Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 2) [2017] FCA 1042

File numbers: NSD 1307 of 2015
NSD 1308 of 2015
NSD 1459 of 2015
NSD 1472 of 2015
NSD 1473 of 2015
Judge: FOSTER J
Date of judgment: 1 September 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether, in all the circumstances, where two groups of class actions have been brought in relation to the same subject matter and where those actions have hitherto been allowed to continue in parallel, the Court should not commence the opt out process in respect of those actions until it has made a determination as to whether it will require group members immediately to elect between groups or to do so as part of the opt out process itself – whether the Court should include within the proposed opt out notices certain statements by way of clarification or correction of representations made by the respondents to the public (including their customers) from time to time in relation to issues arising in the class actions or in relation to matters connected to such issues – what, in all the circumstances, is the appropriate form of opt out notices to be deployed, how should they be distributed and at whose cost  
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 190(3)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), Pt IVA, ss 33J, 33X, 33Y, 33ZF

Privacy Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Hassid v Queensland Bulk Water Supply Authority (T/as Seqwater) [2017] NSWSC 599

Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Ltd (1999) ATPR 41-679

McKay Super Solutions Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Bellamy’s Australia Ltd [2017] FCA 947

Morgan; Re Brighton Hall Securities Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2013) 96 ACSR 232

Sanda v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 14

Smith v Australian Executor Trustees Limited [2016] NSWSC 17

Date of hearing: 18, 19, 24 July 2017 and 24 August 2017
Date of filing of last submissions: 25 August 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 105

NSD 1307 and NSD 1308 of 2015:

Counsel for the Applicants:

Mr R White

Solicitor for the Applicants:

Bannister Law

Counsel for the Respondents:

Mr PJ Brereton SC, Mr IJM Ahmed and Ms E Bathurst

Solicitor for the Respondents:

Clayton Utz

Solicitor Advocate for Austroads Ltd (ACN 136 812 390): Mr S Thompson of Sparke Helmore

NSD 1459 of 2015, NSD 1472 of 2015 and NSD 1473 of 2015:

Counsel for the Applicants:

Mr CA Moore SC, Mr ATS Dawson SC, Mr D Roche and Mr A Hochroth

Solicitor for the Applicants:

Maurice Blackburn Lawyers

Counsel for the Respondents:

Mr PJ Brereton SC, Mr IJM Ahmed and Ms E Bathurst

Solicitor for the Respondents:

Clayton Utz

Solicitor Advocate for Austroads Ltd (ACN 136 812 390): Mr S Thompson of Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

NSD 1307 of 2015
BETWEEN:

RICHARD CANTOR

Applicant

AND:

AUDI AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 077 092 776)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1042
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 2) involved class actions brought by two separate groups of plaintiffs against the same defendants regarding diesel emissions issues. The central legal issues revolved around the management of overlapping class actions, the content and distribution of opt-out notices, and the resolution of costs between the parties. The court had to decide whether it should commence the opt-out process for class members before determining whether they should elect between the groups, and whether the opt-out notices should include clarifications or corrections of previous public statements by the respondents. The court also considered the appropriate form, distribution, and cost allocation of the opt-out notices.

The court rejected the submissions made by Mr. Thompson, aligning with the applicants' requests. It approved the proposed forms of long and abridged opt-out notices, which were to be distributed through various means, including direct communication, publication on websites, and placement in specified newspapers. The court further ordered the costs of the present applications to be costs in the proceedings, allocating them fairly between the parties. Additionally, the court ordered a relisting for further case management to address any remaining issues.

In summary, the court made several key orders, including setting a deadline for class members to opt out, approving the content and distribution of opt-out notices, and allocating the costs associated with these notices. The court also scheduled a further case management hearing to oversee the implementation of these orders and address any additional matters that may arise.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 33J of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), 18 October 2017 is fixed as the date on or before which a group member may opt out of this proceeding.

2. Group members be given notice pursuant to s 33X(1)(a) and s 33X(5) of the Act of the fact that they may opt out of this proceeding in accordance with pars 4 and 5 of these Orders.

3. The form and content of the long form Notice of Opt Out Rights and short form Notice of Opt Out Rights (Notices) which are Annexure A and Annexure B respectively to these Orders, are approved pursuant to s 33Y(2) of the Act.

4. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, any group member who wishes to opt out of this proceeding must, on or before 18 October 2017, deliver to the New South Wales District Registry of the Court an appropriate opt out notice either in the form of the opt out notice which is Annexure A to the Notice of Opt Out Rights which is Annexure A to these Orders or in the form of Annexure B to the said Notice of Opt Out Rights.

5. Pursuant to s 33Y(3) of the Act, the Notices be provided according to the following procedure:

(a) Prior to 8 September 2017, the respondents provide Annexure A to all potential group members for whom they have email or postal addresses in their possession, including from any NEVDIS data supplied to them by Austroads Ltd, by sending Annexure A by email where possible and by sending Annexure A by post to those addressees where no email address is available or where the particular email address does not accept the requisite notification.

(b) Prior to 8 September 2017, the applicant provide Annexure A to all group members for whom his legal representatives have email or postal addresses in their possession, by sending Annexure A by email where possible and by sending Annexure A by post to those addressees where no email address is available or where the particular email address does not accept the requisite notification.

(c) Continuously throughout the period from 8 September 2017 to 24 October 2017, the respondents display Annexure A prominently on their websites listed below:

(i) https://www.volkswagen.com.au/en.html;

(ii) https://au.volkswagen.com.au/emission;

(iii) http://www.skoda.com.au; and

(iv) http://www.skoda.com.au/dieselinfo.

(d) Continuously throughout the period from 8 September 2017 to 24 October 2017, the applicant display Annexure A on the website of the applicant’s solicitors (Maurice Blackburn).

(e) Continuously throughout the period from 8 September 2017 to 24 October 2017, Annexure A be displayed on the class action page for this proceeding on the website of the Federal Court of Australia and be available for inspection at the District Registry of the Court in Sydney, Melbourne, Canberra, Brisbane, Adelaide, Perth, Hobart and Darwin.

(f) Continuously throughout the period from 8 September 2017 to 24 October 2017, the respondents include a recorded message for callers to:

(i) 1800 504 076 (the information line referred to at

https://au.volkswagen.com.au/emission) in the following form:

“Class actions have been commenced in the Federal Court of Australia against Volkswagen and Skoda in relation to the diesel emissions issue. Important information for vehicle owners about the class actions, including the right to opt out of those proceedings, is now available on the Federal Court of Australia website at www.fedcourt.gov.au”;

and

(ii) 1800 502 834 (the customer information line referred to at

http://www.audi.com.au/au/web/en/owners/diesel_emissions_activity.html), in the following form:

“Class actions have been commenced in the Federal Court of Australia against Audi in relation to the diesel emissions issue. Important information for vehicle owners about the class actions, including the right to opt out of those proceedings, is now available on the Federal Court of Australia website at www.fedcourt.gov.au”,

such recorded messages to commence playing as soon as practicable after the call is connected.

(g) Continuously throughout the period from 8 September 2017 to 24 October 2017, the respondents publish a link to Annexure A as displayed on the website of the Federal Court of Australia on the social media platform using the following accounts operated by the respondents and their associated corporations:

(i) https://www.facebook.com/VolkswagenAustralia/

(ii) https://www.facebook.com/AudiAustralia/

(iii) https://www.facebook.com/SkodaAustralia/

with the following post:

“Class actions have been commenced in the Federal Court of Australia against Volkswagen, Audi and Skoda in relation to the diesel emissions issue. Important information for vehicle owners about the class actions, including the right to opt out of those proceedings, is now available on the Federal Court of Australia website at www.fedcourt.gov.au.”

(h) As soon as practicable after 8 September 2017, the applicant, acting in conjunction with and co-operatively with the applicants in proceedings NSD 1307 of 2015, NSD 1308 of 2015, NSD 1459 of 2015 and NSD 1472 of 2015, cause to be published publish Annexure B, as a half page, in the following newspapers:

(i) Herald Sun, Victoria;

(ii) The Daily Telegraph, New South Wales;

(iii) The Advertiser, South Australia;

(iv) The Courier Mail, Queensland;

(v) The Mercury, Tasmania;

(vi) Canberra Times, Australian Capital Territory;

(vii) The West Australian, Western Australia;

(viii) NT News, Northern Territory; and

(ix) The Australian.

6. The costs of sending, displaying and publishing the Notices as described in Order 5 above be paid as follows:

(a) The respondents to bear the initial cost of displaying and linking Annexure A and making available the recorded messages pursuant to Order 5(c), 5(f) and 5(g) above;

(b) The applicant to bear one-third of the initial cost of distributing Annexure A pursuant to Order 5(b) above and pursuant to Order 5(b) made this day (1 September 2017) in proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015 and in proceeding NSD 1472 of 2015;

(c) The applicant to bear one-third of the initial cost of displaying Annexure A pursuant to Order 5(d) above and pursuant to Order 5(d) made this day (1 September 2017) in proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015 and in proceeding NSD 1472 of 2015;

(d) The cost of providing a copy of Annexure A to group members using email and postal addresses as provided for in Order 5(a) above, be initially paid by the respondents on the basis that the applicant will pro tem indemnify the respondents in respect of one-fifth of those costs to the extent that they are reasonable, which proportion of those costs, subject to Order 10 below, will be payable by the applicant to the respondents within 14 business days of true copies of the relevant invoices being provided; and

(e) One-fifth of the cost of publishing Annexure B as required by Order 5(h) above be initially paid by the applicant,

on the basis that all of the above costs will subsequently fall to be dealt with by the Court as part of the costs of the proceeding.

7. If, on or before 18 October 2017, the solicitors for any party receive a notice purporting to be an opt out notice referable to this proceeding, the solicitors file that notice with the Federal Court of Australia, NSW District Registry, within three (3) days of receipt of the notice by the solicitors and the notice shall be treated as an opt out notice received by the Court at the time it was received by the solicitors.

8. The solicitors for the parties be granted leave to inspect the Court file from time to time to the extent that material in the Court file has not been the subject of a confidentiality order and to copy any opt out notices filed.

9. The opt out notices referred to in these Orders may be amended by agreement between Clayton Utz, Maurice Blackburn and Bannister Law before they are posted, emailed or published in order to correct any postal, website, email address or telephone number or any typesetting or typographical error.

10. The parties have liberty to apply on three (3) days’ notice in respect of the costs of providing Annexure A in accordance with Order 5(a) above and generally.

11. The applicant’s Amended Interlocutory Application filed on 8 June 2017 otherwise be dismissed.

12. The costs of and incidental to the applicant’s Amended Interlocutory Application filed on 8 June 2017 be costs in the proceeding.

13. This proceeding and the respondents’ Interlocutory Application filed on 26 June 2017 be listed for further case management at 9.30 am on 15 September 2017 before Foster J.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These are my reasons for rejecting Mr Thompson’s submissions and for making the orders which the applicants sought. Conclusions I have attached to the orders which I propose to make in each of the class actions the settled form of the long Opt Out Notice and the settled form of the abridged Opt Out Notice. As far as the latter document is concerned, very little remained in dispute at the end of the hearings before me. Ultimately, given the decisions which I have made in respect of the long Opt Out Notice, the matters of dispute were very narrow indeed. Certain of those matters were, as night follows day, resolved by the decisions which I made in respect of the long Opt Out Notice (viz whether there should be reference to the applicants’ contentions concerning the likely impact of the recall work being carried out on the affected engines and whether the respondents’ contentions in respect of proposed pars 6.13, 6.14, 6.15 and 6.16 should be adopted). As far as costs of the present applications are concerned, I think that each side of the record has had some successes and some failures in respect of the matters resolved by these Reasons for Judgment. Appreciating that this is a somewhat broad assessment, I think that the appropriate order for costs is that the costs of and incidental to the present applications be costs in the proceedings. In the orders which I propose to make, I have endeavoured to allocate a fair proportion of the costs to be incurred by the applicants in complying with those orders to each group of applicants (the BL applicants and the MB applicants) and to allocate those costs as between applicants within each of those groups on a fair basis. All applicants will need to make a contribution to the costs of publishing the abridged Opt Out Notice. I also propose to make an order relisting these matters for further case management. As I have a tentative listing on 15 September 2017 relating to these matters, I will make an order listing all of them for further case management at 9.30 am on that day. There will be orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At the end of the hearing, the following methods of circulation of the long Opt Out Notice and the abridged Opt Out Notice were agreed between the applicants and the respondents namely:(a)Direct communication of the long Opt Out Notice to the respective clients of Bannister Law and Maurice Blackburn;(b)Publication of the long Opt Out Notice on the websites of Bannister Law and Maurice Blackburn;(c)Publication of the long Opt Out Notice on the Federal Court’s website; (d)Publication of the abridged Opt Out Notice in certain specified newspapers (although the question of who should pay for this had not been resolved);(e)Publication of the long Opt Out Notice on the websites of VW Australia, Skoda and Audi Australia; and(f)Playing an appropriate recording on the hotline maintained by VW Australia, Skoda and Audi Australia advising callers where they can review the long Opt Out Notice. ConsiderationIssue 1—The Overlapping Class Actions Issue In this part of these Reasons, I address the issues which I have identified at [36(a)] and [36(i)] above. On 26 June 2017, the respondents in the class action proceedings filed the overlap IA in each of those proceedings in which they claim relief in respect of the alleged ongoing difficulties caused by the circumstance that two groups of class actions are on foot, namely, the BL class actions and the MB class actions. In substance, the respondents seek orders pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act):(a)Deeming those group members who have entered into a retainer agreement with Maurice Blackburn in respect of proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015 to be a group member in that proceeding for all purposes and not to be a group member of the BL class action NSD 1308 of 2015;(b)Deeming those group members who have entered into a retainer agreement with Bannister Law to be a group member in proceeding NSD 1308 of 2015 for all purposes and not to be a group member in proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015;(c)Deeming those group members who have not entered into any retainer agreement with either Maurice Blackburn or Bannister Law in respect of either NSD 1308 of 2015 or NSD 1459 of 2015 to be a group member in proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015 for all purposes and not to be a group member in proceeding NSD 1308 of 2015; and(d)Deeming those group members who have entered into retainer agreements with both Maurice Blackburn and Bannister Law to be a group member in NSD 1459 of 2015 and not to be a group member in proceeding NSD 1308 of 2015 unless they nominate a different intention as part of the opt out process. In the overlap IA, in addition to addressing proceedings NSD 1308 of 2015 and NSD 1459 of 2015, the respondents also seek to address the overlap between NSD 1307 of 2015 and NSD 1472 of 2015 and the overlap between NSD 1308 of 2015 and NSD 1473 of 2015. In the alternative, the respondents seek orders staying the BL class actions until further order of the Court. The claims for relief made in the overlap IA were supported by an affidavit sworn by Gregory John Williams on 28 June 2017. Mr Williams is the respondents’ solicitor on the record.