Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 268

PARTIES: TYRON GUISEPPI CANTAMESSA

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO:

GAR053-17

MATTER TYPE:

Building matters

DELIVERED ON:

5 September 2019

HEARING DATE:

2 August 2018; 3 August 2018

HEARD AT:

Mackay

DECISION OF:

Member Quinlivan

ORDERS:

1. The decision of the QBCC made on 30 January 2017 to issue Direction to Rectify No 0101527 is set aside.

2.     There is no order as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – STATUTORY POWER TO REQUIRE RECTIFICATION OF DEFECTIVE OR INCOMPLETE BUILDING WORK – Direction to Rectify – defective work – final completion – unfair termination – repudiation

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld)

Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) (repealed)

R v His Honour Judge Miller and the Builder’s Registration Board of Queensland, ex parte Graham Evans & Co (Qld) Pty Ltd [1987] 2 Qd R 446
Imperial Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd v QBCC [2014] QCAT 42

De Luchi v QBSA [2002] QBT Q223-01

Birrell v QBSA [2013] QCAT 56

Laidlaw v Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QCAT 70

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

J P Mould of Counsel, instructed by Kelly Legal

Respondent:

S Hedger, solicitor of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The Applicant seeks the following Orders:

    a)      A declaration that the works, the subject of the Direction to Rectify and/or Complete No. 0101527 (the Direction) were not defective;

    b)      Further or in the alternative a Declaration that any defective works referred to in the Direction were not the responsibility of the Applicant.

    c)      An order that the Direction be set aside;

    d)      Costs.

  2. The Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘QBCC’) seeks that the Tribunal confirms the QBCC’s original decision to issue a Direction to Rectify.

    Background

  3. In February 2014, the Applicant entered into a QBCC contract with Oliver Sabu and Rasmi Nair (‘the Homeowners’) to carry out an extension and renovations to their existing dwelling in Mackay. The works were ‘building works’ within the meaning of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld).

  4. The works commenced around 29 April 2014 and under the contract, the original date for practical completion was 211 calendar days from the date on which the works commenced.

  5. During July 2015, as part of the QBCC’s dispute resolution process, the QBCC carried out an Early Dispute Resolution Inspection at the property. The Dispute Outcome Agreement provided that:

    (a)The dwelling was to be completed by the end of business on Friday 31 July 2015;

    (b)Handover would occur on Monday, 3 August 2015; and

    (c)Final payment would occur in accordance with the terms of the Contract.

  6. The works were not completed by 31 July 2015.

  7. On 10 August 2015, a certifier, David Brookes, attended the property, conducted a final inspection and identified that the following works had to be addressed before a final certificate would be granted:

    (a)Fit termite stickers to sub-board and kitchen cupboard;

    (b)Install mid posts to deck…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantamessa v Queensland Building and Construction Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 268
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, Cantamessa, appealed the decision of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) to issue a Direction to Rectify, arguing that the works completed were not defective and that the QBCC's decision was unfair. The dispute arose from a contract between the Applicant and homeowners for building works on a dwelling in Mackay, which was not completed by the agreed date. The QBCC conducted inspections and identified several defects, leading to the issuance of the Direction to Rectify. The Applicant contended that the QBCC had failed to establish that the works were defective and that the direction was unfair. The Tribunal had to determine whether the works were defective and whether the Direction to Rectify was fair.

The Tribunal considered whether the QBCC had established that the works were defective, noting that the burden of proof lay with the QBCC to demonstrate the defects. The Tribunal found that the installation of the structural floor framing and other works were not defective, but identified specific defects related to the installation of timber surrounds and masonry subfloor areas. Regarding the fairness of the Direction to Rectify, the Tribunal noted that while the works were not entirely defective, the identified defects warranted rectification. The Applicant argued that the QBCC's decision was unfair due to the homeowners' repudiation of the contract and the Applicant's acceptance of this repudiation. The Tribunal concluded that the direction was fair, considering the nature and extent of the defects and the statutory obligations of the QBCC.

The Tribunal set aside the QBCC's decision to issue the Direction to Rectify, finding that while some works were defective, the overall decision was not fair given the homeowners' repudiation and the Applicant's acceptance. The Tribunal did not make an order as to costs. The Applicant's appeal was partially successful, as the Tribunal acknowledged the defects but found the direction unfair under the circumstances. This decision highlights the balance between identifying defective work and considering the broader context of the contractual relationship and statutory obligations.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the QBCC made on 30 January 2017 to issue Direction to Rectify No 0101527 is set aside.

2. There is no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Queensland Building and Construction Commission (‘QBCC’) seeks that the Tribunal confirms the QBCC’s original decision to issue a Direction to Rectify.Background In February 2014, the Applicant entered into a QBCC contract with Oliver Sabu and Rasmi Nair (‘the Homeowners’) to carry out an extension and renovations to their existing dwelling in Mackay. The works were ‘building works’ within the meaning of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld). The works commenced around 29 April 2014 and under the contract, the original date for practical completion was 211 calendar days from the date on which the works commenced. During July 2015, as part of the QBCC’s dispute resolution process, the QBCC carried out an Early Dispute Resolution Inspection at the property. The Dispute Outcome Agreement provided that: (a)The dwelling was to be completed by the end of business on Friday 31 July 2015; (b)Handover would occur on Monday, 3 August 2015; and (c)Final payment would occur in accordance with the terms of the Contract. The works were not completed by 31 July 2015. On 10 August 2015, a certifier, David Brookes, attended the property, conducted a final inspection and identified that the following works had to be addressed before a final certificate would be granted: (a)Fit termite stickers to sub-board and kitchen cupboard; (b)Install mid posts to deck for wire balustrades; (c)Reduce gap on internal stairs to 125 mm or less; and (d)Supply certificates as per decision notice. On 10 August 2015, the Applicant was advised by the Homeowner’s solicitors that they had elected to terminate the Contract pursuant to section 90(1)(b) of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 2000 (Qld) (now repealed). On 14 August 2015 the Applicant issued his final tax invoice to the Homeowners in the amount of $58,500. On 20 August 2015, the Applicant’s solicitors gave notice to the Homeowners that the Applicant considered that they had repudiated the contract. On 25 October 2016 the Applicant’s solicitors advised the Homeowner’s solicitors of his express acceptance of the Homeowner’s repudiation. The Applicant’s final tax invoice remains unpaid. The Applicant was paid a total of $331,500 by the Homeowners under the contract, being approximately 85% of the total contract price. Between 31 August 2015 and 14 March 2017 there were a series of inspections of the property and notices issued by QBCC to the Applicant. On 31 August 2015 following a complaint by the Homeowner, Mr John Cherry, on behalf of QBCC conducted an inspection of the works at the property. In attendance were the Applicant, the Homeowners and Mr Malcolm Hull from Master Builders. This Report dealt with 213 complaint items. On 8 September 2015, QBCC issued the Applicant with an Initial Non-Completion Inspection Report. The Report described the relevant defect complained of as ‘Home Incomplete’. On 28 October 2015 following another inspection by Mr Cherry, QBCC issued the Applicant with an Amended Initial Non-Completion Inspection Report.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that the evidence does not establish that the installation of the waterproofing to the lower-level retaining wall adjoining the rumpus room constitutes defective work.Conclusion as to whether the Building work is defective Counsel for the Applicant submitted that QBCC bears an onus to establish that the works that are the subject of these proceedings were defective. However, QBCC rightly points out that this is a merits review of an administrative decision.[18][18]QCAT Act Section 20 QBCC submits that the Tribunal stands in the shoes of the QBCC as the decision-maker to make the ‘correct and preferable’ decision and must hear and decide the review by way of a ‘fresh hearing on the merits’. The Tribunal has previously held[19] that the QCAT Act does not place an onus of proof on a party in such proceedings to establish facts or make out a case for review. However, as the decision maker the QBCC must use its ‘best endeavours to help the Tribunal so that it can make its decision’.[20][19]Laidlaw v. Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QCAT 70 at [22][20]QCAT Act, s 21. In summary the findings of the Tribunal are:(a)The installation of the structural floor framing to bedroom 4, the rumpus room, entry foyer, dining room, kitchen pantry and stairwell doorway was not defective.(b)Any alleged damage to the glass splashback in the kitchen is not the result of any action by the Applicant.(c)The installation of timber surrounds (reveals and/or architraves) to the windows in the shower area of the ground floor and first floor bathrooms was the responsibility of the Applicant and did not comply with the provisions of the BCA.(d)The installation of the interface between the window and the external wall of the dwelling to the western side of the garage does not constitute “defective” work.(e)The installation the garage door was the responsibility of the homeowners as a result of an undocumented agreement between the Applicant and the homeowners and is not the responsibility of the Applicant.(f)The installation of the structural framing to the external wall below the deck area is not defective work.(g)The installation of the ground floor slab at the perimeter of the ground floor bathroom does not constitute defective work.(h)The roof framing to the dwelling is not defective.(i)The work associated with the installation of the masonry subfloor areas of the dwelling is defective because it does not comply with the BCA.(j)The installation of the structural floor framing to the external upper-level deck does not constitute defective work.(k)The installation of the waterproofing to the lower-level retaining wall adjoining the rumpus room does not constitute defective work. Therefore, the Tribunal is satisfied that Items 3 and 9 constitute defective work.Issue 2: Is it unfair to direct the Applicant to rectify the building work in the circumstances? Taking into account its findings with respect to the alleged defective work, the Tribunal must decide whether it is appropriate to issue a Direction to Rectify.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.