Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works v Dalby [2019] NSWCA 16 Hearing dates: 9 July 2018 Decision date: 18 February 2019 Before: Simpson AJA Decision: 1. The costs of the appeal are to be assessed on the ordinary basis to 16 March 2018, and on an indemnity basis thereafter;
2. Adam Dalby is to pay the costs of the appeal.Catchwords: COSTS – Party/Party – orders against non-parties – factors relevant to exercise of court’s discretion to award costs against non-parties – whether in the interests of justice to order non-party common director of defendant/appellant companies to pay costs
COSTS – Party/Party – indemnity costs – offer of compromise – UCPR 41.14Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Copyright Act 1968 (Cth)
Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)Cases Cited: Brand2 Content Pty Ltd t/as Franchise Works v Solar Australia Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 56
FPM Constructions v Council of the City of Blue Mountains [2005] NSWCA 340
Heath v Greenacre Business Park Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCA 34
Knight v FP Special Assets Limited (1992) 174 CLR 178
May v Christodoulou (2011) 80 NSWLR 462; [2011] NSWCA 75
Oz B & S Pty Ltd v Elders IXL Limited (1993) 117 ALR 128
Ren v Jiang [2014] NSWCA 1
Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (No 8) [2006] FCA 1537
VMA Companies LLC t/as Corbis Global v Ridley Capital Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1567Category: Costs Parties: Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works (Applicant)
Adam Dalby (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
S Balafoutis/R Clark (Applicant)
A J Justice (Respondent)
Origin Lawyers (Applicant)
Osborn Law (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2018/72524 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Supreme Court of NSW
- Jurisdiction:
- Equity – Commercial List
- Citation:
- [2018] NSWSC 56
- Date of Decision:
- 7 February 2018
- Before:
- Ball J
- File Number(s):
- 2018/349668
Headnote
[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]
Brand2Content Pty Ltd (‘Brand2’) commenced proceedings in the Commercial List of the Supreme Court, claiming damages for breach of contract and misleading and deceptive conduct by contraventions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and other related legislation. The defendants were three companies. By cross-claim, an additional company was added as a fourth cross-claimant. Adam Dalby was a director of each of the defendant/cross-claimant companies. In February 2018, Ball J found in favour of Brand2, dismissed the cross-claim, and awarded Brand 2 damages.
In March 2018, the three defendant companies filed an appeal. Brand2 made an offer of compromise, which was not accepted. Before the appeal could be heard, two events occurred. First, the company that had been added as a cross-claimant was placed into members’ voluntary liquidation with debts in excess of $5m. Second, the appellant companies terminated the instructions of their solicitors. Brand2’s solicitors were advised, and sought on a number of occasions to make contact with the appellants directly via email, using an address that the appellants’ former solicitor had…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works v Dalby and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWCA 16
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether it was in the interests of justice to order Adam Dalby, as a non-party and common director, to pay the costs of the appeal, and whether the costs should be assessed on an ordinary or indemnity basis. This involved considering the factors relevant to the court's discretion in awarding costs against individuals who are not parties to the litigation but have a significant role in the proceedings.
The court determined that Adam Dalby was to pay the costs of the appeal. The costs were ordered to be assessed on the ordinary basis up to 16 March 2018, and on an indemnity basis thereafter, reflecting the application of the offer of compromise provisions. This outcome indicates the court found sufficient grounds to exercise its discretion to order the non-party director to bear the costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The costs of the appeal are to be assessed on the ordinary basis to 16 March 2018, and on an indemnity basis thereafter;
2. Adam Dalby is to pay the costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter proceeded to trial, and the trial judge found in favour of Brand2Content on most of the claims, ordering Dalby to pay damages and costs. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Dalby appealed the decision to a higher court. Brand2Content subsequently applied for an order that the appeal costs be assessed on an indemnity basis and for an order that the costs of the appeal be paid by Dalby personally. Brand2Content argued that the appeal was frivolous and without merit, and that Dalby had acted unreasonably in continuing the appeal despite clear instructions to the contrary from his legal representatives. Brand2Content further contended that Dalby, as the common director of the appellant companies, should be held personally liable for the costs of the appeal.
The appeal was ultimately dismissed, and the higher court was asked to consider the appropriate costs orders. Brand2Content sought an indemnity costs order against Dalby, arguing that Dalby had no reasonable prospects of success on appeal and had acted unreasonably in continuing the appeal. Brand2Content also sought an order that Dalby personally pay the costs of the appeal, arguing that Dalby had acted as the common director of the appellant companies and should be held accountable for the costs incurred.
The matter originated in the Federal Circuit Court, where Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works (the appellant) filed a claim against Dalby (the respondent) on 16 March 2018. Dalby, the sole director of several companies involved in the dispute, was subsequently joined as a party to the proceeding. Following the proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court, Dalby, now acting as the defendant and appellant in the current appeal, contested the appellant's claims. The appeal was heard in the Federal Court, where the appellant sought a review of the primary decision. During the course of the appeal, Brand2Content made an offer of compromise under UCPR 41.14, which was not accepted by Dalby. The appellant subsequently applied for indemnity costs based on this offer. The case was ultimately decided in favour of the appellant, leading to this appeal concerning the costs associated with the proceedings. The appeal focused on the appropriate basis for assessing costs and whether it was in the interests of justice to order Dalby to pay costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether it is in the interests of justice for the court to exercise its discretion to order a non-party, who is the common director of the defendant/appellant companies, to pay costs.
2. What factors should the court consider in exercising its discretion to award costs against a non-party in a party/party costs scenario.
3. How the court should approach the assessment of indemnity costs in accordance with UCPR 41.14, particularly in relation to an offer of compromise.
4. Whether the offer of compromise made under UCPR 41.14 affected the court's assessment of costs in this appeal.
Held
1. The court decided that it is in the interests of justice to exercise its discretion to order the non-party, who is the common director of the defendant/appellant companies, to pay costs. Result: Costs order made against the non-party common director.
2. The factors the court should consider in exercising its discretion to award costs against a non-party include the non-party's involvement in the proceedings, the benefit the non-party derived from the proceedings, and the need for the court to maintain the integrity of the legal process. Result: Factors outlined for consideration in future cases.
3. The court should approach the assessment of indemnity costs in accordance with UCPR 41.14 by considering the reasonableness of the offer of compromise, the stage at which the offer was made, and the extent to which the final outcome differed from the offer. Result: Guidelines provided for assessing indemnity costs.
4. The offer of compromise made under UCPR 41.14 did not affect the court's assessment of costs in this appeal. Result: Offer of compromise did not impact the costs assessment.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works v Dalby, the court addressed the issue of whether it was in the interests of justice to exercise its discretion to order a non-party, Adam Dalby, who served as the common director of the defendant/appellant companies, to pay costs. The court found that it was appropriate to do so given the unique circumstances of the case. The court's reasoning in this regard was rooted in the overarching principle that the exercise of discretion in awarding costs should serve the interests of justice. The court considered the nature of Dalby’s involvement and influence over the companies, which led to the conclusion that he was effectively a party to the proceedings despite his formal non-participation.
Further, the court delineated the factors it considered relevant in exercising its discretion to award costs against a non-party in a party/party costs scenario. These factors included the degree of Dalby’s control and influence over the companies, his involvement in the litigation process, and the potential deterrence effect of holding him liable for costs. The court referenced prior cases to support its consideration of these factors, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach that takes into account the practicalities and equities of the situation. By weighing these factors, the court justified its decision to hold Dalby accountable for costs.
Turning to the assessment of indemnity costs, the court applied the provisions of UCPR 41.14, which governs offers of compromise. The court analyzed whether the offer of compromise made by the respondent had any bearing on the final assessment of costs. Under UCPR 41.14, the court is tasked with considering the offer of compromise in the context of the overall conduct of the case and the conduct of the parties. The court examined the timing and content of the offer, as well as its impact on the proceedings. By considering these elements, the court determined the appropriate basis for assessing costs.
The court also evaluated whether the offer of compromise influenced its assessment of costs in this appeal. It was determined that the offer did not significantly affect the court's decision on the basis for costs. The court concluded that the offer was not particularly advantageous to the appellant, and hence, it did not warrant a shift towards an indemnity costs assessment for the entire proceeding. Instead, the court opted for a mixed assessment, applying the ordinary basis to costs incurred up to the date of the offer and the indemnity basis thereafter. This nuanced approach ensured that the assessment reflected the realities of the litigation process and the parties' conduct.
In summary, the court’s reasoning in Brand2Content t/as Franchise Works v Dalby demonstrates a careful balancing of discretion in costs awards against non-parties, guided by the interests of justice and relevant legal principles. The factors considered in exercising this discretion, the application of UCPR 41.14, and the impact of an offer of compromise were all integral to the court’s final decision. The ratio decidendi established by this case provides a framework for future cases involving similar issues, emphasizing the importance of a contextual and equitable assessment of costs.