Cameron v Cavric P/L T/a Cavalier Homes Mackay

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

CITATION: Cameron v Cavric P/L t/a Cavalier Homes Mackay [2010] QCAT 114

PARTIES:Jennifer May Cameron

V

Cavric Pty. Ltd. trading as Cavalier Homes Mackay

APPLICATION NO:                BD010-09

MATTER TYPE:  Building matters

HEARING DATE:  8th, 9th and 17th March 2010.

DECISION OF:  K. Geraghty, Member

DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:  As per Order

CATCHWORDS:  

1      Whether an agreement to terminate a contract was such as to relinquish         any rights to claim damages as a result of breach of that contract.

2.     Consideration of the effect of “betterment” in the assessment of damages,      when a better house was built by the applicant in mitigation of her loss         when the house that the applicant originally contracted for was not built.

3.     Whether damages for notional loss of rent for the period of delay in the           completion of the construction of a house should take into account interest        that would have been paid on borrowings when the ability to pay off the      when the interest on the borrowings has merely been delayed.

CITATIONS:  Haines v Bendall (1991) 172 CLR 60 at page 63

Cattanach v Melchior 215 CLR 1 at paragraph 101

Hyder Consulting (Aust) Pty Ltd v. Wilh Wilhelmsen Agency Pty. Ltd.

The Maersk Colombo [2001] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 275

Consort Express Lines Ltd v J-Mac Pty Ltd (2006) 232 A.L.R. 341 at [14]

Port Kembla Coal Terminal Ltd v Braverus Maritime Inc (2004) 140 FCR 445 at 542 [485]-[486] per Hely J

Harbutt’s Plasticine v Wayne Tank and Pump Co Limited [1970] 1 QB 447 at 473

Pegler v Want (UK) Ltd [2000] All E.R. 260
Hyder Consulting (Aust) Pty Ltd v Wilh Wilhelmsen Agency Pty Ltd [2001] N.S.W.C.A. 313
v Rodier [2006] N.S.W.S.C. 282 Campbell J observed at [143]
Paper Australia Pty Ltd v Ansell Ltd [2007] V.S.C. 484
Davidson v JS Gilbert Fabrications Pty Ltd

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any)

Applicant:Ms C.M. Muir, instructed by McKays Solicitors

Respondent:  Ms S.D. Anderson, instructed by Macrossan and

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant claims $73,945.00 damages plus interest for an alleged breach of a building contract by the respondent, a duly licensed builder.  The defence denies any breach, but alleges that there was a termination by consent of the building contract on the basis that the respondent would pay to the applicant the sum of $12,750.00 by the applicant as a deposit.  It is said that the agreement to terminate by consent was an accord and satisfaction.

  2. Therefore the task for the Tribunal is to determine whether there was a breach of the building contract; to determine whether there was an agreement to terminate the contract by consent whereby the parties relinquished any rights they had to sue for damages; to determine what the legal consequences are of any such termination;  and in the event that the respondent is liable for damages, to assess the quantum of those damages.

    THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE

  3. The applicant was a real estate sales person who became a real estate agent in or about…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cameron v Cavric P/L T/a Cavalier Homes Mackay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QCAT 114
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cameron, a real estate agent and property developer, commenced proceedings against Cavric P/L T/a Cavalier Homes Mackay, a builder, in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Cameron alleged that Cavric P/L had breached a building contract by failing to construct a house on a property at Lenesha Drive, Mackay. The dispute centred on whether Cavric P/L had indeed breached the contract, whether there was an agreement to terminate the contract by consent, and if so, what the legal consequences of such termination were. Additionally, the tribunal had to assess the quantum of damages if Cavric P/L was found liable.

The tribunal examined the evidence presented by both parties. Cameron claimed that she had entered into a building contract with Cavric P/L for the construction of a house on a property at Lenesha Drive, which was to be completed within a specified timeframe. However, Cavric P/L allegedly failed to commence or complete the construction, leading to Cameron's losses. Cavric P/L, on the other hand, argued that the contract had been terminated by consent and that Cameron had made a profit from the Nebo Road transaction, which should be deducted from any damages claimed. The tribunal had to determine the validity of these claims and counter-claims.

The tribunal concluded that Cavric P/L had breached the contract by not commencing or completing the construction as agreed. It found no evidence to support Cavric P/L's claim that the contract had been terminated by consent. Moreover, the tribunal rejected Cavric P/L's argument that Cameron's profit from the Nebo Road transaction should be deducted from her damages. The tribunal awarded Cameron damages in the sum of $40,231.00 for the breach of contract. It also awarded interest on the deposit monies and the capital loss, totalling $2,169.48. The tribunal determined that costs should follow the event, with 60% of Cameron's costs to be assessed on the lowest District Court Scale.

In summary, the tribunal found in favour of Cameron, awarding her damages for the breach of contract and interest on her losses. Costs were awarded on a pro-rata basis, reflecting Cavric P/L's partial success in its defence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Therefore the task for the Tribunal is to determine whether there was a breach of the building contract; to determine whether there was an agreement to terminate the contract by consent whereby the parties relinquished any rights they had to sue for damages; to determine what the legal consequences are of any such termination; and in the event that the respondent is liable for damages, to assess the quantum of those damages.THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE The applicant was a real estate sales person who became a real estate agent in or about February 2007. In the course of her occupation, she had arranged to sell “spec” houses built by the respondent. She was also buying land and building houses on such land for rental purposes. At the same time, the applicant was running a curtain and blinds business known as “Curtain Fairy”. On 27 July 2007 the parties entered into a “QC1 2000 New Home Construction Contract” for the respondent to build a house “the Cambridge 24” on land owned by the applicant at Lot 21 Lenesha Drive, Mackay (“Lenesha Drive”) to specification for a price of $255,000.00 including GST (“the contract”). Amongst other things, the contract provided for construction to start within twenty-one days of Council approval of the plans; for practical completion in 186 days; window furnishings, turf and fencing were excluded from the specifications. The applicant says that she never actually saw the specifications and assumed that the “finish” would be the same as other houses the respondent had built of the same design and which she had become familiar with through her sales activities, and in particular, a house at Companion Way, Mackay; and another house situated at Firefly Crescent, Mackay in respect of which the applicant had also entered into a building contract with the respondent for the respondent to build. The respondent’s witness, Mr Hewitt, who was the respondent’s project manager at the relevant time, agreed that the specifications for Lenesha Drive were the same as for the other houses. It is not in dispute that the respondent knew before entering into the contract that the applicant’s intention was to rent the home once it was completed. The applicant paid a deposit of $12,750.00 to the respondent on 11 September 2007, more than six weeks after the signing of the contract, although the contract provided for that to be paid upon the signing of the contract (Clause 4.2). The applicant said that the reason for the late payment was simply that she paid the deposit when she got an invoice from the respondent requesting payment. She also paid the deposit on the Firefly agreement on the same day, the Firefly contract having also been entered into on 27 July 2007. It would appear from the evidence of Mr Hewitt, who dealt with the applicant, that he was unaware that the deposit had not been paid on the signing of the contract, and assumed that it had been paid on that date. The applicant proposed to pay the progress payments stipulated by the contract by draw- downs from her mortgage on her residential home. Thus an actual mortgage of the Lenesha Drive property was not necessary, but she would still have to pay interest to the lender on the draw-downs, at the home loan interest rate charged by the lender from time to time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept the applicant’s evidence in this regard and I find that there is no causal connection between the respondent’s failure to construct the Lenesha Drive house and the applicant’s decision to buy and then sell the Nebo Road property. Therefore I do not deduct the profit that the applicant made from the Nebo Road transaction from her damages.CONCLUSION I therefore propose to order that the respondent pay to the applicant the sum of FORTY THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED and THIRTY ONE DOLLARS ($40,231.00) for breach of contract. The applicant sought interest on the deposit monies in the amount of $971.48, relating to the applicant having lost the use of that money between 11 September 2007 and 28 July 2008. The respondent did not dispute the calculation of this amount of interest by the applicant. The applicant also sought interest on the capital loss, for which calculations were provided based on the claimed capital loss of $42,945.00 from 13 August 2009 to 12 March 2010. The calculation results in a claim of $1,396.18. Since I have found that the capital loss claimable from the respondent is not $42,945.00, but $23,945.00, I calculate that the interest on a pro-rata basis is $778.00. I add another $100.00 to that to account for a period of approximately two weeks from 12 March 2010 up to the date of judgment. By reason of this matter having commenced prior to the commencement of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal on 1 December, 2009, but the hearing not actually occurring until subsequent to the commencement of QCAT, the cost provisions of the Commercial and Consumer Tribunal Act 2003 still apply – see Owen v The Adams Group Pty. Ltd. [2010] QCAT 10. However, both the parties in this case agree that costs should follow the event, as I understand it, particularly because of the complexity of the matter, including complexity as to the calculation of damages.There also seems to be agreement that if there was a situation where one party was partially successful, costs should be awarded on a pro-rata basis. In any event, if there was no such agreement in fact between the parties, it is my view that the respondent did have partial success in its defence and that it is fair and reasonable that costs be awarded on an approximate pro rata basis. In my view, an appropriate proportion would be allowing 60% of the applicant’s costs of and incidental to this action to be assessed on the lowest District Court Scale

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.