Byrne v Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Byrne v Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 66

INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS – prohibited conduct by employer – whether transfer and suspension of employee prejudiced employment in breach of s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) – employee complaint to Office of Workplace Services – employee participation in legal proceeding under industrial law – employee proposed to give evidence in legal proceeding under industrial law – compensation – penalty
Held: transfer and suspension of employee prejudiced employment for prohibited reasons – order for compensation payable to employee – order for penalty payable by employer  

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss 167(2)(a), 792, 793, 807, 809
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 440D
Penalty Interest Rates Act 1983 (Vic) s 2
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A

Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 3) (1998) 195 CLR 1, applied
Squires v Flight Stewards Association of Australia (1982) 2 IR 155, followed
Ponzio v B & P Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd (2007) 158 FCR 543, referred to
Community & Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2001) 104 IR 195, applied

NICOLE BYRNE (A Workplace Inspector pursuant to s 167 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996) v AUSTRALIAN OPHTHALMIC SUPPLIES PTY LTD (ACN 005 419 107) (Administrator Appointed)

VID 1104 OF 2006

MARSHALL J
14 FEBRUARY 2008
SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1104 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

NICOLE BYRNE (A Workplace Inspector pursuant to s 167 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996)
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN OPHTHALMIC SUPPLIES PTY LTD
(ACN 005 419 107) (Administrator Appointed)
Respondent

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 FEBRUARY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 807(1)(a) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the Act”) a penalty of $60,000 is imposed on the respondent.

2.The penalty is to be paid into Consolidated Revenue within 21 days of the date of this order.

3.Pursuant to s 807(1)(b) of the Act, the respondent pay Ms Joanne Eghnatios, within 21 days of the date of this order, the sum of $6,668.97 by way of compensation for damage suffered by her as a result of contraventions of Div 4 of Pt 16 of the Act by the respondent.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1104 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

NICOLE BYRNE (A Workplace Inspector pursuant to s 167 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996)
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN OPHTHALMIC SUPPLIES PTY LTD 
(ACN 005 419 107) (Administrator Appointed)
Respondent

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE:

14 FEBRUARY 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Ms Joanne Eghnatios worked for the respondent, Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd (“AOS”), as an optical dispenser. Until very recently AOS traded as “Merringtons” and operated a large number of retail shops throughout Australia.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Byrne v Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Byrne v Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd, the applicant, Ms Byrne, sought penalties against the respondent, Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd (AOS), for underpayment of wages and other contraventions under the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth). Ms Byrne, who had previously initiated proceedings in the Magistrates' Court against AOS for underpayment of wages, was represented in both the Magistrates' Court and the current proceeding by the Office of the Workplace Services Ombudsman (OWS). The court was tasked with determining whether AOS had contravened the Workplace Relations Act 1996 by underpaying Ms Eghnatios and whether it had taken adverse action against her in retaliation for her pursuit of her entitlements.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether AOS had contravened the Act by underpaying Ms Eghnatios and whether AOS had taken adverse action against her in contravention of the Act. The court considered the evidence provided by Ms Byrne, which was uncontroverted by AOS, and determined that AOS had indeed underpaid Ms Eghnatios and taken adverse action against her. The adverse action included the transfer and suspension of Ms Eghnatios, which the court found to be an injury to her in her employment and an alteration of her position to her prejudice.

The court reasoned that the transfer and suspension of Ms Eghnatios constituted an injury to her in her employment and an alteration of her position to her prejudice. The suspension denied her the opportunity to work and was disciplinary action that demeaned her in her employment. The transfer was also an injury and alteration because it was part of a plan devised by AOS to make Ms Eghnatios' working life intolerable, leading her to resign. The court found that AOS had contravened the Act by underpaying Ms Eghnatios and by taking adverse action against her. Consequently, the court imposed a penalty on AOS and ordered it to pay compensation to Ms Eghnatios.

The court ordered AOS to pay a penalty of $60,000 and to compensate Ms Eghnatios for the damages she suffered due to the contraventions of the Act. The penalty was to be paid into the Consolidated Revenue within 21 days of the date of the order, and the compensation was to be paid to Ms Eghnatios within the same timeframe.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 807(1)(a) of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“the Act”) a penalty of $60,000 is imposed on the respondent.

2. The penalty is to be paid into Consolidated Revenue within 21 days of the date of this order.

3. Pursuant to s 807(1)(b) of the Act, the respondent pay Ms Joanne Eghnatios, within 21 days of the date of this order, the sum of $6,668.97 by way of compensation for damage suffered by her as a result of contraventions of Div 4 of Pt 16 of the Act by the respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

During the case management of the proceeding the Court had made orders that the trial be by way of affidavit and also made orders for objections to affidavit evidence to be filed 14 days in advance of the hearing. AOS failed to file any such objections to affidavit evidence relied on by Ms Byrne at a time when it was not in voluntary administration and when its solicitors were still acting for it.The evidence The evidence before the Court consists of unchallenged affidavits filed on behalf of Ms Byrne, in respect of which AOS had not taken any evidentiary objections, when it was in a position to do so. The evidence of Ms Byrne demonstrates that:· she has standing to bring the proceeding;·in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding OWS alleged that AOS had underpaid Ms Eghnatios in respect of her entitlements under three awards made by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission;·on 7 June 2006 Magistrate Hawkins ordered, amongst other things, that the Magistrates’ Court proceeding be listed for 16 October 2006;·OWS expected to call Ms Eghnatios as a witness in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding, until late in the week prior to the commencement of the hearing before Magistrate Hawkins when AOS admitted the relevant award breaches. Mr Michael Duke is an employee of the Department. He was employed in OWS when it was part of the Department. In about January 2004, OWS received a Request for Assistance Form from Ms Eghnatios concerning underpayments of wages. Mr Barker gave evidence that he spoke with Mr Richard Adamczyk of Frenkel Partners, who then acted for AOS, on 6 October 2006. Mr Adamczyk told Mr Barker that the affidavit material filed in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding (which included that of Ms Eghnatios) had been forwarded to AOS. Ms Eghnatios commenced employment with AOS on 22 April 2002. She completed her job training at the Northland store. After that training AOS transferred her to its Northcote Central store, where Ms Eghnatios worked for a majority of the time, with occasional stints working at the Northland store. A few years ago, she also worked two days at the Melbourne Central store. The Northcote Central store was part of a work team which also comprised the Broadmeadows, Northland, Greensborough and Airport West stores. It did not include the Werribee store. From her commencement in April 2002 until October 2003, Ms Eghnatios was employed under a traineeship. When the traineeship ended she continued to be paid by AOS as a trainee. She complained to “Wageline” in early 2004 and arranged to receive a form which she completed concerning her underpayments. Ms Eghnatios swore an affidavit in the Magistrates’ Court proceeding. The solicitor for AOS received that affidavit on 8 September 2006, in advance of the trial which was due to commence on 16 October 2006 before Magistrate Hawkins, and forwarded a copy of it to AOS. On 5 October 2006, Ms Eghnatios’ team leader, Mr George Omar, told her that she was being transferred to the Werribee store with effect from 9 October 2006. When Ms Eghnatios asked for a reason, Mr Omar said, “we just need to transfer you.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J

Mr Nguyen said that Mr Omar also said:“Head Office wanted to make it very uncomfortable for Joanne for all the trouble she caused so that she would resign and they would not have to do anything about it.”Mr Nguyen said that in a later conversation, Mr Omar told Mr Nguyen that:“… if someone asked why Joanne was coming to the Werribee store, I should not say anything about the [C]ourt case [the Magistrates’ Court proceeding] and that I should just say that she needed to learn something about dispensing.”Injury/alteration to prejudice The transfer and suspension of Ms Eghnatios by AOS each constituted an injury to her in her employment and an alteration of her position to her prejudice. The suspension of Ms Eghnatios denied her the opportunity to work. It was also disciplinary action which demeaned her in her employment. Although Ms Eghnatios was ultimately paid for the period of her suspension until her resignation, she was not told whether her suspension was with or without pay when it occurred. She was also not told how long it would last. In Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (No 3) (1998) 195 CLR 1 at 18, Brennan CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ referred to injury in employment as a term which “covers injury of any compensable kind”, and alteration to an employee’s position to the employee’s prejudice as:“… a broad additional category which covers not only legal injury but any adverse affection of, or deterioration in, the advantages enjoyed by the employee before the conduct in question.” Suspension from employment is an injury of a compensable kind. It is also an “affection of, or deterioration in, advantages enjoyed” before the suspension. Suspension can be a form of punishment and was most certainly a form of punishment meted out to Ms Eghnatios by AOS for being an alleged “trouble maker” and standing up for her workplace rights. It is noteworthy that in Community & Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2001) 104 IR 195 at 199 the Full Court endorsed the view expressed in Squires v Flight Stewards Association of Australia (1982) 2 IR 155 at 164 by Ellicott J that an employee who was “stood down” on full pay for one month was injured in his employment because he was:“… treated substantially differently to the manner in which [an employee] is ordinarily treated and where that treatment can be seen to be injurious or prejudicial.” The transfer of Ms Eghnatios also constituted an injury in her employment and a substantial alteration to her position because it involved her in an amount of travel to access her workplace which was onerous compared to that required in her then current position. The transfer was also “an injury” and “an alteration” because it was part of a plan devised by AOS to make Ms Eghnatios’ working life so intolerable that she would have no alternative but to resign. It was nasty and egregious conduct and involved an abuse of power by AOS in a relationship where the employer held all the power and Ms Eghnatios was doing no more than asserting her right to her correct entitlements.The employer’s onus