[2012] QDC 295
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 3066 of 2011
| BOX INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD | Plaintiff |
| and | |
| CRYSTALAID MANUFACTURE PTY LTD | Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 04/09/2012
ORDER
CATCHWORDS
Proceeding on the Commercial List - slippage in completing steps threatens to render fixed trial dates impracticable - whether plaintiff justified in not completing steps by date it had indicated willingness to accept because defendant and third party could not agree on the timetable - costs thrown away when a mention of which the plaintiff had no adequate notice had to be revisited
HIS HONOUR: The Court makes an order in terms of the initialled draft. It undoes most of the work done yesterday at a hearing in which the plaintiff didn't participate, except for the provision in paragraph 8 providing for applications that evidence be given by telephone or similar on the 27th of September 2012, which has been fixed by a still earlier order as a mention date for the proceeding.
There are applications for costs thrown away as a result of yesterday's exercise, which, to a certain extent, was wasted. It's not at all clear for the moment that the plaintiff, which appears to be the party in the gun, so to speak, should have to pay those costs. The hearing came about, according to my impression which is subject to correction, because the third party became concerned about slippage in the schedule of steps to lead to a trial for six days commencing the 9th of October 2012, the last two days being 22nd and 23rd of November.
On the 13th of August at an earlier mention it had been anticipated that the parties would agree on directions and Mr Hutchinson, representing the plaintiff, indicated his agreement so that the standout party was the defendant. Its continuing failure to agree in a formal way with the draft order prepared on the 13th of August seems to me to be what led Mr Bradley to bring the application on. Advice of that went to Mr Hutchinson very much at the last minute, he not having been involved in earlier activities generating it. He says the relevant e-mail went from my associate at around 4 p.m. last Friday, and wasn't opened by him until after the hearing yesterday had occurred.
My expectation that the plaintiff would be content with the order yesterday, given that it did no more than fix later dates for the taking of particular steps, proves erroneous. Rightly or wrongly, Mr Hutchinson took the approach that steps were to be taken only on the basis that all preceding steps had been completed. Matters within his purview, as I understand it, were also put on the backburner, awaiting provision by the defendant of copies of documents disclosed by it to complete the disclosure process. That still hasn't happened. By yesterday's order it was to happen by tomorrow, that's not being altered today.
...
HIS HONOUR: Mr Hutchinson now presents a catalogue of difficulties. He says…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Box Information Technology Pty Ltd v Crystalaid Manufacture... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] QDC 295
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the plaintiff had indicated willingness to proceed with the agreed steps, but the defendant and the third party had not agreed on a timetable. The plaintiff's counsel argued that without the necessary documents from the defendant, they could not proceed with their preparations, and this resulted in delays. The court considered the importance of maintaining fixed trial dates, especially towards the end of the court year, and highlighted the importance of having available counsel. The court also noted the plaintiff's concerns about the unavailability of a crucial witness due to the delay in receiving documents from the defendant.
The court decided to undo most of the work done during a previous hearing, except for the provision that allowed for evidence to be given by telephone or similar means. The court reserved the decision on the costs thrown away during the previous hearing and emphasized the need for the parties to keep the order as simple as possible while ensuring that rebuttal evidence was provided in written form. The court allowed the parties to apply if there were any difficulties and invited them to approach the court if they faced any challenges, such as delays in receiving necessary documents. The court also emphasized that the matter should remain on the commercial list only if it was possible to fix and retain trial dates.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi