Brew v Crouch

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

BREW  v  CROUCH; DIONYSUS PTY LTD (RESPONDENT)

Chamber Application

Bleby J

The plaintiff and defendant had entered into negotiations to purchase between them the Finsbury Hotel.  The purchase was to be achieved by means of a company of which the plaintiff and defendant were to be equal shareholders.  Shortly before settlement was due on the contract for purchase, the defendant refused to proceed, claiming that there was no enforceable contract between the parties.  The purchase did not proceed.  The plaintiff then sued the defendant for damages for breach of contract.  The defendant joined as third parties the plaintiff’s parents, alleging that they had guaranteed certain monies which were said to have been payable by the plaintiff, and that they had failed to do so.

At the time that these arrangements were entered into, the plaintiff, although he had been studying in Melbourne, was assisting his parents to operate a hotel at Albury in New South Wales.  The defendant was at all material times and still is a resident of Victoria.

The dispute came on for hearing before Millhouse J on the question of liability only.  On 27 April 1997 (Judgment No S6131) the learned trial judge found that the plaintiff had proved the existence of the contract and of a breach thereof by the defendant.  He entered judgment against the defendant for damages to be assessed.  He dismissed the counterclaim against the third parties.  The third parties have therefore taken no further part in the proceedings.

Since April 1997 various interlocutory steps have been taken towards a hearing on the assessment of the plaintiff’s damages.  I will need to refer briefly to some of those events in due course.  It is sufficient to say for present purposes that the parties have not been able to reach agreement, and the claim for the assessment of the plaintiff’s damages is proceeding.  Since the hearing of the application to which I am about to refer, it has been set down for hearing in August of this year.

On 1 April 1998 the plaintiff filed an application seeking a Mareva injunction against the defendant and a company, Dionysus Pty Ltd (“Dionysus”), named in the proceedings as a “respondent”.  Dionysus had never been a party to the proceedings.  There had been no prior application seeking to join Dionysus as a party, and no such order had been obtained.

In the circumstances, it does not matter, but in my opinion the mere naming of a stranger to proceedings as a “respondent” and seeking an order in the nature of a Mareva injunction against it, is irregular, and would be insufficient in itself to result in any order binding on such a party.  As it happened, Mr Stratford, counsel for the defendant, was also retained on a somewhat limited basis to appear for Dionysus.

Where, as here, it was alleged in affidavits filed in support of the application for the injunction that there existed between Dionysus and the plaintiff a question or issue arising out of or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brew v Crouch and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6633
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Brew and Crouch negotiated to purchase the Finsbury Hotel through a company in which they were to be equal shareholders. The defendant subsequently refused to proceed with the purchase, and the plaintiff sued for damages for breach of contract. Millhouse J found for the plaintiff and entered judgment, which the defendant appealed without success. The parties could not agree on the assessment of damages and the matter is proceeding. On 1 April 1998 the plaintiff applied for a Mareva injunction against the defendant and a company, Dionysus Pty Ltd, which owned the leasehold of the Tattersalls Hotel. Dionysus had never been a party to the proceedings. The plaintiff's application was refused on other grounds. The plaintiff sought an injunction restraining the defendant and Dionysus from removing from the jurisdiction, disposing of, securing in any way or otherwise dealing with in any manner the assets of the Tattersalls Hotel or, in the alternative, restraining the defendant and Dionysus from removing from the jurisdiction, disposing of, securing in any way or otherwise dealing with in any manner the proceeds of sale of the Tattersalls Hotel. The plaintiff also sought to restrain Dionysus from removing from the jurisdiction, disposing of, securing in any way or otherwise dealing with in any manner the proceeds of sale of the Tattersalls Hotel, and to restrain the defendant from removing from the jurisdiction, disposing of, securing in any way or otherwise dealing with in any manner the defendant’s shareholding in Dionysus or any distributions made by that company from the proceeds of sale of the Tattersalls Hotel. The defendant was the director and holder of 99 of the 100 issued shares in Dionysus, and the defendant was a director and holder of 99 of the 100 issued shares in Keith Crouch Holdings Pty Ltd, which owned the freehold on which the hotel was situated. The plaintiff submitted that there was a risk that the defendant might endeavour to defeat the plaintiff’s claim by, if necessary, so organising his affairs as to stultify any judgment against him. The plaintiff submitted that the adverse findings as to the credibility of the defendant by the trial judge, the defendant’s alleged attempts to delay the hearing of the plaintiff’s assessment of damages, and the impending sale of the hotel pointed to a reasonable suspicion of disposal of assets for the purpose of avoiding the final judgment that the plaintiff would inevitably obtain. The plaintiff relied on cases in which Mareva injunctions had been granted against parties who had no cause of action against them and who had been joined for the purpose of the Mareva injunction. The court rejected the application. The court found that the sale of the Tattersalls Hotel appeared to be to an innocent third party by way of an arm’s length transaction in the ordinary course of business, and that there was nothing to suggest that the transaction was otherwise than in the ordinary course of business. The court also found that there was no suggestion that any of the assets of the defendant had been transferred to Dionysus in a similar manner in order to frustrate the plaintiff’s ability to recover a judgment against the defendant. The court found that there was no justification for the grant of a Mareva injunction in any of the terms sought by the plaintiff or at all. If it can be shown that there is some prospect of the defendant or companies which he controls removing assets outside Australia or disposing of them in a manner which can be seen to frustrate the recovery by the plaintiff of any amount adjudged by this Court to be due to him by the defendant, then it will be open for the plaintiff to make a further application if so advised.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.