA) and the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (the EP Act).

  3. As well as the objections lodged by Mr Dunn, other objections to the grant of both mining leases were also lodged, however all other objections were withdrawn prior to this matter being heard.

The Hearing

  1. The applicants were represented…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burtenshaw v Dunn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QLC 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute in Burtenshaw v Dunn was before the Queensland Land Court, where the applicants sought mining leases, and the objector raised objections. The objector argued that the Precautionary Principle, as part of the National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development, should be considered in the objections hearing. The applicants, on the other hand, contended that the Precautionary Principle was not relevant to the decision-making process for the mining lease application.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Precautionary Principle should be considered in objections hearings under the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (EP Act). The court had to determine the relevance of the Precautionary Principle and the National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development to the objections decision. Another issue was whether the objector's conduct during the hearing warranted costs being awarded against them.

The court found that the Precautionary Principle was not a specific legislative requirement in the objections hearing process. While the principles of ecologically sustainable development, including the Precautionary Principle, are relevant to the overall legislative framework, they do not directly influence the objections decision process outlined in the EP Act. The court emphasised that a balanced approach, considering all relevant legislative provisions, standard criteria, and objections, was necessary. Regarding the objector's conduct, the court deemed it unreasonable and awarded costs against them, with the objector paying 50% of the applicants' costs of the hearing, excluding those related to the strike-out application.

In summary, the court dismissed the applicants' strike-out application, directed the Registrar to provide a copy of the decision to the Mining Registrar, and ordered the objector to pay 50% of the applicants' costs of the hearing, excluding those related to the strike-out application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Provided that a special condition consistent with paragraph 38 is made, and subject to the fulfilment of any processes under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cwth), I recommend to the Honourable the Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy and Minister for Trade that ML20541 be granted to the applicants for the purposes and term sought by the applicants.

2. Provided that a special condition consistent with paragraph 38 is made, and subject to the fulfilment of any processes under the Native Title Act 1993 (Cwth), I recommend to the Honourable the Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy and Minister for Trade that ML20542 be granted to the applicants for the purposes and term sought by the applicants.

3. The applicants’ strike-out application is dismissed.

4. The applicants pay the objector's costs of the strike-out application to be agreed between the parties or assessed.

5. The objector pay 50% of the applicants' costs of the hearing, including reserved costs but excluding any costs relating to the strike-out application, to be agreed between the parties or assessed.

6. I direct the Registrar of the Court to forthwith provide a copy of this decision to the Mining Registrar, Mareeba, drawing the Mining Registrar's particular attention to paragraphs 47, 51, 63 and 67 hereof.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

An often overlooked aspect of objections hearings before the Land Court relate to whether or not the Precautionary Principle is relevant. Of course, the Court is required to consider all relevant legislative provisions when considering an application for a mining lease and objections. The environmental objections are before the Court for an objections decision. The relevant provisions are to be found in division 7, subdivision 1 of the EP Act. Section 223 of the EP Act provides as follows:“223 Matters to be considered for objections decisionIn making the objections decision for the application, the tribunal must consider the following–(a) the application documents for the application;(b) any relevant EPP requirement;(c) the standard criteria;(d) each current objection;(e) for a standard application–any relevant standard environmental conditions;(f) any suitability report obtained for the application;(g) the status of any application under the Mineral Resources Act for each relevant mining tenement.” “Standard criteria” (see s. 223(c) above) is defined in Schedule 3 of the EP Act in part as follows:“ “standard criteria” means–the principles of ecologically sustainable development as set out in the ‘National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development’; and . .. . .” Further in Schedule 3 of the EP Act, “National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development” is defined as follows:"“National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development” means the ‘National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development’ endorsed by the Council of Australian Governments on 7 December 1992.”" The National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development of December 1992 contains the following statement of Australia’s goal, core objectives and guiding principles for the Strategy:[11][11] National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development, December 1992, p. 2.“The Goal is:Development that improves the total quality of life, both now and in the future, in a way that maintains the ecological processes on which life depends.The Core Objectives are:•to enhance individual and community well-being and welfare by following a path of economic development that safeguards the welfare of future generations•to provide for equity within and between generations•to protect biological diversity and maintain essential ecological processes and life-support systemsThe Guiding Principles are:•decision making processes should effectively integrate both long and short-term economic, environmental, social and equity considerations•where there are threats of serious or irreversible environmental damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason for postponing measures to prevent environmental degradation•the global dimension of environmental impacts of actions and policies should be recognised and considered•the need to develop a strong, growing and diversified economy which can enhance the capacity for environmental protection should be recognised•the need to maintain and enhance international competitiveness in an environmentally sound manner should be recognised•cost effective and flexible policy instruments should be adopted, such as improved valuation, pricing and incentive mechanisms•decisions and actions should provide for broad community involvement on issues which affect themThese guiding principles and core objectives need to be considered as a package. No objective or principle should predominate over the others. A balanced approach is required that takes into account all these objectives and principles to pursue the goal of ESD.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.