PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Show cause hearing pursuant to r.44.12 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) – no arguable case for the relief claimed – application dismissed.
The applicant appeared in person with the assistance of a Mandarin interpreter.
Solicitor for the Respondents:
Ms Sharon Sangha (Mills Oakley Lawyers)
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY
SYG 2647 of 2015
BZB15
Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
EX TEMPORE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 28 September 2015, the applicant filed an application seeking judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 31 August 2015 and handed down on 1 September 2015 (“the Tribunal”).
On 5 November 2015, the applicant attended a directions hearing before a Registrar of the Court. On that occasion, the applicant was given leave to file and serve an Amended Application giving complete particulars of each ground of review relied upon, together with any further evidence by way of affidavit, as well as submissions in support, by 3 December 2015.
At the request of the first respondent, the matter was listed for hearing today pursuant to r.44.12 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) (“the Rules”), a copy of which was also given to the applicant.
Rule 44.12 of the Rules provides as follows:
“(1) At a hearing of an application for an order to show cause, the Court may:
(a) if it is not satisfied that the application has raised an arguable case for the relief claimed—dismiss the application; or
(b) if it is satisfied that the application has raised an arguable case for the relief claimed—adjourn the proceeding and order a respondent to show cause at a final hearing why an order for the relief claimed should not be made on such of the grounds mentioned in the application as are specified by the Court; or
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BZB15 v Minister for Immigration and more:
The applicant, a citizen of China, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that affirmed a delegate's refusal to grant him a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant claimed to fear harm in China due to his opposition to local government officials regarding the alleged misappropriation of compensation funds following land expropriation. The delegate had refused the visa, finding the applicant's accounts of assault and detention not credible. The AAT subsequently affirmed this decision, finding the applicant's claims lacked credibility due to inconsistencies in his oral and written evidence, implausibility of certain aspects of his account, and concerns regarding the authenticity of supporting documents.
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the AAT erred in law by failing to adequately consider the applicant's documentary evidence and by making adverse credibility findings that were not supported by evidence or were based on an incorrect application of legal principles. Specifically, the court was asked to determine if the Tribunal's rejection of the applicant's claims and supporting documents, based on perceived inconsistencies and implausibilities, constituted a reviewable error.
Emmett J found that the AAT had indeed considered the applicant's documentary evidence, detailing in its decision the reasons for finding it problematic, including the lack of official seals, certification, and the questionable origin of English translations. The Tribunal also thoroughly examined the applicant's oral evidence, noting internal inconsistencies and discrepancies with prior statements, and found his explanations for these deficiencies, such as lack of education, unconvincing. The court concluded that the Tribunal's adverse credibility findings were open to it on the evidence before it and that the Tribunal had not erred in law in its assessment of the applicant's claims or its consideration of the documentary evidence.
The application for judicial review was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
The first respondent, in written submissions, accurately summarised the background, the applicant’s claims, the Delegate’s decision, the Tribunal’s review, and the Tribunal’s decision, as follows:“Background and the applicant's case2. The applicant is a citizen of China who first arrived in Australia on 1 August 2013 on a Visitor (Subclass 600) visa and departed on 8 August 2013: CB 50. He then returned to Australia on 21 February 2014 on a Visitor (Subclass 600) visa, which was valid until 6 March 2014: CB 50.3. The applicant lodged a Protection (Class XA) visa application on 24 February 2014 (CB 1-25) and appointed a migration agent to assist him: CB 26-28.4. In a typed statement accompanying his visa application, the applicant outlined his written claims to fear harm because he opposed the town government for failing to distribute compensation to the villagers after their land was expropriated: CB 29-30. He claimed that in October 2011, all arable, residential and enterprise land was expropriated by the Laishui government and each household was to receive 130,000 RMB but instead the town and village cadres were suspected of misappropriating the compensation money.5. The applicant and another villager were nominated to lodge a petition requesting that the “corrupt situation” be investigated and in June 2013, the applicant petitioned the Baoding government who referred him to the Discipline Inspection Department (DID). The applicant claimed that the town and village cadres sought revenge and on 25 July 2013 they broke into his home and beat him and his family.6. On 18 August 2013, the applicant went to the DID and spoke to the Department Secretary who told him to return the next day. When the applicant returned, he was taken by the police, detained for 15 days on the charge of disturbing social order and allegedly threatened, abused and warned not to oppose the government. His wife was required to pay 2000 RMB to secure his release. The applicant felt disappointed in the government and spent 130,000 RMB to pay an agent to help him obtain a visa for Australia.The delegate's decision7. In a decision dated 22 August 2014, the delegate refused to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa: CB 45-48. The delegate relied on independent country information about the expropriation of land by the Laishui government and was not satisfied that the applicant or the other households in the village were entitled to the claimed compensation. The delegate also found that the applicant's accounts of the assault in July 2013 and detention in August 2013 were not credible: CB 58.The Tribunal proceedings8. The applicant sought review to the Tribunal on 24 September 2014: CB 62-67. He appointed the same migration agent to assist him in connection with the review: CB 64.9. By a letter dated 16 June 2014, the applicant was invited to attend a hearing before the Tribunal scheduled for 23 July 2014 to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in relation to the decision under review: CB 73-74. He attended the hearing on 23 July 2014 and was assisted by a Mandarin interpreter: CB 75. He also provided a copy of his passport to the Tribunal: CB 76-81.10. By a letter dated 27 July 2015, the Tribunal invited the applicant to comment on or respond to information that it considered would be the reason or part of the reason for affirming the decision under review: CB 83-85. The letter outlined four claims made by the applicant at his interview with the delegate on 19 August 2014 and four claims made by him at his hearing before the Tribunal on 23 July 2015. The invitation explained that the Tribunal may find that the evidence given by the applicant about the events leading to his application for a Protection visa was “inconsistent” and the Tribunal may find that his claims were not true. The applicant was required to respond by 19 August 2015.…13. On 6 August 2015, the applicant's representative sought an extension of one month to respond to the Tribunal's letter of 27 July 2015: CB 86. The Tribunal responded on that same date refusing the request on the basis that no reasonable explanation was provided as to why further time was required: CB 88-89. The Tribunal noted that the information put to the applicant for comment or response was discussed with him at the hearing and considered that the information requested through s.424(2) should already be in his possession or capable of electronic transmission from China: CB 88-89...14. On 19 August 2015 the applicant responded to the invitation in writing through his representative and provided further documents: CB 90-95. His representative also requested an extension of one week “to finish his explanation” but again provided no reasons why further time was required: CB 90. In any event, on 20 August 2015, the applicant through his representative provided further documents and a statement: CB 96-99…The Tribunal decision15. On 31 August 2015, the Tribunal made a decision affirming the decision under review: CB 103-117. The Tribunal found that the applicant's claims were lacking in credibility and that much of his oral evidence was either “internally inconsistent” or inconsistent with his prior statements given at the Departmental interview and in the written statement accompanying his visa application: CB 114, par 67. The Tribunal also found the applicant avoided direct questions by repeating his broad claims in a rehearsed way, found that aspects of his account were “implausible or improbable” and that his claim of fear in China was inconsistent with him travelling outside China on two occasions in 2013 but not making any enquiries to prolong his stay or seek protection: CB 114, par 67.16. The Tribunal considered but did not accept the reasons that the applicant advanced to explain the inconsistencies and deficiencies in his evidence namely, a lack of education, memory difficulties, nervousness and an inability to express himself clearly: CB 114-115, pars 68-69. It also found that he gave inconsistent evidence about the period of his detention and whether the entire village or half of the village was expropriated: CB 114-115, pars 69-70.17. The Tribunal found that the applicant sought to avoid answering questions about where he lived following the expropriation of his land and noted the differences in his various accounts on this issue. Given the identified difficulties with his evidence it gave the purported household certificate no weight: CB 115, par 71.18. In addition, the Tribunal noted inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence about when he first complained about inadequate compensation (CB 115, par 72) and also had concerns with his evidence about his claimed attack on 25 July 2013 and subsequent travel to Australia. The Tribunal relied on the applicant's failure to make enquiries about obtaining protection whilst undertaking overseas travel to Australia and Japan and found this undermined his claimed subjective fear of harm: CB 115-116, pars 73-74. The information regarding the applicant's travel to Australia and Japan was obtained from the applicant's passport copy, which he provided to the Tribunal…19. The Tribunal found the applicant's ability to fund three overseas journeys in less than eight months was inconsistent with his claims to be an uneducated farmer who was displaced from his land and paid inadequate compensation: CB 116, par 75.20. The Tribunal considered the applicant's supporting documents provided after the hearing (CB 90-99) but was not satisfied that any of them were genuine. The Tribunal found the documents were problematic because, for example, the land notice did not bear any official seal or letterhead, none of the documents were certified or notarised and the English translations were prepared either by the applicant or some other unidentified translator: CB 116, par 76. It found that the applicant's credibility was “so damaged” by the problems identified with his evidence that it was not satisfied that his documents were genuine…21. For these reasons, the Tribunal rejected all of the applicant's key factual claims and did not accept that he met the criteria for a protection visa under either s 36(2)(a) or s 36(2)(aa) of the Act: CB 116, pars 78-80. The Tribunal relied on its earlier findings of fact to conclude there was no real risk that the applicant would suffer significant harm: CB 116, par 80.”
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
In relation to the applicant’s complaint that the Tribunal did not consider his documentary evidence, the Tribunal’s decision record identifies in detail the documents that were provided by the applicant for its consideration. The Tribunal’s decision record makes clear that the Tribunal had regard to the documents provided, explored the applicant’s claims with him in some detail at the hearing, and put to him matters of concern that it had about the documents provided and his claims. The relevant finding of the Tribunal is as follows: “76. In considering the applicant's claims, the Tribunal has taken into consideration the documents submitted after the Tribunal hearing. Some of these documents are in themselves problematic. In particular, the Tribunal is concerned that the expropriation of land notice does not bear any official seal or letterhead. None of the documents are certified or notarised and the English translations appear to have been prepared by either the applicant or some other unidentified translator. The applicant's credibility is so damaged by the problems in his oral and written evidence described above that the Tribunal is not satisfied that any of the documents submitted following the hearing are genuine. Nor is the Tribunal satisfied that any of the applicant’s claims relating to his past experiences in China are true.” The Tribunal’s decision record makes clear that the Tribunal rejected the applicant’s claims as lacking credibility. In particular, the Tribunal found the applicant’s oral evidence given at the hearing to be either internally inconsistent, or inconsistent with prior statements given by the applicant at his protection visa interview and the written statement that accompanied the applicant’s protection visa application. The Tribunal made the following relevant finding: “67. The Tribunal finds the applicant's claims to be lacking in credibility. Much of the applicant's oral evidence at the Tribunal hearing was either internally inconsistent or inconsistent with his prior statements at the departmental interview and in the written statement accompanying his visa application. At several points during the hearing, the Tribunal formed the impression that the applicant sought to avoid the Tribunal's direct questions by repeating his broad claims in what appeared to be a rehearsed way. The Tribunal had to remind the applicant on several occasions to focus on the question at hand. The Tribunal finds aspects of the applicant's account of his past experiences, to the extent that it can be discerned, to be implausible or improbable. The applicant's claim to fear harm in China as a result of his past experiences is also inconsistent with the evidence that he travelled outside China on two occasions in 2013 but did not make any enquiries with regard to prolonging his stay or obtaining protection abroad.” The Tribunal considered the applicant’s explanation that the inconsistencies and deficiencies in his evidence were a result of his lack of education; memory difficulties; nervousness; and, an inability to express himself clearly. However, the Tribunal found that the applicant had fabricated the claim that he had received only four years of education in China in an attempt to provide a justification for the defects in his evidence.