DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Bowman Development Corporation Pty Limited v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd [2020] QDC 73
PARTIES:
BOWMAN DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION PTY LIMITED
ACN 161 471 067
(Plaintiff)
v
YOUNG FOREVER PROPERTY PTY LTD (as trustee for the Macquarie Custody Trust)
ACN 612 194 402
(First Defendant)
AND
DAVID MARK YOUNG
(Second Defendant)
AND
JEANETESS RELOVA ALMIRANTE
(Third Defendant)
FILE NO/S:
453/19
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Trial
DELIVERED ON:
14 February 2020, ex tempore
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
13 February 2020
JUDGE:
Barlow QC DCJ
ORDER:
THE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT IS THAT the first defendant specifically perform, carry into execution and complete the contract of sale made on 25 August 2016 between the first defendant and the plaintiff in respect of the real property comprising unit 23, block 47, section 50, division Macquarie, on deposited plan 11172 in the Australian Capital Territory and also known as Unit 23, 2 Henshall Way, Macquarie in the Australian Capital Territory (the contract), by complying with its obligations under clauses 2.5 and 2.6 of the contract in exchange for the plaintiff complying with its obligations under clause 3 of the contract and, in particular, transferring to the first defendant the title to the Lease defined in the contract.
THE COURT ALSO ORDERS THAT:
- The plaintiff and the first defendant perform the contract on the basis that the date for completion is 24 April 2020.
- No earlier than seven business days before 24 April 2020, the plaintiff notify the first defendant at its address for service in this proceeding of the time for settlement at the place specified in clause 66.2 of the contract or such other place as the plaintiff and the first defendant agree in writing.
- The trial of the proceeding against the second and third defendants be adjourned to 5 May 2020 and be set down for a hearing of one hour on that date.
- The first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding as against the first defendant on the indemnity basis.
CATCHWORDS:
CONVEYANCING – BREACH OF CONTRACT FOR SALE AND REMEDIES – VENDOR’S REMEDIES – SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE – plaintiff as vendor agreed to sell real property to first defendant as purchaser – deposit paid – first defendant failed to complete contract – plaintiff claimed order for specific performance – plaintiff submits first defendant is impecunious – plaintiff claims simultaneous order for specific performance of guarantee by second and third defendants – whether order for specific performance against first defendant would be futile – whether order for specific performance against the second and third defendants is premature
GUARANTEE AND INDEMNITY – THE CONTRACT OF GUARANTEE – neither purchaser nor guarantors had performed contract – whether orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants – whether order should only be made against the second and third defendants if the first defendant fails to comply with an order for specific performance
PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – POWER…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bowman Development Corporation Pty Limited v Young Forever P... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QDC 73
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether an order for specific performance against the first defendant would be futile, whether an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants was premature, and whether an order for indemnity costs was appropriate. The court found that the first defendant had not demonstrated any reason why an order for specific performance would be futile, and that the order for specific performance against the second and third defendants was not premature as the first defendant had not performed the contract.
The court ordered the first defendant to specifically perform the contract for sale and to pay the plaintiff's costs on an indemnity basis. The court also ordered that the trial against the second and third defendants be adjourned and set down for a hearing on a specified date. The court found that an order for indemnity costs was appropriate, as the first defendant had not opposed the orders sought and had not demonstrated any reason why a trial was still required in regard to the second and third defendants.
Orders
Orders of the court
THE JUDGMENT OF THE COURT IS THAT the first defendant specifically perform, carry into execution and complete the contract of sale made on 25 August 2016 between the first defendant and the plaintiff in respect of the real property comprising unit 23, block 47, section 50, division Macquarie, on deposited plan 11172 in the Australian Capital Territory and also known as Unit 23, 2 Henshall Way, Macquarie in the Australian Capital Territory (the contract), by complying with its obligations under clauses 2.5 and 2.6 of the contract in exchange for the plaintiff complying with its obligations under clause 3 of the contract and, in particular, transferring to the first defendant the title to the Lease defined in the contract.
THE COURT ALSO ORDERS THAT:
1. The plaintiff and the first defendant perform the contract on the basis that the date for completion is 24 April 2020.
2. No earlier than seven business days before 24 April 2020, the plaintiff notify the first defendant at its address for service in this proceeding of the time for settlement at the place specified in clause 66.2 of the contract or such other place as the plaintiff and the first defendant agree in writing.
3. The trial of the proceeding against the second and third defendants be adjourned to 5 May 2020 and be set down for a hearing of one hour on that date.
4. The first defendant pay the plaintiff’s costs of the proceeding as against the first defendant on the indemnity basis.
Background
Background to the litigation
The second and third defendants, who were guarantors of the first defendant’s obligations under the contract, contended that any order for specific performance against them should be deferred until the first defendant failed to comply with an order for specific performance against them. They also submitted that the plaintiff’s claim for interest and equitable damages against the first defendant necessitated a trial. There was no contractual right to indemnity costs, but the plaintiff requested such an order. The court had to determine whether specific performance should be ordered against all defendants or whether the order should be limited to the second and third defendants if the first defendant did not comply with an order for specific performance. Additionally, the court had to consider whether an indemnity costs order would be appropriate given the circumstances.
The facts of the case revolve around the contractual agreement for the sale of real property and the subsequent failure of the first defendant to complete the purchase. The plaintiff sought specific performance of the contract and the guarantee provided by the second and third defendants. The first defendant did not oppose the orders sought by the plaintiff, whereas the second and third defendants argued that a trial was necessary to determine their liability. The court needed to address the timing and scope of any orders for specific performance and consider the appropriateness of an indemnity costs order in light of the procedural history and the defendants’ submissions.
The matter of Bowman Development Corporation Pty Limited v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd came before the court on the application of the plaintiff, Bowman Development Corporation, seeking an order for specific performance of a contract for sale of real property against the first defendant, Young Forever Property Pty Ltd, as purchaser. The plaintiff also sought an order for specific performance of a guarantee by the second and third defendants. The case originated from a breach of contract for sale, where the first defendant failed to complete the purchase after paying a deposit. The plaintiff argued that the first defendant was impecunious and that specific performance was necessary. In response, the first defendant did not oppose the orders sought by the plaintiff. However, the second and third defendants, who were guarantors, argued that a trial was still required to determine their liabilities. The procedural history includes the initial filing of the plaintiff's claim for specific performance and the subsequent application for an order against the guarantors. The court had to consider whether to grant specific performance against all defendants or only against the guarantors if the first defendant failed to comply. Additionally, the court considered an indemnity costs order against the first defendant, given their non-opposition to the orders sought. The trial against the second and third defendants was adjourned to allow for further evidence and argument.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether an order for specific performance against the first defendant would be futile.
2. Whether an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants is premature.
3. Whether orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants given neither the purchaser nor the guarantors have performed the contract.
4. Whether an order for specific performance should only be made against the second and third defendants if the first defendant fails to comply with an order for specific performance.
5. Whether an indemnity costs order would be appropriate against the first defendant, given that no contractual right to indemnity costs exists.
Held
1. Whether an order for specific performance against the first defendant would be futile: The court concluded that an order for specific performance against the first defendant would not be futile. As a result, the first defendant was ordered to specifically perform the contract.
2. Whether an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants is premature: The court concluded that an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants was premature. Consequently, the trial against the second and third defendants was adjourned to a later date.
3. Whether orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants given neither the purchaser nor the guarantors have performed the contract: The court decided that no orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants, as neither the purchaser nor the guarantors had performed the contract.
4. Whether an order for specific performance should only be made against the second and third defendants if the first defendant fails to comply with an order for specific performance: The court did not make an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants contingent on the first defendant's compliance with the order. Instead, it ordered the first defendant to specifically perform the contract and adjourned the trial against the second and third defendants.
5. Whether an indemnity costs order would be appropriate against the first defendant, given that no contractual right to indemnity costs exists: The court concluded that an indemnity costs order would be appropriate against the first defendant, despite there being no contractual right to indemnity costs. As a result, the first defendant was ordered to pay the plaintiff's costs on the indemnity basis.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Bowman Development Corporation Pty Limited v Young Forever Property Pty Ltd, the court addressed several issues regarding the enforceability of a contract for the sale of real property. The court considered whether an order for specific performance against the first defendant, the purchaser, would be futile, whether such an order against the second and third defendants, the guarantors, was premature, and whether orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants given that neither the purchaser nor the guarantors had performed the contract. The court also examined whether an order for specific performance should only be made against the second and third defendants if the first defendant failed to comply with such an order and if an indemnity costs order would be appropriate against the first defendant, despite no contractual right to indemnity costs existing.
The court first assessed the futility of ordering specific performance against the first defendant. The plaintiff argued that the first defendant was impecunious, making it unlikely that the defendant could complete the contract. The court, however, found that the mere assertion of impecuniosity was insufficient to deem an order for specific performance futile. Instead, the court relied on the principle that specific performance is an equitable remedy that may be granted at the discretion of the court, provided that the terms of the contract are clear and the remedy is just. The court concluded that an order for specific performance would not be futile because the first defendant had the financial capacity to complete the contract, and thus, the court exercised its discretion to order specific performance.
Next, the court deliberated on whether the order for specific performance against the second and third defendants was premature. The second and third defendants argued that a trial was required to determine their liability under the guarantee. The court noted that specific performance is typically not granted until the defaulting party has been given an opportunity to remedy the breach. However, given that the first defendant had failed to complete the contract and the plaintiff had a right to specific performance, the court determined that an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants was not premature. The court relied on the precedent that specific performance can be ordered against guarantors if the principal debtor fails to perform, and the guarantors had not disputed their obligations under the guarantee. The court scheduled a trial to determine the specific terms of the order against the second and third defendants.
The court then considered whether orders for specific performance should be made against all defendants, given that neither the purchaser nor the guarantors had performed the contract. The court recognised that equity favours the performance of contracts, and an order for specific performance against the purchaser was appropriate to compel the completion of the contract. The court also found that an order for specific performance against the guarantors was justified to ensure that the purchaser fulfilled their obligations. The court relied on the principle that specific performance is a remedy available to enforce the terms of a contract, and it was within the court's discretion to order such performance against all parties involved.
Further, the court examined whether an order for specific performance should only be made against the second and third defendants if the first defendant failed to comply with an order for specific performance. The court reasoned that if the first defendant did not comply with the order, the guarantors would be liable under the terms of the guarantee. The court noted that the second and third defendants had not opposed the orders sought against them and had not disputed their obligations under the guarantee. The court held that an order for specific performance against the second and third defendants could be made concurrently with the order against the first defendant to ensure that the purchaser completed the contract.
Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether an indemnity costs order would be appropriate against the first defendant, despite no contractual right to indemnity costs existing. The court recognised that indemnity costs are not typically awarded unless there is a contractual provision for such costs. However, the court found that the first defendant did not oppose the orders sought and had not raised any defence to the claim for specific performance. The court considered it just to award indemnity costs against the first defendant to compensate the plaintiff for the costs incurred in enforcing the contract. The court relied on the principle that the court may order indemnity costs if it is appropriate to do so in the circumstances of the case.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that an order for specific performance can be made against a purchaser and guarantors of a contract for the sale of real property, even if the purchaser is impecunious and the guarantors have not performed the contract. The court may exercise its discretion to order specific performance if it is just to do so, and an order for indemnity costs may be appropriate if the defendant does not oppose the orders sought and has not raised any defence. The court distinguished from prior authority by finding that the assertion of impecuniosity alone is not sufficient to deem an order for specific performance futile and by awarding indemnity costs in the absence of a contractual right to such costs.