Brooker v Friend & Brooker Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Brooker v Friend & Brooker & Anor [2006]  NSWCA 385

FILE NUMBER(S):
40438 0f 2005

HEARING DATE(S):               13 March 2006

DECISION DATE:     20/12/2006

PARTIES:
Frederick Clarkson Brooker - Appellant
Friend & Brooker Pty Ltd – First Respondent
Nicholas Macarthur Friend – Second Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P McColl JA Basten JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 5181 of 2000

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Nicholas J

COUNSEL:
R G Forster SC with M S White – Appellant
No appearance - First Respondent
Mr C R C Newlinds SC with H S Packer – Second Respondent

SOLICITORS:
Jonathan D’Arcy & Co – Appellant
No appearance -  First Respondent
Bull, Son & Schmidt – Second Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS - effect of incorporation on liability of parties in quasi–partnership - company’s activities financed in part by funds raised by personal borrowings from family and friends by 2 directors and shareholders on-lent to company - whether agreement to bear burden of personal borrowings equally - nature of relationship between parties - whether evidence established fiduciary relationship.CONTRACT -  ongoing relationship - necessary to look at whole relationship to determine whether contract in existence not only at what was said and done when relationship first formed.PARTNERSHIP - whether manifestation of mutual assent sufficient to prove a partnership agreement pursuant to which parties undertook to assume personal, and equal, responsibility for borrowings from family and friends - whether partnership displaced by incorporation of company.QUASI–PARTNERSHIP - mutual trust and confidence manifest from outset of business relationship - whether fiduciary relationship between parties exposing them to an obligation to account to each other in relation to personal borrowings on-lent to company - nature of the subject matter over which obligation extends EQUITY - fiduciary relationship - fiduciary relationship between parties arising from mutual trust and confidence reposed in each other from the outset of  business relationship – determined by reference to course of parties’ conduct and inferences drawn from that conduct - can exist despite fact parties are in a corporate relationship - can exist between parties who have not reached, and who may never reach, agreement upon the consensual terms which are to govern the arrangements between them.CONTRIBUTION - right of contribution - rests on matters of substance not form - absence of contractual arrangement not controlling - common interest and common burden - shared decision-making touching administration of loan and application of loan proceeds - whether right of contribution where creditor not threatening to enforce debt - whether relief should be refused on discretionary grounds.DELAY – notwithstanding lapse of time possible to grant equitable relief on just terms - respondent on notice claim not abandoned. (D)

LEGISLATION CITED:
Partnership Act 1892

DECISION:
Appeal allowed; see para [58]

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40438/05
SC 5181/00

MASON P
McCOLL JA
BASTEN JA

Wednesday 20 December 2006

FREDERICK CLARKSON BROOKER v FRIEND & BROOKER PTY LTD &…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brooker v Friend & Brooker Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 385
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Mr Brooker (the appellant) and Mr Friend regarding financial obligations arising from their joint business venture, which was conducted through Brooker & Friend Pty Ltd. The core of the dispute centred on the SMK loan of $350,000, which Mr Brooker personally borrowed and on-lent to the company. Mr Brooker sought a declaration that Mr Friend was obliged to contribute equally to the repayment of this loan, asserting a quasi-partnership or fiduciary relationship between them. The case was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The legal issues before the court were whether the relationship between Mr Brooker and Mr Friend, despite the incorporation of a company, gave rise to a fiduciary obligation requiring them to share equally the burden of personal borrowings on-lent to the company, specifically the SMK loan. The court also considered whether the evidence established an agreement, express or implied, for such equal sharing of personal liabilities, and whether equitable relief, such as a right of contribution, was available despite the passage of time and the absence of a formal contractual arrangement.

The Court of Appeal found that a fiduciary relationship existed between Mr Brooker and Mr Friend, arising from the mutual trust and confidence reposed in each other from the outset of their business relationship. This relationship was determined by their conduct and the inferences drawn from it, and could exist notwithstanding their corporate structure. The court reasoned that the parties' conduct, including their agreement to consolidate loans and their discussions about equalising contributions and losses, indicated an intention to bear the burden of personal borrowings equally. The court applied principles of equity concerning fiduciary relationships and the right of contribution, which rests on substance rather than form, and can arise from a common interest and common burden, even without a formal contract.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, declaring that Mr Friend was required to contribute equally to the discharge of the outstanding obligations under the SMK loan arrangements. Consequential orders for payment were to be made, with the parties directed to file agreed short minutes or written submissions detailing any outstanding differences regarding the precise sum and preferred orders. Costs were ordered to follow the event, with the respondent receiving a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

For these reasons the appellant is, in my view, entitled to a declaration that the respondent is required to contribute equally to the discharge of the outstanding obligations under the SMK loan arrangements, with consequential orders for payment of the appropriate sum. The parties should be directed to file agreed short minutes no later than 10 February 2007. If agreement cannot by then be reached the parties should, within a

further 14 days, exchange written submissions detailing their outstanding differences and indicating why their preferred orders should be made. Hopefully, this Court will be able to resolve any outstanding issues without the need to refer the matter to an Associate Justice.

Costs should follow the event with the respondent receiving a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts are in large measure uncontroversial and can conveniently be taken from the judgment below:“Background 7 The following narrative is of events which provide some background for the better understanding of Mr Brooker’s claims. Most of these matters were not in dispute and in any event there was ample evidence for the finding that each took place. 8 In about May 1977 Mr Brooker and Mr Friend resigned from their employment as engineers with John Holland Constructions Pty Limited with the intention of together establishing an engineering and construction business. 9 On 18 July 1977 the company was incorporated to which Mr Brooker and Mr Friend were appointed directors. Their respective family trusts became equal shareholders through a common trustee, Naya Nominees Pty Limited. 10 Between about July 1977 and about 1979 the principal activity of the company was civil engineering construction. In 1979 the scope of the business was widened to include property purchase and development. 11 In about 1980 Mr Brooker and Mr Friend were advised by their accountant, Mr Joslin, that carrying out property development through a trust structure would give them discretion as to the distribution of profits. The advice was accepted, and unit trust structures with corporate trustee companies were used for projects. These included the projects at No. 44 Bridge Street, Sydney and Doohat Avenue, North Sydney by Ilenace Pty Limited, and at No. 11 Hardie Street, Neutral Bay by Duvana Pty Limited. Syelight Pty Limited, a company in which Mr Brooker and Mr Friend each owned one half of the shares, undertook the development of the Neutral Bay property for Duvana Pty Limited. …12 From time to time money was borrowed for use by the company in its business. Funds were obtained by way of direct borrowings from third parties including banks, family members, and friends. Mr Brooker and Mr Friend also, separately, borrowed funds which each on-lent to the company, which loans were reflected in the directors’ loan account as unsecured loans. 13 On about 16 January 1984 the company entered into a contract with the Eurobodalla Shire Council (the council) for the construction of a sewerage reticulation work at Narooma for the sum of $2,531,062.48 (the Narooma contract). To finance the works the company arranged an overdraft facility for $350,000.00 with the ANZ Bank. Funds were also obtained by way of loans from other parties. 14 In about August 1984, at Mr Brooker’s suggestion, it was agreed that all loans from family members and friends should be consolidated into the directors’ loan account, and he instructed the company’s accountant to proceed accordingly. 15 In September 1985 the Narooma contract reached practical completion. In about January 1986 the company submitted a claim for the sum of about $1,000,000.00 to the council for quantities underpaid. The claim was rejected in about April 1986. 16 By early 1986 the company’s account, and the account of the associated company, Syelight Pty Limited, with ANZ Bank had been frozen. In order to fund a construction contract in Canberra which the company then had with Blue Circle Southern Cement Limited arrangements were made to use the account of Ilenace Pty Limited with another bank. 17 In November 1986 SMK Investments Pty Limited (SMK) through its director Mr Graham Richard Peterson agreed to lend Mr Brooker the sum of $350,000.00. These monies were on-lent by Mr Brooker to the company and were applied, inter alia, to repay loans from various lenders. 18 From mid-1987 to mid-1990 Mr Friend secured and managed to completion a number of small construction contracts for the company. Funds were provided through Ilenace Pty Limited and the personal accounts of the directors. Since about July 1990 the company has not been involved in construction work or other trading activity. 19 During 1991 the company was engaged in litigation with the council in respect of its claim. On 6 September 1991 it was paid the sum of $193,680.00 by the council. 20 On 9 June 1993 the council paid the company the sum of $1,634,964.00 pursuant to the arbitrator’s award of 19 March 1993. At about the end of June 1993 various creditors of the company were paid from the proceeds of the first payment from the council. Mr Brooker and Mr Friend each were paid the sum of $63,638.00. 21 On 3 March 1994, after further litigation, the award was increased by the sum of $256,898.00. On 19 September 1994, pursuant to a deed of release the council paid the company a further sum of $900,000.00. 22 In about October 1994 and on 25 January 1995 there were meetings between Mr Brooker and Mr Friend during which Mr Friend denied personal liability for the SMK loan or an obligation to share equally in its repayment. It appears that the parties have been in dispute since then. 23 On 8 February 1995 Mr Brooker and Mr Friend met at the office of the company’s solicitors, Foulsham & Geddes. It was agreed that from the proceeds of the payment of $900,000.00 from the council the sum of $213,933.00 should be applied in payment of the ANZ Bank and small creditors. It was also agreed that the balance of about $687,000.00 be paid out equally to the parties by instalments by way of loans from the company.*24 During the period 24 August 1995 to 3 March 1998 from the proceeds of the third payment received from the council advances were made to each of Mr Brooker and Mr Friend of the total sum of $345,000.00 in various amounts as interest free loans. The sum of about $6,000.00 remains as an asset of the company.The SMK loan 25 In these proceedings Mr Brooker claims that in November 1986 SMK lent to the joint venture or partnership and, in effect, to him and Mr Friend, the sum of $350,000.00. He asserts that he and Mr Friend personally borrowed money for the purposes of the business and hence are personally liable to the lender for it. Mr Friend denies the claim. It is convenient to determine this issue before turning to the others. 26 The circumstances of the loan were that in November 1986 Mr Brooker spoke to Mr Peterson about the financial difficulties of the company, and expressed a need for the sum of $350,000.00. Mr Peterson agreed to provide it. A few days later Mr Brooker had the following conversation with Mr Friend: “I said: ‘Graham and Sue Peterson have offered to loan us $350,000 to take the pressure off until we finalise the claim against the Council’.He said: ‘What do you think?’I said: ‘We do not have a choice. If we do not accept there is no way we can repay Alcon or the De Bakkers or maintain the Trade Credits loan’.He said: ‘Well then, we should do it’.”27 Thereafter arrangements were made pursuant to which SMK provided the funds to Mr Brooker. On 8 November 1986 the sum of $20,000.00 was paid to Mr Brooker in advance of settlement. On 23 December 1986 the balance of $330,000.00 was applied, inter alia, to discharge the company’s loans from Trade Credits Limited, Alcon Investments Pty Limited and G. A. and A. G. de Bakker, and to pay Mr Brooker the sum of $37,183.95. The monies were treated by the company as having been lent to it by Mr Brooker as its accounts show (TB 1270). 28 The loan was secured by first mortgage over the property of Mr Brooker’s wife at No. 12 Milner Street, Mosman for which Mr Brooker was guarantor, and by a second mortgage over the property jointly owned by Mr Brooker and his mother at No. 4 Selwyn Street, Artarmon.29 In evidence Mr Peterson acknowledged that any claim for recovery of the loan would be made against Mr Brooker and not against the company or Mr Friend.”* [The appellant submits that this sentence does not accord with his evidence that the balance was used to pay outstanding loans advanced by various lenders to one or both of the parties].The SMK Loan

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

His Honour also recorded the following evidence as relevant to the relationship issue:“39 The following is a relevant passage from the cross-examination (Tp 63): ‘Q. Just to understand then before I take you to the remaining conversations, your position is that you formed a company to trade through and your understanding was if in the end the company failed and, let's say, was wound up and you had undrawn salary or you had put money in that the company couldn't afford to repay you, that your understanding is that the agreement between you and Mr Friend was that each of you would pay to the other directly across the top of the company, even though it had failed, any amount which was necessary to equalise your contributions? A. Yes, that's exactly what I say. Q. And it doesn't matter that your sole source of business, the company, had failed and that either of you may not have had the money to pay, it would just be an obligation that would be there forever between you? A. It would be an obligation which if it could not be met immediately would be met in time’. And at Tp 64:‘Q. … You tell his Honour that the arrangement between you was that one way or another if the company made a loss and there wasn't enough to repay either of you out of the company, your arrangement extended to one paying across the top the other the extent of his contribution unrepaid; is that right? A. As far as was necessary to equalise the losses, yes. HIS HONOUR: Q. Can I understand that your understanding was that this was the effect of a private arrangement between you and Mr Friend really outside the operations of the company?A. Yes. HAMMERSCHLAG:Q. And you derive that, you say, from conversations which are set out in your affidavit? A. Yes, and the way in which we conducted the business. Q. Well, the way in which you conducted the business was to accrue loan accounts and at all material times pay each other out 50/50, right, of what there was?A. Well, there were never any payouts. Q. In what way then do you tell his Honour that's the way you conducted it?A. By the way in which we kept records of contributions in order to have those records when the time came to equalise those before either sharing surplus or sharing loss’. 40 Mr Brooker relied upon the para 8 conversations (set out in para 34) as the evidence of the agreement. His evidence was (Tp 67): ‘Q. Just go back to para 8. In the middle of the page you say, ‘When the business is at the point where it no longer needs any financial input and each of us has got back what we have put in’. By that you meant from the returns of the business; correct?A. Yes. Q. ‘Like undrawn salary and such like we could start drawing profits sharing equally.’A. Yes. Q. What you meant by that was you would each put in whatever, once the company was in a position to pay you back it would pay you back in accordance with your contributions, and then after that you would share equally? A. That's correct. Q. And that's what your understanding is. At the end of the day, if and when the company could pay each of you back the money it owed it would do so, and whatever was left over would be shared between you equally?A. Yes, that's correct. Q. There is nothing in this conversation that says anything about you being liable to him personally or he being liable to you personally across the top of the company for any ultimate shortfall in either of your contributions, is there?A. I believe that's implicit in that part of the conversation. Q. And that is the conversation which you under your oath tell his Honour from which you derive this agreement between you outside the affairs of the company, that one would be liable to the other for any shortfall when the company couldn't pay?A. Yes. Q. And you say you made that agreement at a time at which either of you had almost nothing to your names?A. Well, that seems to be a double question. We made it at that time, but neither of us had nothing to our names. Q. Each of you had very little, you have told his Honour, and also you were perfectly conscious of the fact that you were about to embark on an enterprise in a risky field of endeavour? A. Yes. Q. Let me put it to you squarely, Mr Brooker. I want to suggest to you that the evidence that you have given his Honour this morning, to the extent that you said the same thing yesterday, that you understood there was an agreement between you two young men at the time that either of you would be liable to the other on failure of the company to be able to pay each of you personally across the top, is untruthful?A. That's not right. That's exactly how I understood the relationship between us’.” (emphasis added)