Brideson by guardian Lynette Brideson and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Brideson by guardian Lynette Brideson and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 2314 (31 July 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2016/6726          

Re:Michael Brideson by guardian Lynette Brideson

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Capital Territory

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:                Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Date:31 July 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the reviewable decision dated 24 November 2016.

............................................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

Catchwords

WORKER’S COMPENSATION – accepted condition of post-traumatic stress disorder – whether a psychiatric assistance dog is a form of medical treatment or an aid for the purposes of the Act – whether the psychiatric assistance dog obtained at the direction of a legally qualified medical practitioner – whether the psychiatric assistance dog is reasonable to obtain – where Tribunal faced with uncertain and vague evidence as to the

medical effects of the psychiatric assistance dog – psychiatric assistance dog is not medical treatment for purposes of the Act – whether psychiatric assistance dog is an aid under the Act – statutory construction – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971, s 37
Disability Discrimination Act 1992, s 9
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 14, 16, 39

Cases

Alamos and Comcare [2014] AATA 629

Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165

Capital Territory Health Commission v Cavanagh [1978] FCA 5

Comcare v Watson (1997) 73 FCR 273

Durham and Comcare [2014] AATA 753

Jorgensen and Commonwealth (1990) 23 ALD 321

Ondrich v Kookaburra Park Eco-Village (2009) 227 FLR 83

Pethes and Comcare [2018] AATA 483

Popovic and Comcare [2000] AATA 264

Queensland v Forest (2008) 168 FCR 532

Rope and Comcare [2018] AATA 42

Smith and Comcare [2018] AATA 2901

Thiele v Commonwealth (1990) 22 FCR 342

Topping and Comcare [2015] AATA 525

WBJM and Comcare [2015] AATA 143

Secondary Materials

Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 22 April 1971, 1893-1898 (William Charles Wentworth, Minister for Social Services).
Explanatory Memorandum, Compensation (Commonwealth Employees) Bill 1971.

Dr Gwendolyn Cazander et al, “Maggot excretions affect the human complement system” 20(6) Wound Repair and Regeneration – the International Journal of Tissue Repair and Regeneration (November-December 2012).

Marguerite O'Haire and Kerri Rodriguez, “Preliminary Efficacy of Service Dogs as a Complimentary Treatment for Posttraumatic Stress Disorder in Military Members and Veterans” (2018) 86(2) Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology pp 179-188.

Dr Ronald Sherman, “Maggot Therapy for Treating Diabetic Foot Ulcers Unresponsive to Conventional Therapy” (2003) 26(2) Diabetes Care – American Diabetes Association.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries AO

31 July 2019

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Michael Brideson had been a long-serving member of the ACT Fire Brigade when, in September 2011, he and his crew attended a large factory fire in Mitchell, ACT. As a result of that attendance he suffered a psychiatric condition (PTSD). Comcare, as the Australian Capital Territory Government’s then insurer, accepted this condition as an injury pursuant to s 14 of under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act). It is also accepted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brideson by guardian Lynette Brideson and Australian Capital... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Lynette Brideson, as guardian for Mr Brideson, against a decision by the Australian Capital Territory (Comcare) concerning a claim for compensation. The dispute centred on whether a psychiatric assistance dog, named Ted, constituted a form of medical treatment or an aid for the purposes of the relevant workers' compensation legislation. The case was heard by Deputy President Gary Humphries Ao.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the psychiatric assistance dog was a form of medical treatment under the Act, whether it was obtained at the direction of a legally qualified medical practitioner, and whether its acquisition was reasonable. The Tribunal was required to interpret the provisions of the Act concerning medical treatment and aids, considering the evidence presented regarding the capabilities and benefits of psychiatric assistance dogs.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on a strict construction of the Act. It found that a psychiatric assistance dog did not meet the definition of "medical treatment." While acknowledging that animals can play a role in supporting injured workers, as evidenced by seeing-eye dogs, the Tribunal concluded that the Act did not extend to providing compensation for the costs of assistance animals. The evidence presented, including expert veterinary opinion and statements from Mr Brideson's former treating psychologist, was considered insufficient to establish that the dog was a necessary medical treatment or a compensable aid under the existing legislative framework. The Tribunal noted that while there might be a lacuna in the Act regarding assistance animals, it was not at liberty to alter the intent of the law.

Accordingly, the Tribunal affirmed the reviewable decision dated 24 November 2016, meaning Mr Brideson's claim for the psychiatric assistance dog was not allowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A report dated 11 May 2019 from Dr John Ayerbe, veterinary surgeon and consultant to Animal Expert Witness Service Ltd, was also tendered. In it he makes the following comments:I have been supplied with information regarding the required competencies of a “psychiatric dog”. It would appear that an animal must have “basic training” first, before commencing training to become a “Minddog”.“Basic training” involved training an animal to respond to stimuli or signals as a result of a positive experience.I believe that it would be extremely difficult to demonstrate that an animal can be trained to perform the tasks required of a “Minddog”.There is evidence that dogs may have a relaxing or calming effect on their owners…2. Can a dog be trained to “sense” whether a person is “nervous”, such that the dog decides to distract or otherwise assist a person?There is anecdotal evidence that animals (dogs in particular) may be able to sense whether an owner is nervous.It may be that a human emits some form of chemical or smell when nervous. This odour would not be detected by humans but may be able to be detected by some dogs. It also may be that a dog is able to interpret body language signals of an owner who is nervous.However, my belief is that while some dogs may have this as an innate competency this ability cannot be “taught” to the animal.If an animal does have an innate ability to detect nervousness then it may be able to have the skill “enhanced” by some form of positive reinforcement training…3. Can a dog be trained to “alert family members in advance” when a person is experiencing suicidal thoughts, depression, hypervigilance and anxiety?I don’t believe that an animal could sense that a person would be having suicidal thoughts and as such would not be able to warn family members in advance of such an occurrence. I don’t believe that a dog can read a human’s mind…5. Can a dog be trained to bark when its handler is in “flashback or a fugue state”?I find it difficult to understand how a dog could recognise when an owner would be suffering from either of these conditions, unless there is a patterned reaction to these states by the handler. If this was the case then it may be possible to train an animal to bark in response to this behaviour…11. Can a dog be trained to assist a person to alleviate the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder in contradistinction to mere obedience training?The methodology involved in training an animal relies upon the process of positive reinforcement of an animal for a patterned experience. The method would be the same for “assisting the effects of post-traumatic stress disorder” as it would be for “mere obedience training”…THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE Dr Nguyen authored a letter to Comcare dated 26 October 2016, following a relapse in Mr Brideson’s PTSD and depression which led to a hospital admission, in which he answered a question relating to the strategies put in place to assist Mr Brideson to self-manage his condition. He made no reference in the letter to Ted, other than to note that Mr Brideson’s claim for the dog had been declined by Comcare.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This proposition is not affected by the reflection that the test is slightly different in s 39 to the test in s 16; in the former, the test is whether the aid is reasonably required having regard to the nature of the employee’s impairment. In my view, it is unlikely that an assistance dog which cannot meet the test of medical treatment can somehow still serve to minimise or relieve the effects of Mr Brideson’s impairment arising from the PTSD.CONCLUSION It may seem strange that the Parliament has not seen fit to make provision, in the parts of this Act dealing with the treatment, support and rehabilitation of injured workers, for assistance animals. Notwithstanding the conclusions the Tribunal has reached here with respect to psychiatric assistance dogs, it should not be doubted that animals can and do play a relevant role in that context – a seeing-eye dog for a blinded employee is an obvious example. If, say, further research in the future polarises around the view that psychiatric assistance dogs do assist psychiatrically ill people to overcome the effects of their condition, and my interpretation of the Act as it now stands is correct, there would be an obvious lacuna in the Act’s scope. To make the observation, however, does not overcome what must be the firm conclusion of the Tribunal that Parliament has not intended to offer injured workers compensation for the costs of assistance animals. To adopt the words of Senior Member McCabe, perhaps Parliament should have done so, but noting that omission is not a licence for the Tribunal to change the intent of the law. Accordingly, the reviewable decision dated 24 November 2016 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In a letter dated 5 April 2017 Ms Wainwright, Mr Brideson’s erstwhile treating psychologist, expressed the opinion that a psychiatric assistance dog would complement Mr Brideson’s evidence-based treatment for symptoms of his condition. This would allow him to undertake CBT [cognitive behaviour therapy] graded exposure tasks that aim to reduce avoidance and improved functioning. In a later letter, dated 19 February 2019, Ms Wainwright notes that she ceased to treat Mr Brideson in November 2016 and that she never used Ted as part of her treatment regime. In a supplementary report dated 19 April 2019 she provided evidence of what she described as a literature review examining the benefits of psychiatric service dogs. She concluded that this showed evidence of improved mental health for military members and veterans with PTSD who used such animals. However, she said that research into the effectiveness of using a psychiatric service dog is a complimentary treatment is in its early stages.CONSIDERATION Mr Brideson did not give evidence during the hearing. Submissions were made to the Tribunal about the weight that it should give to his submissions given his failure to appear and to subject himself to cross-examination. Evidence was led on the question of whether he had the capacity to appear. Counsel for the ACT submitted that, with suitable modifications to the process normally employed to take evidence, Mr Brideson could have given evidence notwithstanding his accepted condition. His counsel, conversely, argued that his condition did not permit him to do so, and led medical evidence in support of that proposition. The Tribunal has not formed a concluded view about those submissions because it finds that Mr Brideson’s application must fail, and the reviewable decision affirmed. It reaches that finding without needing to test the submissions made on his behalf about his personal circumstances; that is, the Tribunal’s finding stands even where the contentions regarding his state of health and the benefits he perceives are conferred on his accepted condition by Ted are accepted. In those circumstances, exploring the question of his capacity to give evidence serves no useful purpose. Similarly, the Territory submitted that the evidence of Mrs Brideson should be discounted on the basis that she was an advocate for the applicant and that her advocacy came at the expense of the truth or at the expense of the correctness of her version of events. In aid of this proposition her evidence was contrasted with the written record. It was established, for example, that, contrary to Mrs Brideson’s original assertions to Comcare, Ted was acquired originally as a family pet, not as an assistance dog. In the witness box Mrs Brideson conceded that she had inaccurately claimed that Ted was acquired on the recommendation of Mr Brideson’s treating psychiatrist. Again, it is not necessary to form a view about Mrs Brideson’s credit as a witness since, even if everything she said to the Tribunal were accepted as the truth, Mr Brideson’s claim still fails.