Bridgefoot v Cic Allianz Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Bridgefoot v CIC Allianz Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPICMP 195

CLAIMANT:

Gelsomina Bridgefoot

INSURER:

Allianz Insurance Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Bridie Nolan

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Alan Home

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Sophia Lahz

DATE OF DECISION:

3 April 2024

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; medical dispute; claimant suffered two injuries to knees in school bus accidents on two separate occasions in 2018 and 2019; the 2019 accident aggravated the pre-existing symptomatic injuries from the 2018 injury of to the right knee; ensuing severe right knee pain which did not improve with conservative treatment of further physiotherapy and came to a self-funded right total knee replacement; whether the right knee injuries the subject of the claims in the 2018 accident and the 2019 accident are injuries caused by the motor accident and whether such an injury is a threshold injury; whether total knee replacement an injury caused by a motor vehicle accident; whether total knee replacement a “soft tissue injury”; Held – right knee pain after the 2018 accident does not constitute a distinct injury to the right knee in the 2018 accident, which constituted any contributory factor to her ongoing knee condition; Medical Assessment Certificate revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

Medical Assessment – Threshold injury

Review Panel Assessment of Threshold Injury

Replacement Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

The Review Panel revokes the certificate dated 21 February 2024 and certifies that:

1.     The following injuries were not caused by the motor accident:

(a)  right knee – anterior, posterior and medial crush injury to the right knee; acceleration and deterioration of osteoarthritis; soft tissue injury.

2.     The following injuries caused by the motor accident:

·        head;

·        cervical spine;

·        sacrum/coccyx;

·        lumbar spine;

·        ribs;

·        left and right shoulder;

·        thoracic spine; and

·        left foot

are THRESHOLD INJURIES for the purposes of the Act.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. The claimant, Gelsomnia Bridgefoot, claims she sustained injuries in two motor vehicle accidents: 30 November 2018 (R-M10564912/23) (the 2018 accident) and 6 December 2019 (R-M10564888/23) (the 2019 accident). On both occasions, the claimant was a passenger on a bus insured by the insurer. The insurer therefore has a liability to pay the claimant any damages and/or statutory compensation entitlements under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the Act).

  2. These reasons support the certificates which the Review Panel (Panel) has issued in respect of both the 2018 accident and the 2019 accident.

THE MEDICAL ASSESSMENT THE SUBJECT OF REVIEW

  1. In relation to the injuries sustained in the accident of 2018 accident, the claimant lodged an application for determination of whether her injuries were minor or non-minor [viz. threshold or non-threshold] as defined in the Act. In that application the claimant alleged, relevantly, she sustained injuries to her:

    (a)    head;

    (b)    cervical spine;

    (c)    sacrum/coccyx;

    (d)    lumbar spine;

    (e)    ribs;

    (f)    right knee - anterior, posterior, and medial crush injury to the right knee; acceleration and deterioration of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bridgefoot v Cic Allianz Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court was an application for a review of the decision of Medical Assessor Ian Cameron, who issued a Medical Assessment Certificate on 21 February 2023. The applicant, Bridgefoot, was seeking to have the certificate revoked and replaced with one that would recognise her injuries as non-threshold. Bridgefoot alleged that she had sustained injuries to her head, cervical spine, sacrum/coccyx, lumbar spine, ribs, right knee, left and right shoulder, thoracic spine, and left foot in two separate motor vehicle accidents. The respondent, Cic Allianz Insurance Limited, opposed the application, arguing that the certificate was correct and that the applicant’s injuries were minor. The court had to decide whether the right knee pain after the 2018 accident constituted a distinct injury to the right knee in that accident, whether such an injury was a threshold injury, whether the total knee replacement was an injury caused by a motor vehicle accident, and whether such an injury was a “soft tissue injury”. The court held that the right knee pain after the 2018 accident did not constitute a distinct injury to the right knee in the 2018 accident, which constituted any contributory factor to her ongoing knee condition. The court also held that the total knee replacement was not a soft tissue injury and that the Medical Assessment Certificate should be revoked.

The legal issues in this case revolved around the interpretation of the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 and the definition of a “threshold injury”. The court had to determine whether the applicant’s injuries were minor or non-minor, and whether they were caused by the motor vehicle accidents. The court also had to consider the definition of a “soft tissue injury” and whether the total knee replacement fell within that definition. The court had to balance the applicant’s submissions with the respondent’s arguments and the evidence presented by both parties. The court had to ensure that its decision was in accordance with the relevant legislation and case law.

The court’s reasoning was based on the evidence presented by both parties and the relevant legislation. The court found that the applicant’s right knee pain after the 2018 accident did not constitute a distinct injury to the right knee in that accident, which constituted any contributory factor to her ongoing knee condition. The court held that the right knee pain was a result of the aggravation of the pre-existing symptomatic injuries from the 2018 injury of to the right knee. The court also held that the total knee replacement was not a soft tissue injury and that it was not caused by the motor vehicle accidents. The court found that the Medical Assessor’s decision was incorrect in a material respect and that the Medical Assessment Certificate should be revoked.

The final orders of the court were that the application for a review of the Medical Assessment Certificate was granted, and the certificate was revoked. The court ordered that a new Medical Assessment Certificate be issued, recognising the applicant’s injuries as non-threshold. The court also ordered that the respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application. The court’s decision was based on its interpretation of the relevant legislation and the evidence presented by both parties. The court ensured that its decision was in accordance with the law and that it was just and equitable in the circumstances of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to the injuries sustained in the accident of 2018 accident, the claimant lodged an application for determination of whether her injuries were minor or non-minor [viz. threshold or non-threshold] as defined in the Act. In that application the claimant alleged, relevantly, she sustained injuries to her:(a) head;(b) cervical spine;(c) sacrum/coccyx;(d) lumbar spine;(e) ribs;(f) right knee - anterior, posterior, and medial crush injury to the right knee; acceleration and deterioration of osteoarthritis; soft tissue injury;(g) left and right shoulder;(h) thoracic spine, and(i) left foot.[our emphasis added] In relation to the injuries sustained in the accident of 2019 accident, the claimant lodged an application for determination of whether her injuries were threshold or non-threshold as defined in the Act in relation to the injuries sustained in the accident of 2019 accident. In that application the claimant alleged, relevantly, she sustained injuries to her:(a) right knee - traumatic meniscal injury and traumatic patellar fracture resulting in total knee replacement;(b) lumbar spine;(c) cervical spine;(d) thoracic spine, and(e) left foot.[our emphasis added] By a certificate dated 21 February 2023, Medical Assessor Ian Cameron assessed the claimant in relation to the above injuries finding that the above injuries were minor [viz. threshold] and determined, relevantly, that the claimant had suffered a soft tissue injury to her right knee in both the 2018 accident and the 2019 accident and as such that injury, and all other injuries were minor injuries. The applications for referral of the medical assessments to a review panel were made by the claimant within 28 days after the parties were issued with the original certificate for the medical assessment for which the review is sought. On 19 April 2023, the President’s delegate referred the medical assessments to the Panel as he was satisfied that there was reasonable cause to suspect that the medical assessment was incorrect in a material respect having regard to the particulars set out in the application. Clause 14F of Schedule 1 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (the PIC Act) provides that the new review provisions apply in relation to a decision of a new decision-maker. A "new decision maker" is defined in cl 14A(1) of Schedule 1 of the PIC Act. As the medical assessment, the subject of the review, was made on or after 1 March 2021, the new review provisions apply. The new review provisions provide that a review panel consists of two Medical Assessors and a member assigned to the Motor Accidents Division of the Personal Injury Commission (Commission). Section 41(2) of the PIC Act enables the Commission to make rules with respect to the practice and procedure before the Commission including proceedings before a panel reviewing a decision of a Medical Assessor. Rules 127 to 130 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) are made pursuant to Part 5 of the PIC Act. A review panel determines how it conducts and determines the proceedings and may determine the proceedings solely based on the written application.