BVF15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BVF15 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION & ANOR [2016] FCCA 169

Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Show cause hearing pursuant to r.44.12 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) – no arguable case for the relief claimed – application dismissed.

Legislation:
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36, 424AA

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), rr.44.12, 44.13

Cases Cited:

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407
Kopalapillai v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 86 FCR 547
SCAA v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCA 668
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Jia (2001) 205 CLR 507
Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H (2001) 179 ALR 425
NADH of 2001 & Ors v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 214 ALR 264

Applicant: BVF15
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: SYG 2466 of 2015
Judgment of: Judge Emmett
Hearing date: 2 February 2016
Date of Last Submission: 2 February 2016
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 2 February 2016

REPRESENTATION

The applicant appeared in person with the assistance of a Mandarin interpreter.

Solicitor for the Respondents: Ms Laura Weston
(Minter Ellison Lawyers)
FEDERAL CIRCUIT
COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT
SYDNEY

SYG 2466 of 2015

BVF15

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

EX TEMPORE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 8 September 2015, the applicant filed an application seeking judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 4 August 2015 and handed down on 5 August 2015 (“the AAT”).

  2. On 22 October 2015, the applicant attended a directions hearing before a Registrar of the Court.

  3. At the directions hearing, the applicant was given leave to file and serve an Amended Application giving complete particulars of each ground of review relied upon, together with any further evidence by way of affidavit by 5 November 2015, as well as submissions in support, by 6 November 2015.

  4. At the request of the first respondent, the matter was listed for hearing today pursuant to r.44.12 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) (“the Rules”), a copy of which was also given to the applicant.

  5. Rule 44.12 of the Rules provides as follows:

    “(1)  At a hearing of an application for an order to show cause, the Court may:

    (a)  if it is not satisfied that the application has raised an arguable case for the relief claimed—dismiss the application; or

    (b)  if it is satisfied that the application has raised an arguable case for the relief claimed—adjourn the proceeding and order a respondent to show cause at a final hearing why an order for the relief claimed should not be made on such of the grounds mentioned in the application as are specified by the Court; or

    (c)  without making an order under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BVF15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCCA 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, a Chinese citizen, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which affirmed the delegate's refusal to grant him a protection visa. The applicant had claimed to fear harm in China due to disputes over land compensation, alleged threats and detention by police, and subsequent harassment. The AAT had found significant credibility concerns with the applicant's claims, based on inconsistencies in his evidence and an overall sequence of events that it considered not to be truthful.

The court was required to determine whether the AAT's decision was affected by error of law. Specifically, the court needed to consider whether the AAT had properly assessed the applicant's credibility and whether its factual findings were open to it on the evidence before it. The central legal issue revolved around whether the AAT's adverse credibility findings were adequately supported by its stated reasons and whether, based on those findings, the applicant had established a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason, or met the complementary protection criteria.

Emmett J found that the AAT had identified the core issue as the applicant's credibility and had provided detailed reasons for its adverse findings, including inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence and the implausibility of the claimed sequence of events. The Tribunal had considered the applicant's claims in light of country information regarding land compensation disputes in China but ultimately concluded that the applicant had not established a real chance of suffering serious harm for a Convention reason. The court accepted that the AAT's findings were open to it on the evidence and that no error of law had been demonstrated.

The application for judicial review was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The first respondent, in written submissions filed on 12 November 2015, accurately summarised the background of the applicant’s claims and the AAT’s decision, as follows:“Factual Background3. The applicant is a Chinese citizen who initially arrived in Australia on a student visa on 13 August 2013: see Court Book (CB) 120, at [10]. He subsequently applied for a protection visa on 7 January 2014: CB 1-25.4. The applicant's claims to fear harm were set out in a document provided with his protection visa application: see CB 29-30. In summary, the applicant claimed to fear harm in China following the compulsory acquisition by the government in March 2012 of land he had contracted for farming. The applicant claimed that he signed a document for the acquisition of the land and commensurate compensation, but that he did not receive compensation in accordance with that agreement. He claimed to have then petitioned the Complaints Bureau of Gaocheng City, and later to have lodged an appeal with a Court in November 2012.5. The applicant claimed that in March 2013, youths came to his home and smashed things at his home and threatened to harm him if he petitioned the government again. After calling the police, the applicant stated that he was apprehended, taken to the local police station and was told he could not go until he withdrew his appeal. He claimed he eventually relented and withdrew the appeal after being detained for a day, and that the police told him if he did not stop petitioning he would face more serious harassment. The applicant claimed he feared persecution and fled to Australia as a result.6. On 3 July 2014, the applicant submitted two documents and translations purporting to be a compensation agreement and a lease agreement to the delegate: see CB 53-59.7. On 22 July 2014, the delegate refused to grant the applicant a protection visa: CB 72-84.8. On 19 August 2014, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate's decision: CB 86-87. By letter dated 30 April 2015, the applicant was invited to appear before the Tribunal to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in his case: CB 96-97. The applicant attended that hearing, and was assisted by a Mandarin interpreter: CB 105-108.9. On 4 August 2015, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision: CB 118-126.Tribunal Decision 10. The Tribunal identified the issue in the case to be the credibility of the applicant and whether, on his accepted claims, he fulfils the criteria for protection: CB 120, at [9].11. After summarising the applicant's background and claims (CB 120, at [10]-[6]) and DFAT country information regarding land acquisition and compensation in China (CB 121, at [17], the Tribunal turned to consider the applicant's claims. The Tribunal accepted that the applicant leased land for farming which was compulsorily resumed, and that this resulted in a compensation proposal which the applicant signed and to which he agreed: CB 121-122, at [21]. However, the Tribunal had significant credibility concerns with the applicant's claims that he was not paid compensation due for the appropriation of his land, and his claims that he lodged a petition and appeal that led to threats and harm by the police and others: CB 122, at [22]. The Tribunal's reasons for its credibility concerns were based on the following matters:(a) various inconsistencies it identified in the applicant's evidence given at different points in the application and review processes: CB 122-123, at [23]-[35]; and(b) the overall sequence of the applicant's claimed actions did 'not ring true' and, while not determinative of its adverse credibility findings, buttressed its other credibility concerns (at CB 124, at [36]-[40]).12. Having cumulative regard to these concerns, the Tribunal was not satisfied the applicant was truthful in relation to key aspects of his claims: CB 124-125, at [41]. Specifically, the Tribunal was not satisfied that (see CB 125, at [42]):(a) the applicant was truthful in relation to the failure of the village committee to pay the agreed compensation or that the applicant lodged a petition and appeal, and attempted to lodge a further appeal, regarding the village committee's actions;(b) unknown men ransacked the applicant's home due to his petition and appeal, or for any other reason;(c) the applicant was detained and questioned by police who forced him to sign a document stating he would not petition or appeal;(d) the applicant was harassed either by phone or in person over the claimed incident at the police station;(e) that the applicant's wife and children have moved to a different location because of the claimed difficulties faced by the applicant;(f) there is any basis on which the applicant would seek to lodge petitions or appeals on any matter relating to land acquisition or otherwise should he return to China. 13. While the Tribunal accepted that independent evidence shows land compensation disputes in China can involve local governments acting in a persecutory way against complainants, it did not accept this happened to the applicant: CB 125, at [43].14. The Tribunal noted that during the hearing the applicant showed it some pictures on his mobile phone showing protesters in a town setting, who the applicant said were in a neighbouring village protesting over compulsory land acquisition and compensation. While the Tribunal was prepared to accept that as true, it was not evidence that corroborated the applicant's own factual claims, and the Tribunal found the pictures had no probative value: CB 125, at [44].15. Given its factual findings, the Tribunal was not satisfied there was an actual chance of the applicant suffering serious harm in the reasonably foreseeable future in China as a result of the matters raised in his claims, and was not satisfied that there was any other basis on which he faced a real chance of serious harm: CB 125, at [45]. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution for the purposes of the Refugees Convention and found, in any event, that the harm claimed to be feared by the applicant was not for a Convention reason: CB 125, at [46]. The Tribunal also found that, given its factual findings, the applicant did not satisfy the complementary protection criterion: CB 125, at [47].”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's claims regarding the compulsory acquisition of his land and the failure to receive compensation are credible.
2. Whether the applicant's claims of threats and harassment by the police and others are credible.
3. Whether the applicant's claims of harm and the sequence of events leading to his departure from China are credible.
4. Whether the applicant has a well-founded fear of persecution in China for Convention reasons.
5. Whether the applicant satisfies the criteria for complementary protection.
6. Whether the applicant has made out an arguable case for the relief claimed in the show cause hearing.

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant's claims regarding the compulsory acquisition of his land and the failure to receive compensation were not credible, and dismissed the application on this ground.
2. The court concluded that the applicant's claims of threats and harassment by the police and others were not credible, and dismissed the application on this ground.
3. The court concluded that the applicant's claims of harm and the sequence of events leading to his departure from China were not credible, and dismissed the application on this ground.
4. The court concluded that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution in China for Convention reasons, and dismissed the application on this ground.
5. The court concluded that the applicant did not satisfy the criteria for complementary protection, and dismissed the application on this ground.
6. The court concluded that the applicant had not made out an arguable case for the relief claimed in the show cause hearing, and dismissed the application on this ground.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In assessing the applicant's claims, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) began by considering whether the applicant's claims regarding the compulsory acquisition of his land and the failure to receive compensation were credible. The Tribunal identified various inconsistencies in the applicant's evidence, particularly regarding the sequence of events and the actions taken by the applicant. The Tribunal noted that while independent evidence showed land compensation disputes in China could involve local governments acting in a persecutory way against complainants, it did not accept this happened to the applicant. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant was truthful in relation to key aspects of his claims, including the failure to pay the agreed compensation and the lodging of petitions and appeals that led to threats and harm by the police and others. This led the Tribunal to conclude that the applicant's claims in this regard were not credible.

Next, the Tribunal considered the applicant's claims of threats and harassment by the police and others. The Tribunal was particularly skeptical of the applicant's account of being detained, questioned by the police, and forced to sign a document stating he would not petition or appeal. The Tribunal also found no credibility in the applicant's claims that he was harassed either by phone or in person over the claimed incident at the police station. Given the inconsistencies and the overall sequence of events, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the applicant was truthful in relation to these claims.

In examining the applicant's claims of harm and the sequence of events leading to his departure from China, the Tribunal found the applicant's overall account did not 'ring true'. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's wife and children had moved to a different location due to the claimed difficulties faced by the applicant, but found no credibility in this assertion either. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's claims in this regard were not credible and that there was no basis on which the applicant would seek to lodge petitions or appeals on any matter relating to land acquisition or otherwise should he return to China.

The Tribunal then addressed whether the applicant had a well-founded fear of persecution in China for Convention reasons. Given its findings regarding the credibility of the applicant's claims, the Tribunal was not satisfied there was an actual chance of the applicant suffering serious harm in the reasonably foreseeable future in China as a result of the matters raised in his claims. The Tribunal found that the harm claimed to be feared by the applicant was not for a Convention reason and concluded that the applicant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution for the purposes of the Refugees Convention.

In considering whether the applicant satisfied the criteria for complementary protection, the Tribunal noted that, given its factual findings, the applicant did not meet the complementary protection criterion. The Tribunal was not satisfied that there was any other basis on which the applicant faced a real chance of serious harm in China.

Finally, the Tribunal addressed whether the applicant had made out an arguable case for the relief claimed in the show cause hearing. The Tribunal found that, based on its assessment of the applicant's claims and the evidence presented, there was no arguable case for the relief claimed. The Tribunal's reasoning was grounded in its findings of fact, particularly regarding the credibility of the applicant's claims, and its conclusion that the applicant did not meet the criteria for protection under the Refugees Convention or for complementary protection.

In summary, the Tribunal's decision hinged on its assessment of the applicant's credibility and the factual basis of his claims. The Tribunal's findings that the applicant's claims were not credible, coupled with its conclusion that the applicant did not meet the criteria for protection, led to the dismissal of the applicant's application. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that credibility and factual basis are critical components in determining the validity of claims for protection under Australian immigration law.