Bukvic v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

BUKVIC v POLICE

[2013] SASC 79

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Sulan

5 June 2013

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - DRUG OFFENCES - DEALING AND DISTRIBUTION OF DRUGS - TRAFFICKING OR SALE AND SUPPLY

ENERGY AND RESOURCES - ELECTRICITY - OFFENCES

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - POWERS OF COURT - OTHER MATTERS

Appeal against convictions for cultivating a controlled plant contrary to s 33B(3) of the Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA), possession of prescribed equipment contrary to s 33LA(1) of the Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA) and interfering with an electricity meter contrary to s 85(1)(b) of the Electricity Act 1996 (SA) - after searching a premises police located 18 cannabis plants being grown hydroponically across three rooms in a house - the electricity meter had been tampered with - no-one present at the time of the search - documents and personal items in the name of the appellant were located in several rooms of the house and in a car parked in the driveway - appellant found by police at another address and no key to the premises was located on him - whether verdicts against the weight of evidence - whether the verdicts unsafe and unsatisfactory - whether Magistrate failed to give adequate reasons.

Held:  Appeal dismissed - although the Magistrate did not state in precise terms the test to be applied in cases where the prosecution rely on circumstantial evidence, satisfied that correct legal principle was applied - having regard to the evidence as a whole satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that appellant cultivated the cannabis, had possession of the prescribed equipment without reasonable excuse and interfered with the electricity meter.

Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA) s 33B(3), s 33LA(1), s 4(7); Electricity Act 1996 (SA) s 85(1)(b), s 85(3); Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 42; Controlled Substances (Controlled Drugs, Precursors and Plants) Regulations 2000 reg 8AA, referred to.
Taylor v Hayes (1990) 53 SASR 282; R v Peacock (1911) 13 CLR 619; Plomp v R (1963) 110 CLR 234; Barca v R (1975) 133 CLR 82; Chamberlain v R (No 2) (1984) 153 CLR 521; Shepherd v R (1990) 170 CLR 573; Douglass v R (2012) 290 ALR 699; Moors v Burke (1919) 26 CLR 265; R v GNN [2000] SASC 447; The Queen v Frangos (1979) 21 SASR 331, considered.

BUKVIC v POLICE
[2013] SASC 79

Magistrates Appeal:   Criminal

  1. SULAN J: This is an appeal against conviction. The defendant and appellant, George Bukvic, pleaded not-guilty to three offences. It was alleged that on 26 September 2011, he:

  2. Cultivated a controlled plant intending to sell controlled plants, contrary to s 33B(3) of the Controlled Substances Act 1984 (SA) (“the Act”);

  3. Had possession of equipment of a kind prescribed by regulation, without reasonable excuse, contrary to s 33LA(1) of the Act; and

  4. Interfered with a meter for measuring the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bukvic v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 79
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The defendant was convicted of cultivating a controlled plant, possessing prescribed equipment, and interfering with an electricity meter. The defendant appealed the convictions on the grounds that the verdicts were against the weight of evidence, unsafe and unsatisfactory, and that the Magistrate failed to adequately express her reasons for rejecting hypotheses consistent with the defendant's innocence. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The court considered the evidence, including the presence of documents and personal items in the defendant's name, the diary entries indicating the defendant's awareness of the cannabis plants, and the tampering with the electricity meter. The court found that the evidence supported the conclusion that the defendant cultivated the cannabis, had possession of the prescribed equipment, and interfered with the electricity meter. The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions were upheld.

The court held that the defendant was presumed to be the person who committed the acts of interference unless there was proof to the contrary. The court was satisfied that the presumption had not been rebutted and that the correct legal principles had been applied. The court concluded that the evidence as a whole satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the defendant cultivated the cannabis, had possession of the prescribed equipment without reasonable excuse, and interfered with the electricity meter. The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions were upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: Appeal dismissed - although the Magistrate did not state in precise terms the test to be applied in cases where the prosecution rely on circumstantial evidence, satisfied that correct legal principle was applied - having regard to the evidence as a whole satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that appellant cultivated the cannabis, had possession of the prescribed equipment without reasonable excuse and interfered with the electricity meter.

Background

Background to the litigation

The defendant was convicted by a Magistrate of all three counts. He appeals on three grounds. First, it is submitted that the finding of guilt in relation to each count was against the weight of evidence. Secondly, that the verdicts of guilt on each count are unsafe and unsatisfactory. Thirdly, it is contended that the Magistrate failed to adequately express her reasons for rejecting hypotheses consistent with the innocence of the defendant with respect to Counts 1 and 2.Background On 26 December 2011, three police officers attended a house at Modbury North. At all relevant times, the premises were owned by Ms Kanittha Khorat. They gained entry and searched the premises. No one was present at the time. Police observed three rooms being used to grow cannabis plants hydroponically. Each room contained six plants in individual pots. Police also found equipment including light shades, light globes, transformers and an air filter that were being used to cultivate the cannabis. Subsequent investigations also revealed that there had been tampering with the electricity meter. Police found a number of items in the name of the defendant at the premises. There were two vehicles in the drive way. One of the vehicles, a Holden Commodore sedan registered in the name of the defendant’s father, Lazo Bukvic, contained a number of documents in the name of Mr G. Bukvic. Inside one of the bedrooms police found numerous personal items in the name of George Bukvic including an expired driver’s license and an Expiation Notice issued to the defendant. Other documents found in the defendant’s name were addressed to a house at 15 Hissar Ave, Salisbury North and another to an address at Parafield Gardens. A diary located in the bedroom was found to contain left and right thumbs prints identical to those of the defendant. In a second bedroom police found an unmade bed and items of clothing. A visa in the name of the defendant was located in a vent in a bedroom ceiling. Police also found $885 cash in one of the bedrooms and $3000 made up of $50 notes in a kitchen cupboard. By letter dated 21 December 2011, solicitors acting for the defendant wrote to police in respect of a sum of $3,970 which was seized by police from the premises. It was claimed that the money belonged to the defendant and was the remainder of significant cash withdrawals evidenced by bank statements. Police arrested the defendant at the Salisbury North address on the same day. In a bedroom which the defendant told police officers was his, police discovered no male clothing that appeared to belong to the defendant except for four folded t-shirts. Police found women’s clothing and possessions in the bedroom. The owner of the Modbury North premises, Khorat, gave evidence that she was in Thailand between June 2010 and March 2012. She was not aware that anyone was staying at the premises and she did not receive any rental income during that time. Nicholas Lymberopoulos is the father of Khorat’s daughter. There was evidence that Lymberopoulos contributed to the purchase of the premises but did not live there. Lymberopoulos had keys to the premises. Khorat denied knowing the defendant. Lymberopoulos admitted to police that he knew the defendant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Counsel submits that the evidence which supports the conclusion that the defendant cultivated the cannabis stems broadly from the same evidence that establishes that the defendant resided at the premises at the relevant time.Evidence that the defendant resided at the premises The evidence which the prosecution rely on as supporting the conclusion that the defendant was the only person who resided at the premises at the relevant time is as follows:·Documents and personal items in the name of the defendant were found in the Holden Commodore parked in the driveway of the premises;·A bedroom in the premises appeared to be lived in. This bedroom contained a number of personal items and documents in the name of the defendant;·One of those personal items was a diary. The diary had the defendant’s fingerprints on it and contained a number of notes and other entries. The following entries are pertinent:·6 January 2011: “spoke to a lawyer re living in a house where there’s a hydro. So long I don’t take any part in it then it’s okay to live in the house without repercussions”.·19 March 2011: “moved in as difficulties arose at previous abode. I was made aware that there were plants growing at this place and I again consulted lawyer as to the legal ramifications of being at a residence used for growing. Again advised so long as I don’t take part in cultivating I would not [fail?/ fall?]”.·Other documents found in the bedroom included an expired driver’s licence in the name of the defendant and other letters and documents in the defendant’s name. They spanned the period 16 March 2011 to 13 September 2011;·Cash in the amount of $885 located in a second bedroom was claimed by the defendant as belonging to him;·Cash in the amount of $3,000 located in the kitchen cupboard above the fridge, claimed by the defendant as belonging to him; and·A visa issued by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs in the name of the defendant was located in a vent in the ceiling of the second bedroom. As to the evidence that supports the conclusion that the defendant was residing at the premises during the period of cultivation:·Ms Khorat gave evidence that she left Australia in June 2010 to visit her ill mother in Thailand. She did not return to Australia until 14 March 2012. About two or three weeks after Ms Khorat left Australia, Lymberopoulos followed to be with his daughter. Over the period that she was away, Lymberopoulos was also in Thailand for most of the time. He would stay in Thailand for periods approximately 3 months at a time, broken up by periods of about 2 weeks back in Australia for Centrelink purposes; and·None of the documents located at the premises in the names of Khorat, or Lymberopoulos, or both, suggest that either of them were present at the premises during the period June 2010 to March 2012. Counsel for the defendant submits that the evidence is only capable of supporting the inference that the defendant was a singular occupier of a room, coming and going from the premises. Counsel contends that the evidence of the defendant’s presence at the premises does not support the inference that the defendant cultivated the cannabis. Counsel points to the fact that no key to the premises was found on the defendant and that there is no forensic link between the defendant and the cannabis plants or equipment. Counsel further submits that the diary entries dated 6 January and 19 March 2011, support the contention that the defendant was merely an occupier of a room in the premises and was not involved in the cultivation of the cannabis.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The defendant is presumed, in the absence of proof to the contrary, to be the person who committed the act of interference. I am satisfied that there is no proof to the contrary. The assertion in the letter from the defendant’s father that the defendant resided elsewhere at the relevant time carries no weight. Counsel has not called the author of the letter to give evidence. I am of the view that the presumption has not been rebutted. Conclusion For these reasons, I dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established