Braze Flames Pty Ltd v Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Braze Flames Pty Ltd v Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd [2021] QCAT 101

PARTIES:

BRAZE FLAMES PTY LTD
(applicant)

v

JERRY YUEN PTY LTD

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

RSL035-19

MATTER TYPE:

Retail shop lease matters

DELIVERED ON:

15 March 2021

HEARING DATE:

1 February 2021

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Presiding Member Hughes
Member Judge

Member McBryde

ORDERS:

1.   Braze Flames Pty Ltd pay to Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd the sum of $760.44 plus GST.

2.   Each party pays its own costs.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION –damages – where premises unfit for use – where insufficient supporting evidence to support claim – where tenant did not lawfully terminate lease – where surrender by operation of law – where tenant’s claim offset by landlord’s right to damages from unlawful termination

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS –  GENERAL MATTERS - where  neither party entirely successful and inadequate material from both parties – where strong contra-indication against awarding costs

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 100

Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), s 43, s 83

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Clarke v Cascade Pools (Qld) Pty Ltd [2010] QCAT 323

Creek v Raine & Horne Real Estate Mossman [2011] QCATA 226

Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Ex. 341

Progressive Mailing House Pty Ltd v Tabali (1985) 157 CLR 17
Ralacom Pty Ltd v Body Corporate for Paradise Island Apartments (No. 2) [2010] QCAT 412
Wood Factory Pty Ltd v Kiritos Pty Ltd [1985] 2 NSWLR 105

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

M Reynolds of MGR Lawyers Pty Ltd

Respondent:

Self-represented by Jerry Yuen

REASONS FOR DECISION

What is this Application about?

  1. Braze Flames Pty Ltd as tenant seeks to recover these amounts from its lessor Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd due to fire damage to its take-away business:

    Bond refund   21,162.00

    Overpaid rent   1,204.00

    Loss of goodwill   24,250.00

    Loss of income   87,474.40 ($841.10 x 104 weeks - 23/01/18 to 22/01/20)

    Total  $130,090.40

  2. Braze also claimed interest and costs.

  3. Yuen did not file a response to the claim or a counter-claim.

    Background

  4. The original lease was between Yuen and another tenant from 5 October 2014 to 4 October 2019, with two five-year options.[1] On 14 November 2016, the lease was transferred to Braze.

    [1]Lease dated 19 November 2014.

  5. On 23 January 2017, fire damaged the premises.

  6. On 30 November 2017 and following numerous telephone calls and text messages, Braze asked Yuen for a refund of rent and an update on rectification.[2]

    [2]Email Deen Lawyers to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 30 November 2017.

  7. On 17 March 2018, Braze notified Yuen that it was giving it “NOTICE to cancel this lease pursuant to clause 6.2 of the lease”, noting the delay in completing rectification.[3]

    [3]Letter Deen Lawyers to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 17 March 2018.

  8. On 22 March 2018, Yuen refunded Braze $3,902.00 for overpaid rent and informed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Braze Flames Pty Ltd v Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Braze Flames Pty Ltd v Jerry Yuen Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Braze Flames, sought to terminate a commercial lease for rectification works following a fire at the premises. The defendant, Jerry Yuen, did not respond to the claim or file a counter-claim. The original lease between Yuen and another tenant was from 5 October 2014 to 4 October 2019, with two five-year options. On 14 November 2016, the lease was transferred to Braze. The premises were damaged by fire on 23 January 2017. Following several communications, Braze demanded a refund of rent and an update on rectification works. On 17 March 2018, Braze notified Yuen of its intention to terminate the lease due to delays in completing rectification works. Yuen responded by refunding overpaid rent and stating that it did not accept the termination. Braze then reaffirmed its decision to terminate, citing further overpaid rent and incomplete rectification works. Yuen countered that it did not accept the termination and disputed the amount of the refund. The dispute escalated with Yuen cancelling the lease in January 2020 and selling the land in March 2020.

The central legal issue in this case was whether Braze was entitled to terminate the lease for rectification works. The court had to determine whether Yuen breached the lease by failing to complete rectification works in a timely manner, thereby justifying termination. Additionally, the court had to decide whether Braze was entitled to a refund of overpaid rent and if the refund should include GST. The court also had to consider the impact of Yuen's counter-claim and the subsequent cancellation of the lease on Braze's right to terminate.

The court found that Yuen breached the lease by failing to complete rectification works in a timely manner, thus justifying termination. The court determined that Braze was entitled to a refund of overpaid rent but that the refund should exclude GST. The court noted that Yuen's counter-claim and the subsequent cancellation of the lease did not affect Braze's right to terminate. The court also found that the delay in completing rectification works was unacceptable and that the building was not safe for public use. The court ordered Yuen to pay Braze $971.93 as a refund of overpaid rent.

The court ordered that Yuen pay Braze $971.93 as a refund of overpaid rent, excluding GST. The court also ordered that Braze's claim for termination of the lease was valid and that Yuen's counter-claim was without merit. The court's decision resolved the dispute and provided clarity on the rights and obligations of both parties under the lease agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Yuen did not file a response to the claim or a counter-claim. Background The original lease was between Yuen and another tenant from 5 October 2014 to 4 October 2019, with two five-year options.[1] On 14 November 2016, the lease was transferred to Braze. [1]Lease dated 19 November 2014. On 23 January 2017, fire damaged the premises. On 30 November 2017 and following numerous telephone calls and text messages, Braze asked Yuen for a refund of rent and an update on rectification.[2][2]Email Deen Lawyers to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 30 November 2017. On 17 March 2018, Braze notified Yuen that it was giving it “NOTICE to cancel this lease pursuant to clause 6.2 of the lease”, noting the delay in completing rectification.[3] [3]Letter Deen Lawyers to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 17 March 2018. On 22 March 2018, Yuen refunded Braze $3,902.00 for overpaid rent and informed Braze that it did not accept the termination and had replaced all necessary items and the premises were ready for internal renovation.[4][4]Letter Joseph Ho Lawyers to Deen Lawyers dated 22 March 2018. On 26 March 2018, Braze purported to “reaffirm” its decision to terminate the lease, informing Yuen that it had overpaid rent of $5,361.00 (a further $1,459.30) and that rectification was still not complete.[5] [5]Letter Deen Lawyers to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 26 March 2018. On 29 March 2018, Yuen informed Braze on a “without prejudice” basis that it did not accept termination of the lease and did not dispute the overpaid rent but that it should exclude GST of $487.39, leaving a refund of $971.93.[6] [6]Letter Joseph Ho Lawyers to Deen Lawyers dated 29 March 2018. An undated document entitled “Termination of the lease” claimed that Yuen used burnt and deformed materials as beams and supports, did not follow building codes in material selection and installation of ceilings and as a result the building was not safe for the public and relevantly stated:Because of the breach of the commercial lease by the landlord JERRY YUEN PTY LTD, the tenant, BRAZE FLAMES is entitled to terminate the contract.…Since, the building (sic) never been ready for public use and or for a business occupation and (sic) unacceptable delay in renovation, BRAZE FLAMES decided to terminate the contract in this regard.[7] [7]Notice of dispute, attachment 12 undated. On 1 June 2018, Yuen informed Braze that the premises had been ready for business since 22 April 2018 and sent rent invoices for May and June 2018.[8][8]Letter Joseph Ho Lawyers to Deen Lawyers dated 1 June 2018. On 10 June 2018, Braze confirmed that it was not continuing the business due to the delay in rectification.[9][9]Letter Braze Flames Pty Ltd to Joseph Ho Lawyers dated 10 June 2018. On 13 June 2018, Yuen served Braze a Notice to Remedy for non-payment of rent.[10][10]Letter Joseph Ho Lawyers to Braze Flames Pty Ltd dated 13 June 2018. On 7 January 2020, Yuen cancelled the lease.[11][11]Historical Title Search dated 18 August 2020. On 6 March 2020, Yuen sold the land.[12]What order is just to resolve the dispute?[13][12]Historical Title Search dated 18 August 2020.[13]Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld), s 83(1).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.