C and C Fisher Pty Ltd v Livadaras

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

C & C Fisher Pty Ltd v Livadaras [2010] FCA 11

Citation: C & C Fisher Pty Ltd v Livadaras [2010] FCA 11
Parties: C & C FISHER PTY LTD (ACN 123 285 370) AND AUSTRALIAN OLIVES LIMITED (ACN 078 885 042) v SPYRIDON LIVADARAS, HUNTLEY MANAGEMENT LIMITED (ACN 089 240 513) AND OTHERS
File number: QUD 22 of 2009
Judge: REEVES J
Date of judgment: 21 January 2010
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – Meeting of members of registered managed investment scheme – Responsible entity and associates cannot vote if have an interest in the resolution other than as a member – Associate is a person who acts or proposes to act in concert with the responsible entity

CORPORATIONS – Decision by chairperson to exclude votes – Whether decision amenable to review – Whether chairperson acted in bad faith or made an error of law – Consideration of what is meant by ‘bad faith’ – Whether the chairperson acted impartially and without bias or prejudgment

CORPORATIONS – Decision by chairperson to exclude votes – Whether decision amenable to review – Whether chairperson acted in bad faith or made an error of law – No separate obligation to act on reasonable grounds – Any decision made in good faith and according to law is final and conclusive – Irrationality and illogicality in fact-finding does not constitute an error of law – Judicial review of administrative decision-making not an apt analogy – Wednesbury unreasonableness limited to discretionary decisions

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 15, 601FB(1), 252B(1)(a), 253E, 253G, Part 1.2, Div 2, Part 2G.4, Part 5C.1, Part 5C.2

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Olives Ltd v Livadaras (2008) 172 FCR 34
Southern Wine Corporation Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Perera (2006) 61 ACSR 40
Bank of Western Australia Ltd v Ocean Trawlers Pty Ltd (1995) 16 ACSR 501
City Pacific Limited v Bacon (No 2) [2009] FCA 772
Lewis v Green [1905] 2 Ch 340
Smart v Allen (1970) 91 WN(NSW) 241
Re Adams International Food Traders Pty Ltd (1988) 13 NSWLR 282
Link Agricultural Pty. Ltd. v Shanahan [1999] 1 VR 466
NAAV v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 228
SCAS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 397

McLean Bros & Rigg Ltd v Grice (1906) 4 CLR 835
Sun Zhan Qui v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 151 ALR 505
Gamaethige v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 109 FCR 424

Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H (2001) 179 ALR 425
Byng v London Life Association Ltd. [1990] Ch 170
Re Telford Inns Pty Ltd (1985) 10 ACLR 312
ANZ Nominees Limited v Allied Resources Corporation Limited (1984) 2 ACLC 783
Perera v Reilly (2007) 59 ACSR 317
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Al-Miahi (2001) 65 ALD 141
Attorney-General (NSW) v Quin (1990) 170 CLR 1
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321
Re Minister for Immigration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read C and C Fisher Pty Ltd v Livadaras and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of C & C Fisher Pty Ltd v Livadaras, the central issue revolved around the voting rights of C & C Fisher Pty Ltd, a member of a managed investment scheme, during a meeting where resolutions were to be considered. The dispute centred on whether the responsible entity and its associates could vote on resolutions where they had an interest, as per the Corporations Act. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether the decision of the meeting's chairperson to exclude certain votes was subject to review and whether the chairperson had acted in bad faith or made an error of law. This involved examining the meaning of 'bad faith' in the context of administrative decisions and whether the chairperson had acted impartially and without bias. The court also had to consider if the decision-making process was subject to the same principles as judicial review, particularly regarding errors of law and Wednesbury unreasonableness.

The court's reasoning focused on the concept of 'bad faith' and whether the chairperson's actions demonstrated a lack of honesty or a knowingly improper purpose. The court found that the chairperson's decision to exclude the votes was not influenced by bad faith, as there was no evidence to suggest that the chairperson had prejudged the issues or acted with personal fault beyond factual errors. The court further clarified that the decision-making process did not involve a separate obligation to act on reasonable grounds and that any decision made in good faith and according to law was final and conclusive. The court rejected the notion that irrationality or illogicality in fact-finding constituted an error of law, distinguishing administrative decisions from judicial review under Wednesbury unreasonableness.

In conclusion, the court dismissed C & C Fisher's challenge to the chairperson's ruling, finding no evidence of bad faith or error of law in the decision to exclude certain votes. The final order was that the application filed on 16 January 2009 be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed on 16 January 2009 be dismissed.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

As to the second of these issues, C & C Fisher and Australian Olives have submitted that it involves a consideration of the reasonableness of Mr Livadaras’ ruling. I will consider whether that is so later in these Reasons.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Before addressing these issues, it is appropriate to set out some more details of the factual background to this dispute.Mr Johnston of Australian Olives offers Mr Campbell Fisher of C & C Fisher a business opportunity In about 2006, Mr Campbell Fisher, a director of C & C Fisher, first met Mr Anthony Johnston, a director of Australian Olives. This meeting occurred because their daughters were attending the same school and their wives both served on that school’s fundraising committee. In early 2008 (this date was later changed in evidence to mid-2008), Mr Fisher became aware that Mr Johnston had an interest in some olive groves located at Yallamundi in New South Wales. This came about because Mr Johnston explained the ownership arrangements for the olive groves and suggested to Mr Fisher that they may present a business opportunity for him. In his explanation, Mr Johnston told Mr Fisher, among other things, that:·the olive groves were held in a number of managed investment schemes;·the olive trees had been affected by drought and were not yielding the forecast yields and, as a result, the investors in the schemes were complaining;·he had invested $20 million in the schemes and he needed to find a way to make them work;·the managed investment scheme structure was an expensive and unduly complex one;·they may be able to collapse the schemes and run the olive groves as an integrated agricultural operation; and·this was where the business opportunity lay. As a result of this discussion, Mr Fisher expressed an interest in becoming involved and Mr Johnston referred him to Mr Simon Beddoe, Australian Olives’ Investment Relations Manager. In August 2008, Mr Fisher contacted Mr Beddoe and obtained from him a purchase interest form. He then had a meeting with Mr Blake Ammit, the Executive Director of Australian Olives, who provided him with a range of documentation in relation to the Australian Olives Project No. 3, ie, the Scheme.C & C Fisher purchases 70 olive groves in the Scheme On or about 20 August 2008, C & C Fisher entered into a Deed of Assignment with Australian Olives for the transfer to it of 70 olive groves in the Scheme. It was originally proposed in an exchange of emails between Mr Fisher and Mr Beddoe that C & C Fisher would pay $20 per grove (ie a total of $1,400). However, as a result of an error on Mr Beddoe’s part, the consideration for the transfer of the 70 groves was stated in the Deed of Assignment to be $140. On 26 August 2008, Mr Beddoe sent an email to Mr Fisher acknowledging receipt of a copy of the signed documentation and advising that the original documentation was expected to arrive on the following day. That email also included the following statement: “You may not be aware the [sic that] a members meeting has been called in relation to Project 3 which has been set down for this Friday 29 August 2008. Please find a copy of the Notice calling the meeting, response from the Board of Australian Olives and a proxy to be completed and returned to this office. Alternatively you may wish to attend the meeting in person; the details are included in the Notice of meeting information”.Extraordinary resolution to remove Australian Olives as the responsible entity

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, there is a number of responses to the allegation (at 43.8 above) that Mr Livadaras took no steps to put Australian Olives, or C & C Fisher, on notice as to the issues he intended to raise at the 12 December meeting. First, there is the obvious response that Mr Livadaras was not to know, until he attended the meeting, that he would be elected as its Chairman. Secondly, and more importantly, all of the members of the Scheme, including Australian Olives and C & C Fisher, had received the notice of the meeting, which set out the extraordinary resolutions to be considered at the meeting. Moreover, this was the third adjourned meeting held to consider those resolutions and it is apparent from the transcript of the 12 December meeting that those who attended were well aware that the entitlement of C & C Fisher to cast its 70 votes was to be the central issue at the meeting. This is borne out by the fact that Mr Shaw, Australian Olives’ solicitor, was sufficiently prepared that he was able to address the meeting at length about the legal issues involved with the C & C Fisher votes, including matters such as what the terms “associates” and “acting in concert” meant in the construction of s 253E of the Act. Further, there was quite a deal of discussion by Mr Shaw and others at the meeting about the reasons of Greenwood J on the similar issues in Livadaras.Conclusion In conclusion on this aspect, whether they are taken separately or together, I consider none of these matters supports C & C Fisher’s serious allegation of bad faith against Mr Livadaras. This is so because none of them provides any support for the conclusion that Mr Livadaras acted with any lack of honesty, or knowingly exercised his power as the Chairman of the meeting for an improper purpose. At the highest for C & C Fisher, these matters suggest that Mr Livadaras held a view that it was in the best interests of the members of the Scheme that Australian Olives be replaced as the responsible entity. However, there is no indication from a fair reading of the transcript of the 12 December meeting, to suggest he pursued that view at the meeting in such a manner that a conclusion of bad faith can be drawn against him. For these reasons, I find that C & C Fisher have failed to establish this aspect of their challenge to Mr Livadaras’ ruling.ERROR OF LAWIntroduction The second issue that arises in relation to the ruling made by Mr Livadaras at the 12 December meeting is, even if it was made in good faith, whether it involved some error of law. On this issue, C & C Fisher do not appear to have identified a specific error of law made by Mr Livadaras, in making his ruling, but instead they have relied upon a somewhat imprecise set of submissions to the effect that Mr Livadaras acted unreasonably in making the ruling and thereby committed an error of law. They may have taken this approach because they were aware of the conclusion Greenwood J reached in Livadaras that the similar ruling made in that case involved conclusions of fact, rather than any questions of law: see Livadaras at [109]. If they did, as my reasons below will show, I consider C & C Fisher are essentially attempting to use this claim of unreasonableness to seek a review of Mr Livadaras’ factual conclusions under the guise of an error of law.Contentions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The concept of “bad faith” has been considered extensively in numerous decisions under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). Whilst there are some unique features of the jurisprudence under that Act, in my view, the principles that have been expressed there in relation to “bad faith” apply equally in the context of this matter. In summary, those principles are that: “bad faith” is a serious allegation involving a lack of an honest or genuine attempt to undertake the task at hand. It includes the exercise of a power knowingly for an improper purpose. It involves personal fault on the part of the decision-maker going beyond error of fact or law. It must therefore be clearly identified and proved: see, for example, NAAV v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 228 at [107] to [108] and SCAS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 397 at [19].Consideration of C & C Fisher’s allegations of bad faith It is appropriate to begin my consideration of C & C Fisher’s allegations of bad faith by noting that Mr Livadaras’ role as Chairman of the 12 December meeting relevantly included a requirement for him to hear the contentions of fact going to the questions he had to decide and to decide those issues impartially taking into account those facts and any facts known to him at the time: see McLean Bros & Rigg Ltd v Grice (1906) 4 CLR 835 (“McLean Bros”) at 860 per Barton J and Livadaras at [68]. The requirement of impartiality obviously dictates an absence of bias or prejudgment. Some of C & C Fisher’s allegations against Mr Livadaras are to the effect he was biased, or more specifically, he had prejudged the issues he had to determine at the meeting: see [43.2], [43.3] and [43.5] above. To establish these allegations of bias, or prejudgment, against Mr Livadaras, C & C Fisher will need to show that Mr Livadaras had, and maintained, a closed mind on the question of the validity of the C & C Fisher votes, or that he was unable or unwilling to decide that question impartially: see Sun Zhan Qui v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 151 ALR 505 at 555 per Burchett J and Gamaethige v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 109 FCR 424 (“Gamaethige”) at 442 to 443 per Stone J (with whom Hill J agreed). It will not be sufficient for C & C Fisher to show that Mr Livadaras held views about the desirability of removing Australian Olives as the responsible entity for the Scheme: see Vakauta v Kelly (1989) 167 CLR 568 at 576 per Dawson J and Gamaethige at 443 per Stone J. This point is important because, on the evidence before me, I find that Mr Livadaras probably did hold the view that it was in the best interests of the members of the Scheme that Australian Olives be removed as the responsible entity for the Scheme. However, I consider that C & C Fisher must go much further than this and show, for example, that Mr Livadaras was not willing to receive relevant information about the validity of the C & C Fisher votes, or was not willing to listen to arguments on that question, or demonstrated by his conduct that he was not open to be persuaded to a contrary view.