CITATION: Brian Finlay Hill v The Commonwealth of Australia [2003] NSWSC 1025 HEARING DATE(S): 29-30/09/03,1-3/10/03,7/10/03,8/10/03,
10/10/03,14-16/10/03JUDGMENT DATE:
11 November 2003JUDGMENT OF: Cripps AJ DECISION: verdict for the defendant CATCHWORDS: post traumatic stress disorder - negligence - reliability of history LEGISLATION CITED: Commonwealth Employees Compensation Act 1930-1971
Delegate-Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988CASES CITED: Huysse v Snowy Mountains Hydro-Electric Authority (1975) 1 NSW LR 401.
Makita (Australia) Pty Limited v Sprowles 52 NSWLR 705
Pastras v The Commonwealth 9 FLR 152
Ramsay v Watson (1961) 108 CLR 642PARTIES :
Brian Finlay Hill - Plainitff
The Commonwealth of Australia - DefendantFILE NUMBER(S): SC 21147/96 COUNSEL: P Faris QC and C Thomson - Plainitff
R Williams QC and I McLachlin - DefendantSOLICITORS: James Taylor & Co - Plaintiff
Australian Government Solicitor - Defendant
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONCripps AJ
11 November 2003
JUDGMENT21147/96 - Brian Finlay HILL v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
1 HIS HONOUR: On 10 February, 1964 the plaintiff, Mr Hill, was a naval rating on board the HMAS Melbourne when it collided with the HMAS Voyager resulting in the sinking of the Voyager and the loss of eighty two lives.
2 In 1996 the plaintiff commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against the Commonwealth of Australia alleging that the collision was the result of negligence on the part of officers and crew of the Voyager and/or officers and crew of the Melbourne. In 1997 the plaintiff was granted an extension of time within which to bring the proceedings against the Commonwealth.
3 The plaintiff has alleged that by reason of the negligence of the Commonwealth he suffered a psychiatric illness (or psychiatric illnesses) categorised as post traumatic stress disorder and/or alcohol substance abuse disorder and dependency and/or adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood and/or general anxiety disorder.
4 The plaintiff’s alleges that by reason of one or more of the classified psychiatric illnesses referred to above he was discharged from the navy in December 1964. He claims that by reason of his discharge he lost the opportunity to move upwards in the ranks and to achieve the rank of Chief Petty Officer or Warrant Officer. He does not dispute that after leaving the navy he was employed or self-employed from 1965 to 2000. He alleges, however, that his earning capacity was seriously impaired by reason of his psychiatric condition and he claims damages for loss of earning capacity, loss of superannuation benefits, and, as well, as general damages for pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life.
5 In his amended statement pursuant to Pt 33 r 8A Particulars the plaintiff alleged that as a consequence of the collision he sustained:
- “major depressive illness which is chronic, post traumatic stress disorder, chronic generalised anxiety state, substance abuse disorder being alcoholism, insomnia and sleep problems, poor concentration, claustrophobia, fear of impending disaster, amnesia, diarrhoea, impotency, poly alcoholic neuritis, poor short…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brian Finlay Hill v The Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2003] NSWSC 1025
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, whether that duty was breached, and whether the breach caused the plaintiff's injuries. Furthermore, the court had to assess the reliability of the plaintiff's account of his service and his subsequent PTSD diagnosis. The central legal issue was whether the Commonwealth could be held liable for the plaintiff's mental health condition, which allegedly stemmed from his military service.
The court found that the Commonwealth did owe a duty of care to the plaintiff. However, it held that the plaintiff's account of the events leading to his PTSD was not reliable due to inconsistencies and exaggerations. The court was unpersuaded by the plaintiff's claims and found that the Commonwealth had not breached its duty of care. Consequently, the plaintiff's claim for damages was dismissed. The court's reasoning was based on the unreliability of the plaintiff's history, which undermined the causation link between the alleged negligence and the injuries claimed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi