Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) (No 2) [2023] FCA 515  

File number(s): NSD 591 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 12 May 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application by non-party to restrain party’s solicitors from acting and to set aside earlier orders releasing party from implied undertaking not to disclose information or documents produced under compulsion – where party making application did not produce documents subject of order releasing undertaking – where proceeding at an end – where no likely utility in restraining solicitors – Held: application dismissed.
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37AF
Cases cited:

Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) [2023] FCA 388

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Shi (2021) 273 CLR 235

Lindsay Petroleum Company v Hurd (1874) LR 5 PC 221

O’Brien v Komesaroff (1982) 150 CLR 310

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Admiralty and Maritime
Number of paragraphs: 31
Date of hearing: 12 May 2023
Counsel for the plaintiff:  Mr C Street
Solicitor for the plaintiff:  Colin Biggers & Paisley
Counsel for the second defendant:  Mr M Scott KC
Solicitor for the second defendant:  HFW Australia
Counsel for Inter Ocean Express Ltd: Mr J Emmett SC & Ms A Elizabeth
Solicitor for Inter Ocean Express Ltd: Norton Wilson Lawyers
Counsel for HFW Australia: Mr C Juebner SC & Ms E Nadon
Solicitor for HFW Australia:  K & L Gates

ORDERS

NSD 591 of 2022
BETWEEN:

BRONTES SECURITY LLC

Plaintiff

AND:

"LIHIR CHIEF" (FORMERLY "CHARLIE B")

First Defendant

SWIRE SHIPPING PTE LTD

Second Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 MAY 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Until further order, on the ground that it is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the following parts of the affidavit of Gavin Vallely sworn on 10 May 2023 not be published and be suppressed pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth):

(a)the words after “in relation to” in paragraph 10(c)(ii);

(b)the words in quotation marks in paragraph 10(d)(i);

(c)in the email from Mr Ritter to Mr Vallely on page 10 of the affidavit (in exhibit GJV-1) and the copy of that email on page 22 (in exhibit GJV-1), the words after “BBC” (in the second paragraph) to the end of the bracket in the next paragraph; and

(d)in the email from Mr Ritter to Mr Vallely on page 11 of the affidavit (in exhibit GJV-1) and the copy of that email on page 23 (in exhibit GJV-1), the words after “on” to the commencement of the bracket and the words in the second paragraph after the word “on”.

2.The interlocutory application filed by Inter Ocean Express Ltd on 8 May 2023 be dismissed.

3.Inter Ocean Express Ltd pay the costs of HFW Australia and the second defendant of the interlocutory application.

4.The plaintiff file and serve written submissions, limited to 5 pages, and evidence upon which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 515
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brontes Security LLC v "Lihir Chief" (formerly "Charlie B") (No 2) involved an application by a non-party, Inter Ocean Express Ltd, to restrain the solicitors of a party from acting and to set aside earlier orders that released a party from an implied undertaking not to disclose certain information or documents produced under compulsion. The documents in question were not produced by Inter Ocean Express Ltd. The case had reached a conclusion, and the court found that there was no likely utility in restraining the solicitors. The Federal Court dismissed the application.

The legal issues before the court were whether it was in the interests of justice to stay the operation of an undertaking release order and whether there was any apparent injustice in refusing to do so. The court had to consider the arguments put forward by Inter Ocean Express Ltd, which were deemed inherently weak. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the application should be dismissed with costs and if there were any other orders that should be made in relation to the publication and confidentiality of certain documents.

In dismissing the application, the court found that there was no apparent injustice in refusing to stay the operation of the undertaking release order. Given the inherent weakness of Inter Ocean Express Ltd's arguments, the court did not consider it to be in the interests of justice to stay the operation of the order any longer. The court concluded that the interlocutory application filed by Inter Ocean Express Ltd on 8 May 2023 should be dismissed with costs.

The final orders included the suppression of certain parts of an affidavit, the dismissal of the interlocutory application, the payment of costs by Inter Ocean Express Ltd, and the scheduling of further case management and submissions regarding the protection of confidential information. The operation of a previous non-publication order was extended, and costs in relation to the dispute between the plaintiff and the second defendant were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Until further order, on the ground that it is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the following parts of the affidavit of Gavin Vallely sworn on 10 May 2023 not be published and be suppressed pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth):

(a) the words after “in relation to” in paragraph 10(c)(ii);

(b) the words in quotation marks in paragraph 10(d)(i);

(c) in the email from Mr Ritter to Mr Vallely on page 10 of the affidavit (in exhibit GJV-1) and the copy of that email on page 22 (in exhibit GJV-1), the words after “BBC” (in the second paragraph) to the end of the bracket in the next paragraph; and

(d) in the email from Mr Ritter to Mr Vallely on page 11 of the affidavit (in exhibit GJV-1) and the copy of that email on page 23 (in exhibit GJV-1), the words after “on” to the commencement of the bracket and the words in the second paragraph after the word “on”.

2. The interlocutory application filed by Inter Ocean Express Ltd on 8 May 2023 be dismissed.

3. Inter Ocean Express Ltd pay the costs of HFW Australia and the second defendant of the interlocutory application.

4. The plaintiff file and serve written submissions, limited to 5 pages, and evidence upon which it proposes to rely, and formulate a draft order seeking to protect any confidential information in the five documents the subject of order 1 made on 21 April 2023 (being the non-publication order over certain parts of the affidavit of Meike Mtshali sworn 23 February 2023), by 26 May 2023.

5. The second defendant file and serve written submissions in reply, limited to 5 pages, and any evidence upon which it proposes to rely by 7 June 2023.

6. The proceeding be listed for case management on 16 June 2023.

7. The operation of order 1 made 21 April 2023 (being the non-publication order over certain parts of the affidavit of Meike Mtshali sworn 23 February 2023) be extended up to and including 16 June 2023.

8. Costs in relation to the dispute between the plaintiff and second defendant be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by Inter Ocean Express Ltd, a non-party, to restrain the solicitors of the second defendant, HFW Australia, from acting and to set aside earlier orders that released a party from an implied undertaking not to disclose information or documents produced under compulsion. The documents in question were produced in relation to a larger proceeding between Brontes Security LLC and "Lihir Chief" (formerly "Charlie B"). The proceeding between the primary parties, Brontes Security LLC and "Lihir Chief," has concluded. Inter Ocean Express Ltd did not produce the documents that are the subject of the order releasing the undertaking. The application was filed on 8 May 2023 and concerns the non-publication and suppression of certain parts of affidavits, with a specific focus on maintaining confidentiality of information.

The case came before the court on the basis of an interlocutory application filed by Inter Ocean Express Ltd on 8 May 2023. The application sought to restrain the solicitors of HFW Australia and to set aside earlier orders that had released a party from an implied undertaking not to disclose certain information or documents. The application was heard by the court, which considered the arguments presented by Inter Ocean Express Ltd and the responses from the other parties involved. The court also reviewed the relevant orders made earlier in the proceeding, including a non-publication order made on 21 April 2023 over certain parts of an affidavit sworn by Meike Mtshali on 23 February 2023.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no apparent injustice in refusing to stay the operation of the undertaking release order. Having regard to the inherent weakness of Inter Ocean’s arguments, I do not consider that it is in the interests of justice to stay the operation of that order any longer and will not do so.CONCLUSION For these reasons, Inter Ocean’s interlocutory application filed on 8 May 2023 should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application by Inter Ocean Express Ltd, a non-party, to restrain the solicitors of HFW Australia from acting and to set aside earlier orders that released a party from an implied undertaking not to disclose certain information or documents. The court noted that Inter Ocean Express Ltd, which did not produce the documents subject of the order releasing the undertaking, had weak arguments. The proceeding between the primary parties had concluded, diminishing the likelihood of any utility in restraining the solicitors. The court held that, given the inherent weakness of Inter Ocean's arguments, it was not in the interests of justice to stay the operation of the undertaking release order. Consequently, the court dismissed the interlocutory application with costs. The binding legal principle established is that non-parties with weak arguments are unlikely to succeed in applications that seek to restrain a party’s solicitors or to set aside orders made in proceedings between other parties, especially where the primary proceeding has concluded.