Broadcasting Co of Australia Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
52 CLR 52

BROADCASTING COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA

PROPRIETARY LIMITED AND OTHERS

THE COMMONWEALTH Regulation-Wireless telegraphy-Remuneration of licensees fixed by regulation-

Accrued rights-Subsequent regulation-Reduction of fees-Retrospective operation

Validity-Interference with accrued rights-Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905- MELBOURNE,

1919 (No. 8 of 1905-No. 4 of 1919), secs. 5, 10-Acts Interpretation Act Oct. 31,1934.

1904-1930 (No. 1 of 1904-No. 23 of 1930), sec. 10. Feb. 21, 1935.

Sec. 10 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919 provides that " the Governor- General may make regulations

prescribing all matters which by this Act are required or permitted to be prescribed or which are necessary convenient to be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to this Act."

Two of the plaintiff companies were established to erect and maintain broadcasting stations for the purpose of transmitting messages by means of wireless telegraphy, and the fees to which they were entitled were fixed by regulation. Subsequently a regulation was passed on 7th August 1928 purporting to amend the earlier regulation by reducing the remuneration payable to the two companies, and by clause (2) thereof purporting to make such reduction operate retrospectively as from 1st November 1927.

Held, by Gavan Duffy C.J., Rich, Evatt and McTiernan JJ. (Starke J. dissenting), that clause (2) of the regulation which made the reduction operate as from a date anterior to the passing of the regulation was void.

Per Gavan Duffy C.J., Evatt and McTiernan JJ. :-(1) The regulation was inconsistent with sec. 10 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1904-1930 and was void: (2) The regulation was also void on the ground that it attempted to alter and set aside the accrued right to remuneration of those who had already

52 CLR 53

provided a broadcasting service. Such a regulation, operating retroactively, was not within the power granted to the Governor-General by sec. 10 of the 1934-1935.

Per Rich J.: The regulation was void in SO far as it purported to authorize a further deduction from the available revenue prior to the date of its adoption, since to diminish the remuneration or revenue to which the licensees had become already entitled for services already rendered was a thing neither required nor permitted to be prescribed by the Act, nor necessary or convenient to be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to the Act. DEMURRER.

The Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty. Ltd., the Associated Radio Co. of Australia Ltd., and Dominion Broadcasting Pty. Ltd. brought an action in the High Court against the Commonwealth of Australia and the Postmaster-General.

The statement of claim, as amended, was, in substance, as follows:- 1. The plaintiffs severally are companies incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Acts of Victoria.

2. The plaintiff Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty. Ltd. at all times material was the proprietor of the class A high power wireless broadcasting station in the State of Victoria known as 3LO, and the holder of a broadcasting station licence of such station under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919 and the Wireless Telegraphy Regulations thereunder.

3.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Broadcasting Co of Australia Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1935] HCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a demurrer filed by the Commonwealth of Australia against broadcasting companies, Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty. Ltd. and Associated Radio Co. of Australia Ltd. The dispute arose from a regulation enacted on 7 August 1928, which purported to reduce the remuneration payable to these companies for broadcasting services. This reduction was made to operate retrospectively from 1 November 1927, impacting fees that had already accrued to the companies.

The central legal issue before the Court was the validity of the regulation, specifically clause (2) which stipulated its retrospective commencement date. The plaintiffs argued that this retrospective operation was beyond the scope of the regulatory power granted by section 10 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919, as it interfered with their accrued rights to remuneration for services already rendered. The defendants contended that the regulation was valid, arguing that the licensing terms incorporated all future regulations and that the retrospective aspect was merely a method of calculation rather than an invalid interference with vested rights.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Gavan Duffy C.J., Rich, Evatt, and McTiernan JJ., held that clause (2) of the regulation was void. Their reasoning was twofold: firstly, the retrospective operation was inconsistent with section 10 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1904-1930, which governs the commencement of regulations. Secondly, and more broadly, the regulation was deemed void because it attempted to alter and set aside the accrued rights to remuneration for services already provided. The majority found that such a retroactive alteration was not within the power granted to the Governor-General by section 10 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act, as it did not serve the purpose of carrying out or giving effect to the Act. Rich J. specifically noted that diminishing remuneration for services already rendered was neither required nor permitted by the Act, nor necessary or convenient for its implementation. Starke J. dissented, finding the regulation valid, arguing that the licensing terms were subject to future regulations and that the retrospective operation was permissible within the broad regulatory power granted.

The demurrer was overruled with costs, meaning the plaintiffs' action could proceed on the basis that the retrospective operation of the regulation was invalid.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty Ltd., the Associated Radio Co. of Australia Ltd., and Dominion Broadcasting Pty Ltd. were companies that operated wireless broadcasting stations in Victoria, holding licenses under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919. Their fees were determined by the available revenue, which was the balance of the fees collected by the Postmaster-General's Department after deducting specified amounts. In May 1928, the Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty Ltd. and the Associated Radio Co. of Australia Ltd. assigned their licence fees and revenues to Dominion Broadcasting Pty Ltd. effective from 1 March 1928 and 1 January 1928, respectively. On 7 August 1928, the Commonwealth passed a regulation under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919, which purported to amend the earlier regulation by reducing the remuneration payable to the Broadcasting Co. of Australia Pty Ltd. and the Associated Radio Co. of Australia Ltd. The new regulation also purported to make the reduction operate retrospectively from 1 November 1927. The plaintiffs sought a declaration that the regulation was void either wholly or in so far as it purported to apply retrospectively or to deal with any liability accrued under the earlier regulation.

Broadcasting Co of Australia Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth is a case that came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal against decisions of lower courts. The plaintiffs, Broadcasting Co of Australia Pty Ltd, Associated Radio Co of Australia Ltd, and Dominion Broadcasting Pty Ltd, sought to challenge the validity of a regulation made under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919, which they argued was inconsistent with the Act and had an impermissible retrospective effect. The case originated from an action brought by the plaintiffs against the Commonwealth and the Postmaster-General, seeking a declaration that the regulation was invalid and an order for the payment of the sums due to them. The Commonwealth and the Postmaster-General demurred to the statement of claim, arguing that it did not disclose a cause of action. The High Court heard the demurrer and delivered its judgment, finding that the regulation was invalid in part due to its retrospective operation and its inconsistency with the Acts Interpretation Act 1904-1930.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the regulation fall within the power granted by the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919?
2. Is the regulation inconsistent with the Acts Interpretation Act 1904-1930?
3. Does the regulation attempt to alter and set aside the accrued rights of the plaintiffs to remuneration for past services?
4. Is the retrospective operation of the regulation necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919?
5. Does the regulation create new obligations or duties in respect of transactions or considerations already past?

Held
1. The court concluded that the regulation was inconsistent with section 10 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1904-1930 and was void.
2. The court concluded that the regulation attempted to alter and set aside the accrued right to remuneration of those who had already provided a broadcasting service and was void.
3. The court concluded that the retrospective operation of the regulation was not necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919 and was void.
4. The court concluded that the regulation created new obligations or duties in respect of transactions or considerations already past and was void.
5. The court concluded that the clause (2) of the regulation which made the reduction operate as from a date anterior to the passing of the regulation was void.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Broadcasting Co of Australia Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth revolves around the validity of a regulation made under the Wireless Telegraphy Act 1905-1919, which sought to reduce the remuneration payable to broadcasting companies for their services rendered prior to the date of the regulation. The key issues addressed by the court were whether the regulation fell within the power granted by the Wireless Telegraphy Act, was inconsistent with the Acts Interpretation Act, attempted to alter accrued rights, was necessary or convenient for carrying out the Act, and created new obligations for past transactions. The majority of the court found the regulation invalid on multiple grounds, while one judge dissented.

First, the court examined whether the regulation fell within the power granted by section 10 of the Wireless Telegraphy Act, which allows the Governor-General to make regulations necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Act. The majority found that the regulation was not necessary or convenient for carrying out the Act, as it did not relate to any operation to be performed under the Act but merely reduced a debt owed by the Commonwealth.

Second, the court held that the regulation was inconsistent with section 10 of the Acts Interpretation Act, which provides that regulations shall take effect from the date of notification unless the contrary intention appears. The regulation sought to have retrospective effect from a date prior to its notification, which was inconsistent with the Act.

Third, the court found that the regulation attempted to alter and set aside the accrued rights of the plaintiffs to remuneration for past services. The majority held that such a regulation was not within the power granted by the Wireless Telegraphy Act, as it did not carry out or give effect to the Act but rather interfered with the plaintiffs' already established rights.

Fourth, the court considered whether the retrospective operation of the regulation was necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Wireless Telegraphy Act. The majority found that the regulation's retrospective effect achieved nothing but a reduction of a matured liability of the Commonwealth, which was not necessary or convenient for carrying out the Act.

Lastly, the court examined whether the regulation created new obligations or duties in respect of transactions or considerations already past. The majority held that the power to make regulations did not extend to affecting accrued or vested rights or applying retrospectively to a period prior to the date of the regulation.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a regulation made under the Wireless Telegraphy Act cannot interfere with the accrued rights of the licensees or have retrospective effect if it is not necessary or convenient for carrying out or giving effect to the Act. The majority of the court found the regulation invalid on these grounds, while one judge dissented, finding the regulation within the power granted by the Act and valid despite its retrospective effect.