OFFICIAL NOTICE
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Application : No. 706901 in the name of Cadbury Schweppes PLC
Title: Process for the Manufacture of Reduced Fat Chocolate
Action: Opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by Effem Foods Pty Ltd
Decision: Issued .
Abstract
The invention relates to a method for making reduced fat chocolate wherein no water is added to the composition during the size reduction step to dissolve unwanted ultrafine particles.
Claims 1 to 10 are novel as no cited art discloses both the absence of the water addition step and prepares a fat reduced chocolate.
Claims 1 to 10 are obvious in light of "Particle Size Distribution Effects in Chocolate Processing" by A.D. Darley, University of Bradford, 1987, which assesses the same issues as addressed in the current application and teaches the exclusion of a water addition step from full fat chocolate manufacture. The delegate concluded that the application of this technique to reduced fat chocolate manufacture would be obvious to try.
The claims were found to be clear, fairly based and directed to a manner of manufacture.
The application was refused.
PATENTS ACT 1990
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS
Re:Patent Application No. 706901 by Cadbury Schweppes PLC and opposition under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990 by Effem Foods Pty Ltd.
BACKGROUND
Patent application no. 706901 was filed under the Patent Cooperation Treaty on 21 December 1995 under International Application Number PCT/GB95/03010. The application claimed priority from British Application 9426078 dated 23 December 1994. The application was advertised accepted on 1 July 1999. Notice of opposition was filed on 1 October 1999 by Effem Foods Pty Ltd ("the opponent ") and the evidentiary stages completed by 12 November 2001.
The opposition was heard in Canberra on 19 February 2002. Cadbury Schweppes was represented by Mr David Clark assisted by Mr Rohan Wallace, both of whom are patent attorneys of Griffith Hack Patent and Trademark Attorneys, Sydney. Effem Foods Pty Ltd was represented by Ms Katherine Leviton and Mr Christian Schieber, both patent attorneys of Watermark Patent and Trademark Attorneys, Sydney.
THE GROUNDS OF OPPOSITION
The grounds of opposition identified in the statement of grounds and particulars, are that the invention as claimed:
is not novel in the light of published documents or acts done in Australia
is obvious and does not involve an inventive step
is not a manner of manufacture
does not comply with the requirements of section 40 in respect of the fair basis and clarity of the claims.
THE EVIDENCE
The evidence in support consists of:
(a)statutory declarations by:
· Cornelius Versteeg, Group Manager, Food Engineering at Food Science Australia, dated 4 October 2000 and Exhibits CV-1 to CV-4 ("Versteeg 1").
· Katherine Margaret Leviton, Patent Attorney of Watermark Patent and Trademark Attorneys, dated , dated 4 October 2000 and Exhibit KML-1 ("Leviton 1").
(b)Documents D1 to D21.
The evidence in answer consists of statutory declarations…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cadbury Schweppes PLC v Effem Foods Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] APO 38
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the claims were novel as the cited prior art did not disclose the absence of the water addition step and the preparation of reduced fat chocolate. However, the court held that the claims lacked an inventive step in light of a prior art document, "Particle Size Distribution Effects in Chocolate Processing" by A.D. Darley, which taught the exclusion of a water addition step in full fat chocolate manufacture. The court concluded that applying this technique to reduced fat chocolate manufacture would have been obvious to try.
The court also addressed Section 40 matters, finding that the claims were clear and fairly based, despite some ambiguity in the term "further processing." The court concluded that the claims were directed to a manner of manufacture and thus patentable.
The court refused the application due to the lack of an inventive step and awarded costs against the applicant.