Cahill v Benjamin

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: Cahill v Benjamin [2010] NTMC 010

PARTIES: LEIGH CAHILL

v

MESEKE BENJAMIN

TITLE OF COURT: COURT OF SUMMARY JURISDICTION

JURISDICTION: Criminal

FILE NO(s): 20904908

DELIVERED ON: 4 February 2010

DELIVERED AT: Darwin

HEARING DATE(s): 12 October 2009

JUDGMENT OF: Ms Sue Oliver SM

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – Traffic Act – Fail to supply sufficient sample – defence of reasonable grounds for failure to supply - drive disqualified – sudden and extraordinary emergency
Hales v Psaras [2003] NTMC 024
Johnson v The State of WA [2009] WASCA 71
CTM v The Queen (2008) 82 ALJR 978
Traffic Act ss 29AAE, 31(1), 29AAU
Criminal Code s 33

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
Complainant: Mr T Smith
Defendant: Mr R Welfare

Solicitors:
Complainant: Police Prosecutions
Defendant: Welfare & Associates

Judgment category classification: A
Judgment ID number: [2010] NTMC 010
Number of paragraphs: 28


IN THE COURT OF SUMMARY JURISDICTION
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 20904908
[2010] NTMC 010

BETWEEN:

LEIGH CAHILL
Complainant

AND:

MESEKE BENJAMIN
Defendant

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 4 February 2010)

Ms Sue Oliver SM:
1. The defendant Meseke Benjamin, has pleaded not guilty to two charges under the Traffic Act alleged to have been committed on 8 February 2009. The first charge is one of failing to provide a sufficient sample of breath for analysis contrary to s 29AAE and, secondly, that being a person disqualified from holding a driver’s licence drove a motor vehicle contrary to s 31(1) of the Traffic Act.
2. There is no dispute that the defendant was driving a vehicle, said to belong to a friend. He was stopped by police who were driving an unmarked vehicle on Trower Road after they observed it drift in the lane and the indicator being put on to turn left and then move lanes to the right. The defendant in his evidence said that he had intended to turn on the windscreen wipers but in that vehicle the indicator stick and windscreen wiper stick were reversed from the normal configuration. When asked where he was going he told the officers that he was going to the hospital. Constable Dudson, who gave evidence, was sceptical about this because the defendant was not travelling in the direction of the hospital but seemingly away from it. Constable Dudson said that it was not raining.
3. The defendant was breath tested at the roadside and, as a result of the indication of blood alcohol produced, was arrested for the purpose of a breath analysis. He was not however showing any signs of intoxication. His speech and walking were “fine”. He was taken to the Darwin Watchhouse where the other officer, Constable Burns, attempted to conduct the breath analysis. A Form 2 under the Traffic Regulations, (“Certificate on refusal or failure to submit to or provide a sample of breath sufficient for completion of breath analysis” (“the certificate”)) was tendered. The certificate is prima facie evidence of the matters stated in the certificate and the facts on which they are based…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cahill v Benjamin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NTMC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cahill v Benjamin involved the defendant, Meseke Benjamin, contesting two charges under the Traffic Act: failure to provide a sufficient sample of breath for analysis and driving while disqualified. The court heard the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, with the defendant pleading not guilty to both charges. The legal issues before the court were whether the defendant had reasonable grounds for failing to provide a sufficient breath sample and whether his driving under a disqualification was excused under the sudden and extraordinary emergency provision.

The court found that the defendant had reasonable grounds for failing to provide a sufficient breath sample due to the pain he experienced while attempting to provide the sample. Although the court acknowledged that pain may indicate detriment to medical condition, it determined that the defendant had not shown that continuing to breathe into the tube would have been detrimental. Instead, the court accepted that the defendant had attempted to provide a sample but was unable to do so due to the pain he was experiencing. Consequently, the court found that the defendant had established the defence of having other reasonable grounds for failing to submit to the breath analysis.

Regarding the charge of driving while disqualified, the court considered whether the defendant's actions were excused under the sudden and extraordinary emergency provision. The court determined that the defendant's desperate need to seek medical assistance, driven by his belief that his life was in danger and that his siblings would be left without support if he died, constituted a sudden and extraordinary emergency. The court accepted that an ordinary person in the defendant's situation might have acted similarly to get medical treatment. Therefore, the court found that the prosecution had not disproved the defence of sudden and extraordinary emergency, and dismissed both charges against the defendant.

In conclusion, the Court of Summary Jurisdiction dismissed the charges against Meseke Benjamin, finding that he had reasonable grounds for failing to provide a sufficient breath sample and that his driving under a disqualification was excused under the sudden and extraordinary emergency provision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established