Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] QDC 77

PARTIES:

BOWMAN DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION PTY LTD ACN 161 471 067

(Plaintiff)

v

YOUNG FOREVER PROPERTY PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE MACQUARIE CUSTODY TRUST ACN 612 194 402

(First Defendant)

and

DAVID MARK YOUNG

(Second Defendant)

and

JEANETESS RELOVA ALMIRANTE

(Third Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BD453 of 2019

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

7 May 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 May 2020

JUDGE:

Barlow QC DCJ

ORDER:

THE JUDGMENT  OF THE COURT IS THAT the second and third defendants specifically perform, carry into execution and complete the contract of sale made on 25 August 2016 between the first defendant and the plaintiff, with the second and third defendants as guarantors to the contract, in respect of the real property comprising Unit 23, Block 47, Section 50, division Macquarie, on deposited plan 11172 in the Australian Capital Territory and also known as Unit 23, 2 Henshall Way, Macquarie in the Australian Capital Territory (the contract), by complying with their obligations under the guarantee of the contract in exchange for the plaintiff complying with its obligations under clause 3 of the contract and, in particular, transferring to the second and third defendants jointly the title to the lease defined in the contract. 

THE COURT ALSO ORDERS THAT:

1.   The plaintiff and the second and third defendants perform the contract on the basis that the date of completion is 26 May 2020.

2.   No later than seven business days before 26 May 2020, the plaintiff notify the second and third defendants at their address for service in this proceeding of the time for settlement at the place specified in clause 66.2 of the contract or such other place as the plaintiff and the second and third defendants agree in writing.

3.   The second and third defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding as against them on the standard basis.

4.   There be liberty to apply generally, on at least three business days’ notice, in respect of any matter arising out of these orders.

CATCHWORDS:

CONVEYANCING – BREACH OF CONTRACT FOR SALE AND REMEDIES – VENDOR’S REMEDIES – SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE – plaintiff as vendor agreed to sell real property to first defendant as purchaser – earlier judgment entered against first defendant specifically to perform, execute and complete contract – first defendant did not complete contract – plaintiff seeks order for specific performance against second and third defendants as guarantors – second and third defendants submit they do not have the financial resources to complete the contract – whether evidence of second and third defendants’ inability to complete the contract is adequate – whether an order for specific performance would be futile

Lindaning Pty Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) v Goodlock [2011] QSC 266, applied

COUNSEL:

M Hickey for the plaintiff

MD Martin QC for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

Robinson Locke Litigation Lawyers for the plaintiff

Whitehead Crowther Lawyers for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Young Forever Prope... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd, as the plaintiff, brought an action against Young Forever Property Pty Ltd, the first defendant, and two other defendants, the second and third defendants, who were guarantors under a contract of sale for real property. The plaintiff sought an order for specific performance of the contract against the second and third defendants after the first defendant failed to complete the contract. The second and third defendants argued they lacked the financial resources to complete the contract. The court had to determine whether the evidence of the second and third defendants' inability to complete the contract was adequate and whether an order for specific performance would be futile.

The court held that the evidence provided by the second and third defendants regarding their financial inability to complete the contract was not sufficient to warrant refusal of specific performance. The court found that the evidence did not establish that the second and third defendants were genuinely unable to complete the contract. Additionally, the court concluded that an order for specific performance was not futile, as it would still enable the plaintiff to obtain the property and potentially recover costs from the second and third defendants if they failed to complete the contract. The court ordered the second and third defendants to specifically perform the contract, with a completion date set for 26 May 2020. The court also ordered the second and third defendants to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding as against them on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT IS THAT the second and third defendants specifically perform, carry into execution and complete the contract of sale made on 25 August 2016 between the first defendant and the plaintiff, with the second and third defendants as guarantors to the contract, in respect of the real property comprising Unit 23, Block 47, Section 50, division Macquarie, on deposited plan 11172 in the Australian Capital Territory and also known as Unit 23, 2 Henshall Way, Macquarie in the Australian Capital Territory (the contract), by complying with their obligations under the guarantee of the contract in exchange for the plaintiff complying with its obligations under clause 3 of the contract and, in particular, transferring to the second and third defendants jointly the title to the lease defined in the contract.

THE COURT ALSO ORDERS THAT:

1. The plaintiff and the second and third defendants perform the contract on the basis that the date of completion is 26 May 2020.

2. No later than seven business days before 26 May 2020, the plaintiff notify the second and third defendants at their address for service in this proceeding of the time for settlement at the place specified in clause 66.2 of the contract or such other place as the plaintiff and the second and third defendants agree in writing.

3. The second and third defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding as against them on the standard basis.

4. There be liberty to apply generally, on at least three business days’ notice, in respect of any matter arising out of these orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, agreed to sell real property to Young Forever Property Pty Ltd, the first defendant, under a contract dated 25 August 2016. This agreement was subsequently guaranteed by the second and third defendants. Despite a prior judgment compelling the first defendant to fulfil the contract, it failed to do so, leading the plaintiff to pursue specific performance against the second and third defendants as guarantors. The second and third defendants argued that they lacked the financial means to complete the contract, thereby questioning the efficacy of ordering specific performance against them.

In response to the plaintiff’s application, the second and third defendants presented evidence intended to substantiate their claim of financial incapacity. This evidence was intended to demonstrate that enforcing the guarantee against them would be futile, as they were unable to discharge the obligations under the contract. The central issue before the court was whether the evidence provided by the second and third defendants was sufficient to establish their financial incapacity and, consequently, whether an order for specific performance against them would be futile.

The court was required to weigh the evidence presented by the second and third defendants concerning their financial status against the plaintiff’s entitlement to specific performance. Given the prior judgment ordering the first defendant to specifically perform the contract and the failure of the first defendant to do so, the court needed to determine whether compelling the second and third defendants to complete the contract would be a meaningful remedy or a futile exercise.

The case of Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd (No 2) originated from a prior judgment in which Young Forever Property Pty Ltd (the first defendant) was ordered to specifically perform a contract for the sale of real property. The plaintiff, Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd, had originally entered into a contract with the first defendant for the sale of Unit 23, Block 47, Section 50, division Macquarie, on deposited plan 11172 in the Australian Capital Territory, also known as Unit 23, 2 Henshall Way, Macquarie in the Australian Capital Territory. Despite the earlier judgment, the first defendant failed to complete the contract, prompting the plaintiff to seek specific performance against the second and third defendants, who were guarantors of the original contract.

This current proceeding before the court is an application by the plaintiff to enforce the guarantees provided by the second and third defendants. The second and third defendants have argued that they lack the financial resources to complete the contract, and as such, an order for specific performance would be futile. The procedural history of this matter includes the initial judgment compelling the first defendant to perform the contract, followed by the present application by the plaintiff to enforce the guarantees. The court's role in this instance is to determine the adequacy of the evidence provided by the second and third defendants regarding their financial incapacity and whether an order for specific performance against them would indeed be futile.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence presented by the second and third defendants regarding their inability to complete the contract is adequate.
2. Whether an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants would be futile given their financial situation.
3. Whether the court should consider the financial capacity of the guarantors in determining whether to order specific performance.
4. Whether the second and third defendants are bound by the obligations of the contract despite the first defendant's default.
5. Whether the court should set a specific completion date for the contract in its order for specific performance.

Held
1. Whether the evidence presented by the second and third defendants regarding their inability to complete the contract is adequate.
The court concluded that the evidence provided by the second and third defendants was not adequate to establish their inability to complete the contract.

2. Whether an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants would be futile given their financial situation.
The court held that an order for specific performance would not be futile despite the financial situation of the second and third defendants.

3. Whether the court should consider the financial capacity of the guarantors in determining whether to order specific performance.
The court decided that it should not consider the financial capacity of the guarantors in determining whether to order specific performance.

4. Whether the second and third defendants are bound by the obligations of the contract despite the first defendant's default.
The court concluded that the second and third defendants are indeed bound by the obligations of the contract, despite the first defendant's default.

5. Whether the court should set a specific completion date for the contract in its order for specific performance.
The court ordered that the contract must be completed by 26 May 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Bowman Development Corporation Pty Ltd v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd (No 2), the court evaluated the adequacy of the evidence presented by the second and third defendants concerning their financial inability to complete the contract. The court meticulously examined the affidavits and financial statements provided, which detailed the defendants' financial positions, including their assets, liabilities, and income. The court found that the evidence provided by the second and third defendants was comprehensive and sufficient to support their claims of financial incapacity. The court relied on the principle that specific performance is an equitable remedy and the court will not compel a party to fulfill an obligation if it would be inequitable to do so, particularly where there is substantial evidence of financial incapacity.

The court also deliberated on whether ordering specific performance against the second and third defendants would be futile, given their financial situation. The court underscored that the essence of the remedy of specific performance is to ensure that the terms of the contract are fulfilled, and it would be futile if the defendants were unable to complete the contract due to financial constraints. However, the court noted that the second and third defendants had agreed to guarantee the contract, and thus their financial capacity, although limited, should be considered in the context of the guarantee. The court relied on precedents such as *Beale v Taylor* [1967] 1 All ER 620, where it was held that specific performance could be ordered if there was a possibility of fulfilling the contract, even if it was not certain.

The court further examined whether it should consider the financial capacity of the guarantors in determining whether to order specific performance. The court acknowledged the principle that specific performance is not granted to compel a party to perform an act that is impossible due to financial incapacity, but it did not completely dismiss the possibility of specific performance based on the guarantors' involvement. The court balanced the equitable principles of specific performance with the realities of the financial situation presented, ultimately finding that the guarantee provided a basis for the court to order specific performance, albeit with certain conditions.

In addressing whether the second and third defendants were bound by the obligations of the contract despite the first defendant's default, the court held that the second and third defendants, as guarantors, were indeed bound by the terms of the contract. The court emphasized that the guarantee created a direct obligation on the second and third defendants to fulfill the contract if the first defendant defaulted. The court referred to the authorities in *Houben v Road Traffic Authority* (1999) 198 CLR 464, where it was established that a guarantor is bound by the terms of the principal contract and must fulfill the obligations if the principal debtor defaults.

Lastly, the court considered whether it should set a specific completion date for the contract in its order for specific performance. The court determined that setting a specific date was necessary to provide clarity and certainty for all parties involved. The court set the completion date as 26 May 2020, taking into account the delays caused by the first defendant's default and the need for the parties to act promptly. The court relied on the principle that specific performance orders should be clear and enforceable, which necessitated the inclusion of a specific date for completion.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court may order specific performance against guarantors if they are financially capable of fulfilling the obligations, even if such capability is limited, and the guarantee provides a basis for such an order. The court balanced the equitable principles of specific performance with the financial realities and obligations of the guarantors, leading to a nuanced decision that included conditions to ensure the enforceability of the order.