Brereton and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 594

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)  No Q99/1389, Q00/18

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )       
           Re      SHIRLEY CLAIRE BRERETON
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member      

Date27 June 2001  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor determines that the applicant, SHIRLEY BRERETON, be paid compensation pursuant to Sections 14, 16, 24 and 27 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 in accordance with these reasons.  The Tribunal further directs that the respondent pay the applicant's costs as agreed, or failing agreement, as taxed by the District Registrar of the Tribunal in accordance with the Tribunal's Practice Direction.
  (Sgd)          DP BREEN  
  PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION - whether meniscal tear and osteoarthritis were work-related - whether the impact of work factors can be separated from underlying degeneration in terms of impairment.

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 4(9), 14(1), 16(1), 19(4), 24 (1), (2),(4), (5) and (7), 27(1)
Re Prica and Comcare (1996-7) 44 ALD 46 at 51
Comcare v Amorebieta (1996) 66 FCR 83 at 96

REASONS FOR DECISION

27 June 2001         Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member                  

  1. This was an appeal against a decision of the respondent dated 10 February 1998, which was affirmed by internal review on 3 May 1999, determining that any condition which the applicant suffered with respect to her knees was not related to her employment with Australia Post.

  2. The matter was heard by me in Ballina on 26 February and in Brisbane on 27 and 28 February 2001.  The applicant, Shirley Brereton, was represented by Mr M Perry of Counsel instructed by Messrs Mitchell Playford and Radburn.  The respondent was represented by Mr N Polin of Counsel instructed by Messrs Sparke Helmore.  Written submissions were received from the respondent on 18 May 2001 and from the applicant on 1 June 2001.  No request was received for an opportunity to present submissions in reply.

  3. Oral evidence was taken from the applicant; Dr Peter Jackson, Muscular Skeletal Physician and Dr Bruce Martin, Orthopaedic Surgeon.  The following documents were also taken into evidence:

  • Exhibit 1            "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 2            Report of Dr Peter Jackson dated 4.3.00

  • Exhibit 3A          Report of Dr A. David N. White dated 7.4.98

  • Exhibit 3B         Report of Dr A. David N. White dated 28.4.99

  • Exhibit 3C         Report of Dr A. David N. White dated 5.10.00

  • Exhibit 4            Notes of Dr A Castagna

  • Exhibit 5            Memo from Far North Coast County Council dated 27.6.97

  • Exhibit 6            Various reports of Dr Ray Randle

  • Exhibit 7            Extra Reports and x-rays reports from Dr Castagna

  • Exhibit 8            Report of Dr Bruce Martin dated 29.11.00

  • Exhibit 9            Separate Report of Dr Bruce Martin dated 29.11.00

  • Exhibit 10          X-ray Report of Dr Barbara A Laing dated 24.11.00

  • Exhibit 11          Report of Dr Neil G Thompson dated 28.7.99

  • Exhibit 12          Report from North Coast Radiology dated 7.9.98

Applicant's evidence

  1. Mrs Brereton was born on 30 June 1944.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brereton and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 594
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Brereton v Australian Postal Corporation, the primary issue before the court was whether Mrs Brereton's meniscal tear and osteoarthritis were work-related. Mrs Brereton, a former employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, sought compensation under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The court had to determine the extent to which her work-related duties had contributed to her injuries and subsequent impairment.

The legal issues before the court involved interpreting the statutory provisions of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and applying case law such as Re Prica and Comcare and Comcare v Amorebieta. The court needed to ascertain if the impact of work factors could be separated from the underlying degeneration to assess the extent of impairment attributable to work-related causes. Medical evidence from orthopaedic surgeons, including Dr Ray Randle and Dr White, was central to this determination, as it provided insights into the progression of Mrs Brereton's knee condition and the potential work-related factors that may have aggravated her condition.

The court examined the medical evidence and the opinions of the treating orthopaedic surgeons. Dr Ray Randle suggested that the use of a mop and bucket could have resulted in the meniscal tears observed during arthroscopy. Dr White concluded that Mrs Brereton's condition was likely aggravated by her employment duties, with a present impairment rating of ten percent according to Comcare Table 9.2 and twenty percent according to Comcare Table 9.5. The court found that while there was a pre-existing degenerative condition, the work-related duties had significantly aggravated the condition. The court attributed half of the impairment to pre-existing factors and the other half to the work-related aggravation.

The court concluded that Mrs Brereton's meniscal tear and osteoarthritis were work-related to the extent that they were significantly aggravated by her employment duties. The final orders of the court recognized this finding and directed the Australian Postal Corporation to compensate Mrs Brereton accordingly for the impairment resulting from the work-related aggravation of her underlying condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

According to Dr Castagna's clinical notes, Mrs Brereton complained of knee pains in 1987 and 1995 and was sent for x-rays on each of those occasions. Mrs Brereton did not recall those incidents.Medical evidence Dr Ray Randle was Mrs Brereton's treating Orthopaedic Surgeon. He provided a number of reports which formed Exhibit 6 but did not give oral evidence. Dr Randle's notes from the arthroscopy in February 1998 are as follows:"Details: EUA stable. Arthroscopy patello femoral joint grade 0 to 1 changes. Medial tibio femoral joint normal. Lateral femoral condyle grade 2 to 3 changes with an area of unstable articular cartilage smoothed and bevelled. Medial meniscus normal. Lateral meniscus several large degenerative tears resected arthroscopically. ACL and PCL normal." Dr Randle stated on 19 February 1998 that "it is possible that this action [the use of a mop and bucket] could have resulted in the meniscal tears noted at arthroscopy on 6 February 1998". He stated on 22 May 2000 that "there is no doubt that use of a joint causes wear in the joint which is normally expressed as osteoarthritis". On 21 July 2000 he expressed the further opinion that:"Meniscal injury normally occurs when the tibia is rotated against the femur in a flexed knee. In this regard it is possible that Mrs Brereton could have injured her knee …. While she was using an orbital polisher". Dr White, Orthopaedic Surgeon, examined Mrs Brereton on three occasions and provided reports dated 7 April 1998, 28 April 1999 and 5 October 2000. He did not give oral evidence at the hearing. In his first report he gave the opinion that:"This lady would appear to have suffered articular cartilage and meniscal damage to the right knee consistent with the history given [Dr White was aware of Mrs Brereton's work duties]. This has been superimposed on a knee suffering from pre-existing, though previously unknown, degenerative osteoarthritis …. It does seem likely that she will be left with a permanent partial disability as a consequence of this injury." On 28 April 1999 he made the following observations:"The long-term prognosis is unfavourable and significant osteoarthritis of the knee is likely to be progressive …. I would consider that her present impairment according to Comcare Table 9.2 is ten percent …. It appears more probable than not that her condition has been significantly aggravated by the employment duties described on or about 22 October 1997." In his final report, Dr White conducted a review of the previous x-rays of the applicant's right knee. He found that the x-ray from 1995 showed only mild degenerative change consistent with the applicant's age. The degeneration had increased in 1997 and then increased significantly by 1999. He drew the following conclusions about her condition:"There are no reliable criteria on which 'from an orthopaedic point of view' extended periods of operation of an orbital polisher/cleaner or the operation of a mop bucket pedal with the right foot can be readily correlated to 'wear and tear on the right knee joint'.There is no question that your client suffers from degenerative osteoarthritis of the right knee which is consistent with the definition quoted of a 'disease' and, on an historical basis, this has been aggravated by her work duties in a material degree.…..The valgus position of the right knee, in part, is the consequence of the increasing degenerative changes associated with progressive narrowing of the lateral compartment of the knee joint as the disease has progressed.The radiological evidence (1995) would suggest that the pre-existing degenerative change in her right knee was relatively mild and, as indicated above, her work duties have contributed to an aggravation of the underlying condition.It has been well established in the orthopaedic literature that there is no significant correlation between the plain radiographic evidence of degenerative change, pain and employment. In view of this it is not possible to predict when the mere presence of an underlying degenerative condition 'would have become so symptomatic as to cause incapacity to the extent now witnessed' and such an assessment would be 'entering the realms of speculation'.It does however appear reasonable to conclude that the presence of any degree of pre-existing change in the right knee, associated with significant obesity, would at some time have produced sufficient symptomatology to adversely effect employment of a physical nature.…..It would appear reasonable to attribute half of her impairment to pre-existing factors.The treatment administered by Dr R Randle would appear to have been rendered necessary by the work-related aggravation of the underlying condition.Her present impairment, according to Comcare Table 9.2 is ten percent and according to Comcare Table 9.5 is twenty per cent."

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.