[2012] QDC 292
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 3066 of 2011
BOX INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY PTY LTD Plaintiff and
CRYSTALAID MANUFACTURE PTY LTD Defendant BRISBANE
..DATE 03/05/2012
ORDER
CATCHWORDS
Corporations Act 2001 s 1335
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 670, r 671Defendant's application for security for costs - director's undertaking to pay costs plaintiff company may be ordered but fail to pay accepted - relevance of value of that undertaking and of defendant's responsibility for plaintiff's impecuniosity - claim would be defeated if security were ordered
HIS HONOUR: This is a defendant's application for security for costs, under section 1335 of the Corporations Act, also rule 670 and following of the UCPR. The plaintiff's claim is for licence fees, which it says came due in 2004 or 2005 in respect of licensing of software, access to which the plaintiff had gained from the third party. The remuneration the plaintiff was entitled to depended on the number and perhaps categories of users of software in the defendant's business.
In 2004 separate payments under the software licence agreement were made of $60,000 and $80,000, the second payment being attributable to additional users having been brought in. The plaintiff asserts, and appears to be correct, that there were yet other users, entitling it to a sum in excess of $300,000 sued for in a District Court claim.
A Magistrates Court claim commenced in the following month, that is September 2011, for remuneration claimed to be due to the plaintiff from the defendant, under a separate maintenance agreement.
Things went wrong, from the plaintiff's point of view, when the former controlling director, Mr Duncan, early in 2005 had an administrator appointed, most likely to obtain some protection in circumstances of financial difficulty.
The administration was short lived, the creditors having been paid in full, thanks to the provision of funds for the purpose by Ms Reale, who is now the principal of the plaintiff. Her maximum commitment of funds for that purpose was $400,000. It's not clear that the whole sum was required. Although the company came out of administration it confronted very difficult circumstances.
The defendant, in reliance on the appointment of administrators, terminated its agreements. It now asserts, although it is not clear that it did so at the time, dissatisfaction with the plaintiff's level of performance under the maintenance agreement. December 2004 payments aggregating $101,000 had been made, and apparently without complaint.
There has been filed, yesterday, an affidavit providing some specificity about complaints, in particular, for example, that labelling, to satisfy requirements such as those of the American Food and Drug Administration, was not provided as required. I have expressed a tentative view that in a context like the present a certain amount of shortfall in performance is, perhaps, to be expected.
Ms Reale has put the plaintiff into action to seek to recover moneys the defendant owes it, in its view, with a view to recouping what she had advanced in 2005. The plaintiff itself is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Box Information Technology Pty Ltd v Crystalaid Manufacture... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] QDC 292
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the plaintiff was likely to be unable to pay the defendant's costs if ordered to do so and, if so, whether the plaintiff could provide sufficient security for those costs. This decision hinged on the impecuniosity of the plaintiff, the value of the personal undertaking by the plaintiff's director, Maria Reale, to cover the costs, and whether the defendant's actions contributed to the plaintiff's financial difficulties.
The court considered the principle that a director's personal undertaking to pay costs should be evaluated for its worth, as established by previous case law. The court also took into account the impecuniosity of the plaintiff and its inability to satisfy any costs order against it. Although the defendant's conduct contributed to the plaintiff's financial difficulties, the court found that this alone did not justify refusing an order for security for costs. However, the court was concerned that ordering security for costs might prevent the plaintiff from litigating its claim due to its financial condition. The court decided to stay the proceedings until the director provided a satisfactory personal undertaking, thereby preserving the plaintiff's right to litigate while managing the risk of costs for the defendant.
The court ordered that the proceedings be stayed until Maria Reale provided a personal undertaking in a form satisfactory to the Registrar, committing herself to pay any costs ordered against the plaintiff in favour of the defendant should the plaintiff fail to pay. Costs were reserved for future determination.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi