Campbell and Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 98 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 205

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No W1999/270

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      ANTHONY JOHN CAMPBELL   
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Associate Professor S D Hotop, Deputy President Mr R D Fayle, Senior Member            

Date16 March 2001

PlacePerth

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.            
  ..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
CORPORATIONS – securities – applicant a representative of a dealer – banning order made against applicant – whether grounds for making banning order – whether applicant contravened a securities law – whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to determine that applicant contravened a securities law – whether applicant contravened s780, s849, s851 or s1078 of Corporations Law – whether applicant did not perform "efficiently, honestly and fairly" the duties of a representative of a dealer – whether appropriate to make banning order – appropriate duration of banning order.

Corporations Law ss 9, 93, 780, 829(d), 829(f), 830, 837, 849, 851, 1077, 1078

Australian Securities Commission v Cooke (1996) 22 ACSR 580
Australian Securities Commission v Kippe (1996) 67 FCR 499
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Farley and Australian Securities Commission (1998) 16 ACLC 1502
Re Kippe and Australian Securities Commission (1998) 16 ACLC 190
Story v National Companies and Securities Commission (1988) 13 NSWLR 661

REASONS FOR DECISION

16 March 2001        Associate Professor S D Hotop, Deputy President Mr R D Fayle, Senior Member                    

  1. On 28 May 1999 a delegate of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission ("the respondent") made a "banning order", under s829 of the Corporations Law ("the Law"), against Anthony John Campbell ("the applicant") prohibiting him "for a period of two (2) years from 18 March 1999 from doing an act as a representative of a securities dealer or an investment adviser".  A statement of the delegate's reasons for making the banning order, dated 23 July 1999, was subsequently furnished to the applicant.  On 20 August 1999 the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the delegate's decision to make the abovementioned banning order.

  2. At the hearing the applicant was represented by Mr M de Kerloy and Ms K Bennett, solicitors, and the respondent was represented by Mr M Gething of the office of the respondent's Regional General Counsel for Western Australia. The Tribunal had before it the documents ("T documents" – comprising T1-T51, pp 1-809) lodged by the respondent pursuant to s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, a Statement of Agreed Facts filed by the parties on 11 May 2000 (Exhibit A1), and the following documentary exhibits tendered by the respondent at the hearing:

    ·     Policy Statement 121 – "Investment advisory services: retail investor protection requirements" – issued by the respondent on 3 March 1997 (R1)

    ·     Policy Statement 122 - "Investment advisory services: the conduct of business rules (s849 and s 851)" – issued by the respondent on 3 March 1997 (R2)

    ·     Extracts from Ascot Production System…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Campbell and Australian Securities and Investments Commissio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 205
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case between Anthony John Campbell and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) arose from ASIC's investigation into Campbell's conduct as a representative of Barkworth Securities Pty Ltd and Banalasta Oil Plantation Ltd, both licensed dealers under the Corporations Law. ASIC sought to ban Campbell from participating in the securities industry for two years, a decision that Campbell contested.

The legal issues before the court were whether the grounds existed to justify making a banning order against Campbell, whether Campbell had contravened any securities laws, and if the Tribunal had the jurisdiction to determine such contraventions. Specifically, ASIC alleged that Campbell had breached sections 780, 849, 851, and 1078 of the Corporations Law by not performing his duties "efficiently, honestly and fairly." The central question was whether these breaches warranted a banning order and, if so, the appropriate duration of such an order.

The Tribunal found that Campbell had indeed contravened the securities laws by failing to perform his duties with the requisite efficiency, honesty, and fairness. The Tribunal concluded that Campbell's actions, particularly in relation to the Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture and the Barkworth Olive Groves Project No. 2, did not meet the standards expected of a representative of a dealer. Despite Campbell's assertion that he did not provide specific investment advice or recommendations, the Tribunal determined that his conduct fell short of the required professional standards. The Tribunal affirmed the banning order made by ASIC's delegate, determining that a two-year ban starting from 18 March 1999 was appropriate.

In summary, the court upheld ASIC's decision to ban Anthony John Campbell from participating in the securities industry for two years, finding that his conduct warranted such a sanction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

A Statement of Agreed Facts, filed by the parties on 11 May 2000 (Exhibit A1), is as follows:"1. Background1.1Anthony John Campbell ('Campbell') was a proper authority holder of Barkworth Securities Pty Ltd (appointed 6 May 1998) and of Banalasta Oil Plantation Ltd appointed (16 June 1998). Each company is the holder of a dealers licence under the Corporations Law ('CL').1.2Barkworth Securities Pty Ltd's Dealers Licence restricts the licensee to carrying on a securities business only in relation to prescribed interests in agricultural, horticultural and forestry schemes and to prescribed interests in the Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture Project No 1.1.3Banalasta Oil Plantation Ltd's Dealer Licence restricts the licensee to carrying on a securities business only in relation to Banalasta Oil Plantation Project No 1 and Banalasta Natural Oil Joint Venture Project No 1.2.The Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture2.1The Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture (the 'Hard Rock JV') is a prescribed interest scheme for which Jedidiah Management Limited ('JML') issued a prospectus. Barkworth Securities Pty Ltd ('Barkworth') marketed and promoted the prospectus. Kevin Phillip Sleight is a director of both Barkworth and JML.2.2The prospectus, dated 25 May 1998, requires a minimum subscription of 450 interests.2.3An applicant to the Hard Rock JV acquires an interest in the business of the development of a quarry. The business will extract hard rock and process it for use as aggregate in the road building and construction industries.2.4JML is the manager of the Hard Rock JV. Rydal Management Pty Ltd ('Rydal') is the Technical Manager of the Hard Rock JV.2.5Australian Rural Group Limited ('ARG') is the Representative under the Hard Rock JV Deed.2.6Upon application, each participant must pay a minimum capital contribution of $19,450 per interest purchased.2.7Participants have the option of funding the investment with a loan from Horizon Lending Company Pty Ltd.2.8Upon commencement of the Hard Rock JV JML will pay the following fees from the capital contributed by the participants:(a) to JML, management fee of $200 per interest;(b) to Rydal, the licence fee of $1,250 per interest;(c) to Rydal, technical management fee of $18,000 per interest issued.2.9 In years 2 to 7 the fees will be 55% of Hard Rock JV revenue.2.10ARG is entitled to a fee paid quarterly in advance. The first year's fee is $25,000 and $25 per interest above minimum subscription. Rydal will pay this from its technical management fee. Fees in subsequent years will be paid from Hard Rock JV revenue.2.11The anticipated revenue from the scheme takes the form of monies earned from the sale of 'product'. The Prospectus defines product as rock, stone or other material extracted from the quarry whether processed or not.2.12The Hard Rock JV is for a period of 7 years. There is no provision for buy back.2.13The total projected earnings per interest after 7 years are estimated to be between $33,500 and $87,600.3.The Barkworth Olive Groves Project No 23.1The Barkworth Olive Groves Project No 2 (the 'Olives JV') is a prescribed interest scheme with a prospectus issued by Barkworth Olive Groves Ltd ('BOGL') and Barkworth Management Ltd ('BML'). The directors are common to both companies.3.2The prospectus dated 9 March 1998 requires a minimum subscription of 175,000 shares.3.3The aim of the project is to increase the size of Barkworth Group's operations and to engage in downstream processing of olives.3.4An applicant in the Olives JV acquires shares in BOGL (generally 1 x parcel of 500).3.5Certain rights attach to the shares including the right to appoint BML to manage their interest. The cost of the investment is $17,630 over 2 years in addition to the 500 x $1 shares in BOGL.3.6Potential investors may elect to have the cost funded through a loan from Barkworth Finance Pty Ltd. The loan amount will be advanced in 2 tranches. The first advance, $12,890, is at commencement and $4,700 one year later.3.7In year one the cost consists of:(a)Management, Processing and Marketing Fees $5,350 to BML;(b)Drainage and Erosion $2,865 to BML;(c)Irrigation $3,050 to BML;(d)Brand Licence $1,000 to BML;(e)Factory Access $450 to BOGL; and(f)Farm Administration $175 to BOGL.3.8In year 2 the cost consists of:(a)Management, Processing and Marketing Fees $4,100 to BML;(b)Factory Access $450 to BOGL; and(c)Farm Administration $150 to BOGL.3.9The estimated return from the investment is shown to be a total of $61,148 after the end of year 20.3.10BML is the manager of the Olives JV. BML will receive prepaid annual fees of $5,350 for year one and $4,100 for year 2. In year 3 BML will receive 70% of the gross income generated from the sale of processed olives. In the following years, fees will be a percentage of the gross from sales at the farm gate plus a % of the gross from sales of processed olives.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the material before it and to the findings adverse to the applicant that it has made, the Tribunal is of opinion that a banning order of 2 years' duration is appropriate in this case. That was, of course, the duration of the banning order made by the delegate of the respondent on 28 May 1999. The banning order made by the delegate was expressed to commence from 18 March 1999 – being the date on which the applicant ceased to hold a "proper authority" from Barkworth Securities Pty Ltd. That date of commencement, in the Tribunal's opinion, was also appropriate. The Tribunal concludes, therefore, that the decision under review was the correct or preferable decision.Decision For the above reasons, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A document entitled "Statement of Anthony John Campbell in relation to Adamson", which is signed and dated 4 May 1999, appears in the T documents (T25). That document states:'1. I have known Mr and Mrs Adamson for approximately 8 years.2.For the past 8 years I have prepared and lodged Mr and Mrs Adamson's tax returns.3.In or about April 1998, Mr Adamson telephoned me to ask me to look over some figures in relation to a proposed purchase of a video store.4.I told Mr Adamson that I would need to see the company's financial statements and other relevant documents for at least the last 3 years. I also told Mr Adamson that I would need to look at their own financial situation in more detail.5.After about 1 week Mr Adamson provided me with this information by facsimile.6.I then undertook some investigation of the video industry and made some enquiries.7.As a result of these enquiries and the information provided by Mr Adamson in relation to the particular video store I formed the view that it was not a viable investment.8.I then telephoned Mr and Mrs Adamson and told them that I did not believe they should invest in the video venture.9.Mr Adamson then asked me to let him know if I was aware of any other investments including possible investments in shares.10.I told Mr Adamson that I had a licence which allowed me to advise on a number of projects similar to the Northern Rivers Tea Tree Project that he and his wife were already involved in. He indicated to me he would be interested in this and any other opportunity to invest. I said he would need to come in and discuss these with me.11.Approximately two weeks later Mr Adamson telephoned me and asked if he and Mrs Adamson could come into my office to discuss the agricultural projects available and I made an appointment for them.Federation Resources Shares12.Before Mr and Mrs Adamson came to see me at my office in relation to the investment projects, I telephoned Mr Adamson to let him know that I knew someone who had some shares he wanted to sell, off the market. I did this because Mr Adamson had told me he was looking for investments and had told me to let him know if I became aware of any. The phone was answered by Mrs Adamson who, when I explained the nature of my call told me that she did not deal with investments and put me through to her husband.13.I told Mr Adamson that if they were interested in buying shares I could give Mr Giovanazzo their telephone number.14.I did not go into detail about the share purchase other than that they were shares in a company called Federation Resources and that it was an off market transaction.15.Mr Adamson said they were interested and would like to meet with Mr Giovanazzo and asked me to give Mr Giovanazzo their telephone number.16.After I gave Mr Giovanazzo their number I had nothing further to do with the matter.17.About six weeks later Mr Adamson telephoned me to ask me if I knew where the share scrip for the shares in Federation Resources was.18.I told him that I did not know as I was not involved in the matter however, I told him that I would follow it up with Mr Giovanazzo for him.19.I then spoke to Mr Giovanazzo and told him about Mr and Mrs Adamson's concerns.20.Mr Giovanazzo did not give me any satisfactory explanations as to why they had not received their Share Certificate. He made some excuses and told me that it would be available soon.21.I continued to follow the matter up with Mr Giovanazzo on behalf of Mr and Mrs Adamson for the next month or so.22.I then discovered that Mr Giovanazzo was being investigated by the Fraud Squad and I reported this matter to the Fraud Squad. I had no further dealings with him.23.At no stage did I recommend to Mr and Mrs Adamson that they invest in the shares.24.I did not provide any financial advice to Mr and Mrs Adamson in relation to the shares, nor did I recommend them. Mr and Mrs Adamson knew that I was not authorised to give any advice in relation to shares as we had previously discussed the limited nature of the advice I could give in relation to investments.25.Mr Adamson had asked me whether I knew of any other investments and I passed on the information about the shares but I did not provide particulars or recommendations.26.Mr and Mrs Adamson met with Mr Giovanazzo. I was not present at this meeting.The Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture Project No.127.On or about June 1998, Mr and Mrs Adamson came to my office to discuss agricultural projects.28.I have been involved in providing advice in relation to these projects for about two years.29.I have a standard procedure which I adopt for every client when showing them the projects. The procedure may vary slightly in accordance with the individual client. The basic steps are as follows:(a)Explain the restrictions on the type of investment advice I am authorised to offer;(b)Explain the type of investment projects I am authorised to advise on and explain the limited nature of the advice provided;(c)Explain the concepts of negative gearing shares and property and other alternatives;(d)Look at the financial situation of the client and their financial goals;(e)Review in detail certain projects as instructed by the client including reviewing the relevant prospectus in detail;(f)In particular, when reviewing the prospectus I highlight to the client the risks involved with the venture. This includes outlining the effect on the client if the project was to fail and/or the project was not approved by the Australian Taxation Office. I work out the likely cost of that scenario to the client.(g)Completion of a worksheet which gives an outline of the cash flow effect of becoming involved in the project or projects selected;(h)Encourage client to consider the prospectus and worksheet and to make a further appointment to answer any queries;(i)Dependant on the level of query, the prospectus would be explained again before any documentation was completed;(j)Complete documentation including comprehensive commission disclosure statement;(k)I then give the client all copies of working papers and other relevant documentation.30.I had previously advised Mr and Mrs Adamson of the limitations of the advice I was authorised to give them. These occasions were as follows:(a)In 1997 when Mr and Mrs Adamson attended at my office to do their tax returns, they had already invested in the Northern Rivers Project and asked me what possible other projects they could invest in for the following year. At this stage I explained the concept of negative gearing for rentals and shares and told them that there were other alternatives similar to what they had already invested in and that they might consider or seek other advice about.I then explained that I had a restricted licence and could only advise on certain types of projects only. I told them that I was not authorised to advise on any other type of investment including shares and trusts;(b)At the beginning of the meeting in June 1998 I again advised Mr and Mrs Adamson of my restricted licence;(c)After the meeting when I asked Mr and Mrs Adamson to read and sign the Letter of Instruction I explained the contents of it again and the fact that my licence was restricted. Mr and Mrs Adamson both read the document and then signed it.31.At the meeting with Mr and Mrs Adamson I initially looked at their financial position and goals.32.I was already familiar with their financial position as I had been doing their tax returns for some time and had recently looked in more depth at their position in relation to a proposed investment in the video store.33.As far as I can recall Mr and Mrs Adamson's financial position was strong. They had a small mortgage over their family home in Padbury and no other significant debts. Both Mr and Mrs Adamson were wage earners on a family income of approximately $60,000. They also had a block of land which was unencumbered.34.Mr Adamson had recently changed jobs and was looking to purchase a business. This meant that he was not sure of what he would be earning over the next couple of years. If an opportunity to invest in a business presented itself he may have purchased it.35.Mr and Mrs Adamson told me that they had already had a long term investment in Northern Rivers Tea Tree Project (I also knew this from doing their tax returns) and they wanted to invest in a more short term returning investment.36.Mr and Mrs Adamson were financially sound and felt that they were capable of sustaining a risk factor associated with these investments.37.I then gave them a brief overview of each project and let them know what projects were available.38.These were Barkworth Olive Groves Project No.2, Banalasta Euc. Project, The Banalasta Natural Oil Joint Venture and The Rydal Hard Rock Joint Venture Project ('Rydal Joint Venture').39.We looked at each project and eliminated each one until Mr and Mrs Adamson found something that met their goals and this was the Rydal Joint Venture.40.Mr and Mrs Adamson wanted to invest in Rydal Joint Venture for the following reasons:(a)This project was short term and they wanted a short term project as they already had a long term investment in Northern Rivers Tea Tree Project;(b)Projected income was to be received earlier than the other projects;(c)The risk factor and returns of the balance of the projects were not suitable for their requirements. The comparable projects involved a financial commitment in Year 2 of the project. Mr and Mrs Adamson did not want to have this commitment in Year 2 as Mr Adamson was unsure of what his income would be in Year 2;(d)The finance options available were attractive.41.I then took Mr and Mrs Adamson through the Rydal Joint Venture Prospectus in detail and explained the risks involved. The risks were laid out in the registered prospectus on page 6.42.In going through the whole prospectus I highlighted the relevant factors in relation to timing of projected return, the structure from a tax office point of view and also the options available to finance the investment if required.43.At the meeting I gave Mr and Mrs Adamson the Disclaimer which confirms that they understand that I have a restricted licence and that the advice provided is on a 'limited advice basis'.44.At the meeting and before signing the documents I told Mr and Mrs Adamson that I would be receiving a commission if they were to decide to sign up on the Rydal Joint Venture.45.I advised Mr and Mrs Adamson that the amount of commission I would be receiving was based on the number of sales of the Rydal Joint Venture I made and, therefore, was unable to advise them of the exact figure for the commission. However, all levels of commission are clearly shown on the Disclosure Statement.46.I gave Mr and Mrs Adamson the Disclosure Statement and asked them to read it. The statement clearly outlines how the commission is calculated and the amounts paid expressed in whole dollars.47.Mr and Mrs Adamson read the documents I had discussed with them and made the decision to proceed with an investment of one interest held jointly in the Rydal Joint Venture. All documentation including application form, finance application form, loan agreement and loan indemnity agreement together with the commission disclosure and disclaimer form were completed in my office at this time.48.This concluded the meeting. Mr and Mrs Adamson then left and I did not see them again until July 1998 in relation to preparing their tax returns."