Bullivant's Natural Health Products Pty Ltd v C F Planners Pty Limited

[1999] QSC 40

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

No. 450 of 1992
Brisbane

Before             White J

[Bullivant’s Natural Health Products Pty Ltd v C F Planners Pty Limited]

BETWEEN:

BULLIVANT’S NATURAL HEALTH PRODUCTS PTY LTD

(ACN 010 008 616)

Plaintiff
AND:

C F PLANNERS PTY LIMITED (ACN 006 887 225)

First Defendant

AND:

MAURICE BERNARD BYRNE and ROBIN O’HAIR

Second Defendants
AND:

BERIMAH PTY LTD (ACN 005 905 895),

THE NEWS VENDING INSTITUTE INCORPORATED and

W HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 005 936 265)

Third Defendants
AND:

DAVID VAUGHAN BULLIVANT

Third Party

BY ORIGINAL ACTION

AND BETWEEN:

ROBIN O’HAIR

Plaintiff
AND:

BULLIVANT’S NATURAL HEALTH PRODUCTS PTY LTD

(ACN 010 008 616)

Defendant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 10 March 1999

CATCHWORDS:     Summonses for particulars and interrogatories - Costs’ Orders. 

Counsel:Mr D Clothier for applicant/plaintiff

Mr A Blow QC for respondent/2nd named 2nd defendant

Solicitors:redchip lawyers for applicant

No solicitor for respondent

Hearing Date:              Written submissions received 5 March 1999.