Bowyer Group Pty Ltd v Cook Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bowyer Group Pty Ltd v Cook Shire Council & Ors [2022] QPEC 33

PARTIES:

BOWYER GROUP PTY LTD ACN 600 221 976

(appellant)

v

COOK SHIRE COUNCIL

(respondent)

and

KALAN ENTERPRISES ABORIGINAL CORPORATION ABN 62 076 988 535

(co-respondent)

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF STATE DEVELOPMENT, INFRASTRUCTURE, LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND PLANNING

(co-respondent by election)

FILE NO:

10 of 2021

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

16 September 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

9-18 May 2022; 25 July 2022.

JUDGE:

Morzone KC DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Appeal allowed.

2.   The development application is refused.

3.   I will hear the parties as to any consequential orders.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – Appeal against approval of approval – support of council and chief executive department – whether a demonstrated economic, planning or community need for the proposed development – whether the proposed development result in unacceptable environmental and ecological impacts and, if so, can such impacts can be managed, including with reference to the precautionary principle – whether the proposed development gives effect to the Cape York Regional Plan – whether the proposed development complies with relevant assessment benchmarks – whether, in the event of any non-compliance with the assessment benchmarks, can any such non-compliance can and should be managed by the imposition of reasonable and relevant conditions – whether there relevant matters that favour approval despite any non-compliance with assessment benchmarks.

LEGISLATION:

Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, ss 5(1), 43, 45(5)(a), 45(5)(b), 45(6), s 45(7), 60(3)
Planning Regulation 2017, s 31.

CASES:

Abeleda & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2021] QPELR 1003
All-A-Wah Carapark v Noosa Shire Council [1989] QPLR 155
Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2019] QPEC 16
Australian National Homes Pty Ltd v Moreton Bay Regional Council & Anor [2019] QPEC 46
Bell v Brisbane City Council [2018] 230 LGERA 374
Berry v Caboolture Shire Council [2002] QPELR 96
Bunnings Building Supplies Pty Ltd v Redland Shire Council (2000) QPELR 193
Caloundra City Council v Pelican Links Pty Ltd [2003] QPEC 52
Clermont Quarries Pty Ltd v Isaac Regional Council [2021] QPELR 65
Cox & Ors v Maroochy Shire Council & Ors [2006] QPELR 628
Cut Price Stores Retailers v Caboolture SC [1984] QPLR 126
Cuthbert v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2016] QPELR 179
Fabcot Pty Ltd v. Cairns Regional Council & Ors [2021] QPELR 40
Fitzgibbons Hotel Pty Ltd v Logan City Council [1997] QPELR 208
Friend v Brisbane City Council [2014] QPELR 24
GFW Gelatine International Ltd v Beaudesert Shire Council [1993] QPLR 342
Harris v Scenic Rim Regional Council [2014] QPELR 324
Indooroopilly Golf Club v BCC [1982] QPLR 13
Intrafield v Redland Shire Council [2001] 116 LGERA 350
Isgro v Gold Coast City Council & Anor [2003] QPELR 414
Jadmont Pty Ltd v Council of the Shire of Miriam Vale [1998] QPELR 351.
Jakel Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2018] QPEC 21
JSFNQ…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bowyer Group Pty Ltd v Cook Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QPEC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Bowyer Group Pty Ltd appealed against the Cook Shire Council's approval of their development application for a new mining operation. The matter was heard by the Queensland Planning and Environment Court, which assessed the application anew, standing in the shoes of the assessment manager. The central legal issues were whether the proposed development met the economic, planning, and community needs, whether it would result in unacceptable environmental and ecological impacts, whether it aligned with the Cape York Regional Plan, and whether any non-compliance with assessment benchmarks could be managed through reasonable conditions. The court also considered whether any relevant matters favoured approval despite non-compliance.

The court found that the proposed development did not sufficiently demonstrate an economic, planning, or community need. Additionally, it was likely to result in unacceptable environmental and ecological impacts, which could not be adequately managed. Although the development aligned with the Cape York Regional Plan, this did not outweigh the negative impacts. The court also determined that there were non-compliances with the assessment benchmarks, which could not be sufficiently managed through conditions. Given these findings, the court found that the relevant matters did not favour approval.

The Bowyer Group's appeal was allowed, and the development application was refused. The court will hear from the parties regarding any consequential orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. The development application is refused.

3. I will hear the parties as to any consequential orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Coen is 380 kilometres northwest of Cooktown and 252 kilometres southeast of Weipa via the PDR. The PDR is the main road transportation link within Cape York Peninsula. It connects the east coast to the town of Weipa as well as a number of remote indigenous communities. Assessment and decision framework The appeal is to be heard by way of hearing anew[2] and must be decided by the court standing in the shoes of the assessment manager.[3][2]Planning and Environment Court Act 2016, section 43.[3]Jakel Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2018] QPEC 21 at [93]. The Planning Act 2016 and Planning and Environment Court Act 2018 apply to the appeal. As the development application required impact assessment, the decision of the court pursuant to s 62(3) must be based upon the assessment required by ss 45(5), (6) and (7) pursuant to s 59(3) and done in a way that advances the purpose of the Act.[4] Accordingly, the court: [4]Planning Act 2016, s 5(1).(a)must carry out the assessment of the development application: (i)against the applicable assessment benchmarks in a categorising instrument in effect at the time the development application was properly made;[5] and (ii)having regard to any matters prescribed by regulation to the extent the assessment manager considers those matters relevant to the development;[6] and(b)may carry out the assessment of the development application against, or having regard to, any other relevant matter (other than personal circumstances, financial or otherwise);[7] and(c)may give the weight the court considers appropriate to any amendments to the planning scheme (none are relevant here);[8] and (d)decide to approve all or part of the application; or to approve all or part of the application but impose development conditions on the approval; or to refuse the application;[9] and(e)when undertaking this task the court must perform its function in a way that advances the purpose of the Act.[10][5]Planning Act 2016, ss 45(5)(a) & 45(6) & Planning Regulation 2017, s 31.[6]Planning Act 2016, ss 45(5)(a) & 45(6) & Planning Regulation 2017, s 31.[7]Planning Act 2016, s 45(5)(b).[8]Planning Act 2016, s 45(7).[9]Planning Act 2016, s 60(3).[10]Planning Act 2016, s 5(1). It seems to me that the use of the phrases “carried out against” and “having regard to” is purposeful. The term “carried out against” connotes a comparative check analysis of the development against some recognised authoritative performance standard, guideline, or other document; whereas “having regard to” connotes regard being had to matters of fact and circumstance. The expression “another relevant matter” or “relevant matter” is not defined in the Planning Act except as one “other than a person’s personal circumstances, financial or otherwise.”[11] A “relevant matter” ought carry its ordinary meaning to capture a matter that has a bearing upon, or is connected with the assessment of the application other than a person’s personal circumstances, financial or otherwise. An “other relevant matter” may include all relevant matters of positive and negative attributes of the proposed development, including any particular community benefits or detriments that might weigh in favour of or against an approval even where a proposal is or is not consistent with the community expectations.[12] And, the nature and extent of “other relevant matters” may overlap and blend with each other. The legislature have provided three examples for the purposes of s 45(5)(b) being:(a)a planning need;(b)the current relevance of the assessment benchmarks in the light of changed circumstances;(c)whether assessment benchmarks or other prescribed matters were based on material errors.[11]Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane City Council & Ors [2019] QPEC 16 at [80].[12]Cf. Trinity Park Investments Pty Ltd v Cairns Regional Council & Ors; Dexus Funds Management Limited v Fabcot Pty Ltd & Ors [2021] QCA 95 at [180]. Contrast, Bell, at [73] & [74].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.