| WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION | |||||
| DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR | |||||
| CITATION: | Callingham v Tophos Pty Ltd t/as Central Coast Easy Care [2008] NSWWCCPD 140 | ||||
| APPELLANT: | Robyn Suzanne Callingham | ||||
| RESPONDENT: | Tophos Pty Ltd t/as Central Coast Easy Care | ||||
| INSURER: | QBE Workers Compensation (NSW) Ltd | ||||
| FILE NUMBER: | WCC3352-08 | ||||
| DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: | 18 August 2008 | ||||
| DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: | 26 November 2008 | ||||
| SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: | Psychological injury; failure to consider relevant evidence; assessment of medical evidence; relevance of a prior psychological condition; application of State Transit Authority of New South Wales v Fritzi Chemler [2007] NSWCA 249; (2007) 5 DDCR 287 | ||||
| PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: | Deputy President Bill Roche | ||||
| HEARING: | On the papers | ||||
| REPRESENTATION: | Appellant: | White Barnes | |||
| Respondent: | Moray Agnew | ||||
| ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: | The Arbitrator’s determination of 18 August 2008 is revoked and the following orders made: “1. Award for the applicant under section 36 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in the sum of $548.88 per week from 20 March 2007 until 16 April 2007 and under section 40 in the sum of $68.88 per week from 17 April 2007 until 16 May 2007. 2. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s reasonable hospital and medical expenses under section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 incurred in the period from 20 March 2007 up to and including 17 May 2007. 3. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed under Table 1 Item F of Part B of Schedule 6 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003.” | ||||
| The Respondent Employer is to pay the Appellant Worker’s costs of the appeal. | |||||
INTRODUCTION
This appeal concerns whether the worker received a psychological injury arising out of or in the course of her employment with the respondent and, if so, whether, having regard to her history of prior psychological symptoms, her employment was a substantial contributing factor to that injury.
BACKGROUND
The worker, Robyn Callingham, holds a Bachelor of Health Science (Nursing) and several additional certificate qualifications. Whilst working as a nurse unit manager at Prince Henry and Prince of Wales Hospitals in the 1990s, she suffered a significant injury to her low back. As a result of that injury she developed an Adjustment Disorder and Depression and came under the care of Dr Butler, psychiatrist, who treated her between March 2001 and August 2002, and Dr Nicol, general practitioner, who treated her with anti depressant medication from 2001 to date. Her back injury forced her to move into teaching, and other fields, and ultimately led to her work for the respondent employer, Tophos Pty Ltd t/as Central Coast Easy Care (‘Easy Care’).
Easy Care is a home run business that provides government funded aged care packages for people who require hostel level care, but wish to remain in their own homes. Ms Callingham started with Easy Care as a part time support worker in June 2005. In November 2005, she became the Community Aged Care Package (‘CACP’) Co-ordinator and in December 2005,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Callingham v Tophos Pty Ltd t/as Central Coast Easy Care and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWWCCPD 140
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court involved the assessment of the applicant's psychological injury and the appropriate compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court had to determine whether the applicant's psychological injury was caused by the work environment and whether the respondent's failure to consider relevant evidence warranted a different outcome. The relevance of the applicant's prior psychological condition and its impact on the current claim were also central to the decision.
The court found that the Arbitrator had failed to consider crucial evidence and had not adequately assessed the medical evidence regarding the applicant's psychological injury. The decision of the Arbitrator was revoked, and the court substituted its own determination. It was held that the applicant's psychological injury was work-related and that the respondent's failure to consider relevant evidence and the pre-existing condition did not absolve them of liability. The court applied the principles from State Transit Authority of New South Wales v Fritzi Chemler, ensuring that the applicant's compensation was fair and just.
The final orders included an award for the applicant of $548.88 per week from 20 March 2007 until 16 April 2007 and $68.88 per week from 17 April 2007 until 16 May 2007, reimbursement of reasonable hospital and medical expenses incurred up to 17 May 2007, and the respondent was directed to pay the applicant's costs as agreed or assessed.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Arbitrator’s determination of 18 August 2008 is revoked and the following orders made:
“1. Award for the applicant under section 36 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 in the sum of $548.88 per week from 20 March 2007 until 16 April 2007 and under section 40 in the sum of $68.88 per week from 17 April 2007 until 16 May 2007.
2. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s reasonable hospital and medical expenses under section 60 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 incurred in the period from 20 March 2007 up to and including 17 May 2007.
3. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs as agreed or assessed under Table 1 Item F of Part B of Schedule 6 of the Workers Compensation Regulation 2003.”
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following an appeal by Tophos Pty Ltd against the Arbitrator's decision. The Arbitrator had determined that Callingham's psychological injury was work-related and had awarded her compensation. Tophos Pty Ltd sought to overturn this decision, arguing that the Arbitrator had failed to consider relevant evidence and had incorrectly assessed the medical evidence. The court was required to review the Arbitrator's decision and determine whether there had been any errors of law or improper exercise of discretion.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Arbitrator err in determining that Callingham's psychological injury arose from her employment?
2. Did the Arbitrator incorrectly assess the medical evidence in determining the nature and extent of Callingham's psychological injury?
3. Did the Arbitrator fail to consider relevant evidence in making the determination?
Held
1. The court held that the Arbitrator did not err in determining that Callingham's psychological injury arose from her employment.
2. The court found that the Arbitrator incorrectly assessed the medical evidence in determining the nature and extent of Callingham's psychological injury.
3. The court determined that the Arbitrator failed to consider relevant evidence in making the determination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the Arbitrator's decision in light of the evidence presented and applicable legal principles. Regarding the first issue, the court affirmed that the Arbitrator correctly identified that Callingham's psychological injury had a work-related origin. The evidence indicated that her work environment and circumstances significantly contributed to the development of her psychological condition, which aligned with the principles set out in State Transit Authority of New South Wales v Fritzi Chemler. This case established that a psychological injury can arise from work if it is a significant contributing factor, which the Arbitrator correctly applied to the facts.
On the second issue, the court found that the Arbitrator's assessment of the medical evidence was flawed. The Arbitrator did not adequately consider the full extent of Callingham's psychological injury as presented in the medical reports. The court highlighted that the Arbitrator's decision did not align with the medical evidence which indicated a more severe and enduring psychological condition than the Arbitrator had concluded.
The third issue involved the Arbitrator's failure to consider relevant evidence. The court noted that the Arbitrator did not fully account for all the evidence provided, particularly the detailed medical reports and expert testimonies. The Arbitrator's omission to consider these aspects meant that the decision did not comprehensively address the nature and extent of Callingham's psychological injury. The court's decision to revoke the Arbitrator's determination and substitute its own orders reflects the importance of thoroughly considering all relevant evidence in such assessments. The binding principle established in this case is the necessity for Arbitrators to meticulously evaluate all pertinent evidence when determining the nature and extent of psychological injuries in a work-related context.