Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) [2023] FCA 388   

File number: NSD 591 of 2022
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 21 April 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application by party for release from implied undertaking not to disclose or use documents or information obtained under compulsion in court proceeding, without the leave of the court, for use for any purpose other than that for which documents or information were given – where proceeding settled – where party later seeks to use documents and information for purpose of commencing new litigation overseas against third parties – whether necessary for proceeding to be reinstated in order to grant relief from implied undertaking – whether implied undertaking interlocutory procedural or substantive – whether necessary in the interests of justice to release party from implied undertaking – held: implied undertaking interlocutory in character, release granted.
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 r 39.05(f)
Cases cited:

Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Phillip Morris Inc (1981) 138 CLR 170

Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389

Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Ltd (2005) 218 ALR 283

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Admiralty and Maritime
Number of paragraphs: 37
Date of hearing: 21 April 2023
Counsel for the plaintiff:  Mr C Street
Solicitor for the plaintiff:  Colin Biggers & Paisley
Counsel for the second defendant:  Mr M Scott KC
Solicitor for the second defendant:  HFW Australia
Counsel for Inter Ocean Express Ltd (appearing conditionally): Mr J Emmett SC
Solicitor for Inter Ocean Express Ltd (appearing conditionally): Norton Wilson Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 591 of 2022
BETWEEN:

BRONTES SECURITY LLC

Applicant

AND:

"LIHIR CHIEF" (FORMERLY "CHARLIE B") IMO 9519327

First Respondent

SWIRE SHIPPING PTE LTD

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 APRIL 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The second defendant be released from the implied undertaking not to use the following documents or information contained in them, being documents that the plaintiff produced or filed in this proceeding, to the extent that it would otherwise be precluded from doing so, for the purpose of bringing proceedings in the courts of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region against Charles Nicholas Alling Brown and Torsten Steffen Hartmann:

(a)affidavit of Henrike Koch sworn 16 August 2022 and exhibits thereto;

(b)affidavit of Sven Lundehn sworn 16 August 2022 and exhibits thereto;

(c)unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 19 August 2022;

(d)partial unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 21 August 2022; and

(e)partial unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 22 August 2022.

2.Order 1 be stayed up to and including 8 May 2023.

3.There be no order as to costs.

Note:   Entry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 388
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Brontes Security LLC v “Lihir Chief” (formerly “Charlie B”) involved an application by the second defendant, Swire, for release from an implied undertaking not to disclose or use certain documents and information obtained under compulsion in the court proceedings, without the leave of the court, for any purpose other than that for which the documents and information were given. The proceedings had settled, but Swire later sought to use the documents and information to commence new litigation overseas against third parties. The legal issues were whether it was necessary to reinstate the proceeding to grant relief from the implied undertaking, whether the implied undertaking was interlocutory procedural or substantive, and whether it was necessary in the interests of justice to release the party from the implied undertaking.

The court held that the implied undertaking was interlocutory in character, as it contained a term that any document produced to the court and information disclosed under compulsion could not be used without the court's leave for any purpose other than that for which it was given. The court also held that it was in the interests of justice to release Swire from the implied undertaking, given the nature of the information and Swire's proposed use of the documents and information. The court noted that the implied undertaking was interlocutory procedural in nature, and procedural matters relating to the suit remained within the control of the court even after the suit had concluded. The court further held that it was not necessary to reinstate the proceeding to grant relief from the implied undertaking.

The final orders of the court were that the second defendant be released from the implied undertaking in relation to certain documents and information, that the order be stayed up to and including 8 May 2023, and that there be no order as to costs. The court made no order as to costs, as no such order had been sought by Swire. The case highlights the importance of understanding the nature of implied undertakings and the role of the court in controlling procedural matters even after a proceeding has concluded.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second defendant be released from the implied undertaking not to use the following documents or information contained in them, being documents that the plaintiff produced or filed in this proceeding, to the extent that it would otherwise be precluded from doing so, for the purpose of bringing proceedings in the courts of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region against Charles Nicholas Alling Brown and Torsten Steffen Hartmann:

(a) affidavit of Henrike Koch sworn 16 August 2022 and exhibits thereto;

(b) affidavit of Sven Lundehn sworn 16 August 2022 and exhibits thereto;

(c) unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 19 August 2022;

(d) partial unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 21 August 2022; and

(e) partial unredacted purported loan agreement attached to the email from Colin Biggers & Paisley to HFW Australia on 22 August 2022.

2. Order 1 be stayed up to and including 8 May 2023.

3. There be no order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Of course, in these reasons, I have refrained from disclosing any of the material or information to which the implied undertaking attached and which may or may not be the subject of any further application by Inter Ocean, if so advised, once the stay I impose on Swire being able to use the documents expires. CONCLUSION I am satisfied that it is in the interests of justice, having regard to the nature of the information the subject of the five documents and Swire’s proposed use of that information and those documents, that Swire be released from its implied undertaking in relation to those documents and that information. I will so order. I make no order as to costs, no such order having been sought by Swire.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Brontes opposes Swire being released from its implied undertaking in respect of the five documents because it says: (1)it is not necessary in the interests of justice within Australia to release Swire from the implied undertaking; (2)the Court cannot make an enforceable order that could confine Swire’s subsequent use of the five documents or the information in them, and there are currently no foreign proceedings on foot which could give any comfort as to how that material may be used elsewhere;(3)Swire had already made a substantive breach of the implied undertaking because it had used the five documents and information in them to obtain advice and prepare the draft statement of claim in Hong Kong based on the disclosure in Ms Mtshali’s affidavit as the purpose for seeking its release from the undertaking. Brontes contended that Swire had not apologised for this supposed breach; (4)Swire had provided no evidence that it needed to be released from the implied undertaking anyway in order to be able to bring the Hong Kong proceedings. Brontes said I should draw an inference based on Handley JA’s observation Commercial Union Assurance Company of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389 at 417-418 that, because Swire led no evidence from Ms Mtshali about the law of Hong Kong (I note that there is no evidence of where she obtained her legal qualification or may be able to practice), her evidence would have been against it being necessary for Swire to rely on or use the five documents or information in them as they are used in the draft statement of claim; (5)there was no evidence: (a)that the five documents, if Swire were released from the implied undertaking, would be applied or used in a proper way;(b)as to whether the draft statement of claim revealed a bona fide cause of action under the law of Hong Kong or what relevance or necessity to support such a cause of action the material in the five documents might have; (6)Swire had not sought permission in the deed of settlement to use the material or information in the five documents and that its current application would undermine the finality of the settlement. CONSIDERATION Necessity of reinstatement of the proceeding In its interlocutory application Swire sought an order to reinstate the proceeding under r 39.05(f) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 as a preliminary step for the purposes of obtaining an order granting relief from its obligations under the implied undertaking in respect of the five documents. That application was, in my opinion, misconceived. The implied undertaking contains, as a term, that any document produced to the Court and information disclosed under compulsion cannot be used without the Court’s leave for any purpose other than that for which it was given unless received into evidence. The requirement for the Court’s leave confirms that the implied undertaking has the character of an interlocutory order. Although the suit in which the five documents were produced has concluded so that the rights of the parties have merged in its resolution and in the deed of settlement, procedural matters relating to the suit, as distinct from substantive ones, remain within the control of the Court.