Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd t/as Ibis Pools and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd t/as Ibis Pools and Anor [2019] QCAT 105

PARTIES:

PAUL DAVID BROWN
(applicant)

v

HAVENFOOT PTY LTD T/AS IBIS POOLS

(first respondent)

TAYLOR ASSOCIATES PTY LTD

(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

BDL077-15

MATTER TYPE:

Building matters

DELIVERED ON:

8 April 2019

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Susan Burke

ORDERS:

1.   Order 1 of the tribunal dated 2 January 2019 be vacated and substituted with orders 2 and 3 hereof.

2.   The first respondent pay sixty percent (60%) of the sum of $52,120.00 to the applicant being $31,272.00.

3.   The second respondent pay forty percent (40%) of the sum of $52,120.00 to the applicant being $20,848.00.

4.   The first respondent pay sixty percent (60%) of the applicant’s costs as fixed by the tribunal in the sum of $23,027.83 being the sum of $13,816.69.

5.    The second respondent pay forty percent (40%) of the applicant’s costs as fixed by the tribunal in the sum of $23,027.83 being the sum of $9,211.13.

CATCHWORDS:

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – CONTRACT – building dispute - contribution of respondents to damage caused – discretion of tribunal to apportion responsibility

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS  – COSTS – building dispute – exercise of discretion to award costs to be exercised judicially by tribunal – apportionment of costs – costs to be fixed – open offer to settle – whether result more favourable

Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld)
Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld)

Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534
Lyons v Dreamstarter Pty Ltd [2012] QCATA 71
Tamawood Ltd v Paans [2005] QCA 111

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Construct Law Group, Solicitors

First Respondent:

Spire Law, Solicitors

Second Respondent:

Meridian Lawyers, Solicitors

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Reasons for the Decision in this matter were delivered on 2 January 2019 (“Reasons for the Decision”).

  2. The first respondent (“Ibis Pools”) and second respondent (“Taylor”) were ordered to make payment to the applicant (“Brown”) the sum of $52,120.00. Further, the first respondent was ordered to make payment to the applicant the sum of $7,000.00.

  3. The parties were directed to provide written submissions in relation to the costs of the proceedings and also in relation to the proportion of contribution of each of the first and second respondents to the sum of $52,120.00 ordered to be paid to the applicant.

  4. The first respondent filed its written submissions in relation to the issues of contribution and costs on 18 January 2019.

  5. Written submissions were delivered on behalf of Taylor on 1 February 2019.

  6. Brown delivered written submissions in relation to the issue of costs on 1 February 2019. In addition, the applicant delivered an affidavit of Paul Brown sworn 2 February…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd t/as Ibis Pools and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brown v Havenfoot Pty Ltd t/as Ibis Pools and Anor before the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) involves a claim by Brown against Ibis Pools and Taylor for damages related to a defective reinforced concrete in-ground swimming pool constructed at 547 Sunrise Road Tinbeerwah, Queensland. Brown sought approximately $124,000 for the rectification of the pool, alleging that both Ibis Pools and Taylor were jointly and severally liable for the defects due to their breaches of contract and negligence. The tribunal found both respondents liable for the defective construction of the pool.

The primary legal issues the tribunal had to decide were the extent of liability and contribution between the respondents, as well as the apportionment of costs between the parties. The tribunal was required to determine whether the respondents should be held jointly and severally liable or if their liability should be apportioned differently. Additionally, the tribunal needed to exercise its discretion to apportion costs between the parties, taking into account the open offer to settle made by Brown.

The tribunal concluded that both respondents were responsible for the defective pool. Ibis Pools was found to be in breach of contract and negligent in various aspects of the pool's construction, such as failing to install the required piers and ensuring adequate foundation. Taylor was found to have breached its duty of care by not properly considering the site conditions and providing adequate advice. Given the tribunal's findings, it decided that the respondents should bear the damages in proportion to their respective contributions to the defect. The tribunal apportioned 60% of the liability to Ibis Pools and 40% to Taylor. Consequently, the tribunal also apportioned costs in the same ratio, with Ibis Pools bearing 60% and Taylor 40% of the costs awarded to Brown. This approach was deemed appropriate given the relative contributions to the damage caused.

The final orders of the tribunal vacated the previous order dated 2 January 2019 and substituted it with new orders. The first respondent, Ibis Pools, was ordered to pay 60% of the sum of $52,120.00 to Brown, amounting to $31,272.00. The second respondent, Taylor, was ordered to pay 40% of the same sum, amounting to $20,848.00. In terms of costs, Ibis Pools was ordered to pay 60% of Brown's costs, amounting to $13,816.69, while Taylor was ordered to pay 40% of the costs, amounting to $9,211.13.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Order 1 of the tribunal dated 2 January 2019 be vacated and substituted with orders 2 and 3 hereof.

2. The first respondent pay sixty percent (60%) of the sum of $52,120.00 to the applicant being $31,272.00.

3. The second respondent pay forty percent (40%) of the sum of $52,120.00 to the applicant being $20,848.00.

4. The first respondent pay sixty percent (60%) of the applicant’s costs as fixed by the tribunal in the sum of $23,027.83 being the sum of $13,816.69.

5. The second respondent pay forty percent (40%) of the applicant’s costs as fixed by the tribunal in the sum of $23,027.83 being the sum of $9,211.13.

Background

Background to the litigation

This decision does not affect the order dated 2 January 2019 that Ibis Pools pay the further sum of $7,000.00 to Brown.Background By application dated 4 May 2015 (which was amended by submissions filed 2 December 2016), Brown sought the sum of approximately $124,000 for the rectification of a reinforced concrete in-ground swimming pool constructed at 547 Sunrise Road Tinbeerwah, Queensland. The claim against Ibis Pools and Taylor was based on the ground that the parties were jointly and severally liable for the defective works; Ibis Pools as the contractor and Taylor as the engineer engaged on the project. In reaching a conclusion that both respondents were responsible for the defective pool, the tribunal reached the following conclusions:-(a)In relation to the liability of Ibis Pools, the tribunal determined that Ibis Pools was in breach of contract and negligent in the construction of the pool in that:(a) it failed to install the number of piers required in the drawings;(b) it failed to ensure the piers were adequately founded into the natural ground;(c) the soil into which the piers were embedded was not competent in that it was poorly compacted fill;(d) the soil into which the piers were embedded was not competent in that it consisted of timber and steel debris;(e) it failed to obtain a geotechnical report which was relevant to the site conditions; and(f) it failed to obtain advice from the engineer upon encountering foundation conditions which had the potential to affect the design parameters for the construction. The tribunal concluded that the construction of the pool was the primary cause of the tilt of the pool, which is the major defect in the pool..[1][1]Paragraphs [144] and [145] of the Reasons for the Decision. With respect to the responsibility of Taylor, the tribunal reached the following conclusions regarding its breach of duty of care owed to Brown, in that:(a)it failed to specify in the Form 15 Certificate the depth to which the piers were to be founded;(b)it failed properly to consider all the conditions of the site including the presence of uncompacted/uncontrolled fill, the slope of the site, the vegetation on the site, including trees near the pool area and the presence of septic systems and soakage pits at the property;(c)it failed to provide advice to the builder regarding the site conditions which were likely to be encountered;(d)it relied upon a Geotech report which was incomplete and not totally relevant to the site; (e)it failed to carry out an inspection of the excavated site prior to the installation of the piers at which time an assessment of the depth of the controlled/uncompacted fill could have been ascertained; and(f)it failed to issue a direction to the builder to engage Taylor to inspect the site once the pool area had been excavated.[2][2]Paragraph [153] of the Reasons for the Decision.The Applicant’s Submissions Brown’s submissions address separately the issues of contribution and costs. In relation to the issue of contribution, Brown submits that:(a)where the tribunal has made an unequivocal finding that both respondents are liable for the damage then the respondents should be jointly and severally liable in regard to the amount awarded; and(b)alternatively, the respondents should be liable fifty percent each to the amount awarded.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established